Little Women Social Reactions: Saoirse Ronan and Florence Pugh are Perfect in Greta Gerwig's Unique Adaptation

Early reactions on social media say Gerwig has delivered an inventive but faithful interpretation of the novel with brilliant performances from its stellar cast.

by | October 24, 2019 | Comments

Another adaptation of Little Women? Louisa May Alcott’s classic novel has been made into a number of movies, and most of them have been highly regarded — by critics, fans, and awards organizations alike. Greta Gerwig’s new version, which just received a standing ovation at a guild screening, is no different. Well, it is apparently different in that it’s a unique take on the material, mostly for the better, according to the first wave of critics’ social reactions to the movie. Still, we can expect the usual Oscar-worthy performances and a generally enjoyable adaptation.

Here’s what critics are saying about Little Women on social media:

Have we gotten another great adaptation?

It’s lovely.
Hannah Woodhead, Little White Lies

It’s inventive and wonderful.
Sean Fennessey, The Ringer

Wonderful. A loving, meticulously-crafted adaptation that exceeded my expectations. Heartfelt, moving and a terrific showcase for its extremely talented cast and beloved source material.
Kara Warner, People Magazine

Little Women is charming just like the novel/prior versions…Rousing score. Timely as ever. Hard not to cheer.
Scott Feinberg, Hollywood Reporter

Someone, please, invent a word stronger than “masterpiece” so I can amply describe Greta Gerwig’s Little Women. More-than-a-masterpiece? Masterpiece 2.0?
David Jenkins, Little White Lies

It rules.
David Sims, The Atlantic

Does it elicit particularly personal reactions?

Jo’s lines in Little Women resonate with me completely differently now as a 33 year old single writer. Wanting to remain independent but wanting to be loved. Greta’s take on the story made me connect with Jo in a way I never had. As a girl, I just thought she was crazy to reject Laurie.
– Amy Kaufman, Los Angeles Times

I’ve seen Little Women twice now and it’s one of my very favorite movies of the year.
– David Canfield, Entertainment Weekly

One of the most pleasurable cinema experiences of my life.
– David Jenkins, Little White Lies

Sony Pictures

(Photo by Sony Pictures)

How is this one different from past adaptations?

Greta Gerwig takes the straightforward story of Little Women and boldly scrambles it, starting two-thirds of the way through and retelling most of what you remember via flashbacks and cross-cutting. Call it Louisa May Alcott meets 21 Grams.
Kyle Buchanan, New York Times

Little Women has a very strong last third… and a modern interpretation of the novel that shines brightly. I liked her take on it even when it is hard to follow regarding flashbacks.
Sasha Stone, Awards Daily

Will fans of the book appreciate it?

Greta Gerwig delivers a both passionately faithful and gorgeously original take.
David Canfield, Entertainment Weekly

There’s nothing to disparage and many reasons to be pleased with Little Women. Especially, I’m thinking, for those who know the book and have a profound affection for this 19th Century saga about choices, tough terms, romance, heartbreak, love, struggle and artistic aspiration.
Jeffrey Wells, Hollywood Elsewhere

How is the ensemble cast?

Each role [is] perfectly cast.
Scott Feinberg, Hollywood Reporter

Saoirse is a fierce Jo, Chalamet/Dern/Streep especially are great in support, and Florence Pugh is astonishing.
David Canfield, Entertainment Weekly

Saoirse Ronan and Florence Pugh are the standout performances.
Gregory Ellwood, The Playlist

Excellent performances from Saoirse Ronan and Florence Pugh.
Jeffrey Wells, Hollywood Elsewhere

Flo Pugh and Streep are standouts.
Sasha Stone, Awards Daily

For my money, the MVP in Little Women is Florence Pugh…She’s hilarious and winning as Amy, the character best served by Gerwig’s structural gambits.
Kyle Buchanan, New York Times

Florence gets a lot of great notes to play as Amy March and she plays each one pretty much perfectly. As we’re seeing over and over again, she has a screen presence and performing instincts that are pretty god damn incredible.
Jordan Crucchiola, Vulture

Sony Pictures

(Photo by Sony Pictures)

What about the men?

