Critics Consensus

Tomatometer Watch: Will Harry Be Deathly Or Hallowed?

Potter 7 Swings At The Series' Unbroken Record.

by | November 12, 2010 | Comments


[tomatometer]MovieID=770672991[/tomatometer]

Another year, another Harry Potter movie — and it’s not over yet, with Warner Bros. cleverly halving the final installment of the series to ensure audiences will be back to do it all again come next summer. But for now we have Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part I, which marks the seventh film of J.K. Rowling’s publishing phenomenon, and the beginning of the end of one of history’s most successful movie franchises.

To date, every chapter of the series has earned a solid “fresh” on the Tomatometer; despite a general preference for some films over others, the lowest score has been 78 per cent — for both 2001’s fledgling Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone and 2007’s Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (curiously, the two highest-grossing movies in the series). Alfonso Cuarón’s Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004) remains the best-loved among critics at 90 per cent, while last year’s Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince conjured up a healthy 83 per cent.

How do the critics see the latest Potter? Reaction thus far seems predicated on the knowledge that this is the opening half of a much larger film, and that perhaps the bigger picture will emerge with Part II‘s release.

IGN UK says “it’s by no means a bad Harry Potter movie,” but adds that “the overriding feeling is that it’s an incomplete one”; Variety suggests it’s “suffused with a profound sense of solitude and loss”; while the UK’s Independent offers, “your appetite will be whetted for what promises to be an almighty showdown.”

Still, questions over the validity of splitting the film in two linger. Empire is eager to move ahead, calling to “bring on part 2”, and Total Film are more direct, arguing that “there’s absolutely no artistic justification for a two-movie split.” And then, for those who never liked the series anyway, there’s The Guardian: “It’s hard to mourn the demise of a franchise that was never more than half-alive to begin with.” Ouch.

So, what’s you guess for Deathly Hallows‘ T-meter? Can it top the best of the series, or will it lower the bar?


As reviews continue to roll in all week, be sure to check back here and on Harry Potter‘s page to keep up on the latest reviews and Tomatometer scores.


Tag Cloud

First Look Video Games adventure Teen Dark Horse Comics Comedy Central Comedy CBS All Access Super Bowl Disney IFC Awards TCA Fall TV Country Reality based on movie Hulu USA Photos Musicals CMT Mindy Kaling ESPN 2016 serial killer History E3 TruTV Pirates CNN TLC Rocky TV NYCC Trailer Best and Worst Calendar dramedy technology MSNBC Winners political drama Winter TV Superheroes Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Fantasy Certified Fresh Character Guide GIFs harry potter Pop SundanceTV politics TNT Reality Competition period drama police drama TBS Musical A&E discovery X-Men composers TCM cinemax Holidays VICE Sneak Peek Toys Tomatazos American Society of Cinematographers Crackle cooking biography Extras Showtime LGBTQ Starz 24 frames 2017 Year in Review Grammys war Valentine's Day Nickelodeon Emmys Fox News VH1 historical drama science fiction Syfy NBC Animation Spring TV E! Disney Channel transformers GLAAD ABC Family SDCC Summer President sitcom Trivia MTV aliens crime drama Rom-Com comiccon diversity crime thriller Logo RT History AMC Comic Book Rock Watching Series Polls and Games social media FOX APB singing competition Sci-Fi 007 HBO docudrama ABC sports Premiere Dates Mary Tyler Moore Adult Swim The CW Schedule thriller Bravo Ellie Kemper Esquire zombie Biopics PaleyFest Ghostbusters supernatural Music cops TV Land Horror Red Carpet Star Wars Infographic Countdown Mystery PBS DirecTV FX Amazon Cartoon Network psycho YA crime Masterpiece Sundance DC Comics Box Office vampires TIFF Netflix Star Trek OWN The Arrangement Kids & Family boxoffice CBS Drama FXX BET TCA 2017 Oscars Martial Arts Lifetime BBC Cosplay Universal Nominations Thanksgiving El Rey Marathons Opinion Marvel GoT Writers Guild of America WGN Nat Geo Freeform Podcast Food Network Election BBC America ITV Set visit travel Lionsgate Tumblr Action 2015 Interview