Stranger Things or This Is Us? Who TV Fans Think Should Win at the Emmys

TV viewers weigh in on the award-worthiness of the past TV season in our 2017 Emmy survey.

by | September 14, 2017 | Comments

Rotten Tomatoes surveyed 8,772 of you TV fans to find out how you feel about this year’s Emmy nominations. Here’s what we found.


This Is Us (Ron Batzdorff/NBC)

If you could vote, what would you vote for in the drama series category?

1 “This Is Us” (NBC) 26%
2 “Stranger Things” (Netflix) 25%
3 “Westworld” (HBO) 13%
4 “House of Cards” (Netflix) 10%
5 “The Handmaid’s Tale” (Hulu) 9%
6 “Better Call Saul” (AMC) 8%
7 “The Crown” (Netflix) 8%

Among men, Stranger Things topped this category at 31%, while 36% of women chose This Is Us. Stranger Things also was favored by 18–34 year olds by 33%.

What do you think will win in the drama series category?

1 “This Is Us” (NBC) 32%
2 “The Handmaid’s Tale” (Hulu) 16%
3 “Stranger Things” (Netflix) 16%
4 “House of Cards” (Netflix) 13%
5 “Westworld” (HBO) 11%
6 “The Crown” (Netflix) 7%
7 “Better Call Saul” (AMC) 4%

This Is Us topped all segments in our question of which series survey respondents feel has a lock on the win.

Who would you vote for in the drama actress category?

1 Viola Davis (“How to Get Away with Murder”) 28%
2 Elisabeth Moss (“The Handmaid’s Tale”) 17%
3 Evan Rachel Wood (“Westworld”) 16%
4 Robin Wright (“House of Cards”) 15%
5 Keri Russell (“The Americans”) 14%
6 Claire Foy (“The Crown”) 10%

Davis topped all segments. The real battle was for second place with Wood besting Moss among men and the 18–34 and 35–54 segments.

Who would you vote for in the drama actor category?

1 Kevin Spacey (“House of Cards”) 23%
2 Anthony Hopkins (“Westworld”) 17%
3 Milo Ventimiglia (“This Is Us”) 16%
4 Sterling K. Brown (“This Is Us”) 14%
5 Bob Odenkirk (“Better Call Saul”) 13%
6 Liev Schreiber (“Ray Donovan”) 11%
7 Matthew Rhys (“The Americans”) 5%

Spacey topped all segments, but Ventimiglia won over the female segment for the second position 22% to Hopkins’ 15%. Men preferred Hopkins 20% to Ventimiglia’s 8%.


MODERN FAMILY - "Lake Life" (ABC/David Moir)

What would you vote for in the comedy series category?

1 “Modern Family” (ABC) 31%
2 “Black-ish” (ABC) 18%
3 “Veep” (HBO) 12%
4 “Master of None” (Netflix) 11%
5 “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt” (Netflix) 10%
6 “Silicon Valley” (HBO) 10%
7 “Atlanta” (FX) 8%

Modern Family topped all segments.

What do you think will win in the comedy series category?

1 “Modern Family” (ABC) 34%
2 “Veep” (HBO) 22%
3 “Black-ish” (ABC) 17%
4 “Atlanta” (FX) 10%
5 “Master of None” (Netflix) 7%
6 “Silicon Valley” (HBO) 6%
7 “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt” (Netflix) 5%

Modern Family again topped all segments.

Who would you vote for in the comedy actress category?

1 Julia Louis-Dreyfus (“Veep”) 24%
2 Tracee Ellis-Ross (“Black-ish”) 18%
3 Lily Tomlin (“Grace and Frankie”) 17%
4 Ellie Kemper (“Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt”) 16%
5 Allison Janney (“Mom”) 14%
6 Jane Fonda (“Grace and Frankie”) 7%
7 Pamela Adlon (“Better Things”) 4%

Women voted 21% for Tracee Ellis-Ross compared to 18% for Julia Louis-Dreyfus.

Who would you vote for in the comedy actor category?

1 William H. Macy (“Shameless”) 26%
2 Anthony Anderson (“Black-ish”) 19%
3 Aziz Ansari (“Master of None”) 18%
4 Donald Glover (“Atlanta”) 16%
5 Zach Galifianakis (“Baskets”) 11%
6 Jeffrey Tambor (“Transparent”) 10%

Macy won across all segments, but Ansari scored higher percentages among men (19%) and 18–34 year olds (24%) compared to Anderson (13% and 16%, respectively).

