Lord of the Rings Vs. Harry Potter: The Ultimate Fantasy Franchise Face-Off

Does the Boy Who Lived out-magic the hobbits, orcs, elves, and dwarves of Middle-earth? Find out as we break both series down by Tomatometer, box office, character quality, and more!

by | May 21, 2020 | Comments

It’s the Super Bowl of fantasy series showdowns in the latest edition of Vs., in which we’re pitting the Lord of the Rings movies against the Harry Potter films – including, for both franchises, the prequels. (And no, this does not help either side on the scoreboard.) Do Peter Jackson’s big-screen takes on J.R.R. Tolkien’s novels walk all over the movie adaptations of J.K. Rowling’s books like so many Ents stampeding through a forest? Or does the Boy Who Lived snatch up victory as if it were some quick-darting Golden Snitch? Find out as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks down each franchise by Tomatometer and Audience Score, box office, heroes and villains, and one special wild card category.

The Lord of the Rings films are available to rent or buy on FandangoNOW, Vudu, iTunes, and AmazonThe Harry Potter films are available to rent or buy on FandangoNOW, Vudu, iTunes, and Amazon

Thumbnail images by Universal courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

true crime documentary golden globe awards psycho Ovation all-time Rocketman cops comic book movies spanish language ViacomCBS CNN YouTube Premium Spike crime drama Calendar Crunchyroll game show technology Reality Competition TruTV action-comedy venice Disney streaming service Premiere Dates crossover popular Pop Watching Series justice league Universal binge historical drama asian-american aapi Hallmark archives ghosts Disney+ Disney Plus Star Wars mcc Sci-Fi Avengers gangster live action witnail Shudder basketball superhero facebook based on movie Ellie Kemper 2015 adenture video Fox News animated PlayStation E3 BBC DC Universe chucky DirecTV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mary Poppins Returns ID Sundance TV 2016 Paramount Plus Hallmark Christmas movies political drama Baby Yoda indie 2017 screen actors guild 90s hidden camera halloween tv police drama series SXSW adventure jurassic park 4/20 latino History Women's History Month Starz Exclusive Video TV movies TV renewals Mudbound spanish remakes CBS All Access Super Bowl Sony Pictures 93rd Oscars BAFTA 1990s Food Network Year in Review Amazon Studios Film Horror what to watch Anna Paquin A&E docudrama indiana jones streaming movies pirates of the caribbean The Arrangement Biopics critics hispanic Disney Extras sag awards Legendary Western quibi social media WarnerMedia USA Pop TV The Witch Superheroe dark Heroines stand-up comedy kids 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards teaser The Purge DGA comic book movie Spectrum Originals obituary olympics Netflix Christmas movies Amazon Prime breaking bad posters 24 frames game of thrones canceled First Reviews Endgame MCU king arthur Sundance Now supernatural Valentine's Day reviews a nightmare on elm street E! 45 Cannes saw sequels comics rt archives australia cars Trailer Rock movies Kids & Family TCA 2017 Comedy Central President Star Trek WGN discovery crime thriller new york theme song PaleyFest international See It Skip It Discovery Channel Television Critics Association Wes Anderson sequel parents zero dark thirty GIFs Freeform rotten movies we love Holidays directors dragons Pet Sematary biography golden globes Shondaland 21st Century Fox concert movie Cartoon Network Tumblr VH1 Drama CMT Syfy Paramount Network TCA strong female leads AMC sports Marvel Studios Britbox criterion period drama Trivia Election Red Carpet Academy Awards Disney Plus Fantasy toy story Interview independent psychological thriller Tokyo Olympics DC Comics Walt Disney Pictures blockbusters Television Academy 72 Emmy Awards cancelled TV shows Binge Guide 73rd Emmy Awards VOD Paramount Marvel BET romantic comedy dramedy prank sitcom christmas movies nbcuniversal Cosplay Apple TV+ mission: impossible scene in color free movies 71st Emmy Awards harry potter french italian Classic Film new star wars movies hist Comedy Martial Arts war comic monster movies Lucasfilm IFC scorecard FX on Hulu Esquire cults Sneak Peek Music A24 television Fox Searchlight toronto TIFF Sundance Nominations jamie lee curtis blaxploitation IFC Films composers National Geographic Amazon Prime Video Turner Classic Movies Alien Teen Winners TCA Winter 2020 godzilla 2019 Opinion rt labs young adult El Rey MSNBC Trophy Talk Song of Ice and Fire The Academy razzies BBC America heist movie Columbia Pictures Reality Nat Geo San Diego Comic-Con Dark Horse Comics Toys space TBS spain Writers Guild of America Grammys Black Mirror Ghostbusters GLAAD blockbuster DC streaming service Nickelodeon king kong james bond 007 TV One TLC spinoff natural history rotten TCA Awards canceled TV shows singing competition nfl transformers 2020 anthology werewolf FOX 2021 dc marvel comics book adaptation Elton John Emmy Nominations children's TV Set visit royal family slasher CBS miniseries Black History Month Apple TV Plus Stephen King festivals Musical Hulu south america japan thriller LGBT RT21 deadpool tv talk Countdown reboot Spring TV cooking festival hollywood X-Men RT History Image Comics TCM HBO high school spy thriller cinemax Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt news Apple Winter TV Family women lord of the rings stop motion batman Pacific Islander NBC Superheroes Acorn TV Captain marvel fast and furious book new zealand TNT PBS docuseries name the review satire Character Guide green book Travel Channel Tubi LGBTQ Holiday Mindy Kaling Christmas Mystery films serial killer The Walking Dead trailers cats Bravo target screenings halloween The CW boxoffice slashers elevated horror video on demand SundanceTV Creative Arts Emmys dogs comic books laika rom-coms versus Chernobyl politics Emmys streaming Vudu Comic Book Rom-Com Tarantino crime black Polls and Games comiccon OWN OneApp universal monsters marvel cinematic universe Pirates FX boxing legend Comics on TV debate science fiction 20th Century Fox Animation Action twilight Tomatazos Podcast classics USA Network Showtime Country child's play New York Comic Con adaptation YouTube Red franchise Netflix FXX spider-man APB documentaries kaiju Rocky Infographic GoT superman Thanksgiving cancelled television cartoon comedies Funimation TV Photos Schedule ABC Signature biopic know your critic Best and Worst finale zombie Masterpiece richard e. Grant worst worst movies joker vampires Warner Bros. ABC nature dexter Lifetime Comic-Con@Home 2021 ESPN disaster NBA YA Pixar Disney Channel Logo 2018 aliens revenge HBO Max unscripted talk show Mary poppins Film Festival foreign stoner fresh Hear Us Out Lionsgate scary movies Adult Swim NYCC ABC Family doctor who American Society of Cinematographers Mary Tyler Moore japanese feel good Peacock 99% Fall TV hispanic heritage month best cancelled TV series Quiz CW Seed Amazon Arrowverse suspense Musicals casting SDCC Video Games YouTube emmy awards Brie Larson dceu award winner First Look Turner die hard HBO Go mockumentary ITV mutant Oscars BBC One VICE telelvision BET Awards travel Marvel Television Certified Fresh Pride Month cancelled MTV ratings diversity wonder woman Lifetime Christmas movies football Awards Tour Broadway critic resources Box Office kong anime Marathons medical drama rt labs critics edition zombies romance TV Land renewed TV shows Awards Epix robots Summer Crackle The Walt Disney Company