RT Talks Music, Irish Stories With "Once" Director John Carney

by | May 14, 2007 | Comments

"Once" is a small Irish film about musicians, shot on a threadbare budget, with no-name actors in the leads. Not exactly a prescription for a blockbuster. So the fact that this little film is connecting with festival audiences in a big way has even director John Carney caught by surprise.

"Once" tells the story of a Dublin street musician (the Frames’ Glen Hansard) who meets a young Czech pianist (Marketa Irglova); together, they form a deep musical and personal bond. In real life, Hansard and Irglova have been collaborators for years (check out their 2006 album, "The Swell Season"), and director John Carney utilized their chemistry to create a heartfelt portrait of two sad people finding their way.

Carney conceived the film as a small project, but it got a major boost at Sundance, where it became a critical favorite and won the festival’s Audience Award. In recent weeks, Carney, Hansard, and Irglova have been touring America by bus, screening "Once" and playing songs from its soundtrack.

"Once" opens May 18 in limited release. Carney spoke with Rotten Tomatoes about his unconventional promotional tour for the film, the concept of making a naturalistic musical, and the state of Irish filmmaking.


Rotten Tomatoes: How’s your tour across America going?

John Carney: It’s great. We’re seeing a lot of the country from the ground, and we’re meeting real people, which is not what happens when you’re just flying into airports. I’m actually getting the scale of this large place you guys call home.

RT: How’s the response been on the road?

JC: Oh, it’s been amazing. Like, weirdly good. I don’t know what it is about this film, but it seems to have connected with people, which is great, because we started it off as a small labor of love and a pet project. To have something that we did from our hearts be received warmly is vindicating and kinda rewarding as an artist.

RT: How much of this film is based upon the lives of the two leads?

JC: They brought a lot to the roles, but originally, I had written it for actors. I was pretty sure Cillian would be the guy, and I’d get an Eastern European actress to play the lead role. But that said, once they had gotten the parts, and once we decided that’s the way we were going to go, Glen and Marketa are very forceful people, and have great chemistry together as musicians, so they brought a lot of that to the finished product. But we actually had to do, structurally, very little changing of the parts once we decided that we weren’t going to go with actors who could half-sing, we were going to go with singers who could half-act. It wasn’t based on their lives, but they brought a lot of themselves to the roles.

RT: Given that you were using non-actors, was the material a hard sell?

JC: Well, you see, it wasn’t, because once we decided to go with non-actors, we also decided we wouldn’t bring it to producers. We wouldn’t try to finance the film in the normal way. We’d get a little bit of state money, and it would be the kind of thing we could shoot for nothing, basically. We’d put in all the favors, and shoot it really quickly, and get it done. If it bombed, then nobody really would have cared about it, and if it did do well, then great. There weren’t a bunch of producers checking their watches and their bank balances. It was very much a John Cassavetes approach to making a film.

RT: Do you think Irish films or filmmakers are underappreciated in the States?

JC: No, we don’t have any good films. We don’t make good films in Ireland. We have yet to find our niche, and our voice. We’ve tried to make films in the last 10 years for an American audience. They all bombed, and rightfully so. If you’re in that fight, you’ve lost the war, because America’s a massive marketplace. So we need to make films for ourselves, primarily, and then if a couple of them strike, that’s great.

Read the rest of the interview here!

Once” is a small Irish film about musicians, shot on a threadbare budget, with no-name actors in the leads. Not exactly a prescription for a blockbuster. So the fact that this little film is connecting with festival audiences in a big way has even director John Carney caught by surprise.

Once” tells the story of a Dublin street musician (the Frames’ Glen Hansard) who meets a young Czech pianist (Marketa Irglova); together, they form a deep musical and personal bond. In real life, Hansard and Irglova have been collaborators for years (check out their 2006 album, “The Swell Season”), and director John Carney utilized their chemistry to create a heartfelt portrait of two sad people finding their way.

Carney conceived the film as a small project, but it got a major boost at Sundance, where it became a critical favorite and won the festival’s Audience Award. In recent weeks, Carney, Hansard, and Irglova have been touring America by bus, screening “Once” and playing songs from its soundtrack.

Once” opens May 18 in limited release. Carney spoke with Rotten Tomatoes about his unconventional promotional tour for the film, the concept of making a naturalistic musical, and the state of Irish filmmaking.

Rotten Tomatoes: How’s your tour across America going?

John Carney: It’s great. We’re seeing a lot of the country from the ground, and we’re meeting real people, which is not what happens when you’re just flying into airports. I’m actually getting the scale of this large place you guys call home.

RT: How’s the response been on the road?

JC: Oh, it’s been amazing. Like, weirdly good. I don’t know what it is about this film, but it seems to have connected with people, which is great, because we started it off as a small labor of love and a pet project. To have something that we did from our hearts be received warmly is vindicating and kinda rewarding as an artist.

RT: And Glen Hansard and Marketa Irglova are playing after the screenings of the film, right?

JC: There’s a little Q and A after each screening and then they’re playing three or four songs. It kinda really helps [reinforce] the intimacy of the project.

RT: So, you’re afraid to fly?

