Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: A Sad "Happily"; A Messy "Cleaner"; Inspiring "Writers"; and Powerful "Men"

by | January 4, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a postmodern fairy tale ("Happily N’Ever After," with voicework from Sigourney Weaver and Sarah Michelle Gellar), a wacky conspiracy caper ("Code Name: The Cleaner," starring Cedric the Entertainer and Lucy Liu), a committed teacher ("Freedom Writers," starring Hilary Swank), and a chilling dystopia ("Children of Men," starring Clive Owen and Michael Caine). What do the critics have to say?

Once upon a time, in the land of make-believe (better known as Hollywood), there was a brand new formula for making dazzling kiddie movies. It was called CG, and children all over the world rejoiced when such fare as "Toy Story" and "Shrek" hit the theaters. But then an evil curse plagued the land, as a string of mediocre stories threatened to make CG stale. The latest: "Happily N’Ever After," a postmodern "Cinderella" spoof. Critics say this is a pretty charm-free affair, with less-than-dazzling images and a bland storyline. At six percent on the Tomatometer, this is a pretty grim fairy tale. And among CG features, only "Doogal," at five percent, is lower-rated.

"Sure, magic will do the dishes, but can it make my movie funny?"

Cedric the Entertainer is a funny guy, and as a supporting player he’s stolen scenes in everything from "Lemony Snicket" to "Be Cool." Sadly, he’s yet to have a starring vehicle that has utilized his comedic talents to the fullest, and it appears "Code Name: The Cleaner" is no exception. In this action/comedy, Cedric plays a janitor who stumbles into the middle of a government conspiracy, from which he tries to extricate himself with the help of Lucy Liu. The critics say the weak script does none of the actors any favors, playing up absurd thriller elements to leaden effect. At a big fat zero percent on the Tomatometer, this one’s in dire need of a "Clean-" up.

"Yes, I’ve always enjoyed the sophisticated yet robust taste of Xtreme Fruit Skittles."

Liberal and conservative education experts both have it wrong. What our inner city schools need is neither greater funding nor vouchers. In order to save the impoverished students of America, we need an unconventional, no-nonsense teacher to instruct students in ballroom dance, football, or poetry, preferably in the guise of Antonio Banderas, The Rock, or Michelle Pfeiffer. In "Freedom Writers," Hilary Swank plays a fresh-faced teacher who gets her students in touch with their creative writing side, and — wonder of wonders — it’s getting reasonably good reviews. The critics say the film may be clichéd, but it’s earnest and features strong performances. At 64 percent on the Tomatometer, this may be one to "Write" home about.

"Remember, Bagels for Complacency Day is next week."

Director Alfonso Cuaron may have made his best movie yet with "Children of Men," continuing a hot streak that began with "Y Tu Mama Tambien" and "Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban." This time, Cuaron has envisioned a world where women have become infertile and every country has become a dystopia or slipped into a fascist state. At 92 percent on the Tomatometer, critics are praising not only the film’s technical aspects (including seamless CG work, fluid camerawork, and complex battle scenes), but also the emotional story and performances.

"Any fool knows a dog needs a home and shelter from pigs on the wing."

Also opening this week in limited release is "Thr3e," a psychological serial killer flick with a spiritual twist, which is currently at 17 percent.

Alex Vo contributed to this article.

Recent CG Animated Films:
77% — Happy Feet (2006)
76% — Flushed Away (2006)
41% — Everyone’s Hero (2006)
76% — Cars (2006)
64% — The Ant Bully (2006)

Recent Hilary Swank Movies:
36% — The Black Dahlia (2006)
92% — Million Dollar Baby (2004)
100% — 11:14 (2003)
42% — The Core (2003)
92% — Insomnia (2002)

Recent Cedric the Entertainer Movies:
81% — Charlotte’s Web (2006)
14% — Honeymooners (2005)
55% — Madagascar (2005)
29% — Be Cool (2005)
9% — Man of the House (2005)

Recent Clive Owen Movies:
88% — Inside Man (2006)
21% — Derailed (2005)
77% — Sin City (2005)
68% — Closer (2004)
29% — King Arthur (2004)

