Amazon Pilot Season 4: What the Critics Think

Are any of the 7 new pilots 'Prime' material?

by | February 2, 2015 | Comments

For the third time, Amazon Studios released a batch of pilot episodes whose fate as fully-produced seasons of television on Amazon Prime will be determined by, among other things, audience member response. With seven original series hopefuls this time around, we take a look at what the critics think. Could there be another Transparent in the works? Not likely, but some of these shows still have a fighting chance — and we’re guessing that you still have about two weeks to watch them and weigh in.

Salem Rogers: Model of the Year 1998  

What It’s About: When 1998’s supermodel of the year, Salem Rogers (Leslie Bibb), finally gets the boot from her rehab facility after a decade, she reconnects with her former assistant (Rachael Dratch), who hopes to write an anti-bullying book based on the abusive relationship with her narcissistic, foul-mouthed boss.

What Critics Think: Even with its barrage of cliched insults, there is enough genuine shock value and funny chemistry between Dratch and Bibb to make Salem Rogers entertaining.


What It’s About: In Cocked, Wade Paxson (Brian Dennehy), the patriarch of a firearms empire, employs his hedonistic son Grady (Jason Lee) and do-gooder son Richard (Sam Trammell) to help take down a competing gun company run by Wade’s brother.

What Critics Think: Dennehy, Lee, and Trammell make the most of their characters, but the predictability of the story and the inability to address gun culture in America make Cocked a misfire.

Down Dog  

What It’s About: Logan Wood (Josh Casaubon) is an affable pothead-turned-yogi who skates through life on his good looks and laid back charm — often to the dismay of his capable female co-workers.

What Critics Think: Though pleasantly breezy, Down Dog is neither funny enough, satirical enough, nor lively enough to be more than a tired wink at New Age stoners.

Mad Dogs  

What It’s About: Based on the U.K. series The Bill, Mad Dogs features four 40-somethings (Steve Zahn, Romany Malco, Michael Imperioli, and Ben Chaplin) who travel to Belize to visit their mysteriously successful friend (Billy Zane), when their frat-boy fantasy takes a wicked turn.

What Critics Think: Exciting twists aside, Mad Dogs mostly squanders its rich landscape and far-too-talented ensemble of actors to make stale midlife-crisis observations.

The Man in the High Castle  

What It’s About: Based on Philip K. Dick’s novel, The Man in the High Castle, this show of the same name tells an alternate history of the Axis Powers winning World War II and the resistance movement growing throughout America in the early ’60s.

What Critics Think: By executive producer Ridley Scott, The Man in the High Castle is unlike anything else on TV, with an immediately engrossing plot driven by quickly developed characters in a fully realized post-WWII dystopia.

The New Yorker Presents  

What It’s About: The magazine come to life in docudrama form, The New Yorker Presents is a mix of profiles, cartoons, short films, and poetry.

What Critics Think: Though it can never live up to its parent publication in terms of purpose and cachet, many of the segments in The New Yorker Presents are classy, polished, and culturally educational.

Point of Honor  

What It’s About: Carlton Cuse takes on the Civil War by portraying a Virginian family who struggles with the idea of slavery while still fighting for the Confederacy.

What Critics Think: Anachronistic, schlocky, and downright offensive, Point of Honor mistreats an important historical subject with utter absurdity.

Have you watched any of the new Amazon pilots? Which ones would you like to see go to series? Let us know in the comments below.