JC: Yeah, I am.

RT: So how did you get over here?

JC: I just had to do one big flight. I can do the one big flight, but if I spend any more time, or I know that I have to do a bunch of flying, I’m just in a very bad mood and I’m very stressed out. I mean, I know the statistics, and I know that I’m safe. But if you look at your greatest fear in life, even if you know you’re wrong%u2026 For me, it’s torture and flying. I didn’t admit to the studio that I had a fear of flying. I kinda dressed [the bus tour] up as a really cool thing to do, and the got it. I was like, “Thank God I don’t have to fly.”

RT: Cillian Murphy was interested in the lead role. But some of the charm of the film is in the fact that the leads are non-actors.

JC: I think that’s a very big factor as to why people are responding to the film, because you feel like you’re watching a real couple. People here feel like it’s got a naturalistic feel to it, an uncontrived feeling, and that they’re not being fed a line, that they’re watching something unfold that’s real. That said, I think Cillian would have done a wonderful job on the film, but people would have expectations if he was in it.

RT: How much of this film is based upon the lives of the two leads?

JC: They brought a lot to the roles, but originally, I had written it for actors. I was pretty sure Cillian would be the guy, and I’d get an Eastern European actress to play the lead role. But that said, once they had gotten the parts, and once we decided that’s the way we were going to go, Glen and Marketa are very forceful people, and have great chemistry together as musicians, so they brought a lot of that to the finished product. But we actually had to do, structurally, very little changing of the parts once we decided that we weren’t going to go with actors who could half-sing, we were going to go with singers who could half-act. It wasn’t based on their lives, but they brought a lot of themselves to the roles.

RT: And how much of it is autobiographical?

JC: My girlfriend and I were living apart. We were in two different countries at the time that I was writing it, and I was feeling quite isolated. I wanted to write something about a character who would meet a woman who would kinda guide him in the right direction. I guess it was a bit of a male fantasy in a way, that I would meet someone where I wouldn’t betray my relationship with my girlfriend, but at the same time you’d meet somebody you could tell your girlfriend about. Sometimes it’s the strangers, the people who know you least, that actually say exactly what you need to hear. It’s not your family or your friends, sometimes it’s the person who comes along and says, “You know what you need?” And suddenly, they’re right. And the little they know about you, the more objective they are. That’s where I was at when I was writing the film, so there’s definitely an autobiographical strand to it.

RT: Given that you were using non-actors, was the material a hard sell?

JC: Well, you see, it wasn’t, because once we decided to go with non-actors, we also decided we wouldn’t bring it to producers. We wouldn’t try to finance the film in the normal way. We’d get a little bit of state money, and it would be the kind of thing we could shoot for nothing, basically. We’d put in all the favors, and shoot it really quickly, and get it done. If it bombed, then nobody really would have cared about it, and if it did do well, then great. There weren’t a bunch of producers checking their watches and their bank balances. It was very much a John Cassavetes approach to making a film.

RT: Do you consider this a musical?

JC: I kind of do, actually. I shouldn’t sell it like that, because if you say it’s a musical, it’ll scare people off. It’s an attempt to make a modern musical that appeals to younger people, an audience that wouldn’t necessarily watch a Gene Kelly film or a Frank Sinatra film, simply because they just don’t buy the “breaking into song” thing, and the fakeness of those films, the kind of suspension of disbelief that you need to have when you’re watching those films. I wanted to make a naturalistic musical.

RT: What’s next for you?

JC: I’m reading some stuff. I’d like to do more human stories, rather than bigger films. I like having that control, and it’s hard once you [work on bigger projects] to have control. I think ultimately audience members like to see someone controlling the quality of a film. A lot of films you see are made by committees, and studios, and producers. I guess I’ll try to balance that and make a film that’s small and heartfelt and sincere, and tell Irish stories, tells some stories from home that show a few other sides of the coin to people about Ireland. There are a lot of misconceptions and preconceptions about Ireland that I’d be interesting in bursting, and revealing some other sides of Irish life at the moment.

RT: Do you think Irish films or filmmakers are underappreciated in the States?

JC: No, we don’t have any good films. We don’t make good films in Ireland. We have yet to find our niche, and our voice. We’ve tried to make films in the last 10 years for an American audience. They all bombed, and rightfully so. If you’re in that fight, you’ve lost the war, because America’s a massive marketplace. So we need to make films for ourselves, primarily, and then if a couple of them strike, that’s great. That’s a really good track record for a smaller country. But we don’t need to be concerned with competing with these big American films. “My Left Foot” and “The Crying Game,” they were flukes. And we’re all trying to copy them, and it’s not the way we should be going. We should make films for our own selves, and they’ll naturally find their audience. [Americans would rather] see films that have a sincere Irish heart, and yet are universal stories.

