Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Crank" Is Well-Ranked; "Illusionist" Is Magic, "Crossover" Is An Air-Ball, "Wicker Man" Gets Burned

by | August 31, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got hoopsters with big dreams ("Crossover," starring Anthony Mackie), scary goings-on on remote islands ("The Wicker Man," starring Nicolas Cage), fast, fast vehicles ("Crank," starring Jason Statham and Amy Smart), and magic ("The Illusionist," starring Edward Norton and Jessica Biel). What do the critics say?

If you want realism, go rent "The Bicycle Thief." Critics say "Crank" is a ludicrously over-the-top action flick with nary a moment of probability. And that’s a good thing. The story involves a hit man (Statham) who must stay awake to complete his mission and get out of the business. The critics say the film makes precious little sense and eschews both the laws of physics and political correctness. They also note that it is a lot of fun, with terrific action sequences and a knowing sense of humor. Why this movie wasn’t shown to critics beforehand is beyond us, since at 75 percent on the Tomatometer it’s the best reviewed unscreened film of the year, beating out "Snakes on a Plane" (69 percent).

It appears Jason Statham’s alarm isn’t working again.

"The Wicker Man" wasn’t screened for critics either, and this time, it looks like there was a good reason for that. Critics say Neil LaBute‘s remake of the 1973 cult classic subtracts most of the subtext of the original and replaces it with tons of unintentional laughs. Cage stars as a cop who gets ensnared in sinister rituals on a remote island while searching for his girlfriend’s missing child. Scribes say the film was misconceived from the get-go and contains a startling amount of sexism. At 11 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Wicker Man" is getting burned. It’s also well below the original (89 percent).

Movie critics tried a bunch of disguises in an attempt to sneak into screanings of "The Wicker Man."

One of the reasons streetball is so much fun to watch is its sheer unpredictability. The critics say the opposite is the case with the hoops drama "Crossover." The film tells the story of Noah (Mackie), a talented kid who hopes to get to med school with an assist from his hoops scholarship, but must deal with the full court press of some of his relationships. The critics are treating "Crossover" the way Dikembe Mutombo would handle a shot in his direction. They say the film is too by-the-numbers to be dramatic. At zero percent on the Tomatometer, "Crossover" is tied with "Zoom" (each of which have 46 rotten reviews) for the title of worst reviewed film of the year.

"Run, Anthony Mackie! Run for your life! Get help!"

"The Illusionist" goes wide this week, and the critics are largely under the spell of this Sundance-approved period mystery. The film tells the tale of Eisenheim (Norton), a magician who runs afoul with the authorities for his feats of illusion and his romance with the prince’s fiancée (Biel). The scribes are praising "The Illusionist" for its remarkable set design, sweeping romance, and its twisty plot. It currently stands at 75 percent on the Tomatometer, good enough for Certified Fresh status.

In "The Illusionist," Ed Norton plays a man outstanding in his field — or is it out walking? (Thank you. I’ll be here all week.)

Also out this week in limited release: hipster fave Andrew Bujalski‘s no-budget comedy "Mutual Appreciation" is at 100 percent on the Tomatometer; Ric Burns‘ "Andy Warhol: A Documentary Film" is also at 100 percent; that lovable collie "Lassie" is at 90 percent; Kirby Dick‘s guerilla investigation of the MPAA, "This Film Is Not Yet Rated," is at 83 percent; Zhang Yimou‘s latest, "Riding Alone for Thousands of Miles," is at 69 percent; Edward Burns‘ latest examination of suburban romantic angst, "Looking for Kitty," is at 38 percent; and Mike Judge‘s "Idiocracy," which is in limited release, was not screened for critics.

"Mutual Appreciation": As Sonic Youth might say, confusion is next and next after that is the truth.

