Lord of the Rings Vs. Harry Potter: The Ultimate Fantasy Franchise Face-Off

Does the Boy Who Lived out-magic the hobbits, orcs, elves, and dwarves of Middle-earth? Find out as we break both series down by Tomatometer, box office, character quality, and more!

by | May 21, 2020 | Comments

It’s the Super Bowl of fantasy series showdowns in the latest edition of Vs., in which we’re pitting the Lord of the Rings movies against the Harry Potter films – including, for both franchises, the prequels. (And no, this does not help either side on the scoreboard.) Do Peter Jackson’s big-screen takes on J.R.R. Tolkien’s novels walk all over the movie adaptations of J.K. Rowling’s books like so many Ents stampeding through a forest? Or does the Boy Who Lived snatch up victory as if it were some quick-darting Golden Snitch? Find out as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks down each franchise by Tomatometer and Audience Score, box office, heroes and villains, and one special wild card category.

The Lord of the Rings films are available to rent or buy on FandangoNOW, Vudu, iTunes, and AmazonThe Harry Potter films are available to rent or buy on FandangoNOW, Vudu, iTunes, and Amazon

Thumbnail images by Universal courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

versus anthology strong female leads Avengers women fresh Lifetime Christmas movies Vudu MTV Sundance quibi Infographic live event 99% 93rd Oscars Pop nfl mockumentary Walt Disney Pictures all-time ABC YouTube disaster cats Arrowverse trophy Disney talk show 73rd Emmy Awards science fiction SundanceTV king kong Spring TV Winter TV slasher Travel Channel Native 2020 spanish VH1 new york National Geographic asian-american Spectrum Originals romance obituary sitcom indie period drama 71st Emmy Awards ID Pacific Islander monster movies diversity fast and furious independent leaderboard Sundance TV Peacock Fall TV rotten football AMC Food Network Hear Us Out TCM Oscars movie Trophy Talk San Diego Comic-Con tv talk Mindy Kaling Superheroes streaming olympics remakes ABC Family Disney+ Disney Plus transformers Cosplay Pride Month GoT dexter popular italian japanese Disney streaming service comiccon Television Academy IMDb TV book adaptation animated TNT high school movies Pop TV Sony Pictures Tumblr Film Festival Geeked Week docuseries franchise summer TV Polls and Games breaking bad documentary blaxploitation game of thrones jurassic park festival Ovation Fargo television critics Calendar 45 a nightmare on elm street obi wan Indigenous DC Comics die hard south america broadcast Star Wars Celebration concert slashers suspense Lucasfilm Film AMC Plus The Walt Disney Company cancelled TV shows Paramount Plus rom-coms Neflix technology Countdown Comic Book gangster Amazon Studios scene in color series dark Writers Guild of America boxoffice Music Instagram Live kong APB Captain marvel festivals DC streaming service target dc Sneak Peek Premiere Dates IFC TLC blockbuster SXSW Watching Series ABC Signature Emmy Nominations The Academy Classic Film award winner trailers Fox Searchlight ViacomCBS Drama TV One FX Biopics black child's play Exclusive Video Country Musicals adenture series anime hispanic historical drama witnail streamig New York Comic Con Dark Horse Comics dogs composers pirates of the caribbean biopic Apple NYCC psycho screenings Amazon Prime Ellie Kemper Columbia Pictures zombie Best Actress Mary Poppins Returns stoner Paramount Pictures dragons History Masterpiece Comedy Central American Society of Cinematographers comic book movies Netflix Christmas movies Musical crossover WarnerMedia Turner nbcuniversal Toys prank CMT spider-man ESPN hispanic heritage month 2019 2021 wonder woman TCA Awards dreamworks OneApp Awards Adult Swim dceu best Acorn TV Disney Plus Thanksgiving BBC First Reviews interviews supernatural Prime Video Christmas screen actors guild DC Universe foreign international twilight South by Southwest Film Festival Heroines rt archives adventure BBC One politics cartoon CBS king arthur BAFTA laika Election marvel comics TV renewals