Cannes 2009: The Tomato Report - Up Soars With Cannes Critics

Pixar's 10th film on its way to Certified Fresh glory.

by | May 13, 2009 | Comments


It’s opening night tonight in Cannes, as Pixar’s latest, Up, receives its world premiere at the Grand Theatre Lumiere — the main stage, as it were, for all films playing in the main competition – and marks the start of the 2009 Cannes Film Festival. The film screened for press first thing this morning and Rotten Tomatoes was on hand to gauge reactions from critics on the ground.

Up is the tale of Carl Fredricksen, a quiet, unassuming widower who’s being forced out of his home as big business builds around him. Missing his wife, the love of his life whom he met as a boy, and longing for the adventures they once dreamed of together, he attaches hundreds of Helium balloons to his house and heads for South America, where he hopes to relive the travels of his favourite explorer, Charles Muntz.

When a knock on the door signals the presence of an intruder — 8-year-old “wilderness explorer” Russell — his careful plans go a little awry, and when he arrives at his destination he finds that adventure is not without its problems.

Renowned as a studio focused on quality cinema, every one of Pixar’s nine films have received generally exceptional reviews, and all eyes are on Up to see if it could make the tally 10. Fortunately, things seemed to go well as this morning’s press screening. It’s a good sign when a press screening in Cannes receives a round of applause, but an even better sign when it receives another after the key credits, and Up can comfortably claim both.

Cannes 2009
Russell tags along for the ride with Carl.

Given that reaction, it’s not surprising to see a sweep of fresh reviews arriving.
Variety and The Hollywood Reporter published their reviews ahead of the screening. Writing in the former, Todd McCarthy says it’s “a captivating odd-couple adventure that becomes funnier and more exciting as it flies along,” and “an exceptionally refined picture; unlike so many animated films, it’s not all about sensory bombardment and volume.

Time Out‘s Dave Calhoun gives it four stars saying, “Pixar triumphs again with a delirious fantasy that has one leg in the real world of hopes dashed and realised and the other in the cartoon tradition of journeying and adventure.

Up‘s plot isn’t afraid to tackle difficult subjects, nor of placing its characters in real jeopardy, and it’s this daring to be different from the usual fare aimed at families that’s wowing critics. For
IGN, Chris Tilly explains, “Pete
and his team of writers and animators never lose touch with the
relationship at the heart of the film – that of the bond between Carl and
Russell. Two lost souls, they start out a bickering comedy odd couple, but
gradually something far more profound develops, as man and boy finds solace and
hope in the friendship of the other.

Even the dissenting voices found it hard to be overly critical of a solid, family film. Kaleem Aftab, who will review for
The Independent, told us after the screening that he generally liked the film. “It had a fantastic start but a slightly disappointing ending. It’s typical of Pixar — nostalgia falls into sentimentality. [But] the first 50 minutes are great.

Cannes 2009
Preparations for tonight’s party.

Red carpet arrivals for the official premiere kick off shortly, followed by what promises to be a big afterparty on the beach later this evening. Preparations, including a scale model of the house from the film held aloft by hundreds of real helium balloons, are well under way for the event and, naturally, RT has a ticket safely in hand.

Stay tuned for future updates on the state of Up‘s Tomatometer and join us tomorrow when we’ll be exploring critical reaction to Andrea Arnold’s
Fish Tank
– already gathering buzz — and Lou Ye’s
Spring Fever

Until then, continue on to our official Cannes page
for more news, reactions, and photos from the festival!

