Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Fury is Certified Fresh

The vibrant Book of Life, the bland Best of Me, and some Certified Fresh TV.

by | October 16, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got soldiers in a tank (Fury, starring Brad Pitt and Shia LaBeouf), a princess and her suitors (The Book of Life, with voice performances by Channing Tatum and Zoe Saldana), and star-crossed lovers (The Best of Me, starring Michelle Monaghan and James Marsden). What do the critics have to say?



Take the star of Inglourious Basterds, mix him in with a ragtag band of soldiers reminiscent of the crew in Saving Private Ryan, and what have you got? Fury, a World War II drama that critics say is a powerful document of the horrors of war that doesn’t quite meet its grand ambitions but still packs a wallop. Pitt stars as tank commander who leads a diverse band of brothers on a deadly mission behind enemy lines to stymie a Nazi attack; along the way, our heroes come face-to-face with the grim realities of life on the battlefield. The pundits say Fury is a rock solid war film, with bracing battle scenes and a feeling of you-are-there authenticity. (Check out Pitt’s 10 best-reviewed films here.)

The Book of Life


Right off the bat, The Book of Life has a couple big things going for it: it’s a visually stunning fantasy that’s rooted in Mexican cultural tradition. And critics say that’s mostly enough, even if the story is never up to brilliance of the animation. It’s the tale of two childhood friends who fall in love with a princess, one of which must make a perilous journey through the land of the dead in order to win her heart. The pundits say The Book of Life is energetic and vibrant, a rare example of style winning out over substance.

The Best of Me


Nicholas Sparks knows the value of corn better than anybody, and the films adapted from his novels (The Notebook, A Walk to Remember ) can extract tears from even the sternest souls. But critics say The Best of Me is so preposterous and bland that it’s more likely to inspire incredulity or boredom than sniffles. Two high school sweethearts are reunited at a mutual friend’s funeral, and find that they still have feelings for each other, before forces beyond their control intervene. The pundits say the actors do what they can with the paper-thin characters and silly dialogue, but ultimately, The Best of Me is too schmaltzy and absurd to resonate.

Certified Fresh on TV this week:

The dubious premise of Jane the Virgin (100 percent) is part of its unlikely charm, which critics say shines thanks to sharp writing and a knockout performance by Gina Rodriguez.

Thanks to a liberal dose of propulsive, bloody action and enough compelling character moments to reward longtime fans, critics say The Walking Dead‘s fifth season (97 percent) continues to deliver top-notch entertainment.

Critics say The Affair (96 percent) is a somber, bewitching exploration of truth and desire, thanks to some smart, creative storytelling and spectacular performances from Dominic West and Ruth Wilson.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Tale of Princess Kaguya, an animated folk tale about a girl who’s found inside a bamboo stalk, is at 100 percent.
  • Dear White People, a comedy about an African American college student whose no-holds-barred radio show shakes up the predominantly white campus, is at 97 percent.
  • Birdman, starring Michael Keaton and Edward Norton in a comedy about an actor famous for playing a superhero who’s trying to mount a Broadway play, is Certified Fresh at 94 percent.
  • Housebound, a horror comedy about a woman sentenced to home confinement who discovers her house is occupied by a malevolent spirit, is at 94 percent.
  • Diplomacy, a historical drama about a plot to destroy Paris during World War II, is at 91 percent.
  • Listen Up Philip, starring Jason Schwartzman and Elisabeth Moss in a dramedy about a self-obsessed author burning bridges with the people around him, is at 87 percent.
  • Watchers of the Sky, a documentary about activists pushing for justice in the wake of mass atrocities, is at 87 percent.
  • Felony, starring Joel Edgerton and Tom Wilkinson in a thriller about three cops dealing with the potential fallout from a bust gone wrong, is at 79 percent.
  • Camp X-Ray, starring Kristen Stewart in a drama about a guard at Guantanamo Bay who develops a friendship with a detainee, is at 64 percent.
  • Rudderless, starring Billy Crudup and Anton Yelchin in a drama about a man who copes with his son’s untimely death by playing music, is at 61 percent.
  • Summer of Blood, a horror comedy about a schlubby guy who becomes a lady-killing vampire, is at 60 percent.
  • Young Ones, starring Michael Shannon and Elle Fanning in a sci-fi drama about a farming family struggling to survive in the midst of a global water shortage, is at 50 percent.