TIFF Lifetime Best Actor live action toronto Mudbound kaiju psychological thriller Mary Tyler Moore Marvel Television Reality Competition Tags: Comedy Schedule BET Best Director free movies BET Awards 21st Century Fox films DGA YA mutant TCA cinemax Grammys latino Trivia Logo Trailer posters WGN TV movies TCA 2017 discovery Amazon MGM Comedy MSNBC Showtime Binge Guide Tubi werewolf political drama Black History Month scary docudrama war game show cults blockbusters casting Amazon Prime Video Mary poppins Box Office 2015 green book Lionsgate 72 Emmy Awards Wes Anderson X-Men Holidays parents Paramount OWN Marvel Studios cooking The Walking Dead justice league 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards MCU Action Pixar Ghostbusters vs. universal monsters Horror stop motion Crackle finale zero dark thirty scorecard emmy awards Rock RT History Pet Sematary Turner Classic Movies superman RT21 travel A24 TBS based on movie IFC Films USA Network cops Apple TV Plus adaptation Discovery Channel chucky First Look DirecTV Interview Fox News Hollywood Foreign Press Association El Rey singing competition renewed TV shows documentaries TruTV YouTube Red Martial Arts FXX mob elevated horror Rocky Bravo police drama medical drama name the review Warner Bros. news doctor who Reality Opinion cancelled Pirates HFPA TV Land Netflix Apple TV+ FOX spy thriller A&E Marvel Cannes rt labs 2017 zombies legend spinoff GLAAD E3 aapi Super Bowl stand-up comedy vampires new zealand joker Tarantino aliens Sony crime thriller Year in Review 24 frames ratings Western HBO cancelled television Red Carpet Alien Tokyo Olympics book Certified Fresh video on demand NBC young adult heist movie nature Hallmark Christmas movies kids Britbox Shondaland Fantasy Rom-Com Animation biography Best and Worst See It Skip It Chernobyl Image Comics Black Mirror golden globe awards Quiz Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt godzilla Creative Arts Emmys hist what to watch natural history thriller Endgame 79th Golden Globes Awards Sundance Now Valentine's Day toy story Academy Awards LGBTQ Emmys Podcast Baby Yoda halloween Disney Channel social media richard e. Grant CW Seed spanish language Comics on TV FX on Hulu Brie Larson rt labs critics edition archives CBS All Access Oscar worst movies unscripted miniseries theme song comic book movie scene in color film series 20th Century Fox LGBT Comic-Con@Home 2021 black comedy Mystery deadpool Winners razzies BBC America Television Critics Association jamie lee curtis Epix sequels SXSW 2022 Spike serial killer 007 sag awards hidden camera mcc debate Broadway Hallmark Nat Geo Focus Features facebook true crime Esquire President saw Rocketman CNN indiana jones robots HBO Max genre Sci-Fi Awards Tour comics Character Guide Photos Freeform mission: impossible teaser Cartoon Network Teen USA crime NBA satire Starz superhero Set visit ITV boxing feel good Summer Legendary spider-verse Hulu 4/20 video cars directors comic hollywood Tomatazos know your critic The Witch Nickelodeon harry potter target scene in color binge Holiday 90s sports comic books Women's History Month revenge VOD marvel cinematic universe batman sopranos french space scary movies 1990s 2018 scene in color Universal Nominations lord of the rings Kids & Family Song of Ice and Fire reviews summer TV preview TCA Winter 2020 Elton John Video Games streaming movies Star Trek criterion australia worst reboot 94th Oscars sequel basketball SDCC Stephen King Marathons action-comedy VICE Superheroe Funimation Family cancelled TV series venice children's TV crime drama rotten movies we love royal family spain telelvision golden globes summer preview Shudder james bond Universal Pictures Best Picture The CW halloween tv YouTube Premium ghosts The Arrangement christmas movies canceled TV shows PaleyFest art house HBO Go critic resources Chilling Adventures of Sabrina PBS GIFs Star Wars Paramount Network E! TV Anna Paquin Syfy canceled romantic comedy classics PlayStation 2016 dramedy japan comedies The Purge new star wars movies Crunchyroll Extras