Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Back-Up Plan Is Second Rate

Plus, The Losers is fun but mindless, and Oceans is visually stunning.

by | April 23, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got pregnancy pratfalls (The Back-up Plan, starring Jennifer Lopez and Alex O’Loughlin); mercenary mayhem (The Losers, starring Jeffrey Dean Morgan and Zoe Saldana); and aquatic animals (The Disney nature documentary Oceans). What do the critics have to say?


The Back-up Plan

Jennifer Lopez hasn’t been heard from in a little while, and the good news is that critics find her appealing in The Back-up Plan. The bad news is they find little else to like in this romantic comedy, which is sitcommy, predictable, and unconvincing. J Lo stars as a woman who’s given up on finding Mr. Right, so she decides to have a child via artificial insemination. Naturally, once she becomes pregnant, she meets the man of her dreams in Stan (Alex O’Loughlin). Can these crazy kids make it work? The pundits say The Back-Up Plan is contrived and artificial, taking an intriguing premise and bulldozing it with strained, weather-beaten gags and manufactured quirkiness. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Lopez ‘s best-reviewed movies.)


The Losers

If you like your slam-bang action-fests to contain not a shred of subtext or intellectual pretention, The Losers is for you. But mindless explosions can only take you so far, and critics say this formulaic flick is pretty brainless stuff. Based upon the Vertigo Comics series of the same name, The Losers is the tale of a group of former black-ops types who vow to enact revenge against a rogue CIA agent after a double-cross – an agent who has designs on destabilizing various geopolitical entities. The pundits say The Losers has its moments of humor and white-knuckle intensity, but it’s a largely disposable film, and a mostly unmemorable one.



It’s Earth Day, and what better way to celebrate than by gazing upon the wonders of nature? If that’s your aim, critics say Oceans should do the trick. Co-directed by Jacques Perrin and Jacques Cluzaud – the team that brought you Winged MigrationOceans scours the sea for images of the many creatures that call the oceans their home, some of which have rarely been captured on film. The pundits say while the images in Oceans may sometimes lack explanation, they’re so remarkable that viewers will likely find themselves immersed.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

The Arrangement Holidays Year in Review E3 Set visit Fall TV Nickelodeon 2016 Countdown WGN Rocky Food Network Awards Martial Arts Music Comic Book discovery crime thriller Logo Certified Fresh Summer Photos boxoffice sports CBS IFC vampires TruTV biography Red Carpet 24 frames Musical The CW 2015 Star Trek Sci-Fi OWN Reality Competition Trailer TCA 2017 Bravo Biopics Sundance 007 Interview comiccon Super Bowl TCM GLAAD First Look crime drama travel MTV serial killer Showtime Drama ITV Video Games Freeform Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Lionsgate Emmys Extras Hulu based on movie Writers Guild of America LGBTQ DirecTV NYCC MSNBC politics Fantasy Paramount docudrama TBS VH1 Ghostbusters BBC America SundanceTV historical drama psycho APB Trivia Star Wars cops DC Universe GoT Marvel FXX transformers CBS All Access TV Opinion Character Guide YA ESPN cooking BET police drama NBC Lifetime Disney Winter TV 2017 Masterpiece CMT Animation Cartoon Network aliens Winners Oscars Syfy PBS Rock Marathons Universal Pop Dark Horse Comics Polls and Games Action HBO SDCC PaleyFest FX dramedy Reality CNN harry potter period drama war Kids & Family Mindy Kaling singing competition Fox News adventure Comedy American Society of Cinematographers TCA Podcast Schedule BBC Ellie Kemper Cosplay Spring TV crime social media science fiction FOX TIFF El Rey Calendar Election technology President DC Comics TV Land ABC Disney Channel USA Horror Mary Tyler Moore Infographic Mystery Pirates diversity Valentine's Day Thanksgiving Watching Series Premiere Dates TNT RT History GIFs Comedy Central ABC Family Sneak Peek Tumblr Starz Nat Geo Musicals Grammys sitcom Amazon Country TLC Warner Bros. Box Office zombie Best and Worst Crackle Toys cinemax composers Rom-Com thriller Tomatazos AMC Esquire E! X-Men Nominations Netflix VICE supernatural Superheroes Teen 45 cats Adult Swim History A&E political drama