Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Out of the Furnace is Tough but Uneven

Plus, Inside Llewyn Davis is Certified Fresh.

by | December 5, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got just one wide release: Out of the Furnace, a blue-collar crime thriller starring Christian Bale and Woody Harrelson. What do the critics have to say?

Out of the Furnace


Gritty, moody, and populated by a cast of A-listers, Out of the Furnace promises a higher class of pulp than your average vengeance thriller. But critics say that while the actors imbue their characters with heft, they’re stuck with an uneven script that serves up many fine moments but fails to fully cohere. Bale stars as Russell, a steel worker whose brother Rodney (Casey Affleck) has just come home from Iraq. But when Rodney disappears after falling in with a local criminal organization, Russell goes looking for him — a search that leads him to Harlan (Woody Harrelson), the gang’s brutal ringleader. The pundits say that Out of the Furnace is raw and atmospheric, but it’s inconsistently paced and occasionally melodramatic. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Bale’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

true crime The CW TV festivals Travel Channel toy story vampires miniseries ID Tomatazos Musicals travel mob CBS talk show AMC posters Winners 2021 Kids & Family Syfy LGBT Amazon green book book adaptation dark series monster movies comic book movie spanish technology Comedy Disney+ Disney Plus 2018 gangster kong young adult rom-coms legend Paramount Plus cancelled live event dexter game show A24 E3 GoT police drama Epix ABC Family serial killer Endgame Mystery National Geographic Teen psycho football Sneak Peek Animation Interview Fantasy Freeform Martial Arts reboot Arrowverse Grammys vs. Black History Month Musical Superheroe Comics on TV versus MTV Comedy Central ghosts adenture archives japan Funimation zombies Sundance TV critic resources stand-up comedy SXSW pirates of the caribbean ESPN revenge TCA Winter 2020 indie 72 Emmy Awards universal monsters HBO 20th Century Fox scary movies NBA new star wars movies Holiday mcc franchise Cannes Countdown 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Pacific Islander halloween asian-american cars Paramount Network crossover New York Comic Con Dark Horse Comics jurassic park A&E President 93rd Oscars Universal godzilla Food Network Apple TV Plus Lifetime Christmas movies Neflix 45 cooking Crunchyroll new zealand blaxploitation lord of the rings spider-verse 2020 discovery scary politics SundanceTV obituary Extras emmy awards Starz trophy TV renewals DC Universe Rocky social media Instagram Live VH1 Sundance Now SDCC doctor who Lucasfilm child's play DC streaming service BBC One black comedy cancelled television VOD australia Universal Pictures Spring TV Emmy Nominations chucky comic books natural history satire TCA unscripted live action Film Festival Cosplay best dragons quibi Hallmark robots Fox News deadpool Sundance 2019 Britbox DirecTV prank witnail Star Trek Opinion anime DGA dreamworks YouTube Red Exclusive Video The Arrangement Star Wars TLC TCA 2017 Masterpiece fresh latino History FXX slashers Nat Geo Drama feel good name the review twilight french harry potter 90s aapi criterion animated japanese NYCC First Reviews superman target IFC Films Paramount crime hispanic heritage month Amazon Prime The Witch hispanic movie Esquire binge BBC America Anna Paquin foreign spy thriller Pet Sematary based on movie Creative Arts Emmys Song of Ice and Fire black TIFF classics RT History james bond action-comedy Vudu composers Apple TV+ critics kids canceled TV shows aliens AMC Plus fast and furious Lifetime Video Games Family 2017 Podcast Acorn TV Fall TV ABC Signature 24 frames game of thrones Disney Plus FOX remakes singing competition Captain marvel The Walking Dead Trailer Character Guide BET Awards Spectrum Originals Film marvel comics Lionsgate zombie RT21 Chernobyl blockbusters medical drama films The Academy CW Seed Mary Poppins Returns sopranos docudrama Shondaland joker cats thriller Hulu Peacock worst comic book movies Rom-Com HFPA psychological thriller rt labs BAFTA a nightmare on elm street CBS All Access ITV Winter TV cancelled TV series olympics Tarantino TCA Awards 79th Golden Globes Awards documentary Mindy Kaling 21st Century Fox Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt justice league Prime Video laika IMDb TV spain Broadway cartoon 2015 YouTube Premium romantic comedy dc disaster Reality Competition Cartoon Network reviews Ellie Kemper king kong nfl theme song casting Hallmark Christmas movies Red Carpet Certified Fresh rotten international television art house Polls and Games anthology finale WGN Super Bowl GIFs directors jamie lee curtis suspense new york Infographic Marathons Horror streaming Biopics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Wes Anderson know your critic Hollywood Foreign Press Association rt archives TNT Country Black Mirror PlayStation Reality boxing Ghostbusters news Television Academy comics YA streaming movies basketball sports canceled leaderboard Oscars TV movies Box Office YouTube royal family Binge Guide Marvel Studios Classic Film Nominations stoner 73rd Emmy Awards genre facebook ratings Columbia Pictures FX spider-man ABC halloween tv 99% independent women LGBTQ what to watch diversity werewolf Hear Us Out Photos trailers BET toronto Academy Awards Best and Worst PaleyFest south america Schedule comiccon OWN zero dark thirty renewed TV shows Sony Pictures Rock Turner Amazon Studios Apple WarnerMedia Mary Tyler Moore BBC spinoff Baby Yoda cancelled TV shows wonder woman Election Warner Bros. hist sag awards Trophy Talk 4/20 Year in Review Alien OneApp kaiju razzies dramedy movies hidden camera batman USA Network richard e. Grant X-Men period drama Set visit FX on Hulu Superheroes CNN E! ViacomCBS heist movie screenings mission: impossible political drama book Avengers dceu APB festival Tokyo Olympics Summer 007 Ovation science fiction Writers Guild of America cinemax award winner Fargo Netflix parents MSNBC Pride Month marvel cinematic universe Christmas adaptation Heroines Comic-Con@Home 2021 First Look TCM The Purge debate high school cops telelvision 1990s Rocketman comic GLAAD dogs king arthur Watching Series PBS blockbuster Pop TV venice Disney TV Land Pop historical drama Tags: Comedy concert El Rey italian Pirates Awards Tour Calendar popular stop motion Thanksgiving scorecard video boxoffice Premiere Dates all-time Marvel Television rt labs critics edition Tumblr Women's History Month die hard 71st Emmy Awards strong female leads crime thriller screen actors guild Sci-Fi docuseries CMT Music Adult Swim teaser Amazon Prime Video elevated horror American Society of Cinematographers DC Comics MCU IFC christmas movies biopic sequels Action cults sitcom video on demand war Trivia Bravo NBC golden globe awards The Walt Disney Company Legendary Fox Searchlight romance USA Toys saw Pixar documentaries spanish language free movies children's TV nature breaking bad slasher supernatural Television Critics Association Shudder Western Showtime Disney Channel Holidays hollywood Logo See It Skip It comedies Mudbound TruTV space Valentine's Day tv talk nbcuniversal superhero Spike Marvel Netflix Christmas movies Image Comics indiana jones golden globes HBO Max Crackle Comic Book Brie Larson TV One Tubi biography 2016 Stephen King Walt Disney Pictures scene in color VICE worst movies Nickelodeon San Diego Comic-Con mutant adventure Disney streaming service crime drama Turner Classic Movies HBO Go Elton John Mary poppins Discovery Channel mockumentary Awards Emmys TBS Quiz rotten movies we love sequel transformers