Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Crank" Is Well-Ranked; "Illusionist" Is Magic, "Crossover" Is An Air-Ball, "Wicker Man" Gets Burned

by | August 31, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got hoopsters with big dreams ("Crossover," starring Anthony Mackie), scary goings-on on remote islands ("The Wicker Man," starring Nicolas Cage), fast, fast vehicles ("Crank," starring Jason Statham and Amy Smart), and magic ("The Illusionist," starring Edward Norton and Jessica Biel). What do the critics say?

If you want realism, go rent "The Bicycle Thief." Critics say "Crank" is a ludicrously over-the-top action flick with nary a moment of probability. And that’s a good thing. The story involves a hit man (Statham) who must stay awake to complete his mission and get out of the business. The critics say the film makes precious little sense and eschews both the laws of physics and political correctness. They also note that it is a lot of fun, with terrific action sequences and a knowing sense of humor. Why this movie wasn’t shown to critics beforehand is beyond us, since at 75 percent on the Tomatometer it’s the best reviewed unscreened film of the year, beating out "Snakes on a Plane" (69 percent).

It appears Jason Statham’s alarm isn’t working again.

"The Wicker Man" wasn’t screened for critics either, and this time, it looks like there was a good reason for that. Critics say Neil LaBute‘s remake of the 1973 cult classic subtracts most of the subtext of the original and replaces it with tons of unintentional laughs. Cage stars as a cop who gets ensnared in sinister rituals on a remote island while searching for his girlfriend’s missing child. Scribes say the film was misconceived from the get-go and contains a startling amount of sexism. At 11 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Wicker Man" is getting burned. It’s also well below the original (89 percent).

Movie critics tried a bunch of disguises in an attempt to sneak into screanings of "The Wicker Man."

One of the reasons streetball is so much fun to watch is its sheer unpredictability. The critics say the opposite is the case with the hoops drama "Crossover." The film tells the story of Noah (Mackie), a talented kid who hopes to get to med school with an assist from his hoops scholarship, but must deal with the full court press of some of his relationships. The critics are treating "Crossover" the way Dikembe Mutombo would handle a shot in his direction. They say the film is too by-the-numbers to be dramatic. At zero percent on the Tomatometer, "Crossover" is tied with "Zoom" (each of which have 46 rotten reviews) for the title of worst reviewed film of the year.

"Run, Anthony Mackie! Run for your life! Get help!"

"The Illusionist" goes wide this week, and the critics are largely under the spell of this Sundance-approved period mystery. The film tells the tale of Eisenheim (Norton), a magician who runs afoul with the authorities for his feats of illusion and his romance with the prince’s fiancée (Biel). The scribes are praising "The Illusionist" for its remarkable set design, sweeping romance, and its twisty plot. It currently stands at 75 percent on the Tomatometer, good enough for Certified Fresh status.

In "The Illusionist," Ed Norton plays a man outstanding in his field — or is it out walking? (Thank you. I’ll be here all week.)

Also out this week in limited release: hipster fave Andrew Bujalski‘s no-budget comedy "Mutual Appreciation" is at 100 percent on the Tomatometer; Ric Burns‘ "Andy Warhol: A Documentary Film" is also at 100 percent; that lovable collie "Lassie" is at 90 percent; Kirby Dick‘s guerilla investigation of the MPAA, "This Film Is Not Yet Rated," is at 83 percent; Zhang Yimou‘s latest, "Riding Alone for Thousands of Miles," is at 69 percent; Edward Burns‘ latest examination of suburban romantic angst, "Looking for Kitty," is at 38 percent; and Mike Judge‘s "Idiocracy," which is in limited release, was not screened for critics.

"Mutual Appreciation": As Sonic Youth might say, confusion is next and next after that is the truth.

Recent Neil LaBute Movies:
65% — The Shape of Things (2003)
64% — Possession (2002)
83% — Nurse Betty (2000)
76% — Your Friends and Neighbors (1999)
89% — In the Company of Men (1997)

Recent Jason Statham Movies:
15% — London (2006)
27% — Revolver (2006)
50% — The Transporter 2 (2005)
73% — The Italian Job (2003)
53% — The Transporter (2002)

Recent Basketball Movies:
90% — The Heart of the Game (2006)
58% — Glory Road (2006)
69% — Through the Fire (2005)
14% — Rebound (2005)
64% — Coach Carter (2005)

