Sydney Pollack: A Retrospective

RT looks at the filmmaker's highest-rated films.

by and | May 27, 2008 | Comments

With two Oscar wins and plenty more nominations under his
belt, Sydney Pollack was a filmmaker that Hollywood admired. He was also a
proven actor’s director whose fruitful relationships with performers like Robert
Redford resulted in films like Three Days of the Condor, The Way We Were,
and Jeremiah Johnson; even his off-screen friction with Tootsie
actor Dustin Hoffman gave way to one of Pollack’s most famous on-screen

Pollack undoubtedly knew how to frame a star, working with
the likes of Jane Fonda, Sally Field, Tom Cruise, Dustin Hoffman and Paul Newman
to superb results. He also worked freely within genres, infusing thrillers,
comedies, and Westerns with a personal brand of socio-political reflection.
Below, we count down the ten highest-rated films that Pollack directed, and then
take a look at the late filmmaker’s most memorable performances in front of the


more info…
10. Sabrina (1995)
Tomatometer: 62%

Pollack took on the legacy of
Billy Wilder in updating the romantic comedy Sabrina, about a beautiful
young woman (Julia Ormond) caught between a charming playboy (Greg Kinnear) and
his no-nonsense brother (Harrison Ford). While comparisons to the original
abound — along with its cast of Golden Hollywood legends Humphrey Bogart, Audrey
Hepburn, and William Holden — Pollack’s Sabrina turned out this side of Fresh
and garnered two Oscar nominations, for John Williams’ score and the song
“Moonlight,” performed by Sting.



This Property is Condemned

09. This Property is Condemned (1966)
Tomatometer: 64%

A pre-Godfather
Francis Ford Coppola co-scripted Pollack’s second feature (along with Fred Coe
and Edith Sommer) based on a Tennessee Williams play; the result was the
consequently steamy, seamy tale of a boarding house floozy (Natalie Wood) and a
railroad man (Robert Redford) caught in a tragic romance in a poor Mississippi
town. Pollack would go on to direct Redford in six more films, including the
Oscar-winning Out of Africa.


The Scalphunters

more info…
08. The Scalphunters (1968)
Tomatometer: 75%

At the tail end of the civil
rights movement, Pollack directed this social satire-masquerading-as-comedy
Western starring Burt Lancaster, Ossie Davis, Telly Savalas and Shelley Winters.
When a trapper (Lancaster) is forced to “trade” his prized pelts for an educated
slave (Davis), he goes after the offending Indians; when they are in turn killed
by a band of scalphunters (led by Savalas), he turns his attentions to them.
Pollack would team up with Lancaster again in his next film, The Swimmer,
co-directed with Frank Perry.


The Firm

more info…
07. The Firm (1993)
Tomatometer: 76%

One of the few thrillers in
Pollack’s filmography (see Three Days of the Condor below) is The
which along with The Pelican Brief, helped launch a wave of
John Grisham fever in 1990s Hollywood. The tale of an ambitious attorney who
discovers sinister doings at his new law firm also captured star Tom Cruise at
the height of his thirtysomething career; Pollack would reunite with Cruise six
years later in Stanley Kubrick’s Eyes Wide Shut, appearing on the other
side of the camera.


Absence of Malice

more info…
06. Absence of Malice (1981)
Tomatometer: 71%

One of the best movies about
journalism came courtesy of former Detroit Free Press editor Kurt Luedtke, who
co-scripted Pollack’s Oscar-nominated film about a man with familial mob ties
(Paul Newman) wrongly implicated in a crime by a hungry newspaper reporter
(Sally Field). Supporting actress Melinda Dillon picked up her second Academy
Award nomination for her role as a devout woman whose tragic secret gets
splashed across the front page.

Sketches of Frank Gehry

more info…
05. Sketches of Frank Gehry (2006)
Tomatometer: 81%

Pollack’s lone documentary
feature focuses on his close friend, prize-winning architect Frank Gehry. The
director integrated interviews with art-world celebrities like Dennis Hopper,
Julian Schnabel, and even himself, creating an intimate and even look at the
“starchitect” behind such awesomely warped feats as Spain’s Guggenheim Museum.


They Shoot Horses, Don't They? Don't They???!!!

