Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Exodus: Gods and Kings Fails to Reach the Promised Land

Plus, Top Five is Certified Fresh, and Sons of Anarchy ties up loose ends in a satisfying fashion.

by | December 11, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a Biblical epic (Exodus: Gods and Kings, starring Christian Bale and Joel Edgerton) and a conflicted comedian (Top Five, starring Chris Rock and Rosario Dawson). What do the critics have to say?

Exodus: Gods and Kings


It’s got a daring escape from slavery, the parting of the Red Sea, the unveiling of the Ten Commandments, and a literal river of blood — yep, the Book of Exodus is certainly one of the Old Testament’s most action-packed installments. Unfortunately, critics say that while Exodus: Gods and Kings director Ridley Scott mostly succeeds in crafting an eye-popping spectacle, he fails to bring the story’s legendary people to vivid life. You probably know the story, but if not, here goes: the orphaned Moses (Christian Bale) was raised by the Pharaoh, but he’s cast out when it’s discovered that his parents were Jewish. God reveals to Moses that he’s been chosen to lead the Israelites out of Egypt, but first he must free his people before undertaking an epic trek across the desert. The pundits say Exodus: Gods and Kings mostly avoids taking a theological stand on the story, but as a result the film’s spectacular visuals overwhelm the heat and passion this oft-told tale continues to evoke. (Watch our video interviews with Scott and stars Bale, Joel Edgerton, and Aaron Paul, and check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Sigourney Weaver’s best-reviewed films.)

Top Five


Few would deny that Chris Rock is one of the best standup comedians of his generation — or that, for the most part, his movie career has left something to be desired. That’s about to change, as critics say Top Five represents a career peak for Rock as a director and actor — it’s a semi-autobiographical portrait of the artist as a neurotic that recalls Woody Allen at his best. Rock plays Andre Allen, a popular comic actor who’s about to be married to a famous reality TV star. He agrees to be profiled by a New York Times reporter (Rosario Dawson), and as they stroll about the city, Allen begins to question the decisions he’s made in his life and career. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Top Five is blessed with palpable chemistry between its leads, and the result is timely, insightful, and often hilarious. (Watch our video interviews with Rock and co-stars Anders Holm, Ben Vereen, and JB Smoove.)

What’s Hot on TV:

Critics say the final episode of Sons of Anarchy is, like the series itself, both twisty and turbulent, but ultimately, “Papa’s Goods” (87 percent) is a fitting farewell to the SAMCRO gang that ties up loose ends in an involving, poetic fashion.

The penultimate episode of HBO’s The Newsroom, “Oh Shenandoah,” stirred up a lot of internet chatter this week, and much of it was negative; critics objected to everything from a subplot on campus rape to the unprompted death of a major character.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