Tag Cloud

Polls and Games adventure emmy awards talk show Toys MSNBC a nightmare on elm street CMT elevated horror crime dramedy asian-american wonder woman Emmy Nominations Trailer comic books rt archives slashers Disney streaming service Tubi ghosts ESPN prank Mudbound twilight foreign E3 2015 Western Year in Review Endgame rotten movies we love golden globes SundanceTV TV Land Horror theme song Tomatazos Turner Classic Movies richard e. Grant legend thriller king arthur SXSW Lionsgate harry potter TruTV japanese 90s 71st Emmy Awards christmas movies 24 frames 93rd Oscars Creative Arts Emmys History Oscars Fox News TIFF DGA deadpool natural history Food Network dogs Pirates movies CBS All Access italian television Rom-Com superman news SDCC ABC Signature YA The Witch quibi popular renewed TV shows YouTube Red scary movies Ghostbusters E! werewolf cults ID TBS AMC Apple TV+ jurassic park child's play Paramount Plus Countdown Box Office Nominations razzies Holidays Travel Channel dragons new star wars movies Winners Crackle Sundance TV 2020 ITV obituary Rocky Arrowverse unscripted Video Games Anna Paquin disaster FOX new zealand IFC Films robots Columbia Pictures Reality Competition Funimation BBC nbcuniversal Black History Month BBC One 1990s Classic Film Pet Sematary cooking 2019 latino video Showtime GLAAD monster movies independent Stephen King animated Thanksgiving serial killer RT21 ABC Family new york period drama satire TCA 4/20 universal monsters Masterpiece Holiday festivals ratings The Walt Disney Company hidden camera Baby Yoda DC streaming service reviews Television Academy Photos WGN Lifetime hist GIFs First Reviews American Society of Cinematographers Broadway Red Carpet Vudu Fantasy Sundance cops historical drama Comics on TV laika Ovation TCM APB Disney Amazon Prime zero dark thirty Writers Guild of America Hear Us Out cancelled TV series travel supernatural TV Animation political drama Chernobyl crime drama book cinemax name the review nfl LGBTQ movie critics dark cartoon Interview Superheroe game of thrones miniseries Alien criterion international CNN Adult Swim Cannes aapi comiccon Mary Poppins Returns Grammys south america james bond Tarantino Lucasfilm venice crime thriller X-Men what to watch medical drama GoT TV movies Comic Book Comedy OneApp Hallmark Christmas movies Britbox boxoffice A24 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ViacomCBS The Arrangement Set visit Marvel Television Teen canceled The Walking Dead Emmys Sneak Peek true crime Country spy thriller Nickelodeon Best and Worst rotten nature DC Comics MTV Discovery Channel docudrama Shondaland teaser target Schedule Esquire Awards BBC America anime Mystery dceu psychological thriller TV One Watching Series Apple TV Plus TCA 2017 Binge Guide Drama king kong PlayStation VOD HBO Max Amazon Studios Starz Ellie Kemper FX festival adenture Paramount Network films Film halloween witnail Marvel Black Mirror MCU Song of Ice and Fire Comedy Central cancelled television Comic-Con@Home 2021 docuseries streaming series hollywood Mary poppins Peacock DC Universe blaxploitation First Look best Nat Geo Amazon Prime Video Character Guide Extras 2018 high school President The CW cancelled TV shows game show Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Sci-Fi Quiz streaming movies Marvel Studios Spring TV YouTube screenings Women's History Month Mary Tyler Moore Pop TV New York Comic Con green book revenge free movies The Purge vampires finale black Mindy Kaling worst Action 2017 children's TV FXX Apple Logo Epix biography Rocketman Martial Arts blockbuster social media sequel indie mission: impossible NYCC Film Festival mockumentary Legendary HBO Go Pacific Islander Academy Awards Television Critics Association BET 007 Fox Searchlight breaking bad video on demand IFC Star Trek romantic comedy Acorn TV Christmas casting women HBO Tumblr Rock VH1 hispanic 2016 NBC LGBT pirates of the caribbean basketball Sundance Now japan RT History kong 2021 superhero Music Superheroes PBS adaptation Opinion telelvision 99% technology El Rey Hulu scorecard Spike Reality Trivia Marathons boxing trailers 45 marvel cinematic universe binge Infographic Amazon Image Comics TCA Awards Disney+ Disney Plus doctor who NBA chucky Heroines blockbusters french Cosplay Wes Anderson cats USA versus 20th Century Fox Biopics Walt Disney Pictures war stop motion dc spinoff 21st Century Fox science fiction Paramount FX on Hulu golden globe awards anthology romance kids WarnerMedia Brie Larson canceled TV shows Trophy Talk australia singing competition National Geographic Bravo TV renewals worst movies VICE Disney Channel Netflix sitcom cars zombies remakes space toronto TLC Syfy Star Wars Freeform Premiere Dates scene in color saw Certified Fresh OWN Awards Tour Calendar transformers based on movie comics documentary jamie lee curtis ABC BAFTA Universal Hallmark DirecTV spanish joker Election Turner zombie rom-coms Family fast and furious stoner Captain marvel aliens facebook Spectrum Originals YouTube Premium batman Pixar Crunchyroll police drama franchise Dark Horse Comics Elton John Winter TV award winner USA Network Tokyo Olympics godzilla directors A&E sag awards toy story archives Musical Kids & Family suspense comedies psycho spain TCA Winter 2020 lord of the rings die hard Valentine's Day sports politics spider-man reboot screen actors guild olympics diversity classics The Academy discovery Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Avengers football sequels Shudder parents BET Awards Pride Month Summer Super Bowl See It Skip It indiana jones stand-up comedy fresh Musicals Exclusive Video Pop CBS spanish language documentaries kaiju Lifetime Christmas movies CW Seed heist movie book adaptation Cartoon Network Fall TV cancelled Sony Pictures Disney Plus San Diego Comic-Con TNT strong female leads mutant Warner Bros. crossover concert live action comic Netflix Christmas movies all-time halloween tv PaleyFest justice league know your critic tv talk 72 Emmy Awards composers Podcast