Tag Cloud

Podcast renewed TV shows NYCC Kids & Family spinoff HBO name the review Mindy Kaling Drama franchise dragons Paramount Network Epix deadpool ghosts Comedy Central TV renewals DC streaming service rotten parents See It Skip It ID Bravo historical drama 2016 Stephen King Teen directors VOD The Academy festivals batman Year in Review children's TV witnail disaster political drama archives christmas movies comics BBC Shondaland IFC Films Character Guide Rocky Video Games ABC cancelled television Captain marvel Oscars Adult Swim travel toronto independent TBS Winners asian-american Esquire best child's play Marvel Television SundanceTV indiana jones Pride Month die hard Classic Film cancelled TCA Winter 2020 dceu tv talk facebook Christmas Shudder E! documentary Netflix ESPN romance true crime worst movies universal monsters Watching Series Fox Searchlight Song of Ice and Fire Martial Arts fast and furious Music Cosplay Elton John TV Land Holiday Emmys Funimation zombie Masterpiece Apple TV Plus Showtime cinemax spanish language CNN miniseries football Writers Guild of America game of thrones Rom-Com Fantasy medical drama harry potter dramedy Apple ITV Nominations Avengers Musical TCA 4/20 NBC concert Election Schedule indie anime Polls and Games BBC America james bond Marvel VICE crime all-time strong female leads Trivia CMT Country President 007 Hear Us Out Food Network Tomatazos politics Trailer adventure TruTV USA Network 45 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina crime drama BAFTA reboot ratings richard e. Grant halloween tv Turner Classic Movies crime thriller MSNBC 2020 docudrama nbcuniversal natural history canceled Film comic Pixar Hallmark Christmas movies canceled TV shows spider-man Animation spanish Holidays The Witch cults Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt sequel PBS Star Wars The Walking Dead animated Fall TV composers Creative Arts Emmys DirecTV TLC National Geographic supernatural First Look New York Comic Con sequels PaleyFest teaser anthology Fox News BET doctor who venice space book TCA Awards cancelled TV series Mary Tyler Moore SDCC cartoon Crackle American Society of Cinematographers The Purge social media award winner science fiction Starz Lionsgate The Arrangement Horror unscripted dc Reality Competition adaptation Turner talk show comiccon Family police drama Thanksgiving Mudbound streaming Hulu Peacock stop motion 20th Century Fox Trophy Talk 2017 green book RT21 rt archives Heroines thriller Discovery Channel TIFF screen actors guild singing competition A24 CBS All Access blockbuster japanese scary movies Pop TV Comedy HBO Go Best and Worst television mockumentary Marathons movie Crunchyroll TCM breaking bad superhero Quiz Endgame DGA emmy awards Academy Awards werewolf Apple TV+ Certified Fresh CW Seed finale Black Mirror discovery LGBTQ Netflix Christmas movies FX on Hulu TCA 2017 game show theme song Dark Horse Comics golden globes Superheroes biography APB Sony Pictures spain a nightmare on elm street Interview TNT Hallmark Arrowverse toy story Set visit Columbia Pictures Nat Geo romantic comedy Star Trek Rock cops Paramount Logo Disney Plus Awards 71st Emmy Awards CBS halloween YouTube sitcom TV casting 99% Disney+ Disney Plus psychological thriller jamie lee curtis quibi zero dark thirty Pet Sematary YouTube Premium Valentine's Day Premiere Dates Sneak Peek 2018 Box Office ABC Family vampires Travel Channel Acorn TV OWN binge Extras PlayStation Super Bowl video on demand kids black Nickelodeon twilight Infographic Grammys based on movie satire robots movies Syfy Film Festival Comic Book Sundance TV italian dogs revenge remakes boxoffice Freeform OneApp Spike Reality slashers sports Awards Tour Ovation Tumblr foreign dark Toys HBO Max Biopics Britbox mutant documentaries MTV spy thriller technology diversity 2019 Television Critics Association Walt Disney Pictures FOX hollywood Television Academy WGN Mystery Amazon nature Ghostbusters Spectrum Originals war FXX Summer Mary poppins transformers australia GLAAD Universal Lifetime Christmas movies Emmy Nominations Red Carpet comic books First Reviews chucky Amazon Prime Video south america Calendar Lucasfilm stand-up comedy stoner psycho zombies aliens BBC One Superheroe Tubi criterion what to watch elevated horror festival 2015 Sundance Now Chernobyl Countdown GIFs Baby Yoda X-Men cooking VH1 screenings MCU latino worst Spring TV Sci-Fi mission: impossible versus 21st Century Fox nfl RT History USA History Warner Bros. San Diego Comic-Con Musicals hispanic The CW Ellie Kemper crossover scorecard Action 24 frames comedies 72 Emmy Awards AMC serial killer Mary Poppins Returns period drama Winter TV Western BET Awards laika Cannes Disney films classics Black History Month E3 Opinion WarnerMedia Pop Vudu cars Anna Paquin Disney Channel LGBT sag awards A&E SXSW hist YA critics DC Universe french reviews justice league video Amazon Prime rotten movies we love Rocketman Cartoon Network YouTube Red Brie Larson FX El Rey Binge Guide DC Comics Sundance joker free movies cancelled TV shows series Marvel Studios Women's History Month GoT IFC obituary blaxploitation cats Lifetime Photos news Tarantino Disney streaming service Pirates Amazon Studios Comics on TV