2017 Awards Tour posters Cosplay name the review Mindy Kaling NYCC 4/20 Oscars Food Network Paramount Plus remakes psychological thriller stoner Holidays Logo unscripted batman Comic Book 90s CBS 2019 CMT cops ESPN Infographic History Calendar lord of the rings political drama PlayStation AMC First Reviews BBC America live event prank thriller TCA Winter 2020 harry potter Superheroe GLAAD TBS Ovation debate laika ITV women San Diego Comic-Con Certified Fresh Sundance TV A24 Starz vs. Netflix Academy Awards E! Nickelodeon Marvel Television FX on Hulu Mystery Avengers comedies vampires basketball Esquire VICE directors indie The CW black comedy medical drama Pride Month Sony Pictures worst movies El Rey fresh wonder woman Pet Sematary Syfy Fox Searchlight Rock spinoff Premiere Dates Rocketman Thanksgiving robots king arthur spain Prime Video blaxploitation rt labs spanish language suspense Television Academy TV One sopranos festival Binge Guide Ghostbusters trophy stop motion nfl diversity Peacock Chernobyl docuseries Election discovery sequels comiccon zero dark thirty sitcom Turner social media cars screen actors guild parents CNN book HBO psycho Disney+ Disney Plus OWN Sci-Fi docudrama 73rd Emmy Awards animated classics Image Comics kids Pirates Nominations child's play james bond canceled sequel HBO Go TNT crime thriller movie Emmy Nominations razzies RT21 comic book movies 72 Emmy Awards zombie know your critic Winter TV romance Fargo Teen Countdown composers Apple TV Plus FOX Acorn TV DC Universe latino comics dramedy space 24 frames Amazon Studios WGN Ellie Kemper Pop Amazon Prime Video Red Carpet south america superhero The Walking Dead rotten movies we love police drama critics crime series National Geographic revenge Classic Film japan football science fiction Trailer MSNBC richard e. Grant video See It Skip It Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt adventure TIFF Disney streaming service movies Dark Horse Comics dogs monster movies YouTube anthology Tubi MCU NBC Broadway finale Super Bowl mutant hollywood 2020 Schedule Summer Marvel Studios Paramount Reality DC Comics satire BET Awards Marvel Captain marvel comic books scorecard game of thrones critic resources YouTube Red Elton John rotten hispanic heritage month Disney Channel Freeform art house Watching Series adaptation new star wars movies Character Guide casting biopic witnail game show based on movie Alien FX cinemax scary spider-man obituary universal monsters toy story high school Martial Arts WarnerMedia olympics theme song Brie Larson anime HFPA telelvision Turner Classic Movies reviews 45 The Arrangement DC streaming service Tomatazos 93rd Oscars Exclusive Video golden globes Showtime Shondaland royal family Podcast Columbia Pictures Western hispanic Tarantino X-Men SXSW The Academy feel good Vudu streaming Amazon Prime mob DirecTV cancelled TV shows genre elevated horror gangster Hulu Arrowverse Pop TV Star Wars Masterpiece black E3 APB ABC Family The Witch Film Festival RT History period drama Rocky TCA children's TV PBS cancelled television Country DGA USA Network The Walt Disney Company documentaries Reality Competition dceu kong Crunchyroll Comics on TV Bravo dragons breaking bad FXX GoT criterion historical drama Trophy Talk ABC The Purge dreamworks TCA 2017 teaser disaster New York Comic Con zombies ratings Sundance Baby Yoda Song of Ice and Fire twilight cancelled Creative Arts Emmys Star Trek biography Fantasy scene in color LGBTQ best Valentine's Day quibi Lifetime target Christmas Neflix films Discovery Channel spy thriller Quiz 99% Disney Plus natural history ID LGBT Lucasfilm Extras Film YouTube Premium halloween tv slasher popular 007 Paramount Network Travel Channel Amazon 2016 dexter IFC Films Trivia Black Mirror nbcuniversal Superheroes BAFTA emmy awards Video Games foreign blockbusters Set visit christmas movies adenture king kong new zealand Horror young adult CBS All Access aliens international Spring TV Opinion godzilla australia 2015 Polls and Games legend Hallmark Christmas movies cooking Biopics television Shudder OneApp Spectrum Originals Comic-Con@Home 2021 Epix Universal die hard Lionsgate werewolf binge news Hallmark ViacomCBS versus tv talk marvel comics streaming movies HBO Max Fall TV worst hidden camera SundanceTV award winner BBC TV IMDb TV 71st Emmy Awards canceled TV shows Sneak Peek Heroines Best and Worst Photos AMC Plus Grammys serial killer Action VOD Pixar Hear Us Out Interview Black History Month book adaptation Tokyo Olympics 21st Century Fox Walt Disney Pictures trailers independent Stephen King concert Musical nature comic Winners 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ghosts cartoon renewed TV shows cults miniseries Music Box Office Wes Anderson TCM deadpool Drama Endgame TV Land IFC rom-coms halloween Year in Review Writers Guild of America japanese spanish Anna Paquin Rom-Com chucky war Toys justice league comic book movie TruTV stand-up comedy french 79th Golden Globes Awards Cannes CW Seed leaderboard what to watch boxing cats video on demand facebook Kids & Family screenings venice A&E TV renewals Fox News kaiju documentary politics franchise hist 20th Century Fox scary movies heist movie superman blockbuster saw aapi President Awards Universal Pictures Musicals Cartoon Network indiana jones TV movies pirates of the caribbean Funimation cancelled TV series romantic comedy boxoffice spider-verse TCA Awards sag awards First Look Disney PaleyFest a nightmare on elm street Mudbound dc crime drama live action Crackle Hollywood Foreign Press Association action-comedy true crime SDCC Netflix Christmas movies jurassic park Legendary mockumentary fast and furious Mary poppins mcc 2021 Apple Mary Tyler Moore NBA marvel cinematic universe American Society of Cinematographers Tumblr italian transformers all-time slashers Women's History Month dark Animation supernatural Marathons mission: impossible new york festivals GIFs Britbox Nat Geo reboot golden globe awards toronto USA Pacific Islander singing competition joker Family green book Spike VH1 BET 2018 rt labs critics edition Warner Bros. TLC BBC One rt archives Television Critics Association talk show Tags: Comedy Holiday travel free movies Apple TV+ doctor who Lifetime Christmas movies Comedy Instagram Live asian-american jamie lee curtis YA Mary Poppins Returns Emmys Adult Swim technology Comedy Central sports ABC Signature 1990s MTV archives crossover strong female leads Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sundance Now