Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Parental Advisory for Baby Mama; Harold and Kumar Is Up In Smoke

Plus, Deception proves defective.

by and | April 24, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have expecting ladies (Baby Mama, starring Tina Fey and Amy Poehler), on-the-lam stoners (Harold and Kumar Escape From Guantanamo Bay, starring John Cho and Kal Penn), and embroiled bankers (Deception, starring Hugh Jackman and Ewan McGregor). What do the critics have to say?

Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle was a delightful surprise — a stoner comedy that made more than a few trenchant points about American race relations. The critics say Harold and Kumar Escape from Guantanamo Bay has plenty of laughs, but is shorter on smarts than its predecessor. In Guantanamo, Harold (John Cho) and Kumar (Kal Penn) attempt to smuggle a bong onto a flight to Amsterdam, and are subsequently accused of a terrorist plot; the pair go on the run from the law, encountering babes, marijuana, and Neil Patrick Harris along the way. The pundits say this lowbrow, un-P.C. comedy has its moments, but the easy charm and originality of the original is missing. It’s currently at 54 percent on the Tomatometer. (Check out RT’s interview with John Cho here.)


“I told you I could light it 10 times in a row!”
Tina Fey is one of the brightest talents to emerge from Saturday Night Live in recent years; as an actor and writer for Mean Girls and TV’s 30 Rock, she’s proven herself to be a sharp satirist of modern times. Fey and her Baby Mama co-star Amy Poehler go a long way toward making this surrogate pregnancy comedy watchable, critics say. Fey stars as a career woman who can’t conceive a child, so she turns to a working girl (Poehler) to carry her baby; hilarity ensues when Poehler loses her job and moves in with Fey. The pundits say Baby Mama lacks the sharp wit to be a truly subversive comedy about our baby-obsessed culture, and the film too often relies on bathroom humor to generate laughs. However, they also note the cast is outstanding, with Fey and Poehler playing nicely off each other. Baby Mama currently stands at 60 percent on the Tomatometer.

“Guess which one of these ladies has volunteered to enter the
containment unit?”


You know exactly what you’re getting with a title like Deception: an expendable potboiler with inexplicably big names attached to it. Ewan McGregor stars as a Wall Street banker who is invited into an ominous sex club by his friend (Hugh Jackman), only to become a suspect in a woman’s (Michelle Williams) disappearance. Critics say this limp thriller’s major flaw is its obsession with piling inane plot twists and turns, most of which can be easily deduced well before they arrive. At 13 percent, Deception is all smoke and mirrors.

“So what if I said Dawson’s Creek is bad?”

Also opening this week in limited release:
Without the King, a documentary about Swaziland, the world’s last absolute monarchy, is at 100 percent.
Bomb It, a doc about graffiti artists from around the world, is at 78 percent.
Standard Operating Procedure, Errol Morris‘ examination of Abu Ghraib, is at 76 percent.
Roman de Gare, the new thriller from Oscar-winning director Claude Lelouch, is at 75 percent.
Then She Found Me, Helen Hunt‘s directorial debut, is at 64 percent.

Stuff and Dough, a suspense thriller from Romania, is at 57 percent.
And Deal, a poker drama starring Burt Reynolds, is at zero percent.

Burt spending his hard-earned Uwe Boll money.

Recent Hugh Jackman Movies:
74% — Flushed Away (2006)
51% — The Fountain (2006)
74% — Happy Feet (2006)
75% — The Prestige (2006)
37% — Scoop (2006)