Tag Cloud

TCM FX on Hulu Shudder quibi tv talk Amazon boxoffice FOX Academy Awards Awards Fox News Spring TV twilight Disney+ Disney Plus Hear Us Out Toys satire Endgame SDCC MTV cancelled TV series child's play die hard Biopics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina romance Black History Month Spike AMC adaptation The CW Funimation NBC foreign spanish language science fiction dark Lucasfilm a nightmare on elm street PaleyFest reviews Valentine's Day nbcuniversal CBS All Access LGBTQ indie rotten movies we love Turner Classic Movies cults video films Ovation Set visit Oscars Star Wars Columbia Pictures Chernobyl SXSW Drama American Society of Cinematographers YouTube joker Trailer 007 RT21 comic fast and furious Food Network christmas movies name the review miniseries Rocky Lifetime emmy awards The Purge 2015 comics Baby Yoda movies crime drama Discovery Channel thriller Reality Competition Mary Poppins Returns FXX political drama Pop TV Binge Guide Sony Pictures video on demand singing competition ratings Mystery remakes Vudu revenge TV Land romantic comedy aliens Turner spinoff 2017 dramedy E3 20th Century Fox Musical facebook Television Academy robots Ghostbusters Creative Arts Emmys what to watch based on movie TBS Sundance TV historical drama Bravo GLAAD TV renewals zombie cancelled television worst movies Martial Arts Avengers scary movies Awards Tour Masterpiece The Witch Elton John mission: impossible theme song Paramount Network travel obituary Captain marvel Apple TV+ Premiere Dates batman History San Diego Comic-Con ABC Podcast Disney Channel Disney The Walking Dead Marvel Television Women's History Month green book TCA diversity toy story Universal The Arrangement Tomatazos game of thrones Tubi Hulu Rocketman Mindy Kaling laika chucky Super Bowl screenings DC streaming service unscripted spider-man Fantasy Best and Worst news Christmas documentaries LGBT Logo cops Winners BAFTA stand-up comedy Mary Tyler Moore YouTube Premium USA TCA Winter 2020 TCA 2017 worst Film A&E YouTube Red Superheroes BBC America Polls and Games Mudbound Syfy vampires OWN police drama Esquire Amazon Prime Video Holidays USA Network award winner serial killer blockbuster hispanic Television Critics Association witnail politics Disney streaming service El Rey rotten universal monsters Cosplay Musicals Grammys TCA Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Heroines Ellie Kemper BET stoner Apple Trivia GoT cancelled Star Trek Sci-Fi richard e. Grant classics CNN See It Skip It Character Guide Crunchyroll dogs Hallmark versus anthology Marathons Peacock transformers TIFF Nat Geo children's TV Writers Guild of America blaxploitation hollywood Hallmark Christmas movies Summer disaster Emmys Countdown cooking adventure A24 discovery 2019 elevated horror Amazon Studios Cartoon Network Sneak Peek ABC Family critics Warner Bros. Opinion directors Year in Review Spectrum Originals Epix Schedule game show spain RT History Britbox criterion zero dark thirty Arrowverse Horror renewed TV shows YA space kids superhero Brie Larson IFC Music breaking bad Acorn TV golden globes GIFs cars BBC Travel Channel supernatural dceu Western zombies biography cartoon talk show doctor who VICE Photos OneApp Pride Month slashers 21st Century Fox Trophy Talk 72 Emmy Awards reboot Apple TV Plus stop motion APB 24 frames crossover Sundance composers best 2018 MSNBC comedies Lionsgate Winter TV Superheroe DGA Country casting Extras all-time Pop technology Nominations MCU Shondaland spy thriller psycho IFC Films Nickelodeon sitcom Fall TV ghosts Freeform President free movies Comedy Central binge VOD Showtime Animation asian-american finale Crackle harry potter Dark Horse Comics Thanksgiving Sundance Now screen actors guild HBO Watching Series dragons docudrama crime parents HBO Max New York Comic Con Black Mirror social media Netflix Emmy Nominations WGN BET Awards ESPN jamie lee curtis Pixar Marvel Studios Action CBS 71st Emmy Awards documentary latino Classic Film Infographic period drama werewolf Marvel FX crime thriller Lifetime Christmas movies concert festival hist Comic Book canceled TV shows National Geographic anime CMT Rom-Com SundanceTV DirecTV sequels Reality mutant Stephen King venice E! Election Rock comiccon Video Games cancelled TV shows Cannes Teen psychological thriller Adult Swim First Reviews WarnerMedia Tarantino nature Kids & Family scorecard Anna Paquin Pirates HBO Go TLC sequel animated movie true crime Box Office teaser First Look war TV independent X-Men Holiday NYCC strong female leads nfl franchise DC Comics halloween natural history PBS indiana jones CW Seed TNT Family justice league Certified Fresh Tumblr Mary poppins sports festivals 45 PlayStation cinemax Amazon Prime streaming sag awards Comics on TV BBC One dc Comedy Netflix Christmas movies Calendar VH1 Song of Ice and Fire toronto Film Festival Paramount south america series Walt Disney Pictures book Quiz mockumentary Red Carpet television Starz 4/20 Disney Plus Pet Sematary canceled DC Universe 2020 ITV medical drama football Interview TruTV 2016 cats