Limited Series

Ewan McGregor as Emmit Stussy in Fargo (Matthias Clamer/FX)

What would you vote for in the limited series category?

1 “Fargo” (FX) 32%
2 “Big Little Lies” (HBO) 24%
3 “Genius” (National Geographic) 18%
4 “Feud: Bette and Joan” (FX) 14%
5 “The Night Of” (HBO) 12%

More women, 31%, voted for Big Little Lies, compared to 25% for Fargo.

What do you think will win in the limited series category?

1 “Fargo” (FX) 32%
2 “Big Little Lies” (HBO) 30%
3 “Feud: Bette and Joan” (FX) 14%
4 “Genius” (National Geographic) 12%
5 “The Night Of” (HBO) 12%

Again, more women, 35%, voted for Big Little Lies, compared to 29% for Fargo.

Who would you vote for in the limited series/TV movie actress category?

1 Reese Witherspoon (“Big Little Lies”) 27%
2 Nicole Kidman (“Big Little Lies”) 21%
3 Carrie Coon (“Fargo”) 16%
4 Susan Sarandon (“Feud”) 13%
5 Jessica Lange (“Feud”) 12%
6 Felicity Huffman (“American Crime”) 11%

More men voted for Carrie Coon (25%) from Fargo, than for Reese Witherspoon (23%) from Big Little Lies.

Who would you vote for in the limited series/TV movie actor category?

1 Benedict Cumberbatch (“Sherlock: The Lying Detective”) 31%
2 Ewan McGregor (“Fargo”) 22%
3 Robert De Niro (“The Wizard of Lies”) 18%
4 Riz Ahmed (“The Night Of”) 11%
5 Geoffrey Rush (“Genius”) 10%
6 John Turturro (“The Night Of”) 8%

Benedict Cumberbatch won handily across all segments for Sherlock: The Lying Detective.

Other Categories

Sherlock, Season 4 premiere (Courtesy of Robert Viglasky/Hartswood Films 2016 for MASTERPIECE)

What would you vote for in the television movie category?

1 “Sherlock: The Lying Detective (Masterpiece)” (PBS) 38%
2 “Black Mirror: San Junipero” (Netflix) 17%
3 “Dolly Parton’s Christmas Of Many Colors: Circle Of Love” (NBC) 17%
4 “The Wizard Of Lies” (HBO) 15%
5 “The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks” (HBO) 14%

Sherlock: The Lying Detective trounced the competition across all segments.

What would you vote for in the reality competition category?

1 “The Voice” (NBC) 26%
2 “American Ninja Warrior” (NBC) 25%
3 “Top Chef” (Bravo) 17%
4 “The Amazing Race” (CBS) 14%
5 “RuPaul’s Drag Race” (VH1) 12%
6 “Project Runway” (Lifetime) 6%

Surprise! American Ninja Warrior was more popular among men (33%, compared to 22% for The Voice) and the 18–34 (34% compared to 18% for The Voice) and 35–54 (26% compared to 24% for The Voice) segments.

What would you vote for in the variety talk series category?

1 “Jimmy Kimmel Live!” (ABC) 27%
2 “The Late Late Show With James Corden” (CBS) 22%
3 “Last Week Tonight With John Oliver” (HBO) 20%
4 “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert” (CBS) 17%
5 “Full Frontal With Samantha Bee” (TBS) 8%
6 “Real Time With Bill Maher” (HBO) 6%

More 18–34 year olds (27%) voted for Last Week Tonight With John Oliver than Jimmy Kimmel Live! (25%). Men were evenly split at 26% for both series.


Big Bang Theory (Monty Brinton/CBS)

What was the biggest series snub in the Emmy nominations?

1 “The Big Bang Theory” (CBS) 16%
2 “Mr. Robot” (USA) 12%
3 “13 Reasons Why” (Netflix) 11%
4 “The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon” (NBC) 10%
5 “The Americans” (FX) 8%
6 “The Leftovers” (HBO) 5%
7 “Insecure” (HBO) 4%
8 “Dancing with the Stars” (ABC) 4%
9 “Bloodline” (Netflix) 3%
10 “The Good Place” (NBC) 3%
11 “Late Night With Seth Meyers” (NBC) 3%
12 “The Young Pope” (HBO) 3%

In one of the most divisive questions, a higher percentage (16%) of 18–34 year olds voted for 13 Reasons Why (compared to 11% for Big Bang Theory), and 17% of men voted for Mr. Robot (compared to 16% for Big Bang Theory). A few respondents (41) wrote in “Game of Thrones,” but the series didn’t air during the eligibility period for this year’s Emmys.

