Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Invisibles" Lacks Focus; "Stomp" Comes Up Short; "Curse" Is A Mixed Blessing; "Dog" Has Bite; "Primeval" Not Screened

by | January 11, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a kid who ventures into a magical world ("Arthur and the Invisibles," with voice work from Robert De Niro and Madonna), a frat dance-off ("Stomp the Yard," starring Meagan Good), a lavish tale set during the Tang Dynasty ("The Curse of the Golden Flower," starring Chow Yun-Fat and Gong Li) and a ripped-from-the-headlines teen crime pic ("Alpha Dog," starring Bruce Willis and Justin Timberlake). What do the critics have to say?

Written by Nick Hershey and Alex Vo

"Arthur and the Invisibles" is a partially animated children’s film from director Luc Besson. Ten-year-old Arthur must find a passage to a magical world populated by tiny little beings called Minimoys in order to save his grandfather’s home. Critics say that the story tries to do too much, and the film wastes the big-name voice talent on a predictable script (including Robert De Niro, Madonna, and Snoop Dogg). In addition, they note that while the animation is interesting, it doesn’t hold up to the current CG standard. At 28 percent on the Tomatometer, "Arthur and the Invisibles" may not be something to see.

"Look how you’ve grown! You’re as tall as my ex-boyfriend now."

Two rival fraternities compete for the allegiance of a street dancer from Los Angeles in "Stomp the Yard." "Stepping" is the latest dance, and "Yard" has plenty of pep, thanks to appealing performers like Columbus Short and Meagan Good. But critics say that while "Stomp" contains impressive musical and dance numbers, it loses its momentum during the intervening soap opera-style subplots. At 27 percent on the Tomatometer, "Stomp" doesn’t quite go the extra yard.

"Let’s stomp the desert!"

You wouldn’t expect it from a Yimou Zhang movie, but "The Curse of the Golden Flower" is something not to be over-thought, but simply watched. Critics say the film goes to great lengths to visually mesmerize the audience, with enormous sets lavished in gold and silk, jade and brocade, and exquisitely bloody swordfights. But they also say the story is melodramatic. Really melodramatic. At 63 percent on the Tomatometer, this one’s both a blessing and a curse.

Apparently they had Jell-O shots in the Tang Dynasty.

Like a Hollywood remake of a Larry Clark movie, "Alpha Dog" is a glossy yet unflinching look into a violent and hedonistic teenage community. Bruce Willis and Sharon Stone play scene-chewing figures of authority, but critics say it’s Justin Timberlake who’s noteworthy, and the relationship his and Anton Yelchin’s character develop is the emotional tether that holds "Alpha Dog" together. The scribes say that while some of the techniques director Nick Cassavetes employs are a bit over the top, he’s able to draw good performances out of the cast. At 63 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Dog" has bite.

"Step 1: Cut a hole in a box."

Looks like we’re starting the year off right: we’re just two weeks into 2007, and already we’ve got a movie that wasn’t screened for critics. It’s called "Primeval," and it’s about a serial killer that has claimed more than 300 victimsm. It’s probably mediocre. Guess that Tomatometer.

Nope, it ain’t ‘The Searchers.’

Also opening this week in limited release: the compelling Holocaust documentary "Verdict on Auschwitz" is at 100 percent; "God Grew Tired of Us," a powerful doc about the Lost Boys of Sudan, is at 93 percent; "Ever Since the World Ended," a mockumentary about post-apocalyptic San Francisco, is at 75 percent; and "Tears of the Black Tiger," a heavily stylized Thai western, is at 73 percent.

Luc Besson-Directed Films:
50% — Angel-A (2007)
30% — The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc (1999)
68% — The Fifth Element (1997)
81% — Leon The Professional (1994)
86% — La Femme Nikita (1990)

