Video Interviews

Best Toy Story Movie Yet?: The Ultimate Toy Story 4 Debate

Mark Ellis, Scott Mantz, Jacqueline Coley, and Alex Vo are split on Forky – and on how the fourth entry in the series stacks up against the rest.

by | June 22, 2019 | Comments

Toy Story 4 is now out in theaters, and there’s no doubt it’s super Fresh – Certified Fresh, in fact, at 98% on the Tomatometer. That’s on par for now with Toy Story 3, and just below the first two Toy Story movies, which are both at 100%. But the big question everyone is asking is: Tomatometer aside, is it the best entry in the series so far? Or maybe the worst? Or maybe somewhere in between? We decided to dive deep into the franchise and debate the new film’s merits and how it stacks up against its predecessors in a special episode of the spoiler-filled Rotten Tomatoes Aftershow. Host Mark Ellis is joined by Scott Mantz and Rotten Tomatoes’ own Jacqueline Coley and Alex Vo for the lively discussion that also covers who the best new characters are (Forky? Ducky? Bunny?), whether the movie will indeed be the last (doubtful), and whether the movie really needed to exist in the first place?

Toy Story 4 is in theaters now.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Thumbnail image: ©2019 Disney/Pixar. All Rights Reserved.

Tag Cloud

Action disaster Hulu best LGBTQ Reality MCU sitcom parents period drama OneApp Toys Video Games 71st Emmy Awards theme song Amazon anime spanish language Emmys cancelled Trophy Talk CBS Kids & Family name the review natural history Election spain BBC One hist Rocky Television Academy Shondaland 2020 laika Mystery First Look Funimation movies singing competition Bravo Shudder south america mutant Sneak Peek Holidays Lifetime Christmas movies NYCC Anna Paquin The CW TIFF comedies Writers Guild of America Ghostbusters dceu Sci-Fi Endgame National Geographic Trivia 4/20 video TV Land franchise VH1 romance TCM Ellie Kemper Character Guide Apple TV+ President Star Trek Epix Sundance TV VOD harry potter Song of Ice and Fire series Sony Pictures See It Skip It Film Festival joker Country cars ABC television Tubi emmy awards HBO Go canceled TV shows Heroines Animation Best and Worst award winner casting PBS Emmy Nominations Pirates Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt HBO Max supernatural The Walking Dead stop motion 45 Music Rocketman strong female leads Crackle Countdown composers Black History Month Disney streaming service BBC America Amazon Prime Video First Reviews blockbuster RT History diversity facebook Trailer Masterpiece child's play IFC Films Tarantino comic Spike Tumblr psycho Film dramedy scary movies book Chilling Adventures of Sabrina free movies Universal 20th Century Fox DC streaming service TCA Winter 2020 batman latino all-time twilight movie directors Mary poppins Biopics The Purge GLAAD die hard Columbia Pictures FX Chernobyl Disney Calendar Disney Channel Showtime screen actors guild canceled Marvel Television Turner doctor who BET ESPN Adult Swim docudrama psychological thriller DC Comics talk show Winter TV Paramount Network TCA Awards dark BET Awards true crime MTV Hear Us Out hispanic Television Critics Association Hallmark Interview space obituary Superheroe Hallmark Christmas movies blaxploitation Apple TV Plus unscripted ITV Mary Poppins Returns biography spider-man Nominations chucky game show teaser politics Year in Review USA Thanksgiving FX on Hulu streaming children's TV documentary Binge Guide Acorn TV Lucasfilm sag awards Awards PaleyFest TLC indiana jones Horror christmas movies what to watch Fall TV FOX quibi A&E police drama The Witch Polls and Games satire stand-up comedy hollywood VICE PlayStation Infographic Red Carpet DC Universe Baby Yoda Cannes WGN spy thriller breaking bad USA Network Lifetime Set visit Crunchyroll witnail critics Warner Bros. Avengers BAFTA DirecTV technology Logo Cartoon Network Mary Tyler Moore Certified Fresh SXSW indie documentaries Fox News news Rom-Com cats mission: impossible screenings mockumentary Captain marvel crime Quiz TCA 2017 Valentine's Day Teen cults zombie Black Mirror tv talk Arrowverse Family A24 Esquire Oscars thriller BBC Paramount cancelled TV series E3 DGA ratings anthology foreign Pet Sematary rotten San Diego Comic-Con ABC Family Disney Plus Comedy Central Mindy Kaling Pop TV Awards Tour Sundance golden globes crime drama CNN Musicals Classic Film HBO Comics on TV Schedule vampires Cosplay universal monsters sports Watching Series binge a nightmare on elm street Starz History Elton John RT21 APB comiccon Musical toy story E! Nickelodeon X-Men Syfy films GoT nature Stephen King Marvel WarnerMedia nbcuniversal 2016 dragons Creative Arts Emmys game of thrones Premiere Dates 24 frames jamie lee curtis Travel Channel El Rey CBS All Access Ovation YouTube Premium Pop Lionsgate Summer adventure The Arrangement Comedy 72 Emmy Awards IFC Walt Disney Pictures sequels renewed TV shows TNT Martial Arts romantic comedy TCA Sundance Now Vudu YouTube Red Extras 21st Century Fox independent TBS science fiction travel cops festivals green book CW Seed Pride Month discovery Amazon Prime Holiday serial killer animated comics Super Bowl cartoon Freeform SundanceTV sequel reboot Discovery Channel Superheroes aliens miniseries 2018 YouTube dc concert cinemax transformers Fantasy robots cancelled television Box Office Brie Larson Opinion Reality Competition Western GIFs richard e. Grant justice league Pixar AMC SDCC halloween based on movie fast and furious asian-american werewolf NBC Christmas worst crime thriller boxoffice versus Photos Drama reviews cancelled TV shows YA TV renewals Netflix criterion historical drama social media FXX Rock Dark Horse Comics American Society of Cinematographers MSNBC New York Comic Con Disney+ Disney Plus Turner Classic Movies Food Network ghosts Marvel Studios kids 2019 TruTV Mudbound cooking crossover Grammys classics medical drama political drama Winners Academy Awards Spectrum Originals dogs Podcast superhero zombies 2015 Britbox Star Wars Peacock Netflix Christmas movies 2017 war Tomatazos Amazon Studios spinoff adaptation OWN video on demand zero dark thirty Women's History Month 007 rotten movies we love Nat Geo TV elevated horror Marathons CMT Spring TV stoner LGBT Comic Book Apple slashers revenge finale