Cannes 2009: The Tomato Report - The White Ribbon Stuns Critics

Michael Haneke starts rumbles of Palme d’Or honours.

by | May 22, 2009 | Comments

Wednesday night’s screening of The White Ribbon left the Cannes crowds shocked and stunned, and seems to have impressed every critic in attendance, with the film achieving 100% on the Tomatometer after nine reviews.

Directed by festival favourite Michael Haneke, the film follows the trials and tribulations of a Protestant village in northern Germany on the eve of World War I. Shot in beautiful black and white and performed by an incredible ensemble cast, the film has been roundly praised for is sensitive portrayal of some pretty shocking material.

Variety’s Todd McCarthy is certainly a fan, writing that the film has “an absolute confidence and mastery of its own cinematic language, and the performances Haneke elicits from his first-rate cast, particularly the children, are eerily perfect.”

Cannes 2009
The White Ribbon

The Telegraph’s Sukdev Sandu concurs, stating “this is – by Haneke’s normally icy standards – a surprisingly affecting forensic study of social breakdown.”

What plot there is in the film revolves around a series of mysterious accidents taking place in the village, and Time Out’s Dave Calhoun claims that while the perpetrator of the crimes remains a mystery, that doesn’t really matter. “Once the film comes to a close,” he writes, “You might be asking the same questions as early on: why are we watching these people? Why do they behave as they do? Who is behind a series of crimes they suffer? But, by then, you’ve been presented with a portrait of a place that is so rich, so detailed and so full of telling relationships and behaviour that you feel you have gained an understanding of the very essence of these people.”

Cannes 2009
Haneke’s film has critics talking Palme d’Or

And while Variety’s Todd McCarthy calls it “a difficult film to embrace,” he nevertheless states that the narrative “goes beyond its general analysis of humanity to implicitly suggest some tendencies in the German character and culture that could point to certain developments in the subsequent three decades.”

Where it stands in terms of winning the Palme d’Or remains to be seen however. The film faces stiff competition from early favourites The Prophet, Fish Tank, Bright Star and the like, although Heat’s Charles Gant believes it has a chance. “I think it’s a mug’s game trying to second-guess what the jury will decide,” he says “But Haneke has never won the award before, and it’s definitely a strong film.”

Tag Cloud

President Pixar Star Trek films Showtime Hallmark free movies Year in Review Disney+ Disney Plus Drama Crackle cops MTV screen actors guild Logo Universal Super Bowl Animation Mudbound ESPN Horror American Society of Cinematographers El Rey 2015 Podcast TNT technology Comic Book Reality series stop motion First Look comiccon strong female leads A24 crime Peacock FXX HBO Go reviews YouTube Lionsgate comics adaptation Tumblr reboot TBS joker Marvel Reality Competition Hulu streaming casting TCA Premiere Dates TV Film Festival CMT stand-up comedy VICE worst BET Awards USA rotten politics cancelled TV shows TIFF Classic Film miniseries dramedy 71st Emmy Awards Action Cartoon Network Masterpiece Funimation crossover Spectrum Originals facebook satire romantic comedy 2017 FX Schedule Anna Paquin Country TV Land Disney a nightmare on elm street serial killer what to watch Amazon Prime Video Ghostbusters spy thriller MSNBC APB adventure tv talk Rom-Com Marathons revenge Pirates DC Comics CBS south america movie Holiday Baby Yoda Apple TV+ natural history critics Lifetime Nominations LGBT renewed TV shows 21st Century Fox GoT video on demand anime 2016 cars period drama MCU dc child's play spider-man Marvel Television documentary ratings zombies die hard superhero sag awards documentaries Disney Plus mutant Opinion video BAFTA elevated horror obituary sports batman cooking Countdown Columbia Pictures disaster Writers Guild of America Biopics Esquire TCA Winter 2020 PBS asian-american The Purge talk show TV renewals E3 BBC America witnail cinemax thriller nbcuniversal Black Mirror cults social media Heroines Musicals travel news Brie Larson space Winter TV Endgame quibi HBO christmas movies TCA Awards Summer nature BBC One Vudu binge GLAAD Turner Classic Movies canceled Interview cancelled TV series Netflix Disney streaming service Mystery finale psycho IFC Family hollywood GIFs TCA 2017 Pet Sematary cancelled television DC Universe crime thriller See It Skip It fast and furious true crime book Quiz golden globes criterion teaser 24 frames Food Network OneApp zero dark thirty Polls and Games television RT21 stoner Emmy Nominations Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Teen Academy Awards WGN movies Best and Worst doctor who Comics on TV Hear Us Out 2020 DGA Grammys Election Travel Channel DC streaming service Shudder laika USA Network Epix Watching Series transformers Discovery Channel spanish language halloween Music Fox News Nat Geo aliens Awards harry potter dark franchise vampires Dark Horse Comics Creative Arts Emmys Kids & Family latino DirecTV Musical Mary Tyler Moore game show medical drama Trailer breaking bad Trivia versus sitcom Oscars Martial Arts blaxploitation diversity richard e. Grant Thanksgiving independent spain Adult Swim docudrama spinoff Pride Month crime drama Box Office Infographic 72 Emmy Awards Ovation HBO Max hispanic Comedy Central romance Captain marvel Extras The Arrangement PlayStation Spring TV San Diego Comic-Con Pop Sundance political drama Comedy directors dceu screenings concert all-time ABC Syfy Acorn TV Toys Sneak Peek unscripted Rock cancelled Winners TCM Valentine's Day 2018 emmy awards ABC Family Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt RT History National Geographic FOX Sci-Fi Amazon Studios Fall TV award winner E! supernatural Cosplay biography green book NBC Emmys Photos mockumentary Nickelodeon game of thrones parents police drama CNN Crunchyroll 4/20 Marvel Studios LGBTQ AMC cats Mary poppins Television Critics Association comic boxoffice slashers psychological thriller Black History Month SDCC Tubi BET Ellie Kemper war blockbuster justice league New York Comic Con Western Arrowverse comedies Sundance Now Elton John Spike mission: impossible 45 Sony Pictures Walt Disney Pictures YouTube Premium Rocky TLC sequel dragons kids Film festivals best ghosts chucky Tarantino Video Games First Reviews Netflix Christmas movies Star Wars Warner Bros. Tomatazos ITV Superheroes The CW OWN Starz CW Seed YA toy story Superheroe robots canceled TV shows SXSW Binge Guide Turner hist VH1 History rotten movies we love Song of Ice and Fire Cannes VOD Amazon Prime Bravo universal monsters Freeform 007 Red Carpet Lucasfilm discovery Disney Channel IFC Films Apple Chernobyl The Witch Pop TV 2019 composers Women's History Month TruTV animated science fiction Rocketman Paramount Certified Fresh twilight CBS All Access Paramount Network Shondaland name the review theme song Amazon YouTube Red indiana jones based on movie 20th Century Fox dogs Avengers Britbox jamie lee curtis The Walking Dead FX on Hulu PaleyFest BBC zombie Calendar WarnerMedia X-Men foreign Character Guide Mindy Kaling Apple TV Plus Fantasy Trophy Talk children's TV anthology SundanceTV indie Television Academy NYCC Set visit werewolf Mary Poppins Returns Lifetime Christmas movies Christmas scary movies Sundance TV cartoon Awards Tour historical drama A&E singing competition Stephen King Holidays classics Hallmark Christmas movies