Critics Consensus

Coco Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Call Me By Your Name, Darkest Hour, Godless Season 1, and She's Gotta Have It Season 1 are also all Certified Fresh.

by | November 22, 2017 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have a spirited Pixar outing (Coco, featuring the voices of Gael García Bernal and Benjamin Bratt) and Denzel Washington as a lawyer in crisis (Roman J. Israel, Esq., co-starring Colin Farrell and Carmen Ejogo). What are the critics saying?


Coco (2017) 97%


The concept of death isn’t exactly taboo in animation — as any film lover can tell you, countless classic cartoon characters are orphans, and the loss of a loved one has offered the motivation for many an ultimately heartwarming tale. But it’s rare to see a family-friendly movie whose plot is centered around mortality — let alone one that takes pains to honor the traditions of a culture that many viewers consider foreign. Leave it to Pixar to take both leaps with Coco, in which a young Mexican boy named Miguel (Anthony Gonzalez) is caught between his dreams of being a musician and his obligations to his family. With a story (and overall aesthetic) influenced by the Mexican holiday of Día de Muertos, Coco represents a thematic and visual departure for the studio — which is exactly why critics say the movie is such a delight. While audiences can still expect all the tight storytelling craft and attention to detail that’s become synonymous with the Pixar name, the end result is still fresh enough to avoid feeling like formula. Whether Coco‘s characters remind you of your own family or you don’t know your mariachi from your norteño, this looks like a sure thing for families heading out to the theater over the long holiday weekend.


Roman J. Israel, Esq. (2017) 55%


Denzel Washington is one of our more remarkably gifted working actors, capable of bringing such depth to his performances that even the less compelling entries in his filmography can often be worth watching just for the opportunity to see him in action. All of which is to say that writer-director Dan Gilroy made the right move when he hired Washington to play the lead in Roman J. Israel, Esq., his drama about a principled lawyer whose life is upended when the senior partner in his small firm dies, forcing him to open up to uncomfortable changes — or potentially damaging lapses in ethics. It’s the type of part Washington can be counted on to invest with real feeling even when the screenplay or editing make it difficult; unfortunately, critics say that’s often the case here, adding up to a movie that, while far from a disaster, is also much less than the sum of its award-winning talent. Hardcore Washington or Gilroy fans may want to head to Israel this weekend, but for everyone else, there’s no reason not to wait for the movie’s arrival on home video.


What’s New on TV

Godless: Miniseries (2017) 83%

Vistas and violence root Godless firmly in traditional Western territory, but its female-driven ensemble sets it apart in a male-dominated genre.


She's Gotta Have It: Season 1 (2017) 84%

Fun, fascinating, and feminist, Spike Lee‘s classic is born again for a new generation.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