04. They Shoot Horses, Don’t They?
Tomatometer: 83%

Dreams are dashed left and
right in Pollack’s deeply moving spectacle of ambition and desperation at a
Depression-era dance marathon, which earned a total of nine Oscar nominations
but won only one, for Gig Young’s performance as the contest’s tireless MC. It
also earned Jane Fonda her first Oscar nod, marking a turning point in Fonda’s


3 Days of the Condor

more info…
03. Three Days of the Condor (1975)
Tomatometer: 89%

Re-teaming with Robert
Redford would prove very successful for Pollack, and he put Redford’s leading
man magnetism to work as Joe Turner, AKA Condor, a low-level CIA intelligence
operative who becomes the target of a covert assassination plot. Evoking the
Hollywood thrillers and unsettled political climate of the 1970s (and suggesting
Jason Bourne long before the Bourne saga hit theaters), Three Days of
the Condor
excelled in creating taut, believable Hitchcockian suspense.



more info…
02. Tootsie (1982)
Tomatometer: 89%

Dustin Hoffman became
Hollywood’s favorite cross-dresser with Tootsie, a comedy about a thorny
actor so desperate for work that he turns to drag and becomes a soap opera
sensation — as a woman. The comedy was nominated for ten Oscars, winning one
for Jessica Lange as Best Supporting Actress; Pollack’s onscreen turn as
Hoffman’s aggravated agent brilliantly segued on-set tensions between the
director and his star into one of the film’s most crackling scenes.


Jeremiah Johnson

more info…
01. Jeremiah Johnson (1972)
Tomatometer: 100%

Pollack’s best-reviewed film
is yet another of his many collaborations with Robert Redford, the hard-bitten
saga of a 19th century mountain man who encounters life, death, and
Indians in the wide open terrain of Utah. While passed over by the Oscars — it
was the year of Cabaret, Deliverance, and The Godfather
Jeremiah Johnson nevertheless remains Pollack’s most critically
celebrated work. As with many Pollack films, the Western isn’t merely a genre
exercise; it’s also an existential character study that examines the impact of
living the anti-establishment life, a driving theme in 1970s New Hollywood.

Sydney Pollack started out in the business as an actor, appearing in 60s
television fare like The Twilight Zone and Alfred Hitchcock Presents.
He acted less frequently when he found his calling in directing and producing,
which, in a way, made him a more fascinating actor; he found the freedom to
choose roles that played to his strengths and particular style. Here, we take a
look at Pollack’s best roles in movies not directed by himself.


Husbands and Wives

Husbands and Wives (1992)
Tomatometer: 100%

Husbands and Wives is arguably Woody Allen’s most realized drama (that
doesn’t involve murder), with its cinema verite filmmaking and strong
performances from Allen, Judy Davis, Mia Farrow, and Sydney Pollack. The role
of Jack is vintage Pollack, a man who never lets go of his measured regality
even as his life begins to crumble away.

There aren’t any Pollack clips on YT, but check out this fantastic scene with Davis.


Eyes Wide Shut

Eyes Wide Shut (1999)
Tomatometer: 78%In Kubrick’s
Eyes Wide Shut
, Pollack portrays Victor Ziegler, the closest this infamously
murky movie gets to having a “bad guy.” He’s a complacent figure, watching as
his friend and doctor, William (Tom Cruise), goes on a nightmarish trip of
sexual politics and self-discovery.


Changing Lanes

Changing Lanes (2001)
Tomatometer: 78%

Pollack made an acting career out of lawyers, businessmen, and meeting room
dwellers whose moral ethics never made a sinner out of him, but never quite the
innocent man, either. He delivers a speech in Changing Lanes that sums up
his MO: “I can live with myself because at the end of the day I think I
do more good than harm. What other standard have I got to judge by?”


Michael Clayton

more info…
Michael Clayton (2007)

Pollack re-entered
the public consciousness at large with his brawny supporting role in Michael
. Working in a law firm filled with “fixers” probably means your
moral compasses are slight askew, but Pollack gives his role major gravitas,
becoming a voice of reason as George Clooney freefalls into a diabolical


Made of Honor

more info…
Made of Honor (2008)
Tomatometer: 12%

The wacky parent has long been a staple in romantic comedies Pollack gets his
turn in the Patrick Dempsey-Michelle Monaghan vehicle, Made of Honor. It
may not be the most glamorous final role, but at least demonstrates Pollack’s
willingness to continually push himself as an actor, even after a spot was
reserved for him as a major movie director and producer.

