Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Back-Up Plan Is Second Rate

Plus, The Losers is fun but mindless, and Oceans is visually stunning.

by | April 23, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got pregnancy pratfalls (The Back-up Plan, starring Jennifer Lopez and Alex O’Loughlin); mercenary mayhem (The Losers, starring Jeffrey Dean Morgan and Zoe Saldana); and aquatic animals (The Disney nature documentary Oceans). What do the critics have to say?


The Back-up Plan

Jennifer Lopez hasn’t been heard from in a little while, and the good news is that critics find her appealing in The Back-up Plan. The bad news is they find little else to like in this romantic comedy, which is sitcommy, predictable, and unconvincing. J Lo stars as a woman who’s given up on finding Mr. Right, so she decides to have a child via artificial insemination. Naturally, once she becomes pregnant, she meets the man of her dreams in Stan (Alex O’Loughlin). Can these crazy kids make it work? The pundits say The Back-Up Plan is contrived and artificial, taking an intriguing premise and bulldozing it with strained, weather-beaten gags and manufactured quirkiness. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Lopez ‘s best-reviewed movies.)


The Losers

If you like your slam-bang action-fests to contain not a shred of subtext or intellectual pretention, The Losers is for you. But mindless explosions can only take you so far, and critics say this formulaic flick is pretty brainless stuff. Based upon the Vertigo Comics series of the same name, The Losers is the tale of a group of former black-ops types who vow to enact revenge against a rogue CIA agent after a double-cross – an agent who has designs on destabilizing various geopolitical entities. The pundits say The Losers has its moments of humor and white-knuckle intensity, but it’s a largely disposable film, and a mostly unmemorable one.



It’s Earth Day, and what better way to celebrate than by gazing upon the wonders of nature? If that’s your aim, critics say Oceans should do the trick. Co-directed by Jacques Perrin and Jacques Cluzaud – the team that brought you Winged MigrationOceans scours the sea for images of the many creatures that call the oceans their home, some of which have rarely been captured on film. The pundits say while the images in Oceans may sometimes lack explanation, they’re so remarkable that viewers will likely find themselves immersed.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Fall TV CBS All Access Masterpiece thriller Reality Competition Video Games Freeform ABC Winners First Look TCA 2017 Logo transformers Pop 2016 IFC Infographic Esquire Food Network GLAAD Photos TV Mary Tyler Moore The CW sitcom Fox News Sundance Toys Mystery BBC 21st Century Fox Calendar TCM binge Martial Arts Grammys Musicals Nat Geo police drama RT History CNN E3 Musical TCA Extras Tomatazos Nominations Spring TV adventure Adult Swim period drama MSNBC 45 Disney Lionsgate harry potter Tumblr Emmys Lifetime talk show Holidays Kids & Family Polls and Games psycho what to watch SundanceTV Paramount Amazon Winter TV SDCC DirecTV American Society of Cinematographers Disney Channel Premiere Dates Sneak Peek Year in Review FX VH1 biography HBO supernatural The Arrangement WGN Superheroes Marvel diversity Cosplay technology dc war TruTV LGBTQ Schedule Sci-Fi CBS crime thriller Thanksgiving Cartoon Network Western comiccon Trailer USA ITV Set visit justice league DC Comics politics Netflix GIFs Warner Bros. Box Office Ellie Kemper BBC America Interview cinemax Drama composers Starz historical drama Trivia 2015 Universal APB romance aliens Countdown TLC Animation Mindy Kaling 2017 singing competition docudrama X-Men cats PaleyFest Reality Best and Worst Comedy Central discovery Opinion Summer Star Wars Biopics Hulu Character Guide 007 Comedy Watching Series Music TNT Rom-Com Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dramedy NYCC Syfy Dark Horse Comics Certified Fresh Writers Guild of America GoT TV Land Super Bowl President TIFF Showtime E! dceu Awards Podcast ESPN MTV DC Universe Crackle FXX Nickelodeon Horror Star Trek cops medical drama based on movie El Rey A&E political drama vampires Election Country Bravo Teen Oscars Pirates Rocky Red Carpet crime CMT PBS YA Comic Book BET Rock sports crime drama cooking science fiction Valentine's Day Ghostbusters serial killer History FOX Marathons Action social media ABC Family zombie VICE Fantasy 24 frames OWN AMC boxoffice NBC travel TBS