News

Doctor Sleep First Reviews: Rebecca Ferguson Shines in Faithful, Surprisingly Thoughtful Sequel

Critics say Mike Flanagan's follow-up to the Stephen King classic packs an unexpected emotional punch but has enough scares and callbacks to please fans.

by | October 30, 2019 | Comments

Despite opening to mixed reviews in 1980, Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining has become one of the landmark horror classics of all time. That’s why creating a legacy sequel almost 40 years later was seen as a daunting task. Fortunately, Mike Flanagan’s Doctor Sleep, a follow-up to both Stephen King’s novel of the same name and Kubrick’s adaptation of its predecessor, is receiving mostly positive reviews out of the gate. Not everyone considers the new installment worthy, but thanks to Flanagan’s unique talents and at least one must-see performance, the movie seems set to satisfy fans of both of its sources.

Here’s what critics are saying about Doctor Sleep:


Is it a worthy follow-up to The Shining?

“I still don’t know if The Shining needed a second act, but Doctor Sleep presents one that’s fresh and unsettling enough to justify its existence.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

Doctor Sleep may not be ‘necessary,’ per se, but it’s highly engaging and entertaining on almost every level, and that makes it absolutely worthwhile.” – Germain Lussier, io9

“[It’s] not only a satisfactory sequel, but one that refuses to use the original as a crutch while still integrating it appropriately.” – Deirdre Molumby, entertainment.ie

“[It’s] both a magnificent movie in its own right and a worthy follow-up to one of the greatest films of all time.” – Eric Eisenberg, Cinema Blend

Doctor Sleep is somewhat entertaining and interesting but cannot, in any way, compare to its predecessor.” – Allison Rose, FlickDirect

“It’s a snooze-fest.” – Linda Marric, The Jewish Chronicle


So we should just avoid comparing it to Kubrick’s film?

“A completely different beast to The Shining…Flanagan and Doctor Sleep forge their own place in horror canon.” – Kyle Anderson, Nerdist

Doctor Sleep isn’t a typical sequel. It uses The Shining as a launching point but weaves an extremely different tale.” – William Bibbiani, Bloody Disgusting

“If we are going to get an endless string of sequels and reboots, then the best we can probably hope for is for talented artists to use those sequels and reboots to say the things they want to say about the stuff that matters to them.” – Matt Singer, ScreenCrush


Warner Bros. Pictures
(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures)

Does it honor both the Kubrick movie and King’s novels?

Doctor Sleep works as both a sequel to the book and the movie of The Shining, bringing together the two universes seamlessly.” – Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

“Flanagan weaves fluidly between the separate worlds of King and Kubrick in much the way that Dan mediates between the living and the dead.” – Anton Bitel, Little White Lies

“In a way that poignantly echoes the plight of young Danny himself, the new movie sometimes brings to mind a child caught between two quarreling parents, and attempting to stage a reconciliation.” – Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

“It stays true to the source material but also satisfies fans of the film. It’s a delicate balance, to be sure, but one that absolutely works. Maybe too well.” – Germain Lussier, io9

“Pandering to dueling source material results in a jagged puzzle beneath both of their standards.” – Eric Kohn, IndieWire


Do you need to have seen or read The Shining?

“There’s absolutely an argument to be made that Flanagan relies a bit too much on Kubrick’s film.” – Germain Lussier, io9

“It’s a fascinating application of cultural memory in the service of storytelling, considering how much its central emotion mandates audience investment in the earlier events.” –  Eric Kohn, IndieWire


What’s it like to return to the Overlook Hotel?

“The loving recreation of The Shining’s Overlook Hotel production design is awe-inspiring.” – Eric Eisenberg, Cinema Blend

“As a fan of Kubrick’s movie, as Flanagan clearly is, it’s supremely satisfying to see the iconography of The Shining as a weapon against an even greater foe.” – Kyle Anderson, Nerdist

Doctor Sleep impeccably recreates scenes from Kubrick’s The Shining, but smartly reframes them as young Danny’s perspective on those shocking events.” – William Bibbiani, Bloody Disgusting

“While Flanagan manages to make them look almost identical, there’s an uncanny valley quality to what we’re seeing. Yes, it’s technically correct – but something seems off.” – Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

“The time at The Overlook Hotel is frustratingly short considering the time we spend waiting to get there.” – Jenny Desborough, Daily Express

“Once the movie circles back to the Overlook Hotel for a prolonged half-hour climax, the whole endeavor collapses into cliché.” – Eric Kohn, IndieWire

“An extravagant act of fan service. It taps into the minutiae of Kubrick’s masterwork without fully teasing out its mystery.” – Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times


Warner Bros. Pictures
(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures)

What will surprise us most about the film?