And what was the biggest performance snub in the Emmy nominations?

1 Winona Ryder (“Stranger Things”) 12%
2 Mandy Moore (“This Is Us”) 11%
3 Jeffrey Dean Morgan (“The Walking Dead”) 9%
4 Jimmy Fallon (“The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon”) 7%
5 Rami Malek (“Mr. Robot”) 7%
6 Taraji P. Henson (“Empire”) 7%
7 Ed Harris (“Westworld”) 5%
8 Michael McKean (“Better Call Saul”) 4%
9 Samira Wiley (“Orange Is the New Black”) 4%
10 Claire Danes (“Homeland”) 3%
11 Paul Giamatti (“Billions”) 3%
12 Jude Law (“The Young Pope”) 3%
13 Billy Bob Thornton (“Goliath”) 3%
14 Oprah Winfrey (“The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks”) 3%
15 Issa Rae (“Insecure”) 3%
16 Justin Theroux (“The Leftovers”) 3%

Among women, Mandy Moore was the bigger snub: 14% compared to Winona Ryder at 11% in the segment. Among those 55+, the spread was even greater with 12% voting for Moore, 8% voting for Jimmy Fallon, and 7% voting Ryder. Among 18-34 year olds, Ryder was followed by Jeffrey Dean Morgan at 10%, then Moore at 9%.

The 69th Emmy Awards will telecast live from the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles on Sunday, September 17 (8:00 p.m. ET/5 p.m. PT) on CBS. 