Tag Cloud

American Society of Cinematographers Lifetime Oscars comic Hulu social media anthology doctor who dogs NBC Thanksgiving Nat Geo blockbuster south america Paramount Network APB crime serial killer crime thriller spider-man The Purge scary movies Syfy YA Avengers TV Land toy story Women's History Month comedies VOD Emmys Mary Tyler Moore hist Music Film Anna Paquin BET Awards Film Festival E3 Fox News revenge 007 mission: impossible spy thriller Lionsgate Emmy Nominations 2015 cats 2018 renewed TV shows Schedule Disney Plus cars The CW Interview finale Hallmark Christmas movies ABC Family Country Academy Awards Toys WGN Apple TV Plus Character Guide free movies Baby Yoda video on demand based on movie Endgame Amazon Prime 2016 Sneak Peek movie Walt Disney Pictures Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt miniseries PBS Watching Series singing competition child's play NYCC Horror Lucasfilm biography Mary poppins Star Trek composers Britbox Freeform rotten movies we love TV renewals game of thrones DC Comics versus adaptation quibi OneApp TruTV Ghostbusters First Reviews romance Comedy Central FOX FX ITV PlayStation spain Western TCA Awards Starz Tomatazos Television Critics Association Brie Larson CNN Musical Holiday Trailer war dceu Set visit LGBT strong female leads Reality Competition facebook Turner The Witch Cosplay Super Bowl Martial Arts richard e. Grant Song of Ice and Fire Black History Month tv talk batman TNT GLAAD YouTube Red Warner Bros. Captain marvel harry potter New York Comic Con nature justice league GoT E! HBO Superheroe dramedy technology Shondaland concert Television Academy Netflix Christmas movies sports Apple BAFTA robots Superheroes Mudbound name the review MSNBC Calendar franchise Marvel Television dark Awards Shudder Winter TV foreign mockumentary Trivia chucky TCA 2017 Sony Pictures sag awards BBC One psychological thriller Cartoon Network romantic comedy VICE cops Teen streaming children's TV politics Awards Tour FXX dc ratings 2017 President Rocky Amazon Prime Video Mystery Drama DC streaming service Certified Fresh Creative Arts Emmys RT21 hispanic vampires Box Office boxoffice A24 sitcom VH1 latino medical drama OWN Tubi crossover WarnerMedia Rom-Com Lifetime Christmas movies Discovery Channel SDCC 24 frames die hard zombie teaser Chilling Adventures of Sabrina twilight Showtime elevated horror Peacock Pride Month Action theme song asian-american Summer award winner Paramount TBS 71st Emmy Awards National Geographic Reality spinoff werewolf Marathons El Rey screen actors guild 21st Century Fox Amazon unscripted docudrama Esquire historical drama Tarantino Sci-Fi Chernobyl Pop TV binge golden globes true crime Countdown Turner Classic Movies halloween 2019 Arrowverse San Diego Comic-Con Comic Book christmas movies Travel Channel TCM Disney+ Disney Plus supernatural kids Kids & Family stand-up comedy Bravo independent Disney streaming service Crackle green book A&E cancelled TV series Marvel Studios Premiere Dates Hear Us Out satire Disney Channel talk show slashers YouTube Nominations parents Pop cooking Writers Guild of America RT History stoner Spectrum Originals diversity DirecTV Fall TV ABC series AMC Pet Sematary Ovation Podcast Disney BBC America animated Opinion Infographic Adult Swim best Spike IFC Films TV period drama Grammys Red Carpet Funimation X-Men canceled TV shows Universal jamie lee curtis First Look transformers Ellie Kemper CW Seed HBO Max SXSW CBS police drama Winners 20th Century Fox cinemax zombies Rocketman zero dark thirty MTV Fantasy universal monsters Hallmark witnail 45 comics Comics on TV cancelled LGBTQ TCA Winter 2020 Epix SundanceTV YouTube Premium Pixar Photos Family Biopics Masterpiece comiccon 4/20 TIFF Election discovery documentary reviews documentaries space Comedy blaxploitation Rock casting Dark Horse Comics Columbia Pictures Binge Guide DGA GIFs thriller political drama BET Marvel Sundance TV Logo BBC screenings TLC Nickelodeon Sundance CMT Best and Worst Christmas Cannes critics CBS All Access PaleyFest cancelled television Vudu canceled Amazon Studios Quiz TCA book disaster Crunchyroll a nightmare on elm street DC Universe Classic Film Valentine's Day Video Games The Arrangement dragons joker news Star Wars films anime Trophy Talk Stephen King Elton John Animation Holidays what to watch cartoon science fiction Tumblr natural history breaking bad television travel Pirates cults indie cancelled TV shows all-time Spring TV aliens reboot See It Skip It Sundance Now ESPN Acorn TV video criterion directors Food Network ghosts The Walking Dead Netflix crime drama FX on Hulu Polls and Games MCU Black Mirror sequel HBO Go Extras adventure Musicals festivals History Mary Poppins Returns indiana jones IFC movies Year in Review Mindy Kaling Apple TV+ USA Network psycho game show USA spanish language 2020 Heroines mutant