A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood First Reviews: Tom Hanks is "Perfect," "Transporting" As Mr. Rogers

Critics at the Toronto International Film Festival say Tom Hanks is as good as you're hoping as Fred Rogers in a smart, moving new film that creeps up on you.

by | September 8, 2019 | Comments

Is it even possible to make a bad movie about Mr. Rogers? Arriving on the heels of the successful 2018 documentary Won’t You Be My Neighbor?, biopic A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood (2019) 95% comes equipped with the too-perfect casting of Tom Hanks as children’s television icon Fred Rogers. The very first critics who saw the film couldn’t help but be charmed by the movie and Hanks’ portrayal, as represented in the first reviews out of the Toronto International Film Festival. Viewers were in tears at the premiere and calling it one of the actors’ best, which says a lot, of course. (Note, these are the very first reviews for the film, drawn mostly from the movie’s world premiere at the festival; as the movie is screened in the next few days more early reviews will come in and we will add those to this article as they’re published.)

Here’s what critics are saying about A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood:

Let’s get this out of the way: Is Hanks perfect as Rogers?

“There’s no question that Hanks is perfect in the part…people will relax into the movie so much that they’ll forget they’re watching an impersonation.” – Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter

“Hanks’ body language is at once stoic and vulnerable, the pace of his speech as Fred is slow, slower than most people. But the actor brings so much focus that it’s impossible to find a reason to move faster, if it would mean missing a single moment spent in his company.” – Ella Kemp, The Playlist

“Hanks’ cuddly pedigree means he was born to play Rogers, and he immerses himself in the role.” – Eric Kohn, IndieWire

“Hanks isn’t just good — he’s transporting.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“It’s hard to imagine that his pitch-perfect channeling of Rogers’ magnificent and slightly unsettling calm won’t put him in the thick of a supporting-actor race.” – Steve Pond, The Wrap

“There’s a sweetness to the performance that never veers towards saccharine; Hanks consistently strays away from any sort of cliches to find deeper meaning.” – Jordan Ruimy, World of Reel

A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood

(Photo by Lacey Terrell)

Is this just a standard biopic?

“This is no straightforward biopic, and for that we can probably be glad…it’s the rare biopic that doesn’t wander into predictability or cheese, or both.” – Sara Stewart, New York Post

“It’s absolutely not a biopic…it’s a two-hour therapy session about the relationships we have with our parents and learning to cope with death, with Hanks’ Fred Rogers as a conduit.” – Mike Ryan, Uproxx

And it’s not even just about Mr. Rogers?

“This movie isn’t about Rogers himself: He takes a backseat here, which should worry anybody who might face Hanks for a best-supporting-actor Oscar.” – Brian Truitt, USA Today

“Perhaps this is the only way to really make a film about Fred Rogers — by making it about the people whose lives he touched.” – Hannah Goodhead, Little White Lies

“The film is smart enough to not get us too close to Rogers. Look, you just can’t. He’s almost too otherworldly.” – Mike Ryan, Uproxx

“Some viewers may be disappointed this film isn’t all about Fred Rogers, but after a bit of reflection, I think less may be better.” – Sara Stewart, New York Post

How is Marielle Heller’s direction?

“Heller’s filmmaking is a patchwork quilt of influences from Mr Rogers himself. She uses an imagined episode of the show as a framing device; takes musical inspiration from Rogers’ own compositions and puts a miniature Vogel in rabbit ears, enforcing a bonding moment with Mr Rogers’ puppets.” – Wendy Ide, Screen Daily

“Heller, as she proved in Can You Ever Forgive Me?, has a gift for taking straightforward scenes and flooding them with emotion.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“Heller does take a few ambitious swings, and they always come as a welcome surprise.” – Eric Kohn, IndieWire

“After her fantastic first two features, The Diary of a Teenage Girl and Can You Ever Forgive Me?, it’s a bit disappointing to see Heller taking on material with no edge at all.” – Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter

“[Heller gives] her audience some kind of recognizable knot in the stomach, one of nostalgia, one of gratitude and grace.” – Ella Kemp, The Playlist

“Having proven herself to be among the more empathetic directors working today, her equally understated delivery reaches the ethos of Rogers’ philosophy.” – Luke Parker, We Got This Covered

What about the screenplay?

“The script by the team of Micah Fitzerman-Blue and Noah Harpster serves up very little that you can’t guess after the first few minutes.” – Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter

“The script, by Micah Fitzerman-Blue and Noah Harpster, applies Rogers’ genial mode of address to present a prototypical case study of anger management. It’s not the most sophisticated device, but it positions Rogers above the drama with an ethereal glow that matches his otherworldly reputation, and lingers in his appeal.” – Eric Kohn, IndieWire

A Beautiful Day In the Neighborhood

(Photo by Lacey Terrell)

Should we expect to shed tears?