Tag Cloud

Endgame Country Mindy Kaling 2018 Instagram Live stand-up comedy comedies BET new york 45 stop motion twilight discovery Holiday universal monsters Best Picture revenge natural history Ovation Britbox Walt Disney Pictures french basketball Pacific Islander ID sequels harry potter Pirates Pop TV First Look Apple hidden camera elevated horror japanese mockumentary 99% crossover ABC Family GLAAD Biopics Crunchyroll feel good OneApp Baby Yoda indie New York Comic Con Trivia name the review psychological thriller Ellie Kemper toy story rotten movies we love Comics on TV adaptation romantic comedy Toys foreign cancelled television sports target scene in color spider-man sag awards Television Critics Association Wes Anderson festivals E! Sony die hard Turner Cartoon Network space Disney+ Disney Plus 007 Disney Channel satire 71st Emmy Awards Mary Poppins Returns police drama 4/20 TruTV south america Infographic X-Men Amazon Prime Video Sundance TV asian-american Election rt labs critics edition ABC Signature Black History Month Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Tokyo Olympics SDCC spanish language FX on Hulu FXX streaming Comic-Con@Home 2021 versus renewed TV shows Marvel Studios 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Netflix Christmas movies National Geographic Calendar CW Seed Reality Focus Features scene in color series quibi scene in color film series Mary Tyler Moore Starz TCM monster movies SXSW 2022 Lionsgate james bond spain 79th Golden Globes Awards serial killer Musicals films Peacock Pet Sematary MGM Winter TV cops Sony Pictures stoner DirecTV Comic Book all-time docudrama Warner Bros. TNT BET Awards trailers children's TV Rom-Com legend wonder woman crime thriller The CW witnail screen actors guild popular American Society of Cinematographers mob Animation critics singing competition game show TCA 2017 jurassic park TV renewals Binge Guide boxoffice casting blockbuster green book Epix child's play king kong Avengers YouTube Red Turner Classic Movies true crime zombies leaderboard archives Classic Film joker cats Prime Video laika Image Comics Martial Arts Christmas cancelled San Diego Comic-Con political drama Ghostbusters GIFs olympics chucky hispanic heritage month Fox Searchlight Disney streaming service Nat Geo sequel SXSW miniseries TV Neflix medical drama IMDb TV Set visit Oscars breaking bad Star Wars Celebration dramedy Watching Series Elton John biography Sneak Peek football Trophy Talk Bravo italian japan supernatural hist independent TCA Winter 2020 Best Actress hispanic comic books Winners 21st Century Fox best Superheroes tv talk critic resources Western nature NBC crime cancelled TV series Photos video on demand disaster Amazon crime drama worst movies toronto HFPA NYCC theme song franchise politics Extras comiccon Quiz Mystery Television Academy Polls and Games concert high school CBS doctor who Native television australia Disney Creative Arts Emmys posters AMC Sci-Fi President Sundance Paramount Pictures TLC psycho Black Mirror Emmys Tarantino christmas movies Fall TV Paramount Plus The Arrangement Awards black comedy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DGA mcc nfl based on movie rt labs HBO Heroines festival godzilla scorecard Comedy Central worst cults Hulu History summer TV preview Best Actor Dark Horse Comics A24 travel CBS All Access telelvision rt archives Marathons streamig VH1 2016 animated saw hollywood ITV documentary Alien blockbusters Shondaland classics 2020 heist movie movie Funimation superman dexter vampires First Reviews Netflix period drama Syfy Tumblr summer preview LGBTQ ViacomCBS dceu razzies social media anime spanish obituary Apple TV+ screenings TBS 2021 DC Comics transformers Year in Review Writers Guild of America venice BBC One canceled TV shows cars Podcast Music 2017 HBO Max TIFF summer TV Rock comic parents cancelled TV shows Arrowverse See It Skip It Grammys Women's History Month 93rd Oscars Nominations CNN slashers free movies know your critic Comedy Tomatazos Paramount Network diversity video The Walking Dead thriller dc strong female leads IFC Superheroe rom-coms Video Games The Witch Drama Oscar werewolf comics Star Trek Exclusive Video Countdown WarnerMedia robots ABC Acorn TV MTV Tubi marvel comics justice league OWN canceled halloween halloween tv Brie Larson mutant Showtime Spectrum Originals TV movies royal family YA Spring TV Anna Paquin Esquire aliens Mudbound emmy awards Lifetime 20th Century Fox Academy Awards LGBT BBC Vudu WGN scene in color Musical latino Shudder binge Trailer ratings APB Lifetime Christmas movies Columbia Pictures Marvel live action king arthur suspense technology FOX composers Super Bowl Food Network USA Network aapi movies Teen Cannes Red Carpet El Rey war sitcom dragons spy thriller Universal Pictures The Walt Disney Company Cosplay Geeked Week Star Wars boxing Awards Tour Mary poppins cartoon Tags: Comedy art house PBS Schedule scary movies obi wan indiana jones nbcuniversal fresh Film Pixar Chernobyl women VICE docuseries kids news Hallmark criterion PlayStation Stephen King Logo game of thrones Box Office target TV Land 24 frames A&E RT History dogs interviews slasher spider-verse Pride Month 90s historical drama kong spinoff Freeform TCA Awards Rocketman Horror broadcast reboot documentaries The Academy rotten Best Director scary series 2019 Interview talk show GoT FX Lucasfilm 72 Emmy Awards lord of the rings Rocky Adult Swim richard e. Grant USA Nickelodeon Fox News book new zealand Thanksgiving Film Festival Apple TV Plus Marvel Television kaiju young adult unscripted Amazon Prime Summer directors debate a nightmare on elm street streaming movies TV One IFC Films ghosts AMC Plus ESPN teaser Hollywood Foreign Press Association zombie science fiction comic book movies jamie lee curtis HBO Go Certified Fresh golden globes new star wars movies Hallmark Christmas movies book adaptation deadpool E3 DC streaming service South by Southwest Film Festival Disney Plus The Purge dreamworks Amazon Studios Sundance Now reviews mission: impossible Universal BAFTA fast and furious prank Emmy Nominations anthology 73rd Emmy Awards Crackle genre what to watch NBA VOD gangster Pop adenture 94th Oscars trophy golden globe awards Reality Competition facebook cinemax 2015 YouTube Captain marvel adventure MCU YouTube Premium Broadway DC Universe romance cooking black Valentine's Day Paramount Indigenous dark Travel Channel remakes Character Guide Fargo marvel cinematic universe Spike zero dark thirty award winner action-comedy 1990s international Kids & Family comic book movie Family blaxploitation MSNBC TCA Premiere Dates Opinion Action SundanceTV RT21 vs. sopranos Holidays Legendary CMT Song of Ice and Fire finale Best and Worst live event Discovery Channel Hear Us Out superhero Fantasy BBC America biopic pirates of the caribbean Masterpiece batman PaleyFest