Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Out of the Furnace is Tough but Uneven

Plus, Inside Llewyn Davis is Certified Fresh.

by | December 5, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got just one wide release: Out of the Furnace, a blue-collar crime thriller starring Christian Bale and Woody Harrelson. What do the critics have to say?



Out of the Furnace

54%

Gritty, moody, and populated by a cast of A-listers, Out of the Furnace promises a higher class of pulp than your average vengeance thriller. But critics say that while the actors imbue their characters with heft, they’re stuck with an uneven script that serves up many fine moments but fails to fully cohere. Bale stars as Russell, a steel worker whose brother Rodney (Casey Affleck) has just come home from Iraq. But when Rodney disappears after falling in with a local criminal organization, Russell goes looking for him — a search that leads him to Harlan (Woody Harrelson), the gang’s brutal ringleader. The pundits say that Out of the Furnace is raw and atmospheric, but it’s inconsistently paced and occasionally melodramatic. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Bale’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Nickelodeon Star Trek Emmys black doctor who cancelled TV shows ESPN Legendary Hear Us Out binge GLAAD scene in color Cosplay worst science fiction politics pirates of the caribbean Family ratings high school Toys italian rt archives Sci-Fi Endgame Biopics Black History Month travel Mystery Acorn TV TV Land crime batman remakes ABC Family fast and furious Certified Fresh Walt Disney Pictures women game of thrones true crime Dark Horse Comics E! docudrama Apple TV+ FX on Hulu HBO Max adaptation Set visit IFC Films halloween classics The Arrangement spider-man 2019 streaming TV 21st Century Fox Crackle jurassic park PlayStation President reboot Chernobyl Amazon Studios Reality Marvel screenings OneApp venice sequel james bond criterion screen actors guild composers See It Skip It comic books Stephen King Tomatazos Lifetime Trailer 2018 Western richard e. Grant Bravo popular ITV cancelled political drama BBC First Reviews Vudu comedies Summer quibi australia blockbuster Showtime DirecTV cancelled TV series streaming movies Universal superman nbcuniversal Avengers witnail teaser romantic comedy natural history A&E Anna Paquin cults Amazon Prime OWN Ellie Kemper BBC America Mary poppins Heroines FOX VICE Spike Film Festival documentary Quiz zombies YA 4/20 rom-coms christmas movies adventure Hallmark Christmas movies Shondaland Ovation Thanksgiving TV movies Superheroes directors APB Creative Arts Emmys Pet Sematary Masterpiece Amazon football Reality Competition hidden camera Star Wars Fall TV A24 period drama monster movies LGBTQ sitcom 93rd Oscars dark series ID SundanceTV dramedy rotten singing competition comics anime YouTube mutant Box Office Funimation TBS Disney Plus elevated horror canceled latino X-Men TCA 71st Emmy Awards renewed TV shows werewolf slashers Marathons halloween tv USA Adult Swim 24 frames Pop TV Mindy Kaling Peacock live action new zealand Sneak Peek king kong The CW diversity YouTube Red blockbusters films First Look CW Seed police drama hist NBC target know your critic Music war sag awards Netflix what to watch Turner Pride Month Watching Series ABC Signature game show Opinion deadpool talk show Food Network Photos aliens ViacomCBS Countdown Image Comics San Diego Comic-Con hollywood versus Amazon Prime Video franchise best The Walt Disney Company 45 Travel Channel Pop new york facebook USA Network boxoffice TIFF The Witch hispanic 2021 Film The Walking Dead Emmy Nominations Apple TV Plus BBC One Syfy medical drama comiccon Horror Columbia Pictures aapi romance technology independent movie Cannes worst movies blaxploitation Binge Guide Cartoon Network Discovery Channel SXSW Grammys Best and Worst Mary Poppins Returns space dragons El Rey Premiere Dates Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt BET vampires Sony Pictures CBS MSNBC Mudbound Oscars laika Animation BAFTA Television Critics Association Calendar zombie cats cooking WGN thriller Lionsgate Fantasy Awards Tour video on demand National Geographic NYCC strong female leads golden globes unscripted Freeform free movies Disney Channel asian-american TruTV 72 Emmy Awards Brie Larson anthology spinoff twilight Super Bowl psycho CMT breaking bad IFC Holiday 99% DGA Rock based on movie prank nfl canceled TV shows supernatural south america toy story dceu Comic Book razzies festival 007 Television Academy SDCC new star wars movies Character Guide kong Paramount Plus Nominations Alien VH1 casting Martial Arts book E3 crime drama historical drama FX Arrowverse revenge Lucasfilm obituary archives TCA 2017 french History disaster movies sports child's play BET Awards Tarantino festivals spy thriller cinemax sequels stand-up comedy nature a nightmare on elm street Shudder Captain marvel comic Elton John Podcast universal monsters spain Esquire Black Mirror Musicals joker TLC cops crime thriller transformers CNN kids biography Spring TV Schedule 2020 LGBT dogs television MTV 20th Century Fox mockumentary documentaries justice league spanish language stop motion Pacific Islander children's TV news Rom-Com Tubi Starz Polls and Games Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Disney Disney streaming service Sundance DC Universe animated book adaptation TV renewals discovery satire emmy awards theme song Awards dc fresh marvel cinematic universe golden globe awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards heist movie New York Comic Con zero dark thirty Academy Awards toronto Song of Ice and Fire Pirates 2017 Comics on TV CBS All Access Comedy Rocketman Fox Searchlight harry potter die hard ABC Pixar GIFs Spectrum Originals ghosts indie Women's History Month Comedy Central chucky name the review award winner Sundance Now The Academy Year in Review jamie lee curtis Epix DC streaming service TV One YouTube Premium telelvision Apple spanish Teen TNT PBS tv talk Netflix Christmas movies Red Carpet Country FXX Infographic 2016 Paramount trailers reviews Hallmark concert WarnerMedia serial killer Election Video Games stoner cartoon robots Warner Bros. AMC indiana jones Exclusive Video Christmas miniseries TCA Winter 2020 godzilla Ghostbusters Musical video docuseries mission: impossible critics Marvel Television Logo Britbox boxing PaleyFest Turner Classic Movies Trophy Talk American Society of Cinematographers Writers Guild of America Disney+ Disney Plus foreign HBO superhero lord of the rings Extras psychological thriller cars scary movies scorecard Classic Film Kids & Family RT21 VOD MCU kaiju japanese Hulu Broadway TCM green book parents RT History Winter TV cancelled television Baby Yoda TCA Awards international rotten movies we love HBO Go crossover Superheroe Sundance TV Rocky Crunchyroll Holidays finale Mary Tyler Moore Tumblr Interview DC Comics Lifetime Christmas movies Paramount Network The Purge social media Winners all-time Marvel Studios saw 2015 Drama Valentine's Day Action Fox News Nat Geo Trivia GoT