“When the film comes out, there won’t be a dry eye in the megaplexes of America.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“Suffice it to say that tears were flowing onscreen and off at Roy Thomson Hall in Toronto.” – Steve Pond, The Wrap

But does it get too sentimental?

“Heller sticks to understatement in a way that threatens to become dull or sappy but never does. What she pulls off here is a small, sweet miracle of sorts.” – Steve Pond, The Wrap

“In the hands of a lesser storyteller, [the film] would resort to cheap, maudlin devices…Heller, however, excels at pulling heartstrings from sturdy foundations” – Eric Kohn, IndieWire

Are the laughs to be had?

“…this film is indeed very funny, as investigative journalist Vogel chafes at the idea of a 400-word assignment to write about Rogers for a special issue devoted to heroes.” – Steve Pond, The Wrap

A Beautiful Day In the Neighborhood

(Photo by Lacey Terrell)

And How is Matthew Rhys?

“But it’s Rhys who dominates the film, with a fine, fractured performance as a man who can’t bring himself to forgive the sins of his father.” – Wendy Ide, Screen Daily

“Matthew Rhys triumphs as the jaded investigative journalist, fighting both his professional cynicism and deeply rooted resentment for his imperfect father… It’s a transformative performance, one that begins with stony bitterness and gives way to an emotionally naked revelation without ever losing an ounce of gravitas.” – Ella Kemp, The Playlist

Are there any issues with this Mr. Rogers tale?

Beautiful Day relies a bit too much on Rogers’ built-in appeal, but it exhibits a visible confidence about the rationale for staying within those bounds.” – Eric Kohn, IndieWire

“Visually, the film could have been sharper, with more color and luster.” – Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter

“…it won’t be for everyone. The laser-focussed niceness that was Mr Roger’s USP can seem a little disconcerting to those not accustomed to it. But even in territories where audiences are unfamiliar with Fred Rogers’ hokey appeal, the film’s humour, its amiable charm offensive and its gentle weirdness should disarm all but the most cynical.” – Wendy Ide, Screen Daily

Will A Beautiful Day In the Neighborhood make me a better person?

“Hanks’ all-in portrayal ought to snag him an Oscar nomination, and ideally will also inspire a little more kindness in all of us.” – Sara Stewart, New York Post

“Not only does [Rogers] cast his spell on Vogel but also on the audience watching the movie. You feel like a better and more determined person once end credits role.” – Jordan Ruimy, World of Reel

“If you do open yourself up, there’s something wonderful to find in this movie…you will learn more about yourself.” – Mike Ryan, Uproxx

“No one can be Mr Rogers, but at the same time, everyone can. All it takes is a little kindness to yourself, and a little kindness towards others.” – Hannah Goodhead, Little White Lies

“This grand episode is also one for us, too, to learn a lesson about forgiveness at a time when we might need it the most…It’s still Rogers’ neighborhood and we’re still learning from him.”- Brian Truitt, USA Today

A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival on September 7, 2019. It will be in theaters November 22, 2019.

Adjusted Score: 118425%
Critics Consensus: Much like the beloved TV personality that inspired it, A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood offers a powerfully affecting message about acceptance and understanding.
Synopsis: Lloyd Vogel is an investigative journalist who receives an assignment to profile Fred Rogers, aka Mr. Rogers. He approaches the... [More]
Directed By: Marielle Heller

