Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Insidious: Chapter 2 is a So-So Frightfest

Plus, The Family favors brutal violence over satirical wit.

by | September 12, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a bedeviled family (Insidious: Chapter 2, starring Patrick Wilson and Rose Byrne) and some witnesses who need little protection (The Family, starring Robert De Niro and Michelle Pfeiffer). What do the critics have to say?

Insidious: Chapter 2


With Insidious and The Conjuring, director James Wan has moved away from his blood-soaked Saw roots toward a more atmospheric brand of horror. However, critics say Insidious: Chapter 2 is something of a step back; despite strong performances and a few effective scares, it’s decidedly short on the tension and surprises that made its predecessor so chilling. This time out, the Lamberts have moved to a new residence but continue to be haunted by a malevolent spirit. Could it be that it’s one of the family members, not the house, that’s possessed? The pundits say Insidious: Chapter 2 is better crafted and performed than your typical frightfest, but it’s too reliant on jump scares and backstory to fully captivate. (Read our interview with star Patrick Wilson here.)

The Family


With its distinguished cast and high concept premise, The Family looks like a can’t-miss proposition on paper. Unfortunately, critics say this fish-out-of-water action/comedy suffers from jarring tonal shifts and an overabundance of gratuitous violence. Robert De Niro stars as a mob snitch who’s been placed in the witness protection program. But when he and his family relocate to a village in France, they don’t keep a particularly low profile, and soon the mob is on their trail. The pundits say The Family boasts solid performances, but the actors can only do so much with a script that favors brutal violence over satirical wit. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down De Niro’s best-reviewed movies, and be sure to watch our video interviews with the cast.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Mother Of George, starring Danai Jekesai Gurira and Isaach De Bankolé in an impressionistic drama about a recently married woman who is under pressure to have a child, is at 100 percent.
  • Sample This, a documentary that recounts the strange history of the Incredible Bongo Band’s version of “Apache,” is at 100 percent.
  • The Saudi Arabian import Wadjda, a drama about a young suburban girl who tries to scrape together the money to buy a bicycle, is at 97 percent.
  • Blue Caprice, starring Isaiah Washington in a psychological thriller from the perspective of the perpetrators of the Beltway sniper attacks, is at 96 percent.
  • Harry Dean Stanton: Partly Fiction, a documentary portrait of the celebrated character actor, is at 93 percent.
  • Informant, a documentary about a far-left activist who became an FBI informer, is at 92 percent.
  • Mademoiselle C, , a behind-the-scenes look at fashion journalist Carine Roitfeld’s attempt to start a new magazine, is at 71 percent.
  • And While We Were Here, starring Kate Bosworth in a romantic drama about a lonely woman who meets a younger man while accompanying her husband on a trip to Naples, is at 58 percent.
  • GMO OMG, a doc that takes a skeptical view of genetically modified crops, is at 43 percent.
  • Jayne Mansfield’s Car, starring Billy Bob Thornton and Robert Duvall in a culture clash comedy about two different families that gather for a funeral, is at 35 percent (check out Thornton’s Five Favorite Films here).

