Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Express Scores, Body of Lies Falls Flat

Plus, Ember lacks luster, and guess Quarantine's Tomatometer!

by | October 9, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got suspicious spies (Body of Lies, starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Russell Crowe), gridiron greats (The Express, starring Rob Brown and Dennis Quaid), underground empires (City of Ember, starring Bill Murray and Tim Robbins), and deadly outbreaks (Quarantine, starring Jennifer Carpenter). What do the critics have to say?

Troubled times inspire troubled movies, and critics say Ridley Scott‘s espionage thriller Body of Lies is brainier and politically sharper than your typical spy yarn. However, others say it gets too bogged down in action scenes to totally hit its mark. Leonardo DiCaprio stars as Roger Ferris, a CIA operative who has tracked down a terrorist leader in Jordan; however, he must get approval from his boss, Ed Hoffman (Russell Crowe), as well as the head of the Jordanian Intelligence agency. Naturally, machinations and intrigue follow. The pundits say Body of Lies‘ impressive pedigree goes a long way toward redeeming the film; it’s well acted and expertly crafted. However, some critics feel the story is way too labyrinthine and scattershot to be emotionally involving. Body of Lies currently stands at 57 percent on the Tomatometer.


“Dude, for the last time, you are not the king of the world.”


The inspirational, tragic life of Ernie Davis was ready-made for cinematic treatment: the first African American player to win college football’s Heisman Trophy, Davis set rushing records — and battled racial prejudice — before succumbing to leukemia on the eve of turning pro. Critics say The Express is a worthy big-screen tribute to one of pigskin’s greatest heroes, overcoming formulaic biopic tropes with sincerity and excellent performance. Rob Brown stars as Davis, an extremely talented but apolitical young man thrust into the harsh glare of history, and Dennis Quaid plays Syracuse coach Ben Schwartzwalder, a man who changes as a result of his charge’s heroic perseverance. The pundits say The Express has plenty of solid gridiron action, and it exceeds typical inspirational sports movie fare with its heart and craft. At 65 percent on the Tomatometer, The Express sails through the uprights.


“I told you not to use auto-draft for your fantasy team!”

Set in a crumbling underground city that houses humanity after earth’s surface has become uninhabitable, City of Ember follows the exploits of two youngsters who find a magic box that provides clues on how to escape from the depths. The pundits say City of Ember has whimsy to spare, and should please younger viewers with its phantasmagorical imagery, but the plot is difficult to follow and character development is limited at best. At 46 percent on the Tomatometer, Ember doesn’t quite shine. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we take a closer look at the best-reviewed films of star Bill Murray‘s career.)


“Zuul will never find me here…”

It seems that Keira Knightley stars in every other British period piece these days. And, as The Duchess demonstrates, that’s not necessarily a bad thing. Knightley stars as Georgiana Spenser, an ancestor of Princess Di’s, who becomes an 18th century style icon while navigating the rough waters of palace life. The pundits say The Duchess is a visual treat, and Knightly and Ralph Fiennes turn in excellent performances. However, some feel The Duchess is too frothy and melodramatic, and forgoes the meaty parts of Spenser’s real-life contributions in favor of obsessing over her frippery and fashion. The Duchess is at 61 percent on the Tomatometer.


Keira Knightley’s 346th birthday party was a pretty gloomy affair.

Apparently out of concern for critics’ physical well-being, Quarantine has been, ahem, quarantined, since reviews aren’t coming out until the day of its release. The film stars Jennifer Carpenter and Steve Harris as a television crew trapped in an apartment building where a strange outbreak of rabies is causing people to commit savage killings. Kids, guess that Tomatometer!


“This one-woman protest isn’t having the impact I’d hoped for.”

Also opening this week in
limited release:

Finally, we’d like to sing the praises of halose7en, who correctly guessed An American Carol‘s 14 percent Tomatometer.

Recent Leonardo DiCaprio Movies:

Tag Cloud

National Geographic 20th Century Fox DC Universe Watching Series Interview Nickelodeon Starz Writers Guild of America Opinion 2015 blaxploitation Toys adaptation ratings cats biography dc binge Film Festival Biopics aliens Comic Book Extras Pet Sematary Mary poppins Country Elton John Captain marvel Star Wars DC Comics natural history Bravo Marathons Western serial killer Spike TBS Rocky Set visit WarnerMedia historical drama anthology Year in Review CNN strong female leads politics ESPN dramedy Comedy Central crime drama CBS All Access Rock Video Games Chernobyl Cartoon Network Best and Worst Fall TV Holidays richard e. Grant Trivia Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Mary Tyler Moore Heroines harry potter Amazon Comics on TV Rom-Com Esquire sports crossover USA Network HBO Max psychological thriller Drama Winners Martial Arts unscripted dceu Action travel Black Mirror Photos LGBTQ PaleyFest doctor who Walt Disney Pictures police drama animated Epix diversity Red Carpet Tomatazos Superheroes Stephen King Sony Pictures Spectrum Originals VH1 zombie Syfy Universal Awards Tour TNT zombies Countdown NYCC 24 frames E3 Crackle Polls and Games Nominations BBC Freeform El Rey Brie Larson HBO political drama Nat Geo psycho The Arrangement TCM 45 Creative Arts Emmys award winner Music Warner Bros. Acorn TV APB Marvel space The Witch 2017 ABC Family Trophy Talk Hulu Dark Horse Comics 2016 TLC romance true crime facebook Lifetime technology Adult Swim Mystery cooking Logo Masterpiece witnail elevated horror 2019 Pop TruTV Netflix mutant Rocketman 21st Century Fox Sundance Now transformers Pixar anime Winter TV Fantasy Pride Month President TCA MTV DC streaming service Teen golden globes Animation Spring TV social media Vudu vampires MCU FXX X-Men streaming E! miniseries GLAAD Sundance Thanksgiving Sneak Peek See It Skip It Summer discovery cops spider-man casting Mary Poppins Returns hist sitcom AMC Fox News DirecTV Superheroe CMT science fiction Star Trek war YouTube Red spy thriller Emmys A&E talk show boxoffice Lucasfilm crime OWN Tumblr Disney Channel Ovation IFC Films IFC Awards TIFF medical drama Anna Paquin SXSW docudrama nature PBS Trailer jamie lee curtis American Society of Cinematographers LGBT Song of Ice and Fire Schedule sequel singing competition thriller CW Seed RT21 comiccon disaster Ghostbusters Box Office SundanceTV period drama Christmas Sci-Fi TV Columbia Pictures Shudder Reality Competition SDCC Mindy Kaling Showtime Premiere Dates YouTube Premium Apple Grammys BBC America TV Land 007 BET Comedy festivals theme song Mudbound crime thriller GIFs teaser cults Amazon Prime Emmy Nominations Kids & Family what to watch Reality spinoff 2018 YA game show First Look Paramount WGN comic Calendar based on movie television Valentine's Day CBS Food Network robots Cannes DGA Ellie Kemper Tarantino New York Comic Con green book ABC RT History Britbox ITV zero dark thirty VICE Infographic San Diego Comic-Con composers The CW dragons Oscars Paramount Network Super Bowl adventure Musical justice league Pirates USA GoT History Quiz Cosplay Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Shondaland Character Guide finale Certified Fresh Horror Podcast NBC FX cinemax mockumentary supernatural toy story FOX Women's History Month TCA 2017 Election MSNBC Musicals Lionsgate Disney