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

NBA science fiction crime composers DirecTV Fox News kaiju quibi Legendary 79th Golden Globes Awards 2016 dceu book Schedule concert CBS posters book adaptation godzilla comic book movies ABC Signature Logo politics Polls and Games rt archives FX on Hulu Black History Month AMC Plus police drama Tomatazos 20th Century Fox Cannes 007 doctor who football GIFs mcc name the review ABC Family 1990s reviews mission: impossible HBO Max toy story genre ghosts archives Tags: Comedy Star Trek latino indiana jones nature Apple TV Plus First Reviews television classics Disney streaming Freeform 2017 Mary Poppins Returns free movies Drama Alien Comic Book kong Crunchyroll Film History San Diego Comic-Con Fall TV chucky documentary FOX sag awards golden globe awards 2019 satire Rom-Com Ovation Amazon Prime Video TCM movies docudrama HFPA Lionsgate anime cults The CW king arthur crime thriller Emmys dark golden globes Image Comics transformers Summer harry potter Comics on TV spanish Podcast Song of Ice and Fire Masterpiece 4/20 Quiz HBO art house comiccon DC streaming service Travel Channel live action cinemax Teen CW Seed award winner Chernobyl BBC America news scary halloween Disney Channel Endgame comic book movie MTV crime drama hollywood Emmy Nominations technology serial killer Spectrum Originals Sneak Peek tv talk sequels Apple Television Academy Pop TV RT History video Wes Anderson Universal Pictures japan VICE YouTube Kids & Family Netflix Christmas movies Christmas Valentine's Day revenge The Walking Dead dc independent ESPN Calendar Country ratings blockbuster A24 boxing new zealand BBC One scorecard what to watch spinoff adventure feel good thriller sopranos GLAAD trophy Classic Film vampires leaderboard FXX MSNBC Shondaland Action australia Showtime APB IMDb TV CMT fast and furious NBC Musicals critics Amazon stoner Acorn TV hist American Society of Cinematographers Winners Western Nat Geo south america rt labs critics edition sequel Awards Tour medical drama Academy Awards best streaming movies Animation festival social media saw Hear Us Out TCA 2017 Rocky Rocketman christmas movies Star Wars royal family New York Comic Con slasher talk show Tokyo Olympics RT21 critic resources cancelled TV series The Arrangement Shudder Music Awards marvel cinematic universe disaster suspense directors die hard Mudbound 2021 X-Men scary movies anthology spider-man Trivia basketball Peacock DGA A&E BET Awards wonder woman deadpool Bravo Winter TV comics popular crossover Comic-Con@Home 2021 renewed TV shows Sundance dreamworks TV renewals Pixar TCA Winter 2020 canceled Holiday TCA Awards TV Land Food Network justice league Interview Television Critics Association YouTube Red twilight Hallmark Christmas movies franchise Comedy Central jamie lee curtis debate Hollywood Foreign Press Association screen actors guild Syfy Lifetime nfl Turner Epix worst movies Nominations Vudu Film Festival Reality Competition spider-verse TNT emmy awards CNN breaking bad Brie Larson SundanceTV women President Sundance TV vs. jurassic park Crackle 2015 E3 NYCC dramedy 72 Emmy Awards ViacomCBS Chilling Adventures of Sabrina legend razzies rt labs spy thriller Holidays Best and Worst werewolf theme song boxoffice fresh remakes SDCC ID parents strong female leads Amazon Prime DC Comics Grammys Paramount Plus target Photos elevated horror TCA series CBS All Access laika Mindy Kaling Spike WarnerMedia sitcom Marvel Television Election Disney+ Disney Plus mockumentary action-comedy marvel comics stop motion scene in color PaleyFest batman Oscars El Rey video on demand Super Bowl comedies TV screenings finale foreign kids hidden camera Creative Arts Emmys ITV historical drama Exclusive Video BET young adult Mary Tyler Moore Warner Bros. Ellie Kemper TBS Pride Month romance Starz new star wars movies Lifetime Christmas movies children's TV james bond Mary poppins Comedy 24 frames gangster Stephen King nbcuniversal universal monsters TLC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Fantasy Character Guide cancelled TV shows Extras spanish language space asian-american 2018 supernatural Walt Disney Pictures festivals joker HBO Go halloween tv adaptation zero dark thirty cats teaser Paramount Network AMC worst hispanic SXSW miniseries PlayStation The Walt Disney Company monster movies heist movie Britbox Captain marvel Pet Sematary cancelled Certified Fresh mob 71st Emmy Awards films japanese telelvision reboot robots Toys Disney streaming service italian Baby Yoda binge discovery Biopics Turner Classic Movies pirates of the caribbean Premiere Dates Trophy Talk See It Skip It docuseries stand-up comedy Tarantino 45 cartoon based on movie true crime singing competition period drama Broadway Sony Pictures Netflix sports movie WGN Sundance Now toronto BAFTA Video Games witnail Fargo 2020 venice Hallmark trailers The Academy TV One adenture unscripted aliens USA Network Adult Swim cars biography casting VH1 new york OneApp psycho Musical LGBTQ 93rd Oscars Trailer biopic rotten know your critic Prime Video Superheroes romantic comedy 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards E! Apple TV+ comic books black olympics Martial Arts Lucasfilm psychological thriller Horror Marathons king kong Avengers Ghostbusters Family Dark Horse Comics National Geographic obituary spain IFC Films superman mutant animated Marvel indie The Purge french The Witch Funimation game of thrones Box Office Discovery Channel 99% Fox Searchlight VOD Superheroe game show diversity Red Carpet Hulu GoT Neflix TV movies rotten movies we love Set visit ABC Mystery FX TIFF all-time blockbusters rom-coms Pop Esquire Women's History Month Instagram Live lord of the rings documentaries LGBT richard e. Grant criterion Marvel Studios Thanksgiving travel Columbia Pictures 21st Century Fox zombie Paramount cancelled television YouTube Premium aapi PBS natural history 73rd Emmy Awards Writers Guild of America versus IFC Arrowverse YA Universal dexter political drama facebook slashers black comedy Pacific Islander USA canceled TV shows BBC Year in Review Nickelodeon Anna Paquin prank Amazon Studios Spring TV child's play Binge Guide Sci-Fi First Look Cartoon Network cooking war Reality DC Universe MCU Opinion high school dragons dogs Heroines Black Mirror Rock Pirates live event Watching Series hispanic heritage month 90s international Tubi green book Countdown TruTV a nightmare on elm street comic cops zombies Disney Plus superhero OWN blaxploitation Elton John Cosplay Tumblr Infographic