Bohemian Rhapsody Is the Worst-Reviewed Golden Globe Winner in 33 Years

The Fresh-bottomed Queen biopic's surprise win also reveals some surprising stats.

by | January 7, 2019 | Comments

(Photo by Alex Bailey / TM & copyright © Twentieth Century Fox Film Corp. All rights reserved. /Courtesy Everett Collection)

The Golden Globes cemented its reputation as the biggest populist movie awards ceremony out there, last night awarding Green Book as Best Motion Picture (Musical or Comedy) and Bohemian Rhapsody as Best Motion Picture in the Drama category. (See full 2019 winners list.) Both movies have connected with theater audiences, through high CinemaScore grades and as revealed in their Rotten Tomatoes’ Audience Scores: 95% for Green, and 90% for Boho.

But look at the Tomatometers and different stories emerge. While Green Book‘s Certified Fresh 81% is in the same realm of its Audience Score, Bohemian Rhapsody struggled to even be Fresh. The film was Rotten for a significant amount of time as reviews came in prior to release, before finally settling on the just-Fresh 62%.

And now it’s won the Golden Globe for Best Picture. (In Drama, and not Musical/Comedy, but that’s been another story entirely.) A cursory glance over the decade’s past Best Picture – Drama winners reveals a gallery of Certified Fresh films, where something like The Revenant‘s 79% is a precipitous drop. But now with Bohemian Rhapsody officially in the club, its 62% Tomatometer makes it the lowest-rated movie to take top honors in either Drama or Musical/Comedy in 33 years, since Out of Africa, which rides a parlous 60%. The infamously staid Robert Redford and Meryl Streep joint won Best Picture – Drama at the 1986 ceremony, while Prizzi’s Honor took Musical/Comedy.

So where would Boho Rhapso rank among all Best Motion Picture winners in Golden Globes’ 76-year history? Using our Adjusted Tomatometer (which includes several factors including release year and number of reviews), the Queen biopic places 128 out of 149 winners. In last place? 1953’s Biblical epic The Robe, which should think about covering up its 33% Tomatometer.

Want to learn more about Golden Globes history? Don’t stop us now, because here’s the full list of Golden Globe winners ranked by Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Columbia Pictures politics sitcom The Arrangement American Society of Cinematographers period drama miniseries justice league Trophy Talk crime Oscars Sneak Peek Valentine's Day Western Character Guide social media Dark Horse Comics Countdown LGBTQ Pet Sematary San Diego Comic-Con Set visit Fox News Rom-Com dramedy Kids & Family singing competition Marathons Teen Nickelodeon The CW Mindy Kaling thriller 24 frames Mudbound sequel Horror cults transformers Grammys witnail cats See It Skip It casting Cannes Extras CNN dragons New York Comic Con spider-man nature adaptation MSNBC HBO 007 GIFs President Showtime FXX Sci-Fi dceu zero dark thirty streaming Musicals cooking game show Marvel Ovation aliens DGA Quiz ABC Family Nat Geo VICE FX 2016 TCA Comic Book Creative Arts Emmys robots diversity Awards TCM docudrama Podcast science fiction travel SundanceTV finale crossover Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt spinoff USA Network Sony Pictures SDCC Opinion GLAAD Sundance Now Netflix space 2015 comiccon Pride Month Musical romance BBC IFC Best and Worst police drama 45 X-Men Country Rocky Walt Disney Pictures YouTube Red Britbox Starz 20th Century Fox Polls and Games Disney Shudder NYCC Calendar Vudu TNT TruTV BET Christmas toy story cinemax animated ratings Women's History Month blaxploitation unscripted Writers Guild of America Ghostbusters discovery Lifetime Superheroes sports anthology boxoffice FOX 2017 Drama E! mutant PaleyFest Action Song of Ice and Fire spy thriller based on movie Fall TV Pop Adult Swim Freeform disaster serial killer VH1 TIFF Amazon Prime Cosplay Trivia Disney Channel Rocketman TV Watching Series Mystery Tomatazos YouTube Premium Black Mirror 2018 true crime hist MTV Biopics Star Wars composers harry potter TCA 2017 Pixar Ellie Kemper anime Brie Larson talk show CMT Bravo elevated horror jamie lee curtis Sundance YA Toys Syfy Nominations GoT 21st Century Fox Schedule Martial Arts DC Universe Elton John Star Trek natural history what to watch Anna Paquin RT21 facebook doctor who zombies Tarantino Comedy Holidays Captain marvel BBC America Cartoon Network ABC Awards Tour Certified Fresh theme song biography Video Games green book Thanksgiving Food Network Spectrum Originals RT History political drama richard e. Grant Red Carpet NBC teaser First Look comic Rock Winter TV TBS ESPN Election CW Seed CBS All Access festivals Stephen King DC Comics Universal Shondaland WGN Photos Paramount Network Apple OWN Acorn TV Chernobyl PBS mockumentary Chilling Adventures of Sabrina DC streaming service television award winner technology vampires Lionsgate El Rey Premiere Dates SXSW Mary Poppins Returns A&E Summer Lucasfilm Spring TV Amazon Fantasy war Animation E3 Mary poppins Comics on TV Epix 2019 Year in Review Pirates Masterpiece adventure CBS Tumblr Spike crime drama Comedy Central strong female leads The Witch USA Emmys AMC Heroines Hulu National Geographic Interview psychological thriller Crackle Infographic crime thriller APB Reality Superheroe Paramount MCU Logo golden globes psycho Esquire historical drama Warner Bros. Winners Super Bowl Mary Tyler Moore History medical drama Music Trailer ITV TLC IFC Films Box Office Film Festival dc zombie Reality Competition TV Land binge supernatural DirecTV cops