Timothee Chalamet is the best thing about Little Women. He lights up the screen in every scene he’s in.
Jazz Tangcay, Awards Daily

Best part of Greta Gerwig’s Little Women is the idea that Louis Garrel as a heartthrob will soon be implanted in mainstream American brains. As he should be.
Ryan Lattanzio, IndieWire

What about the contributions behind the camera?

Greta Gerwig, writer/director of the new version of Little Women [got] a standing ovation. And it was well deserved!
Pete Hammond, Deadline Hollywood

Fervent, top-notch direction by Greta Gerwig; superb lensing and set design.
– Jeffrey Wells, Hollywood Elsewhere

Are there any problems?

Little Women is charming if not a wee bit long…for such a pretty score it’s overscored? There are moments you just want to hear the girls banter but… nope.
Gregory Ellwood, The Playlist

At best, it’s a fresh approach that makes you rethink familiar material. But it can also make simple plot and character developments a bit harder to locate.
Kyle Buchanan, New York Times

I have to say that it didn’t quite grab me as I’d hoped. Flashbacks, curious dream sequences, confusing here and there. Handsome and lusciously authentic, but feels in-and-outish.
Jeffrey Wells, Hollywood Elsewhere

Sony Pictures

(Photo by Sony Pictures)

Is it an awards contender?

Best Picture nominee… maybe?
Gregory Ellwood, The Playlsit

The last three Best Picture winners end happily and portrayed the world as ultimately hopeful. Greta Gerwig’s Little Women is the first movie of the year that does just that. So… front runner?
Sean Fennessey, The Ringer

We’ll see as far as Oscars — nice to have an upbeat option. The 36-year-old actress turned auteur could become the first female two-time best director Oscar nominee.
Scott Feinberg, Hollywood Reporter

I’m not saying Jo March is Saoirse’s Oscar, but truly her only issue as an actress is that she’s so good & makes her roles look so effortless and genuine and complete that she might fall into the Amy Adams camp of being so simply good it’s like Academy voters take her for granted.
Jordan Crucchiola, Vulture

An award-season cherry.
Jeffrey Wells, Hollywood Elsewhere

Little Women is in theaters December 25.


Little Women (2019)

Adjusted Score: 113.317%
Critics Consensus: With a stellar cast and a smart, sensitive retelling of its classic source material, Greta Gerwig's Little Women proves some stories truly are timeless.
Synopsis: Writer-director Greta Gerwig (Lady Bird) has crafted a Little Women that draws on both the classic novel and the writings... [More]
Directed By: Greta Gerwig