“At times, it’s a deeply emotional film.” – Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

“It’s a warmer film than Kubrick was perhaps ever capable of, and more interested in its characters.” – Chris Hewitt, Empire Magazine

“There are some heart-breaking scenes in there.” – Deirdre Molumby, entertainment.ie

Doctor Sleep has the feel of a ‘mutants assemble’ film, recalling the X-Men franchise.” – Anton Bitel, Little White Lies

Doctor Sleep is one of the best-looking movies of 2019.” – Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

“It’s also a complex work of thoughtful film criticism.” – William Bibbiani, Bloody Disgusting


Is it scary?

“Despite its warm heart, Doctor Sleep doesn’t skimp on the horror. The film packs in several nightmarish moments, many of them involving endangered children.” – Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

“The True Knot remain a chilly and effective creation, cut from the same cloth as the ruthless family killers of The Devil’s Rejects but with more daunting powers.” – Eric Kohn, IndieWire

“After sitting through so many fright-films-of-the-week that bamboozle rather than terrify, I found myself lured into a movie that dares to depict evil as something that makes us suck in our breath.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“There’s a moment involving a hand that will make you squirm.” – Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

“While I generally didn’t find Doctor Sleep all that scary, there are a couple of excellent sequences that remind you why Flanagan is the important horror filmmaker he is.” – Kyle Anderson, Nerdist

“The whole thing plays more like a solid, psychological thriller than a horror movie. Which is fine, but perhaps different from Flanagan’s intention.” – Germain Lussier, io9


Warner Bros. Pictures
(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures)

How is Ewan McGregor as a grown-up Danny Torrance?

“Ewan McGregor turns in an affecting performance as Danny Torrance.” – Katherine McLaughlin, The List

“McGregor gives one of his best performances in a long time.” – Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

“McGregor doesn’t always get props, but he’s a sneakily good actor, and he’s great portraying the ‘Shining’ trauma made real in Dan’s grownup existence.” – Brian Truitt, USA Today


Who else stands out in the cast?

“It’s fair to say that Doctor Sleep fully belongs to Rebecca Ferguson and her delightfully wicked performance.” – Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

“When she’s around, she’s the whole show, threatening, cajoling, erotically boiling when prey is at hand. The actress, along with the character, looks to be having a jolly old time… she gives every moment she’s onscreen here a real kick.” – Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter

“Camp and chilling in equal measure, Ferguson’s Rose the Hat is mesmerizing.” – Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

“Truly the performance that everyone will be talking about… set to be remembered as one of the all-time great cinematic Stephen King villains.” – Eric Eisenberg, Cinema Blend


Is the length an issue?

“It doesn’t quite justify the length.” – Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

“[It’s] a film that remains for too long on the low burner; it would be hard to argue that this really needed to run two-and-a-half hours.” – Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter

“Even the biggest Stephen King fans may find themselves checking their watch.” – Jenny Desborough, Daily Express

Doctor Sleep, unlike the whack-a-demon It films, at least uses its length to sink into a mood of genuine contemplative dread.” –  Owen Gleiberman, Variety


Doctor Sleep is in theaters November 8. 

#1

Doctor Sleep (2019)
77%

#1
Adjusted Score: 90.896%
Critics Consensus: Doctor Sleep forsakes the elemental terror of its predecessor for a more contemplative sequel that balances poignant themes against spine-tingling chills.
Synopsis: "Doctor Sleep" is the continuation of Danny Torrance's story 40 years after the terrifying events of Stephen King's The Shining.... [More]
Directed By: Mike Flanagan