Tag Cloud

Fox Searchlight Spectrum Originals Box Office jamie lee curtis Oscars stoner Spring TV FX on Hulu harry potter Masterpiece Sci-Fi ESPN international Mystery Tags: Comedy Star Wars scary movies TV renewals aliens dceu spider-verse movie 20th Century Fox Baby Yoda Sundance TV TLC Video Games Rom-Com Animation nbcuniversal south america Syfy elevated horror halloween TV Lifetime Christmas movies emmy awards Walt Disney Pictures Mary Tyler Moore CNN suspense 2020 President Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pacific Islander space DGA werewolf IMDb TV Wes Anderson critics rt labs critics edition Bravo zero dark thirty spider-man Lifetime political drama Universal Holidays high school remakes Disney streaming service 24 frames dexter Paramount The Academy anthology The Walt Disney Company HFPA binge rt labs quibi police drama theme song anime screen actors guild CBS All Access japanese fast and furious nfl festival Character Guide strong female leads trophy 72 Emmy Awards kaiju Black History Month boxing pirates of the caribbean Sundance Now name the review Calendar Cosplay satire Columbia Pictures politics superman batman Tumblr Shondaland Dark Horse Comics AMC jurassic park Logo Year in Review Winners Writers Guild of America mob 21st Century Fox Creative Arts Emmys technology TV One die hard sag awards Set visit BAFTA franchise ratings casting obituary Emmys gangster WGN IFC Films stop motion Fox News Turner spinoff TV Land Tomatazos japan sequel Rock TruTV Disney Channel American Society of Cinematographers Pop comic Lionsgate french dreamworks target Exclusive Video zombie Superheroes biopic rotten movies we love See It Skip It Hear Us Out richard e. Grant NBA comic book movie Action Comics on TV Hallmark venice Elton John live event Holiday USA Network Quiz Thanksgiving comics animated HBO Go Marvel Studios superhero cancelled TV shows Interview cinemax Sony Pictures mockumentary MSNBC popular Star Trek Nickelodeon vampires movies dragons comedies 73rd Emmy Awards Spike Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cops Cannes GoT documentaries basketball The Purge Marvel Television psychological thriller YouTube Premium SDCC king arthur cats Election ABC Family all-time BBC One AMC Plus Lucasfilm docuseries comic book movies italian YouTube Amazon Prime canceled TV shows doctor who mutant finale Trailer Infographic TCA Fall TV zombies razzies boxoffice Black Mirror Tokyo Olympics cartoon action-comedy debate ABC Signature Freeform scary spy thriller OneApp San Diego Comic-Con BET Awards blockbusters Countdown ViacomCBS posters thriller Instagram Live Paramount Plus Teen Comedy Acorn TV Apple TV+ Women's History Month docudrama book concert Food Network Song of Ice and Fire universal monsters Rocky chucky Discovery Channel ABC kids halloween tv kong DC streaming service royal family aapi latino Trivia singing competition First Look SundanceTV Showtime The Walking Dead 99% Emmy Nominations mission: impossible a nightmare on elm street children's TV DC Comics Certified Fresh book adaptation Travel Channel Red Carpet tv talk 79th Golden Globes Awards 45 Family justice league teaser witnail cults streaming movies E3 Shudder women 1990s Nat Geo indie natural history MTV blockbuster 2021 discovery Reality Competition Mary Poppins Returns video YouTube Red The Arrangement biography what to watch BBC America leaderboard adventure Heroines sports stand-up comedy PlayStation Country hist Grammys Musical Broadway Marathons Music CW Seed Endgame Tubi young adult Awards Tour game show The Witch child's play Disney+ Disney Plus godzilla Starz talk show crime drama Apple Crackle Warner Bros. Marvel game of thrones Ovation period drama IFC Britbox golden globe awards lord of the rings 90s Kids & Family television NYCC new zealand MCU unscripted series art house know your critic true crime Alien DC Universe dc WarnerMedia New York Comic Con war 007 A24 reboot telelvision Television Academy Apple TV Plus Comedy Central USA Fantasy cancelled ID australia TV movies VOD Funimation Netflix Christmas movies historical drama renewed TV shows king kong Universal Pictures Pixar hispanic heritage month sitcom 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Western crime thriller Amazon 2017 Comic Book Pirates best Epix genre Classic Film parents Vudu dark CBS TBS APB Mudbound Peacock Film Festival classics Chernobyl 2018 Summer dramedy revenge Drama Sneak Peek worst movies Comic-Con@Home 2021 NBC disaster Martial Arts sequels trailers asian-american black Toys 2015 hidden camera toronto Valentine's Day prank Photos CMT Superheroe Crunchyroll Horror rt archives spanish OWN Hulu GIFs VICE LGBT Schedule scene in color FXX Avengers travel Podcast joker video on demand critic resources twilight Polls and Games blaxploitation 71st Emmy Awards screenings ghosts Academy Awards Watching Series fresh saw feel good VH1 Mary poppins PaleyFest new york comiccon social media marvel cinematic universe Mindy Kaling Captain marvel Awards reviews cancelled TV series composers miniseries Anna Paquin BET Musicals HBO Max DirecTV adenture deadpool romantic comedy serial killer archives SXSW National Geographic versus hollywood YA slasher criterion black comedy Opinion indiana jones hispanic Ellie Kemper science fiction Binge Guide laika RT History christmas movies TCA Winter 2020 diversity toy story A&E transformers cancelled television medical drama Sundance live action worst 93rd Oscars Amazon Studios E! foreign Nominations Film Hallmark Christmas movies TCA Awards Tarantino Legendary james bond Reality Rocketman Neflix Ghostbusters canceled festivals Pet Sematary news psycho Paramount Network Adult Swim facebook El Rey robots mcc dogs Hollywood Foreign Press Association Winter TV breaking bad football golden globes vs. olympics Super Bowl PBS new star wars movies Extras Fargo Amazon Prime Video Cartoon Network BBC films TNT crossover Brie Larson wonder woman heist movie nature ITV Turner Classic Movies Biopics free movies Pop TV marvel comics crime FOX spanish language 2019 RT21 cooking based on movie slashers Best and Worst TIFF 4/20 sopranos Disney Plus TCA 2017 comic books Stephen King Image Comics scorecard History Prime Video First Reviews legend documentary monster movies supernatural The CW award winner X-Men GLAAD adaptation Christmas Netflix Trophy Talk green book Pride Month Television Critics Association streaming rom-coms rotten Premiere Dates TCM FX cars independent directors Disney 2016 Arrowverse Esquire LGBTQ spain HBO romance