Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Oz the Great and Powerful Looks Good But Lacks Magic

Plus, Dead Man Down's great cast struggles to rise above the film's absurd plot.

by | March 8, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a wonderful wizard (Oz the Great and Powerful, starring James Franco and Mila Kunis) and a pair of avengers (Dead Man Down, starring Noomi Rapace and Colin Farrell). What do the critics have to say?

Oz the Great and Powerful


Few films could hope to match the influence and popularity of The Wizard of Oz, so it was probably a wise move for director Sam Raimi to forge a different path down the Yellow Brick Road with Oz the Great and Powerful, a prequel to the 1939 classic. Whether he was successful is a different matter; some critics find this Oz to be a witty visual phantasmagoria, while others say it suffers from so-so storytelling and inconsistent performances. James Franco stars as a roguish carnival magician who finds himself transported to a magical world. There, he meets a trio of witches and is treated like a king. Can our hero summon the courage and smarts to bring peace to the land of Oz? The pundits say that while Oz the Great and Powerful is often entertaining and always fun to look at, its plot is relatively bland and surprisingly short on magic. (Check out our interviews with Raimi and the stars of Oz, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down star Michelle Williams’s best-reviewed movies.)

Dead Man Down


Buoyed by the success of the Swedish version of The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, director Niels Arden Oplev and star Noomi Rapace re-team for the neo-noirish crime thriller Dead Man Down. Unfortunately, critics say it’s a cut blow their previous collaboration; while the fine cast keeps the movie watchable throughout, it’s is weighted down by absurd plot twists and a slack pace. Seeking revenge for the murder of his wife and child, Victor (Colin Farrell) infiltrates a criminal organization with the intention of killing the boss. However, Victor’s also being blackmailed by a mysterious woman (Rapace), who needs his help to settle a score of her own. The pundits say Rapace and Farrell are compelling, but Dead Man Down is too ponderous and clichéd to work as a whole.(Check out Rapace’s Five Favorite Films here.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Silence, a thriller about a pair of eerily similar crimes that haunt the residents of a small German town, is at 100 percent.
  • Electrick Children, a coming-of-age drama about a sheltered teenager who flees her family for the big city, is at 83 percent.
  • The Romanian drama Beyond The Hills, about a young woman who attempts to convince a childhood friend to leave her orthodox religious community, is at 81 percent.
  • Michel Gondry‘s The We and the I, a comedy about a diverse group of high school students on a bus home from the last day of school, is at 80 percent.
  • Greedy Lying Bastards, a documentary about corporate and political resistance to climate change legislation, is at 80 percent.
  • Don’t Stop Believin’: Everyman’s Journey, a concert doc about the venerable hard rock group and its new singer, is at 68 percent.
  • The Monk, starring Vincent Cassel in a gothic fantasy about a friar who gives in to temptation after meeting a newcomer to the monastery, is at 67 percent.
  • The ABCs of Death, a horror anthology featuring a scary short for each letter of the alphabet, is at 48 percent.
  • Emperor, starring Tommy Lee Jones and Matthew Fox in a period drama about the United States’ post-World War II Occupation of Japan, is at 41 percent.
  • Gut Renovation, a documentary about the gentrification of Brooklyn, is at 29 percent.

Finally, props to Matthew Reimer for coming the closest to guessing The Last Exorcism Part II‘s 14 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Infographic period drama technology BET Grammys Pop serial killer TV Kids & Family TBS NBC Ellie Kemper Lionsgate Mary Tyler Moore crime thriller dramedy Toys Interview BBC Sundance Biopics Cosplay Ghostbusters Podcast Netflix HBO political drama American Society of Cinematographers Martial Arts Cartoon Network TruTV Animation Watching Series PaleyFest singing competition Nickelodeon Super Bowl MSNBC biography DC Comics Hulu Year in Review cops 007 Star Wars Red Carpet Dark Horse Comics Showtime Tomatazos ABC Horror Schedule Country composers Photos CBS psycho Sneak Peek Nat Geo Extras FXX Thanksgiving Logo Holidays NYCC El Rey Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Fall TV police drama comiccon Star Trek VH1 TLC Reality Competition based on movie sports Musical TV Land Opinion 2017 APB Spring TV ESPN First Look Fox News Set visit harry potter Musicals Emmys Mindy Kaling sitcom Winners ITV crime drama Disney Channel Polls and Games USA zombie Sci-Fi CBS All Access Superheroes Best and Worst Bravo DirecTV Nominations Adult Swim Writers Guild of America Reality politics Freeform Marvel Rock TIFF docudrama Fantasy SDCC vampires Trailer Comedy Comic Book IFC war TCM The CW Valentine's Day The Arrangement Teen Election Winter TV BBC America OWN GoT boxoffice Masterpiece Certified Fresh crime E! SundanceTV CMT supernatural Character Guide Marathons transformers Drama MTV Starz Premiere Dates Pirates cooking Disney historical drama Music TCA E3 FX GIFs Lifetime TCA 2017 discovery aliens Universal Action Comedy Central Video Games YA PBS Trivia X-Men Esquire AMC VICE Food Network 24 frames ABC Family diversity travel Summer GLAAD thriller Box Office 2016 CNN Countdown adventure Amazon social media cinemax Rom-Com A&E Rocky Crackle Awards science fiction Syfy RT History Calendar WGN LGBTQ Mystery History President FOX Oscars TNT Tumblr 2015