Tomatometer Watch: Prometheus

In cyberspace, everyone can hear the critics scream.

by | May 31, 2012 | Comments



Don’t call it a prequel. Or do. Wait, now it isn’t. At this stage everyone’s probably a little weary of the speculation over whether or not Ridley Scott’s Prometheus is a direct forerunner to his 1979 classic Alien — most of us simply can’t wait to get a look at the thing. Well, the wait is (almost) over and the first reviews have started to arrive from the trades and outlets in the UK (once again those lucky geezers have the jump on American audiences). What do the critics have to say?

We won’t delve too deeply into it for fear of possible spoilers, but so far the word is strong — well, strong enough, with plenty of praise for Scott’s visuals and a sense of welcome return to sci-fi for the filmmaker, who hasn’t touched the genre since 1982’s Blade Runner.

“Not only does Prometheus herald the rebirth of Alien, it breaths life back into intelligent sci-fi,” says Grant Rollins at the UK’s Sun, while the Hollywood Reporter‘s Todd McCarthy says the movie brings “enough visual spectacle, tense action and sticky, slithery monster attacks to hit the spot with thrill-seeking audiences worldwide.”

At The Guardian, however, Peter Bradshaw writes that Scott “has counter-evolved his 1979 classic Alien into something more grandiose, more elaborate — but less interesting,” and Variety‘s Justin Chang reports that Prometheus “remains earthbound in narrative terms, forever hinting at the existence of a higher intelligence without evincing much of its own.”

Where will the critics meet on Prometheus? Scott’s highwater mark is his 1977 debut The Duelists, which is at 100% (albeit with only 14 reviews aggregated), but the more appropriate comparisons in terms of genre would be Alien — currently at 96% — and Blade Runner, which is 92% fresh. We’d be surprised if the movie charts in that hallowed company, but it’s gotta be better than Alien: Resurrection, right?

If you need to temper those expectations, of course, remember that Sir Ridley’s last endeavor, 2010’s underwhelming Robin Hood, earned a less than stellar 43% from critics.

Stay tuned for more reviews as they come in.

Prometheus is in theaters on June 8.

Tag Cloud

adventure Awards IFC Teen Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Musical Thanksgiving composers boxoffice what to watch Netflix Sci-Fi Opinion Star Wars PBS President social media cooking thriller Ghostbusters NBC Masterpiece Election Comic Book Box Office Drama The CW Sundance romance singing competition TLC medical drama Character Guide 007 Esquire transformers GLAAD Pirates Holidays CBS TV Land Photos war Marathons ABC justice league DC Comics sitcom Trailer A&E CNN Paramount Disney Channel Summer WGN Comedy Central Writers Guild of America APB History Spring TV Premiere Dates CMT Tomatazos DC Universe Reality cops docudrama Western vampires Amazon Reality Competition Fantasy ABC Family Nominations Rom-Com RT History E! zombie Universal Starz Logo Marvel Pop Comedy Martial Arts First Look BBC America MSNBC Red Carpet Country Crackle science fiction Animation Extras crime TCA Mindy Kaling dc GIFs Ellie Kemper based on movie Cosplay sports comiccon Video Games 2017 Emmys serial killer 45 TCA 2017 OWN Freeform CBS All Access Trivia Calendar supernatural TV Disney DirecTV VH1 American Society of Cinematographers cats Kids & Family Mystery Music talk show technology Showtime FX X-Men Set visit TIFF Winter TV Rock 2015 cinemax Watching Series 21st Century Fox LGBTQ BET MTV harry potter police drama VICE YA FXX BBC politics TruTV Horror Oscars crime drama GoT ITV Syfy 2016 aliens ESPN Grammys Interview Mary Tyler Moore Year in Review biography Sneak Peek Nickelodeon Hulu Nat Geo Schedule Lionsgate The Arrangement AMC Warner Bros. El Rey Valentine's Day TCM NYCC Action Infographic SDCC Countdown SundanceTV Biopics Adult Swim Food Network Bravo TNT Cartoon Network Super Bowl Musicals Toys Certified Fresh Star Trek binge Superheroes historical drama TBS USA discovery Podcast Fall TV Tumblr travel FOX crime thriller psycho Best and Worst period drama 24 frames Polls and Games dceu HBO Lifetime Winners E3 Dark Horse Comics political drama diversity Rocky Fox News dramedy PaleyFest