Tag Cloud

spider-man satire Walt Disney Pictures New York Comic Con Amazon Prime award winner Christmas Ovation Captain marvel game show what to watch The Arrangement Oscars ITV sitcom Vudu green book DGA nature cops miniseries Character Guide romantic comedy diversity GIFs Logo dceu latino justice league science fiction National Geographic theme song psychological thriller TCA Crackle period drama zero dark thirty psycho Shudder 2018 E3 Video Games Tumblr space Ghostbusters Hulu SundanceTV Pet Sematary Television Academy Apple TV Plus travel Universal Adult Swim Syfy dogs political drama First Look Warner Bros. werewolf indiana jones sag awards Black History Month PlayStation American Society of Cinematographers Pop Certified Fresh FX streaming Brie Larson Turner mutant Film CMT hispanic canceled TV shows Esquire children's TV CBS All Access critics Lifetime Christmas movies sequel Columbia Pictures slashers USA Network television TNT Elton John HBO NYCC El Rey NBC die hard Hallmark Christmas movies Marvel zombies thriller GoT IFC Films Starz Teen crime thriller BAFTA dark Extras Family docudrama foreign cancelled Spike scary movies Awards Tour comiccon Comics on TV anime MSNBC hist WGN blaxploitation Acorn TV E! AMC name the review Sundance TV SDCC Star Trek Hear Us Out Disney+ Disney Plus Rom-Com MTV Tomatazos Summer screenings blockbuster Sci-Fi transformers BET Awards talk show HBO Max technology Netflix VICE Disney streaming service Heroines Travel Channel Pirates CW Seed twilight TV Land Photos Quiz Watching Series teaser Kids & Family Netflix Christmas movies Rocketman 2016 Masterpiece First Reviews screen actors guild book HBO Go concert mission: impossible reviews The Purge Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cancelled TV shows FX on Hulu BET Musicals batman Pride Month Sundance Now TV Schedule Stephen King casting Marathons Set visit films Mindy Kaling Disney Plus toy story Ellie Kemper unscripted Nickelodeon Cannes ABC Disney Channel cinemax Fantasy Premiere Dates DirecTV medical drama documentary Red Carpet vampires LGBT Cosplay adventure Music all-time Academy Awards GLAAD The Walking Dead crime drama Amazon Prime Video WarnerMedia Apple TV+ Black Mirror chucky spinoff Countdown natural history Lifetime supernatural Amazon Comic Book free movies Spectrum Originals Endgame cancelled TV series RT21 Country Martial Arts child's play 2017 Mudbound YA historical drama Food Network Super Bowl DC Comics MCU Creative Arts Emmys TBS comedies 2020 Writers Guild of America ratings series Mary Tyler Moore war 2019 SXSW zombie Mary poppins cartoon Valentine's Day 45 Arrowverse Hallmark San Diego Comic-Con biography Crunchyroll BBC One social media Marvel Television Holiday Animation Reality Competition Lionsgate anthology Peacock Dark Horse Comics cults APB Film Festival sports doctor who Baby Yoda Biopics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina golden globes franchise Drama Superheroe OWN BBC America TCA Winter 2020 Spring TV Horror Nat Geo based on movie 2015 crime disaster FOX video a nightmare on elm street dramedy christmas movies crossover YouTube Premium Rock adaptation Comedy Central independent A24 cooking robots Polls and Games Toys discovery witnail Tubi Infographic Winter TV Fox News Chernobyl spain renewed TV shows movie Showtime Funimation versus Holidays The Witch tv talk parents TruTV LGBTQ canceled Tarantino Paramount news Rocky Mystery south america Bravo Freeform Fall TV Avengers true crime singing competition TIFF comic finale Classic Film Year in Review Apple TCM Shondaland composers ESPN YouTube festivals TCA 2017 X-Men directors joker cancelled television 24 frames movies Emmy Nominations CNN quibi dc VH1 TLC Anna Paquin ABC Family Pop TV binge BBC cars Awards A&E Comedy PaleyFest PBS serial killer 4/20 Marvel Studios RT History Action Song of Ice and Fire cats CBS Thanksgiving 20th Century Fox Women's History Month stoner Calendar Opinion Western elevated horror animated Podcast richard e. Grant Sony Pictures rotten movies we love 007 aliens IFC Cartoon Network Election Pixar game of thrones romance Mary Poppins Returns See It Skip It Trailer Sneak Peek Grammys Star Wars Box Office politics Turner Classic Movies Discovery Channel criterion Epix Emmys DC Universe Winners Reality harry potter dragons boxoffice indie Lucasfilm VOD police drama revenge video on demand asian-american Nominations spanish language kids 21st Century Fox OneApp Disney The CW documentaries TV renewals Interview FXX Trivia reboot jamie lee curtis Binge Guide DC streaming service USA facebook breaking bad spy thriller stand-up comedy strong female leads History ghosts Trophy Talk universal monsters Superheroes Britbox President comics Paramount Network best Musical YouTube Red 71st Emmy Awards Sundance halloween mockumentary Amazon Studios Best and Worst