Tag Cloud

Alien Columbia Pictures HFPA rt archives Apple TV+ Stephen King Animation Pacific Islander animated australia scary movies Holiday Turner Classic Movies documentaries Epix Mystery Podcast live event HBO Go dreamworks mutant TV Holidays Universal ABC Family Trophy Talk travel CMT DGA marvel cinematic universe game of thrones spider-verse IFC Trivia TCA FX on Hulu biography cancelled japan Song of Ice and Fire trophy award winner rt labs critics edition critics CBS All Access crime NBC Women's History Month 2021 nature SundanceTV Anna Paquin comiccon franchise Christmas Valentine's Day Tumblr Chilling Adventures of Sabrina psychological thriller DC streaming service finale Pop TV cooking Logo strong female leads AMC Plus scary asian-american BBC One richard e. Grant black Video Games cops Red Carpet A24 FX 2018 Dark Horse Comics worst 71st Emmy Awards sports ViacomCBS Nominations video on demand wonder woman Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pixar vampires hist Best and Worst women Avengers Super Bowl telelvision cancelled TV series werewolf 90s Travel Channel BBC America Interview TV movies pirates of the caribbean Brie Larson composers harry potter golden globes Sundance crossover debate IMDb TV Lionsgate Elton John Drama french Comedy ID Sci-Fi mob Netflix Christmas movies SXSW zombie 45 king kong toy story children's TV indiana jones disaster OneApp Endgame stoner PaleyFest Watching Series Esquire comics ESPN Pirates YouTube Premium critic resources transformers miniseries E3 hispanic heritage month cults Acorn TV MSNBC reviews TNT Broadway blockbuster GoT Thanksgiving Binge Guide Summer Disney+ Disney Plus period drama A&E tv talk Photos universal monsters PlayStation Classic Film FOX TCA 2017 Apple TV Plus posters PBS Sony Pictures obituary YouTube basketball Fox News Kids & Family Prime Video Lifetime Christmas movies 2020 Captain marvel Comic Book Emmy Nominations Paramount Exclusive Video superman psycho blaxploitation 2017 See It Skip It Polls and Games Mary Poppins Returns GIFs police drama Lifetime Toys boxoffice Black History Month nfl Marvel Television Spike BBC Disney Plus Academy Awards RT21 japanese Amazon Studios high school royal family documentary concert marvel comics mcc adventure Awards Tour National Geographic Turner Comic-Con@Home 2021 black comedy chucky popular fast and furious quibi sitcom Year in Review E! DirecTV politics lord of the rings adaptation rotten movies we love Instagram Live IFC Films golden globe awards Cannes Hollywood Foreign Press Association worst movies festival classics Box Office Horror San Diego Comic-Con President Winners scorecard Nickelodeon Amazon directors comic book movies die hard Fall TV Peacock space leaderboard hidden camera vs. Teen GLAAD Premiere Dates Ellie Kemper YA international emmy awards suspense ITV FXX Pet Sematary Walt Disney Pictures halloween cinemax aapi Calendar parents Tags: Comedy video Cartoon Network Nat Geo criterion 99% social media ratings Apple stop motion Mary Tyler Moore Reality technology prank festivals war saw batman independent Food Network First Reviews supernatural sequels Ovation Freeform CW Seed deadpool theme song spinoff LGBTQ Superheroe dc Superheroes ghosts new star wars movies TV One medical drama Television Academy 21st Century Fox 2015 diversity book adaptation The Walking Dead Image Comics child's play science fiction 2016 jurassic park Star Trek jamie lee curtis art house slasher all-time name the review Reality Competition Television Critics Association The Walt Disney Company remakes joker Hulu 007 reboot laika The CW canceled TV shows Musicals Fargo Cosplay spain 24 frames what to watch screenings Hallmark Christmas movies singing competition twilight MCU Rocketman Marvel foreign a nightmare on elm street Disney streaming service based on movie book Starz olympics cartoon justice league anthology talk show godzilla monster movies Spectrum Originals Tubi CNN target 1990s Legendary Opinion Baby Yoda The Arrangement New York Comic Con Marathons Mindy Kaling films canceled renewed TV shows dark indie political drama VOD American Society of Cinematographers movie game show First Look facebook Mudbound robots USA Network Oscars History casting docuseries Discovery Channel Quiz new zealand mission: impossible TV Land Tarantino Bravo Disney Channel Grammys Certified Fresh TV renewals south america legend BAFTA Tokyo Olympics discovery comic live action Infographic 20th Century Fox Awards cancelled TV shows Extras crime thriller Marvel Studios TCA Winter 2020 Sundance Now streaming stand-up comedy TCM scene in color thriller Fox Searchlight serial killer dceu blockbusters Emmys venice elevated horror spy thriller new york adenture Pride Month Sneak Peek AMC dragons sag awards LGBT italian Rock ABC Winter TV latino 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Neflix natural history Crackle Schedule razzies genre MTV The Witch spanish CBS Shudder historical drama Funimation know your critic Biopics binge Lucasfilm boxing romance true crime cancelled television dogs crime drama kaiju Sundance TV anime Ghostbusters Family Countdown fresh HBO superhero Comics on TV james bond Crunchyroll Heroines king arthur biopic streaming movies Wes Anderson Disney spider-man Paramount Network Election Star Wars Musical Amazon Prime Character Guide movies cats Universal Pictures BET Awards 93rd Oscars comic book movie Showtime rom-coms OWN kids action-comedy 4/20 Country rotten HBO Max zombies Mary poppins VH1 football aliens VICE BET TIFF comedies 72 Emmy Awards NYCC Warner Bros. TLC kong RT History Vudu Chernobyl archives Martial Arts Film free movies teaser spanish language nbcuniversal YouTube Red doctor who sequel TBS satire docudrama WarnerMedia Hear Us Out 79th Golden Globes Awards Rocky Shondaland SDCC Action Pop revenge Tomatazos series Trailer hispanic heist movie witnail sopranos 73rd Emmy Awards Amazon Prime Video X-Men unscripted comic books christmas movies Paramount Plus dexter Syfy DC Universe television Masterpiece NBA The Purge dramedy Hallmark gangster Britbox Rom-Com The Academy Set visit Spring TV Writers Guild of America DC Comics APB hollywood Black Mirror young adult zero dark thirty Comedy Central Arrowverse Creative Arts Emmys romantic comedy feel good toronto Adult Swim green book trailers ABC Signature rt labs El Rey WGN mockumentary news Netflix Film Festival Fantasy TruTV Western versus halloween tv Music 2019 best USA breaking bad screen actors guild TCA Awards slashers cars