science fiction rotten movies we love high school Apple TV+ cats adaptation composers crime drama Quiz GLAAD Sundance Now Paramount Plus best what to watch HBO docudrama travel Box Office stop motion Nominations NBA Awards Tour christmas movies franchise renewed TV shows Syfy mission: impossible Holiday venice Fox Searchlight Starz cops Calendar Nickelodeon Turner Classic Movies SXSW sequel live action 2019 witnail A&E Television Critics Association worst movies mockumentary cinemax classics spy thriller scorecard toy story screenings Comic-Con@Home 2021 Binge Guide WarnerMedia critics APB green book Action Pop TV telelvision Nat Geo Legendary Avengers Apple japan sequels space BET basketball stand-up comedy kaiju halloween Kids & Family cancelled television The Walking Dead Tokyo Olympics FXX diversity Crunchyroll black CMT politics crossover 71st Emmy Awards dogs MSNBC cults 21st Century Fox halloween tv Video Games Warner Bros. animated biography The Walt Disney Company The Witch Comics on TV Vudu TCA Awards marvel cinematic universe TBS ESPN indiana jones movie Sundance TV Esquire werewolf films Winter TV 1990s Rock Tubi Mary poppins finale comiccon Watching Series RT21 Wes Anderson a nightmare on elm street SundanceTV dragons zero dark thirty TV renewals Toys zombies Spring TV adenture Western 99% suspense television ratings comedies war Universal Cannes Fantasy 007 canceled TV shows Chilling Adventures of Sabrina PBS mutant Exclusive Video TCA Winter 2020 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt social media IFC Films Musicals Columbia Pictures cartoon Emmy Nominations universal monsters zombie Mindy Kaling sports hollywood foreign BET Awards true crime Classic Film Song of Ice and Fire Netflix Ghostbusters Amazon Superheroe documentaries Disney+ Disney Plus cancelled Black Mirror Funimation Peacock ABC Signature international king arthur TV One Mystery robots disaster MTV Walt Disney Pictures Comedy SDCC Valentine's Day Thanksgiving Crackle Comedy Central Paramount Network E3 VH1 Bravo TV movies concert streaming movies Spectrum Originals VOD GoT DC Comics canceled Rocky OneApp romance crime spain Pop Image Comics Premiere Dates police drama TLC cooking Adult Swim WGN Film Festival hist Freeform independent Super Bowl Anna Paquin series Masterpiece Hear Us Out wonder woman jurassic park Women's History Month Epix USA Network stoner anime Music streaming FX BAFTA DC streaming service TV TCA 2017 Star Trek Broadway Reality Competition YA Dark Horse Comics remakes olympics Travel Channel Black History Month nbcuniversal Sony Pictures HBO Go football festival archives PaleyFest Shudder south america reviews video on demand game of thrones Brie Larson Superheroes game show TCM Drama serial killer 4/20 IFC theme song ID New York Comic Con news italian blockbuster hidden camera medical drama The Arrangement Discovery Channel criterion AMC trailers TIFF Elton John Star Wars dc supernatural psycho Podcast nature Mary Poppins Returns FX on Hulu elevated horror Character Guide Academy Awards satire saw Endgame Netflix Christmas movies Holidays MCU aapi historical drama Apple TV Plus cancelled TV series comic books 2016 El Rey CBS Chernobyl Christmas monster movies A24 period drama emmy awards Stephen King breaking bad quibi parents Hallmark Christmas movies Cartoon Network YouTube Red DC Universe Marvel Studios Pacific Islander award winner Family Sundance LGBTQ Pet Sematary video rt archives Polls and Games Marvel political drama superhero Summer batman 2020 YouTube Shondaland FOX The CW golden globes Pixar comic Cosplay thriller blaxploitation french sag awards Disney Plus Baby Yoda romantic comedy psychological thriller Year in Review Schedule kids nfl 45 revenge Grammys godzilla ViacomCBS boxing miniseries HBO Max Certified Fresh spider-man Horror dceu technology child's play obituary Biopics dramedy NYCC 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 93rd Oscars Lifetime Pirates Interview binge strong female leads jamie lee curtis DGA rom-coms The Academy reboot scary movies heist movie sitcom BBC America Awards Sneak Peek hispanic james bond Fall TV See It Skip It razzies Television Academy festivals Sci-Fi Ellie Kemper CW Seed BBC One golden globe awards transformers Animation GIFs movies Comic Book justice league anthology toronto vampires LGBT Lifetime Christmas movies Fox News new zealand singing competition cancelled TV shows Extras fast and furious women pirates of the caribbean richard e. Grant X-Men unscripted Disney Channel name the review twilight adventure History children's TV 2015 Spike comics chucky PlayStation casting 24 frames japanese king kong Tumblr discovery all-time Photos Disney streaming service natural history Film NBC Disney Lionsgate boxoffice worst Oscars versus Marvel Television fresh Set visit talk show docuseries latino indie Arrowverse Food Network ghosts 2021 target tv talk Trivia The Purge Tarantino lord of the rings directors Showtime Tomatazos Logo OWN legend Opinion Creative Arts Emmys Marathons 72 Emmy Awards Countdown Ovation USA Rocketman doctor who Turner teaser documentary First Reviews American Society of Cinematographers ABC Family TV Land laika spinoff Musical Pride Month TruTV Captain marvel E! asian-american Hulu Britbox Mary Tyler Moore facebook Teen book adaptation slashers President Amazon Prime blockbusters Amazon Studios 2017 San Diego Comic-Con Emmys Alien First Look RT History joker Election Writers Guild of America Hallmark popular based on movie screen actors guild CBS All Access crime thriller Paramount Trophy Talk Country Acorn TV rotten Best and Worst Rom-Com Winners aliens DirecTV superman Trailer know your critic Mudbound Heroines Martial Arts australia die hard 20th Century Fox Red Carpet ITV book ABC VICE Lucasfilm dark prank kong Reality TCA spanish language new york National Geographic 90s YouTube Premium Infographic CNN spanish BBC 2018 deadpool new star wars movies Amazon Prime Video harry potter cars TNT free movies scene in color