Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Parental Advisory for Baby Mama; Harold and Kumar Is Up In Smoke

Plus, Deception proves defective.

by and | April 24, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have expecting ladies (Baby Mama, starring Tina Fey and Amy Poehler), on-the-lam stoners (Harold and Kumar Escape From Guantanamo Bay, starring John Cho and Kal Penn), and embroiled bankers (Deception, starring Hugh Jackman and Ewan McGregor). What do the critics have to say?

Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle was a delightful surprise — a stoner comedy that made more than a few trenchant points about American race relations. The critics say Harold and Kumar Escape from Guantanamo Bay has plenty of laughs, but is shorter on smarts than its predecessor. In Guantanamo, Harold (John Cho) and Kumar (Kal Penn) attempt to smuggle a bong onto a flight to Amsterdam, and are subsequently accused of a terrorist plot; the pair go on the run from the law, encountering babes, marijuana, and Neil Patrick Harris along the way. The pundits say this lowbrow, un-P.C. comedy has its moments, but the easy charm and originality of the original is missing. It’s currently at 54 percent on the Tomatometer. (Check out RT’s interview with John Cho here.)


“I told you I could light it 10 times in a row!”
Tina Fey is one of the brightest talents to emerge from Saturday Night Live in recent years; as an actor and writer for Mean Girls and TV’s 30 Rock, she’s proven herself to be a sharp satirist of modern times. Fey and her Baby Mama co-star Amy Poehler go a long way toward making this surrogate pregnancy comedy watchable, critics say. Fey stars as a career woman who can’t conceive a child, so she turns to a working girl (Poehler) to carry her baby; hilarity ensues when Poehler loses her job and moves in with Fey. The pundits say Baby Mama lacks the sharp wit to be a truly subversive comedy about our baby-obsessed culture, and the film too often relies on bathroom humor to generate laughs. However, they also note the cast is outstanding, with Fey and Poehler playing nicely off each other. Baby Mama currently stands at 60 percent on the Tomatometer.

“Guess which one of these ladies has volunteered to enter the
containment unit?”


You know exactly what you’re getting with a title like Deception: an expendable potboiler with inexplicably big names attached to it. Ewan McGregor stars as a Wall Street banker who is invited into an ominous sex club by his friend (Hugh Jackman), only to become a suspect in a woman’s (Michelle Williams) disappearance. Critics say this limp thriller’s major flaw is its obsession with piling inane plot twists and turns, most of which can be easily deduced well before they arrive. At 13 percent, Deception is all smoke and mirrors.

“So what if I said Dawson’s Creek is bad?”

Also opening this week in limited release:
Without the King, a documentary about Swaziland, the world’s last absolute monarchy, is at 100 percent.
Bomb It, a doc about graffiti artists from around the world, is at 78 percent.
Standard Operating Procedure, Errol Morris‘ examination of Abu Ghraib, is at 76 percent.
Roman de Gare, the new thriller from Oscar-winning director Claude Lelouch, is at 75 percent.
Then She Found Me, Helen Hunt‘s directorial debut, is at 64 percent.

Stuff and Dough, a suspense thriller from Romania, is at 57 percent.
And Deal, a poker drama starring Burt Reynolds, is at zero percent.

Burt spending his hard-earned Uwe Boll money.

Recent Hugh Jackman Movies:
74% — Flushed Away (2006)
51% — The Fountain (2006)
74% — Happy Feet (2006)
75% — The Prestige (2006)
37% — Scoop (2006)