Recent Neil LaBute Movies:
65% — The Shape of Things (2003)
64% — Possession (2002)
83% — Nurse Betty (2000)
76% — Your Friends and Neighbors (1999)
89% — In the Company of Men (1997)

Recent Jason Statham Movies:
15% — London (2006)
27% — Revolver (2006)
50% — The Transporter 2 (2005)
73% — The Italian Job (2003)
53% — The Transporter (2002)

Recent Basketball Movies:
90% — The Heart of the Game (2006)
58% — Glory Road (2006)
69% — Through the Fire (2005)
14% — Rebound (2005)
64% — Coach Carter (2005)

Tag Cloud

elevated horror GLAAD spinoff facebook travel President police drama Sundance politics golden globes NBC Music Hulu adaptation A&E spy thriller Tarantino Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TIFF Tomatazos TLC Lucasfilm AMC dc Netflix Song of Ice and Fire Nominations Cannes Sony Pictures Disney Channel DirecTV Film Festival Cartoon Network Walt Disney Pictures Heroines Countdown period drama USA X-Men DC Comics Drama Spring TV Writers Guild of America Freeform Set visit Disney E3 Fall TV Kids & Family spider-man Black Mirror BET LGBTQ Spectrum Originals justice league Paramount Warner Bros. cats Ghostbusters crime thriller psychological thriller mockumentary SDCC E! Election Marathons Reality Mudbound CNN 2018 24 frames Super Bowl space Superheroes biography Winners RT History NYCC cinemax Pet Sematary Animation Pop VICE CBS All Access Ovation Creative Arts Emmys PaleyFest Trivia MTV crossover Watching Series crime drama Sneak Peek ESPN Musicals Summer Showtime unscripted ITV natural history Oscars zombie green book robots The Arrangement 21st Century Fox Schedule SundanceTV Logo disaster Superheroe Comic Book Chernobyl finale Universal ratings transformers crime 007 ABC Family cooking Amazon game show serial killer FX SXSW nature CW Seed Bravo Christmas true crime aliens hist sports Masterpiece anthology Mary poppins BBC America Thanksgiving Horror Adult Swim Extras Interview Mindy Kaling DC streaming service singing competition CBS Opinion witnail mutant American Society of Cinematographers festivals Certified Fresh doctor who Awards DC Universe dramedy Trophy Talk what to watch binge Mary Poppins Returns Infographic Rocky Stephen King Winter TV TCM award winner Amazon Prime Columbia Pictures Grammys Toys political drama animated RT21 2017 Lionsgate supernatural New York Comic Con 45 streaming comic VH1 diversity Paramount Network OWN Elton John Dark Horse Comics Fantasy Spike El Rey romance psycho TCA 2017 sequel richard e. Grant Apple Sundance Now blaxploitation vampires BBC casting Brie Larson boxoffice Musical talk show Holidays Rock Red Carpet Rocketman WGN Pixar Awards Tour Nat Geo Star Trek war Epix Quiz Best and Worst Britbox Acorn TV historical drama Fox News Valentine's Day The CW FXX Video Games PBS Box Office 2019 Comedy Central medical drama DGA TruTV Martial Arts Anna Paquin adventure Character Guide Teen Cosplay TNT Biopics Sci-Fi TCA Photos Ellie Kemper Trailer Pirates zero dark thirty Pride Month strong female leads Tumblr USA Network social media APB theme song Syfy Calendar MSNBC IFC Women's History Month Mystery Vudu discovery Lifetime technology science fiction Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Rom-Com San Diego Comic-Con Food Network Esquire Shudder Star Wars 2016 comiccon Premiere Dates YouTube Red cults History Starz cops GoT 20th Century Fox Nickelodeon TV Land HBO Country miniseries Crackle Year in Review 2015 dceu Western TBS teaser Reality Competition MCU based on movie National Geographic Comics on TV YouTube Premium jamie lee curtis The Witch IFC Films CMT Emmys Action First Look harry potter television sitcom TV Captain marvel See It Skip It Shondaland GIFs composers ABC thriller docudrama Podcast Polls and Games FOX zombies Marvel dragons Mary Tyler Moore Comedy YA anime toy story