Early Consensus: "Revenge of the Sith" May Be the Best "Star Wars" Movie

by | May 12, 2005 | Comments

After George Lucas’s first two "Star Wars" prequels received lukewarm responses from fans, it looks like he will end the series on a triumphant and satisfying note with the concluding chapter. Early reviews from the nation’s print, online, and broadcast critics, are gushing praises for "Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith."

This grimmer chapter, chronicling Anakin Skywalker’s decent into the dark side and transformation into Darth Vader, has scored an exceptional 86% on the Tomatometer. Despite some clunky lines, critics think the character-driven Episode III is an exhilarating rollercoaster ride and a satisfying sendoff of a beloved series. Todd McCarthy of Variety calls it "the best in the overall series since ‘The Empire Strikes Back.’" Kirk Honeycutt of Hollywood Reporter says, "The final episode of George Lucas’ cinematic epic ‘Star Wars’ ends the six-movie series on such a high note that one feels like yelling out, ‘Rewind!’"

Compared to the previous two prequels, both of which are in the low to mid-60’s on the Tomatometer, Episode III’s 86% is a major improvement, and the only prequel chapter to be Certified Fresh. When it is released next week, there’s also a very good chance that it’ll be the best reviewed film in wide release. For comparison, "The Empire Strikes Back" scores 98% on the Tomatometer and the original "Star Wars" scores 93%.

Tomatometer Scores for the Star Wars series:

86% – Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith
65% – Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones
62% – Star wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace
80% – Return of the Jedi
98% – The Empire Strikes Back
93% – Star Wars

Tag Cloud

Sundance ABC Family American Society of Cinematographers TruTV NYCC cooking Pirates Mary Tyler Moore TCM zombie 24 frames Winter TV BET Rom-Com Hulu biography MSNBC Set visit Star Wars VH1 Superheroes sitcom Marvel crime thriller The CW Countdown E! Awards Spring TV ESPN Box Office aliens war Holidays diversity Logo Grammys Action vampires NBC Nat Geo Starz Disney TV Nominations Musicals Crackle Masterpiece Comedy Super Bowl cops Freeform Interview FX Bravo harry potter 007 Comedy Central social media CMT Biopics El Rey GLAAD Comic Book Best and Worst Universal serial killer Music Fox News thriller Disney Channel Mystery Character Guide Cosplay Country Polls and Games Writers Guild of America Fall TV TNT CNN Animation A&E Lionsgate Toys Rock VICE science fiction LGBTQ CBS Year in Review crime OWN comiccon USA Adult Swim Kids & Family psycho TLC Extras MTV Horror PaleyFest dramedy Rocky Lifetime Calendar Sneak Peek First Look sports FOX Emmys Infographic DC Comics RT History Winners FXX crime drama Martial Arts Showtime travel ABC GoT Ghostbusters boxoffice Premiere Dates Sci-Fi The Arrangement Amazon docudrama SDCC GIFs cinemax Valentine's Day Photos AMC Summer TCA History period drama Tomatazos Exclusive Video technology Cartoon Network Pop Netflix 2015 Thanksgiving Star Trek TBS Nickelodeon 2017 police drama TCA 2017 HBO Marathons APB X-Men Esquire Election Watching Series supernatural TV Land PBS Trivia 2016 President Oscars Podcast CBS All Access Trailer discovery Reality Competition Tumblr Dark Horse Comics Reality Drama Red Carpet Video Games BBC America Syfy Certified Fresh DirecTV Teen WGN Schedule based on movie politics singing competition SundanceTV Fantasy Food Network adventure TIFF Opinion BBC ITV IFC