Tag Cloud

prank heist movie LGBTQ foreign IFC Films rt archives Syfy series Warner Bros. rt labs Adult Swim Song of Ice and Fire Podcast Sony Pictures documentaries streaming movies docuseries PBS cinemax die hard FXX RT History comedies 007 Britbox Martial Arts The Walking Dead Christmas slasher spy thriller comic crime children's TV Holidays adventure Writers Guild of America LGBT Creative Arts Emmys miniseries video on demand Animation TNT Pirates BBC One streaming debate zombies comics Superheroe diversity joker Tomatazos Hear Us Out justice league Pride Month Premiere Dates sag awards Image Comics ABC Family Hulu jurassic park 45 WarnerMedia The Purge renewed TV shows animated new york Funimation Captain marvel Prime Video doctor who what to watch gangster crime drama natural history Biopics Music romantic comedy YouTube Premium Pixar golden globe awards 99% sitcom spain HBO Go Legendary cancelled TV shows CMT critics USA Network TCA 2017 nbcuniversal breaking bad President Awards Tour Comic Book Trailer hollywood TruTV Comedy anthology satire TV One green book composers YA Showtime social media Box Office Paramount Plus FOX Cartoon Network Reality Pop TV MSNBC Heroines ratings romance scorecard 2019 independent rt labs critics edition target news elevated horror Apple TV Plus Cannes Mary Tyler Moore movies 93rd Oscars politics TLC dceu 21st Century Fox Freeform comic books Binge Guide Turner Classic Movies japan political drama king kong Spring TV 73rd Emmy Awards TBS cars Star Trek venice black Marvel Studios Super Bowl Best and Worst marvel comics mcc Quiz 24 frames Paramount versus finale TV renewals DC streaming service WGN dexter italian Shudder spanish language BAFTA Teen free movies 2020 psychological thriller docudrama PlayStation NBC Year in Review award winner Comedy Central movie richard e. Grant DC Universe Universal Pictures Universal Toys rom-coms X-Men Schedule comic book movie Brie Larson boxing cops cults know your critic Tarantino mockumentary Crackle BBC halloween Nominations IFC DirecTV talk show Marathons Spike NYCC feel good BET Awards Peacock Avengers Countdown GIFs Fox Searchlight The Arrangement suspense Acorn TV spider-verse Trivia vampires Amazon Prime Video canceled TV shows Polls and Games werewolf chucky YouTube CNN festival Tumblr casting asian-american First Look Emmys Amazon Prime Kids & Family best deadpool 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards IMDb TV kaiju Netflix Christmas movies game of thrones Sneak Peek TCM harry potter Character Guide Summer twilight TV Land Television Academy Film Star Wars Wes Anderson trophy singing competition hispanic TCA Winter 2020 20th Century Fox a nightmare on elm street Anna Paquin scene in color binge A&E Disney pirates of the caribbean Neflix Action Mystery classics high school based on movie Ghostbusters Logo Disney streaming service psycho ITV Bravo mutant fresh blockbusters Rocky dogs SDCC Horror godzilla scary movies lord of the rings king arthur Stephen King APB slashers E3 TIFF comiccon Baby Yoda Election GLAAD kong Oscars historical drama Academy Awards Black Mirror ABC BBC America action-comedy RT21 Winter TV travel monster movies revenge discovery New York Comic Con Fall TV football all-time San Diego Comic-Con 2015 disaster tv talk video Mary Poppins Returns Disney+ Disney Plus Paramount Network Interview Arrowverse black comedy robots saw popular Cosplay Sci-Fi Opinion Apple zero dark thirty Calendar Infographic Hallmark Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt hispanic heritage month GoT ghosts indiana jones game show ABC Signature scary Extras Fantasy Reality Competition Travel Channel wonder woman Comics on TV VH1 Lionsgate NBA Women's History Month Netflix Tubi olympics teaser leaderboard nature japanese child's play theme song kids archives trailers space Watching Series Pacific Islander rotten movies we love Photos basketball TV movies nfl south america obituary Hollywood Foreign Press Association universal monsters OneApp crossover new zealand Television Critics Association Family TCA facebook Musicals razzies spider-man Esquire Comic-Con@Home 2021 hist screen actors guild royal family 2016 Lifetime Christmas movies Crunchyroll cartoon posters Trophy Talk Chernobyl 2017 Tokyo Olympics Dark Horse Comics cooking Holiday Country 2018 TCA Awards Shondaland Certified Fresh Mindy Kaling festivals YouTube Red medical drama Marvel Fox News Sundance Now OWN comic book movies 71st Emmy Awards The Academy thriller Starz Epix ESPN concert Food Network blaxploitation stoner book E! fast and furious legend strong female leads documentary Winners Instagram Live 72 Emmy Awards Musical Amazon stand-up comedy VOD emmy awards AMC Endgame halloween tv book adaptation Red Carpet Vudu 79th Golden Globes Awards aapi superman laika supernatural DGA indie TV ID spanish Rock remakes canceled adenture Sundance technology french dramedy zombie new star wars movies latino james bond sequel telelvision SXSW Apple TV+ international Alien BET Exclusive Video aliens Valentine's Day mission: impossible science fiction women adaptation live event Set visit History worst Spectrum Originals cats critic resources Grammys 4/20 Lucasfilm A24 Awards war genre Nat Geo christmas movies Ovation Fargo batman unscripted CBS The Walt Disney Company FX on Hulu biography Disney Plus AMC Plus crime thriller dragons HFPA worst movies CBS All Access art house Amazon Studios mob Film Festival parents Hallmark Christmas movies First Reviews Tags: Comedy sopranos serial killer biopic police drama American Society of Cinematographers VICE Masterpiece Broadway Classic Film ViacomCBS spinoff Mary poppins cancelled jamie lee curtis witnail DC Comics reviews toy story See It Skip It dreamworks PaleyFest Mudbound SundanceTV Elton John live action quibi Columbia Pictures 1990s Drama National Geographic anime HBO stop motion marvel cinematic universe reboot MCU 2021 The Witch cancelled TV series name the review Rom-Com golden globes period drama franchise boxoffice CW Seed Pop rotten USA screenings superhero Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Superheroes Thanksgiving Black History Month Emmy Nominations films true crime Turner The CW Nickelodeon Ellie Kemper directors toronto australia hidden camera Sundance TV vs. transformers sequels Rocketman criterion young adult El Rey 90s Marvel Television FX Disney Channel Video Games MTV dark dc sports Western cancelled television Lifetime television blockbuster Walt Disney Pictures HBO Max Discovery Channel Pet Sematary