Tag Cloud

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina hispanic RT History CW Seed cops BBC America A24 sports LGBT streaming based on movie Polls and Games Food Network mutant DC Comics Election Ovation CNN composers robots Sneak Peek Showtime Family disaster Box Office Ghostbusters cancelled TV series Musicals Mindy Kaling Avengers Classic Film versus Pet Sematary 71st Emmy Awards Amazon Prime Video Apple TV+ Netflix El Rey Thanksgiving OWN series Sci-Fi Mary Tyler Moore 007 dc Tumblr Superheroes spider-man E! Emmy Nominations Podcast crime thriller comiccon Drama APB Super Bowl south america Arrowverse 24 frames Brie Larson YA Teen diversity Baby Yoda FXX Discovery Channel police drama Women's History Month game show Trivia Pixar Mary poppins Amazon Prime Martial Arts Summer animated Turner Classic Movies Video Games Hallmark binge singing competition PaleyFest revenge Reality Competition sequel stand-up comedy Cartoon Network GLAAD MCU CBS All Access Esquire transformers Musical Crackle comics DGA TV Land Walt Disney Pictures Spectrum Originals Quiz canceled Photos Hulu Nat Geo Awards Tour blaxploitation FX slashers festivals Tomatazos boxoffice Lifetime Christmas movies aliens Anna Paquin medical drama Valentine's Day Netflix Christmas movies justice league thriller Dark Horse Comics 2020 ESPN Winter TV Rocky OneApp cartoon hist Animation Rocketman batman Red Carpet sag awards Lionsgate Acorn TV Pride Month Comic Book Creative Arts Emmys History television romance dragons RT21 independent Film name the review cancelled TV shows kids docudrama Crunchyroll WGN Ellie Kemper jamie lee curtis Elton John X-Men San Diego Comic-Con casting CBS christmas movies talk show Lucasfilm war Holidays 2017 BET latino blockbuster Tubi USA Network Shondaland Fantasy Premiere Dates travel IFC cults ghosts science fiction mockumentary finale Mary Poppins Returns MSNBC Action USA Infographic Spring TV facebook YouTube Premium anthology cancelled FOX Pop 21st Century Fox Captain marvel E3 HBO Max Vudu natural history American Society of Cinematographers WarnerMedia BBC adaptation children's TV TV video Paramount Music crime Calendar Best and Worst Marvel Television Fall TV adventure Spike game of thrones Paramount Network psychological thriller Country crossover Star Wars See It Skip It Trailer President golden globes DC streaming service social media romantic comedy Watching Series TCM Warner Bros. AMC 2018 reboot IFC Films Stephen King Universal toy story Adult Swim dceu Extras Mudbound indie zombies TruTV 2015 documentary Nominations New York Comic Con politics GoT Cosplay Marathons spain teaser Disney streaming service Nickelodeon Set visit period drama doctor who movies Columbia Pictures Academy Awards Television Academy Starz Comedy TBS nature Marvel Studios 20th Century Fox National Geographic TCA VICE Logo TNT Character Guide Grammys discovery Holiday Oscars cats Lifetime Epix Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Shudder Disney+ Disney Plus Emmys The Walking Dead psycho TLC Hallmark Christmas movies Sony Pictures richard e. Grant Masterpiece Year in Review witnail 2016 The Purge miniseries ABC Family NBC breaking bad free movies Awards what to watch serial killer spanish language Sundance Now Syfy historical drama Cannes Superheroe YouTube Red book Heroines Comedy Central anime SundanceTV unscripted tv talk TCA Winter 2020 comic cancelled television cars Countdown elevated horror NYCC Christmas Disney Channel Toys Fox News ABC HBO Freeform directors dramedy CMT biography Tarantino Western Black Mirror Amazon award winner Sundance The Arrangement Film Festival vampires DirecTV ratings TCA 2017 SDCC Apple rotten movies we love sitcom Interview werewolf canceled TV shows A&E Britbox Pirates halloween true crime DC Universe Schedule harry potter Disney Plus 2019 zero dark thirty spinoff technology crime drama The Witch Reality zombie GIFs Apple TV Plus Bravo Writers Guild of America TV renewals TIFF 45 renewed TV shows Mystery Chernobyl Rock Turner Disney Biopics Song of Ice and Fire Star Trek Rom-Com MTV Horror ITV Kids & Family Peacock supernatural foreign SXSW Opinion Binge Guide Certified Fresh joker quibi theme song The CW LGBTQ Comics on TV cooking Marvel screenings strong female leads First Look First Reviews political drama Winners PBS Sundance TV cinemax green book VH1 YouTube Endgame spy thriller screen actors guild space Trophy Talk