Finally, props to Andrew LaPlant for coming the closest to guessing Addicted‘s eight percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Spring TV Character Guide Schedule children's TV 2017 Syfy Holidays Tumblr MSNBC Marvel 2016 Infographic singing competition Walt Disney Pictures richard e. Grant First Look See It Skip It justice league PBS YouTube Premium ABC aliens Mindy Kaling miniseries Musical vampires mockumentary VH1 binge Ellie Kemper animated Action Netflix Spectrum Originals Podcast Musicals Vudu anthology Acorn TV video Pet Sematary Mudbound Trophy Talk Dark Horse Comics comic Summer Calendar Horror finale Writers Guild of America Sundance adventure award winner Song of Ice and Fire social media Winter TV Hulu zombies politics cats SXSW BET Apple hispanic PaleyFest Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dramedy police drama MCU nature Awards Tour Film NBC Freeform Comic Book CW Seed FOX Superheroes WGN Country Tarantino historical drama Countdown Emmys Arrowverse Star Trek Ghostbusters streaming discovery TCA TCA 2017 political drama VICE San Diego Comic-Con FXX 20th Century Fox series CBS USA Network Certified Fresh Amazon Anna Paquin Sony Pictures zero dark thirty disaster CNN period drama DGA dceu supernatural Amazon Prime Video crossover witnail RT21 ITV YouTube Red thriller Awards Disney what to watch Western Women's History Month Lifetime kids Peacock cinemax sitcom MTV Cosplay El Rey Stephen King ESPN true crime Paramount Network festivals Nat Geo serial killer SundanceTV zombie Captain marvel Heroines Toys movies Film Festival TBS Esquire Rocketman golden globes doctor who crime drama sequel Chernobyl Nominations anime tv talk Britbox Cartoon Network game show Showtime History President NYCC south america spain Comics on TV TV Land Shondaland revenge Bravo Reality Competition Shudder Opinion GLAAD Television Academy Cannes E3 Fox News comiccon Creative Arts Emmys game of thrones New York Comic Con Comedy Central cars AMC sports TruTV Christmas Sci-Fi cooking technology LGBT diversity teaser OWN Warner Bros. A&E Paramount psychological thriller E! hist Trailer dc theme song National Geographic TLC Sneak Peek Watching Series boxoffice Interview APB Mary poppins 24 frames 71st Emmy Awards Lionsgate 45 Marathons composers DirecTV docudrama American Society of Cinematographers ABC Family 2015 Logo Rocky transformers adaptation cops 2019 romance crime Starz Brie Larson Reality Extras Pixar green book Pride Month Polls and Games Thanksgiving HBO Animation Binge Guide ratings Crackle Video Games Chilling Adventures of Sabrina CMT Sundance Now HBO Max Comedy Music 2018 foreign medical drama Oscars Grammys The Arrangement The CW Election based on movie Mystery spider-man Tomatazos BBC America strong female leads TNT The Witch DC Universe Fall TV latino jamie lee curtis TCM biography SDCC Pirates spy thriller Trivia DC streaming service war DC Comics Set visit Teen crime thriller science fiction Mary Tyler Moore Ovation Family robots Masterpiece Elton John harry potter dragons IFC travel Spike USA Star Wars Universal television Black Mirror WarnerMedia Year in Review casting 007 space Super Bowl Amazon Prime Disney streaming service Epix YA LGBTQ CBS All Access elevated horror BBC Valentine's Day Kids & Family First Reviews Nickelodeon Quiz spanish language Red Carpet spinoff unscripted Fantasy Rock Best and Worst mutant ghosts IFC Films Mary Poppins Returns book blaxploitation Photos 21st Century Fox stand-up comedy Superheroe X-Men cults Pop Rom-Com Martial Arts Food Network Emmy Nominations Box Office facebook quibi talk show RT History GoT FX Disney Channel Winners Premiere Dates Lucasfilm TV Columbia Pictures TIFF Adult Swim natural history psycho Drama Biopics toy story GIFs