Critics Consensus

You're a Fresh One, Mr. Grinch... For Now

Plus, Overlord is grisly fun, The Girl in the Spider's Web is style over substance, Beautiful Boy is earnest and well acted, and The Ballad of Buster Scruggs is Certified Fresh.

by | November 8, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a green grumbler (The Grinch, featuring the voices of Benedict Cumberbatch and Rashida Jones), Nazi zombies (Overlord, starring Jovan Adepo and Wyatt Russell), a vigilante hacker (The Girl in the Spider’s Web, starring Claire Foy and Sverrir Gudnason), and an ambivalent addict (Beautiful Boy, starring Steve Carell and Timothée Chalamet). What are the critics saying?


The Grinch (2018) 58%

Various works of beloved author Theodor Geisel, a.k.a. Dr. Seuss, have been adapted in several forms over the years, but his best-known character is arguably the titular grump from his 1957 story How the Grinch Stole Christmas! The tale was first made into an animated TV special in 1967, then a stage production, and eventually a live-action film starring Jim Carrey as the Grinch. This week, we get the latest incarnation of the character in Illumination Entertainment’s The Grinch, in which Benedict Cumberbatch voices the holiday curmudgeon who plots to ruin Christmas for the citizens of nearby Whoville. Critics say The Grinch’s animation is colorful and top notch, and while it feels tame compared to the 1967 special, it’s currently teetering on the cusp of Freshness, and it’s probably enjoyable enough for young viewers unfamiliar with the story.


Overlord (2018) 81%

Over the past decade and change, J.J. Abrams has made a career of elevating genre films into major blockbuster entertainment — or taking major blockbuster entertainment and gleefully infusing it with genre elements. This week, audiences will get a proper dose of full-on B-movie goodness with an A-list sheen in the Abrams-produced Overlord, a revisionist World War II horror-thriller courtesy of director Julius Avery. Jovan Adepo and Wyatt Russell star in the grisly creature feature, which follows a group of U.S. paratroopers who crash land behind enemy lines, only to come across a secret Nazi lab full of unspeakable horrors. It’s pulpy, visceral, and action-packed, and critics say it’s an entertaining thrill ride for viewers who don’t mind a bit of blood and guts in their popcorn.


The Girl in the Spider's Web (2018) 40%

Swedish author Stieg Larsson’s hugely popular “Millennium” series of novels were already made into a trilogy of films before David Fincher took a crack at adapting the first book again in 2011, with franchise aspirations. Now we get a new story — based on one of the series’ novels that Larsson didn’t write — with another new cast, and it would seem something has been lost in translation. Claire Foy dons the black leather and dragon tattoo as Lisbeth Salander, whose talents are enlisted to secure a dangerous piece of software from the NSA, and critics say the film fails to capture what previously made Lisbeth such a compelling presence. Eschewing complex character development for fairly standard spy-movie elements and favoring action over intrigue, The Girl in the Spider’s Web has style to spare but may not offer much in the way of substance.


Beautiful Boy (2018) 68%

Be prepared for a whole lot more of Timothée Chalamet. After turning heads with his performance in Luca Guadagnino‘s Oscar-winning Call Me By Your Name, Chalamet has signed on for a number of big films, working with people like Greta Gerwig (again) and Denis Villeneuve. Before all that, though, he appears in this drama alongside Steve Carell, and both of them have got people talking about awards. Based on the dual memoirs of writer David Sheff and his son Nic, Beautiful Boy traces Nic’s struggle with addiction that nearly tore his family apart, and critics say it’s an earnest depiction that’s beautifully acted and feels genuine, even if the narrative covers familiar ground. While it may not shed any new light on the nature of addiction, the film is a showcase for Chalamet and Carell, who make the most of their meaty roles.