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

American Society of Cinematographers VOD travel nfl disaster 2018 YouTube Comedy dceu RT21 historical drama hist kids vampires prank comics blockbusters festival Logo Tumblr USA golden globe awards Drama free movies PaleyFest cartoon YA Kids & Family BET President Freeform Awards witnail venice cars Creative Arts Emmys BBC America romantic comedy Mary Poppins Returns talk show festivals Nickelodeon psychological thriller cinemax heist movie classics satire remakes know your critic GoT scorecard mockumentary book Action Food Network romance Fall TV LGBT Tomatazos Reality Television Academy Lionsgate Rock Disney unscripted tv talk 20th Century Fox FX Rocketman space movies hidden camera 2015 Pride Month obituary renewed TV shows Holidays documentary TCM Legendary ESPN Premiere Dates Shondaland APB TV One superhero 2019 DirecTV breaking bad ghosts name the review Baby Yoda SDCC Crunchyroll Warner Bros. BBC One rotten child's play black Sony Pictures elevated horror quibi miniseries First Reviews NYCC Hulu Mystery lord of the rings Podcast biography Nominations E3 Trailer latino Thanksgiving WarnerMedia Starz football strong female leads Rom-Com Black History Month The Purge TruTV james bond justice league ViacomCBS Disney streaming service Trophy Talk Infographic Amazon Apple TV Plus Tubi Sundance TV serial killer Certified Fresh king kong stoner TBS Fantasy CMT Adult Swim TV Land TV movies Broadway harry potter true crime video Best and Worst BET Awards Pop comedies anthology toronto TCA Winter 2020 Superheroe Election Epix cops Brie Larson streaming movies Academy Awards Teen marvel cinematic universe The Academy cancelled TV shows Mindy Kaling screenings TCA 2017 rt archives Opinion 71st Emmy Awards MCU Travel Channel Country chucky sports Video Games FXX Mary poppins Anna Paquin crime thriller Tarantino ITV critics crime drama Lucasfilm ABC Signature Toys Oscars HBO canceled diversity cancelled television Schedule Alien Polls and Games movie Peacock deadpool versus directors monster movies The Walking Dead Spectrum Originals Disney Plus discovery Paramount Network kong Horror LGBTQ transformers 2017 ABC Family IFC Films documentaries boxoffice Marvel Studios Amazon Prime children's TV DC streaming service indiana jones popular 93rd Oscars Awards Tour Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Lifetime Netflix Christmas movies australia Trivia 007 Star Trek crossover TNT Countdown Spike Netflix supernatural a nightmare on elm street dogs YouTube Premium Television Critics Association scene in color El Rey Ghostbusters Apple parents BBC Film First Look halloween cats medical drama series Holiday Writers Guild of America Masterpiece Hear Us Out X-Men emmy awards 2021 Elton John See It Skip It rotten movies we love reboot Sundance Now Grammys Fox Searchlight hispanic BAFTA VH1 Showtime finale adventure NBC dragons laika spinoff Dark Horse Comics singing competition cults richard e. Grant award winner sequel Black Mirror Crackle joker new star wars movies Columbia Pictures Emmy Nominations Bravo Stephen King Paramount Star Wars international SXSW TV Musicals dramedy Cosplay Universal Ellie Kemper Box Office Comic Book HBO Max E! psycho Esquire kaiju Comedy Central Pacific Islander Ovation razzies WGN Avengers cancelled saw live action Winners asian-american Women's History Month anime Rocky Interview canceled TV shows FOX Spring TV Heroines new york fresh Biopics aapi aliens slashers animated spain independent Film Festival Extras Exclusive Video Christmas politics stop motion Fox News Song of Ice and Fire Animation women OWN Sci-Fi blaxploitation game show TLC docudrama Amazon Prime Video Cannes Acorn TV toy story Mudbound The Arrangement stand-up comedy TCA television Sundance golden globes Apple TV+ police drama DC Universe GLAAD sequels franchise The Walt Disney Company theme song 45 french Sneak Peek Superheroes DC Comics Disney Channel Marathons spanish language Lifetime Christmas movies Funimation best adaptation Super Bowl comic books FX on Hulu Martial Arts Chilling Adventures of Sabrina crime trailers Turner Classic Movies werewolf Amazon Studios docuseries San Diego Comic-Con New York Comic Con period drama mission: impossible Paramount Plus Marvel Television indie spider-man SundanceTV films robots social media Family archives Emmys Turner PBS universal monsters Red Carpet casting Valentine's Day MTV ratings criterion mutant Character Guide Summer nbcuniversal batman Britbox telelvision jurassic park science fiction Endgame technology news 24 frames A&E south america worst movies political drama new zealand zombies thriller rom-coms TIFF Marvel Vudu natural history Photos 99% MSNBC all-time IFC Year in Review foreign Reality Competition 72 Emmy Awards composers Mary Tyler Moore Hallmark Christmas movies 2016 4/20 DGA CNN video on demand Musical PlayStation sag awards cooking twilight nature Music pirates of the caribbean Comics on TV Western boxing Walt Disney Pictures what to watch Quiz halloween tv comiccon sitcom The Witch teaser 2020 scary movies spy thriller japanese Pop TV USA Network ID spanish Binge Guide RT History war facebook comic blockbuster game of thrones italian VICE A24 reviews superman streaming target Winter TV Pixar Syfy christmas movies Discovery Channel Calendar YouTube Red Image Comics 21st Century Fox The CW Captain marvel History hollywood Cartoon Network Pet Sematary OneApp Disney+ Disney Plus Classic Film Hallmark zero dark thirty Watching Series dc fast and furious based on movie Shudder dark worst CBS GIFs green book National Geographic book adaptation concert doctor who revenge Arrowverse high school 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards CBS All Access HBO Go ABC screen actors guild binge jamie lee curtis AMC TV renewals CW Seed Set visit zombie Pirates Nat Geo die hard cancelled TV series TCA Awards Chernobyl godzilla