Tag Cloud

Action festivals 90s dexter Extras Superheroe indie italian canceled TV shows all-time golden globes Epix Year in Review spanish genre Esquire Thanksgiving Adult Swim Apple The Witch royal family Ellie Kemper young adult nfl anime Valentine's Day social media Food Network marvel cinematic universe Academy Awards DC streaming service transformers Columbia Pictures Amazon Prime GIFs game of thrones Disney TV Land classics Song of Ice and Fire game show ESPN Baby Yoda streaming Sundance TV hist TV movies NBA binge Election dceu CMT harry potter marvel comics telelvision Bravo Best Actress Watching Series BBC America Trophy Talk slashers godzilla Fargo series A24 screen actors guild based on movie Legendary docuseries hollywood blaxploitation Comic-Con@Home 2021 Premiere Dates Awards Tour Box Office adaptation vampires GoT comedies Fall TV Creative Arts Emmys San Diego Comic-Con reboot spanish language Emmy Nominations Mary Poppins Returns Super Bowl Marvel Studios Photos Western Discovery Channel blockbusters WarnerMedia TCA Winter 2020 Best and Worst cancelled TV series aliens Shondaland mission: impossible Britbox Opinion 2018 The Purge TV One Mindy Kaling Tomatazos Neflix name the review Lifetime Christmas movies golden globe awards USA Network E3 movie Reality Universal Writers Guild of America Sony Pictures Family obituary documentary Calendar Tarantino Oscar Set visit movies YouTube Red Lucasfilm police drama technology free movies hispanic heritage month spider-man 72 Emmy Awards CW Seed Horror Rocky singing competition Fox News 21st Century Fox Dark Horse Comics Nat Geo comic book movies adenture king arthur mcc jamie lee curtis Cosplay screenings cooking MTV fresh Tumblr Endgame spy thriller Showtime SXSW 2022 The Arrangement Shudder BET Awards toronto razzies Stephen King IMDb TV Lifetime Countdown Biopics TruTV Pop TV 79th Golden Globes Awards Certified Fresh justice league Film Festival comics renewed TV shows know your critic Teen IFC Films children's TV Fox Searchlight Winter TV Mary Tyler Moore Crunchyroll Holiday Drama 93rd Oscars HBO serial killer critics toy story sequels best latino Binge Guide animated wonder woman Red Carpet Toys ViacomCBS Women's History Month Television Academy The Walt Disney Company kids YouTube Premium Prime Video posters Superheroes spider-verse Walt Disney Pictures cinemax Paramount Network ID batman Tubi Chernobyl Turner twilight lord of the rings cartoon french Pop parents action-comedy critic resources Sneak Peek TV monster movies teaser talk show black comedy TCM scary movies 45 rom-coms sag awards biography book adaptation Tokyo Olympics streaming movies YA WGN suspense Black History Month Marvel Television 2021 comiccon LGBT laika VH1 supernatural ABC Signature black FOX zombies MSNBC halloween The Walking Dead Country nature Hallmark Christmas movies biopic Freeform strong female leads olympics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina APB IFC superhero political drama The Academy finale Amazon Studios Black Mirror die hard VOD stand-up comedy dark Music directors FXX franchise zero dark thirty Best Actor Infographic miniseries prank TCA Awards halloween tv christmas movies cults Best Director period drama Netflix cars archives Universal Pictures Elton John gangster Marvel thriller Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt revenge Sundance Now rt labs critics edition scary comic PlayStation 24 frames CNN Reality Competition romantic comedy NBC See It Skip It asian-american Emmys Schedule worst Broadway international Summer doctor who 2016 FX on Hulu joker SDCC Pride Month nbcuniversal Grammys TIFF award winner japanese SXSW HFPA Awards First Look Trivia blockbuster south america feel good new york cancelled television australia Pixar DC Comics psychological thriller Star Wars trophy canceled MCU independent Vudu 94th Oscars video on demand casting adventure zombie 2020 TLC A&E Christmas Film 20th Century Fox aapi DGA DC Universe robots Acorn TV Pirates Polls and Games 4/20 rotten movies we love Ovation BBC One rt archives high school dragons Mudbound FX women ratings werewolf live event target Tags: Comedy Pacific Islander new star wars movies mockumentary Disney+ Disney Plus DirecTV comic books jurassic park Musicals deadpool History Paramount Plus docudrama fast and furious Star Trek USA foreign CBS All Access 2017 RT History OneApp Mary poppins Nominations BAFTA spain ABC Family 71st Emmy Awards heist movie richard e. Grant king kong war travel child's play rotten Starz boxing Brie Larson Animation National Geographic popular VICE CBS YouTube book Comic Book Pet Sematary james bond El Rey sports Sci-Fi Ghostbusters spinoff RT21 quibi Alien ITV TCA crime drama indiana jones PBS NYCC Winners versus hidden camera Comedy TV renewals slasher OWN new zealand Peacock HBO Go football remakes news Logo crime Oscars SundanceTV Cannes dramedy Netflix Christmas movies venice disaster witnail Hallmark cops 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards medical drama Musical anthology video TCA 2017 historical drama Disney streaming service what to watch crossover green book Kids & Family pirates of the caribbean Heroines MGM Crackle Syfy Sundance natural history streamig stop motion a nightmare on elm street politics Character Guide saw Classic Film cancelled TV shows theme song TNT ABC concert South by Southwest Film Festival Cartoon Network scorecard Comics on TV Holidays ghosts AMC japan Hulu BET Hollywood Foreign Press Association films tv talk Paramount facebook Instagram Live emmy awards Turner Classic Movies comic book movie science fiction mutant Disney Plus boxoffice Wes Anderson mob Mystery Interview AMC Plus Comedy Central sopranos Rock elevated horror kaiju Podcast Martial Arts crime thriller space dogs Amazon 007 President Disney Channel art house breaking bad trailers Warner Bros. Television Critics Association GLAAD legend kong cancelled Spring TV LGBTQ Quiz American Society of Cinematographers live action TBS composers The CW Arrowverse debate 2019 Apple TV Plus diversity Travel Channel Apple TV+ basketball vs. E! psycho chucky satire Exclusive Video criterion 1990s Masterpiece television HBO Max superman festival worst movies sequel Avengers scene in color Hear Us Out cats Rocketman rt labs Captain marvel Best Picture Image Comics obi wan Trailer Marathons 99% Spike true crime Fantasy Anna Paquin Spectrum Originals Lionsgate discovery Amazon Prime Video X-Men First Reviews universal monsters unscripted reviews New York Comic Con BBC leaderboard Funimation 73rd Emmy Awards sitcom dreamworks Nickelodeon Video Games Rom-Com stoner 2015 romance documentaries PaleyFest dc hispanic