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Freeform renewed TV shows breaking bad romantic comedy canceled CMT Turner 2019 richard e. Grant IFC Apple Extras Interview Comedy Central GLAAD Walt Disney Pictures Grammys NBC nature Netflix Christmas movies medical drama TV space serial killer IFC Films Britbox game of thrones Dark Horse Comics USA Network movie blockbuster movies HBO Max 2017 directors Black Mirror Tomatazos YouTube Premium CBS game show comics elevated horror MSNBC aliens Marvel universal monsters award winner Video Games 2015 Lifetime Anna Paquin what to watch Star Wars cooking spy thriller Emmy Nominations Film The Arrangement Sony Pictures halloween Warner Bros. Television Academy boxoffice 2020 zombie screenings YouTube witnail YA Showtime FX DC Universe Adult Swim San Diego Comic-Con Photos Binge Guide Endgame Infographic blaxploitation joker Bravo Disney streaming service Heroines natural history harry potter Paramount Network Lucasfilm true crime Spectrum Originals American Society of Cinematographers Pop Hulu A24 Mudbound Podcast festivals social media Creative Arts Emmys Disney Esquire FX on Hulu documentary SDCC Chernobyl cats Set visit TV renewals Academy Awards streaming Musical rotten movies we love Election Universal adventure cinemax unscripted TV Land Masterpiece theme song cancelled television BBC America Cartoon Network RT History dramedy Rock singing competition jamie lee curtis crossover Paramount political drama Action Song of Ice and Fire 2018 Black History Month teaser Teen LGBTQ TCA Winter 2020 Comedy Captain marvel Travel Channel transformers talk show Best and Worst Funimation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Columbia Pictures technology FXX crime drama screen actors guild Crackle spanish language toy story TIFF children's TV CNN anime spider-man Comics on TV First Reviews stand-up comedy Disney Plus Reality Competition canceled TV shows justice league Character Guide Rocketman VICE dogs E3 DC streaming service Family Fantasy politics Schedule Winter TV BET TCM Apple TV Plus Shudder Epix romance DC Comics binge psycho Nominations comic Mystery WGN ghosts Pride Month cops PBS Sundance Now zero dark thirty Polls and Games ABC Family TNT batman Watching Series Acorn TV green book reviews robots DirecTV National Geographic historical drama werewolf Amazon Comic Book Vudu miniseries cancelled TV series 21st Century Fox animated franchise Nickelodeon New York Comic Con OWN CBS All Access Kids & Family Lifetime Christmas movies TruTV Arrowverse Toys Superheroes Rocky Cosplay scary movies casting tv talk SXSW BBC Trailer free movies Pet Sematary First Look sports Turner Classic Movies ITV Sci-Fi cars revenge AMC 2016 period drama X-Men based on movie zombies LGBT cartoon travel Marvel Television Mary Tyler Moore dceu indie MCU APB Ovation HBO cancelled Awards Tour facebook TBS video dragons President Amazon Prime Video cancelled TV shows spinoff Red Carpet Drama Awards police drama crime Pop TV Avengers Opinion MTV Thanksgiving versus thriller RT21 GIFs Tarantino Spring TV Baby Yoda Amazon Studios Holidays Apple TV+ TLC El Rey kids diversity WarnerMedia television Animation finale 007 supernatural anthology Music comiccon CW Seed Mary poppins Horror Musicals Christmas Western Logo quibi Marvel Studios spain Oscars Fox News Calendar History Winners slashers Ghostbusters Discovery Channel Pixar war PaleyFest Sneak Peek Premiere Dates Year in Review NYCC Food Network doctor who ABC vampires Martial Arts SundanceTV south america foreign USA OneApp hispanic Sundance Valentine's Day Spike Disney+ Disney Plus Fall TV reboot TCA 2017 Super Bowl A&E Cannes docudrama Stephen King Trivia crime thriller Syfy Country Amazon Prime independent The Purge Shondaland DGA Pirates biography YouTube Red FOX dc Women's History Month sag awards mockumentary Certified Fresh hist christmas movies E! The Walking Dead TCA sitcom name the review The Witch Reality Trophy Talk Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Tubi discovery Ellie Kemper VH1 Tumblr Holiday adaptation latino Peacock mutant Crunchyroll Classic Film Nat Geo cults GoT Film Festival See It Skip It 45 Disney Channel composers The CW Marathons ratings sequel Box Office 24 frames psychological thriller golden globes Rom-Com Lionsgate Netflix ESPN Hallmark Quiz Brie Larson Writers Guild of America 71st Emmy Awards series Superheroe Elton John 20th Century Fox Mindy Kaling Starz science fiction Countdown Biopics strong female leads Sundance TV disaster Emmys book Hallmark Christmas movies Summer Mary Poppins Returns Star Trek