Video Interviews

Best Toy Story Movie Yet?: The Ultimate Toy Story 4 Debate

Mark Ellis, Scott Mantz, Jacqueline Coley, and Alex Vo are split on Forky – and on how the fourth entry in the series stacks up against the rest.

by | June 22, 2019 | Comments

Toy Story 4 is now out in theaters, and there’s no doubt it’s super Fresh – Certified Fresh, in fact, at 98% on the Tomatometer. That’s on par for now with Toy Story 3, and just below the first two Toy Story movies, which are both at 100%. But the big question everyone is asking is: Tomatometer aside, is it the best entry in the series so far? Or maybe the worst? Or maybe somewhere in between? We decided to dive deep into the franchise and debate the new film’s merits and how it stacks up against its predecessors in a special episode of the spoiler-filled Rotten Tomatoes Aftershow. Host Mark Ellis is joined by Scott Mantz and Rotten Tomatoes’ own Jacqueline Coley and Alex Vo for the lively discussion that also covers who the best new characters are (Forky? Ducky? Bunny?), whether the movie will indeed be the last (doubtful), and whether the movie really needed to exist in the first place?

Toy Story 4 is in theaters now.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Thumbnail image: ©2019 Disney/Pixar. All Rights Reserved.

Tag Cloud

Lucasfilm The CW cartoon quibi james bond Character Guide Peacock fast and furious Sci-Fi toy story FOX TV BBC Hear Us Out Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt stop motion SundanceTV Dark Horse Comics Netflix television Toys criterion king kong Superheroes cancelled TV shows Song of Ice and Fire Mindy Kaling venice Musical stoner hidden camera diversity animated Britbox Martial Arts E3 Summer Paramount DC streaming service The Walt Disney Company VOD Fall TV GLAAD Freeform Pride Month WarnerMedia HBO scorecard Hulu historical drama women fresh TCA Awards trailers IFC Films nature Mudbound 2019 Shondaland travel Pet Sematary comedies christmas movies true crime Country Animation archives 4/20 Turner Amazon Best and Worst CBS All Access sequel APB spy thriller Fox Searchlight ITV PaleyFest TCA Sneak Peek 2017 TV Land Showtime composers MSNBC Shudder prank 2020 Kids & Family Binge Guide canceled TV shows Marvel Television jurassic park Set visit comic books Thanksgiving Reality NBC latino PlayStation Bravo disaster Mary Poppins Returns TruTV versus GIFs reviews Tarantino Sony Pictures cars Calendar Certified Fresh DGA police drama Trailer crossover dramedy OWN cancelled television miniseries spain game of thrones video on demand Grammys strong female leads Holiday Walt Disney Pictures ESPN cooking Valentine's Day popular ABC Signature FXX New York Comic Con Cannes Elton John Discovery Channel dc Music DirecTV Amazon Studios game show revenge TBS Baby Yoda nfl Universal satire Mary Tyler Moore Sundance Now french El Rey stand-up comedy unscripted Superheroe MTV news spider-man based on movie cinemax Paramount Plus classics cults BET ViacomCBS war The Walking Dead NYCC football romantic comedy batman anime TLC kong laika name the review elevated horror TV renewals cats ABC Family Anna Paquin VICE docuseries Western ghosts Nickelodeon rt archives south america Arrowverse Mary poppins 2021 concert Photos Legendary Star Trek blaxploitation Mystery blockbusters Horror discovery Women's History Month Crunchyroll hispanic Heroines Interview GoT finale AMC Infographic Comic Book Food Network australia Television Academy Columbia Pictures book adaptation Tomatazos Lifetime Christmas movies boxoffice teaser Captain marvel Disney+ Disney Plus Lionsgate Masterpiece DC Comics Drama YouTube Red documentary crime drama thriller BBC One blockbuster Video Games Watching Series Quiz zombies Television Critics Association 007 72 Emmy Awards anthology Chilling Adventures of Sabrina zero dark thirty jamie lee curtis razzies Fox News japanese Pixar Apple TV Plus documentaries Family National Geographic transformers period drama TNT dogs sequels Disney Channel MCU Crackle godzilla critics Marvel Vudu A24 science fiction asian-american FX on Hulu telelvision biography TCA 2017 free movies Rom-Com Box Office Oscars twilight green book natural history kaiju directors 99% DC Universe TCM sitcom Action Spring TV Amazon Prime Video politics golden globe awards Winter TV screenings worst movies Comedy 21st Century Fox foreign USA Network supernatural Fantasy Pop TV FX Extras Premiere Dates BAFTA A&E Polls and Games video 2016 45 comics deadpool Musicals italian The Arrangement CMT werewolf YA kids RT History YouTube child's play Lifetime witnail doctor who social media comiccon Pirates Reality Competition Writers Guild of America Tumblr black award winner binge a nightmare on elm street Spectrum Originals Amazon Prime spanish X-Men Countdown Avengers The Purge festival Christmas spanish language First Reviews Marvel Studios remakes USA best 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Brie Larson First Look halloween tv rom-coms Biopics dceu Trivia richard e. Grant cops spinoff Ovation Sundance reboot The Witch new star wars movies IFC joker worst rotten movies we love Opinion Ellie Kemper singing competition chucky 93rd Oscars WGN films emmy awards all-time TIFF Emmys Awards Tour HBO Go theme song CW Seed Academy Awards Chernobyl adventure History Turner Classic Movies CNN 20th Century Fox Holidays LGBT hollywood mutant BBC America Schedule tv talk LGBTQ Stephen King Warner Bros. E! Disney streaming service Endgame Teen crime thriller Disney series aliens psychological thriller mission: impossible breaking bad Black Mirror die hard movies Starz Emmy Nominations 71st Emmy Awards vampires justice league movie Ghostbusters Travel Channel ID Hallmark docudrama Alien technology psycho CBS Red Carpet 2018 RT21 facebook children's TV ratings Acorn TV Rocketman Pop hist Year in Review Hallmark Christmas movies renewed TV shows VH1 Rocky TCA Winter 2020 President Nominations crime Netflix Christmas movies space Logo romance universal monsters Super Bowl Broadway San Diego Comic-Con nbcuniversal serial killer Film Comedy Central superman boxing heist movie Comics on TV Black History Month rotten indiana jones canceled Apple PBS zombie American Society of Cinematographers Nat Geo SXSW political drama dark Winners what to watch medical drama indie ABC festivals Cosplay casting Esquire Syfy halloween The Academy sag awards OneApp Classic Film 24 frames harry potter Podcast Paramount Network Election Apple TV+ screen actors guild talk show cancelled Spike monster movies Creative Arts Emmys adaptation See It Skip It 2015 independent book sports YouTube Premium Marathons franchise parents SDCC mockumentary robots Sundance TV Star Wars superhero Film Festival TV One Epix pirates of the caribbean obituary Disney Plus cancelled TV series Cartoon Network slashers Awards comic scary movies Adult Swim Trophy Talk toronto golden globes Tubi HBO Max streaming Exclusive Video Rock dragons BET Awards Funimation