What’s New on TV

The Great British Baking Show: Season 5 (2014) 93%

There’s even more caramel, cakes, and camaraderie to enjoy in the fifth season of The Great British Baking Show.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Ballad of Buster Scruggs (2018)Joel and Ethan Coen‘s anthology film presenting six stories from the wild west, is Certified Fresh at 94%.
  • Chef Flynn (2018) , a documentary about teen culinary sensation Flynn McGarry, is at 89%.
  • El Angel (El ángel) (2018) , a drama about a 17-year-old thief in 1970s Argentina, is at 79%.
  • The Long Dumb Road (2018) , a comedy about a pair of strangers who decide to take a road trip together, is at 73%.
  • Weightless (2018) , about a lonely man who is suddenly reunited with the 10-year-old son he hasn’t seen since infancy, is at 71%.
  • The Delinquent Season (2018) , a drama about two seemingly happy married couples whose lives begin to unravel after a confrontation, is at 70%.
  • In a Relationship (2018) , about two couples whose lives intertwine over the course of a summer, is at 69%.
  • The Front Runner (2018) , starring Hugh Jackman as former U.S. presidential candidate Gary Hart in Jason Reitman‘s look back on his scandal-plagued campaign, is at 68%.
  • Liz and the Blue Bird (2018) , a Japanese animated film about a pair of young musicians who drift apart as they near the end of high school, is at 67%.
  • The New Romantic (2018) , about a college student frustrated with boys her own age who decides to date an older man, is at 65%.
  • Outlaw King (2018) , a Netflix original period adventure-drama starring Chris Pine as Scottish king Robert the Bruce, is at 56%.
  • Postcards From London (2018) , about a gay teen from rural Essex who moves to London and falls in with a group of male escorts, is at 50%.
  • Here and Now (Blue Night) (2018) , starring Sarah Jessica Parker as a veteran blues singer who attempts to balance a new tour with troubling medical news, is at 21%.

Tag Cloud

Dark Horse Comics 21st Century Fox Awards science fiction LGBTQ historical drama Shudder Teen supernatural Disney Summer Star Trek PBS doctor who DC Comics Awards Tour Watching Series zombie New York Comic Con HBO American Society of Cinematographers Sundance Now Calendar SDCC IFC Fantasy Star Wars Mary Poppins Returns TV President Epix CBS All Access Bravo Year in Review streaming police drama 2017 Cartoon Network serial killer facebook WGN Countdown crime talk show Fox News ITV harry potter Crackle period drama Spike TCA 2017 Mary poppins Acorn TV NBC Red Carpet anime Spring TV Captain marvel crime thriller Cosplay ABC binge Horror Lucasfilm X-Men Syfy TCM Spectrum Originals Christmas vampires APB Food Network political drama CMT Reality Competition Superheroes Masterpiece Lionsgate PaleyFest discovery Paramount finale Superheroe Music diversity Nat Geo Photos Reality aliens zombies Grammys AMC MTV Freeform cults First Look Esquire sequel Winners based on movie ABC Family Showtime miniseries 20th Century Fox USA RT History NYCC Trailer Sneak Peek Character Guide TruTV SXSW MSNBC composers Animation Pirates psycho Premiere Dates National Geographic BET Comic Book See It Skip It adaptation dc The Arrangement Set visit Super Bowl CBS technology robots Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Walt Disney Pictures 45 spider-man VH1 Fall TV GoT unscripted Starz Sundance Apple mockumentary Rocky Adult Swim Writers Guild of America dramedy Schedule what to watch SundanceTV History hist cinemax Warner Bros. biography Best and Worst boxoffice war Marathons BBC America Box Office Western cats cops sports BBC medical drama The CW Mary Tyler Moore MCU A&E TV Land Amazon Prime E3 Pop crossover transformers OWN Nominations TLC TCA El Rey Pixar 24 frames sitcom FXX docudrama spy thriller ratings Mystery Martial Arts Rom-Com E! thriller Sci-Fi dceu Trivia Musical Paramount Network Certified Fresh VICE Comedy Central 2019 travel Song of Ice and Fire cooking Universal Creative Arts Emmys 2015 Opinion Amazon green book casting Britbox ESPN FOX Action Toys Infographic Sony Pictures Valentine's Day Anna Paquin mutant Shondaland golden globes television Black Mirror IFC Films Extras Quiz GLAAD justice league Hulu CNN blaxploitation 2016 Drama TNT social media Tumblr Marvel Biopics 007 politics Netflix Musicals Ovation Interview Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Logo DC streaming service 2018 Brie Larson jamie lee curtis Tomatazos singing competition Oscars romance DGA Comics on TV Winter TV Country Polls and Games GIFs Thanksgiving Ghostbusters Lifetime Rock DC Universe comic Podcast DirecTV Kids & Family Election adventure Mindy Kaling crime drama CW Seed Disney Channel YouTube Red YouTube Premium Ellie Kemper YA USA Network San Diego Comic-Con Emmys Video Games Columbia Pictures Nickelodeon comiccon FX TBS Holidays TIFF award winner Comedy festivals Trophy Talk