Critical Consensus: "Red Eye," "The 40 Year-Old Virgin" Soar

by | August 18, 2005 | Comments

This week at the movies brings four studies in aviation. What happens when you’re trapped on a plane with a creepy seatmate? (See "Red Eye.") Is it ever too late for Cupid’s arrows to take flight? (Check out "The 40 Year-Old Virgin.") Were the unsung heroes of the Allies in WWII… pigeons? ("Valiant," this one’s for you.) Isn’t it cool when those Supercross dudes, like, totally go up in the air, and like, for a few seconds, y’know, it looks like they’re, like, flying? (Ahem…."Supercross: The Movie.") And most important of all: which of these flicks will fly with the critics?

Alfred Hitchcock once famously declared, "I like to play the audience like a piano." Wes Craven is no Hitchcock (who is?), but in his finest moments, his work embodies the spirit of that sentiment. And critics say "Red Eye" is one of Craven’s finest moments. Much like many of Hitch’s films, the plot strains credibility, but who cares; brisk, paranoid, and tense, this is excellent popcorn fare, with stars in the making Rachel McAdams and Cillian Murphy getting their share of props. "Red Eye" soars, scoring 84 percent on the Tomatometer. And it’s Craven’s best reviewed film since "Scream" (87 percent) in 1996.

Speaking of overdue props, Steve Carell has been stealing scenes from movies for a while (and he was in those weirdly funny FedEx commercials — am I the only one who remembers that?). So now that he’s getting his shot in the spotlight, he’s unsurprisingly making the most of it. Critics are showing a lot of love for "The 40 Year-Old Virgin," a film that continues the recent trend of mixing tasteless humor with aching sincerity. At 85 percent, "The 40 Year-Old Virgin" may be worth a date. And it’s getting better reviews than even the surprise comedy megahit of the summer, "Wedding Crashers" (currently at 74 percent).

So CGI is the wave of the future? Maybe. But technology can only go so far; a movie still has to tell a compelling story. Critics say even the technology isn’t that good in "Valiant," a tale of carrier pigeons’ heroism in WWII. And though it features voice work from some of our favorites from across the pond (Ewan McGregor, Ricky Gervais, John Cleese, Hugh Laurie), the writers say it’s plucky but impersonal, and too odd in its plot to make much sense to younger viewers, the assumed target demographic. At 24 percent on the Tomatometer, this bird’s having trouble achieving takeoff. And it’s the worst-reviewed CGI film ever, sinking lower than last year’s "Shark Tale" (35 percent).

Since there is apparently little appeal in "Segway: The Movie" or, perhaps "Jet-Ski: The Movie," X-treme fans will have to make do with "Supercross: The Movie." But according to critics, there couldn’t be much less appeal to this teen romance in between totally radical and tubular stunts. The reason old-school exclamations make sense in this context is that the plot of this movie is pretty dated; heck, "Don’t Worry Baby," the classic Beach Boys song about romance and drag racing, pretty much told the same story in three minutes. But "Supercross" does soar above the competition in one respect: at three percent on the Tomatometer, it’s among the worst reviewed movies of the year.

Worst Reviewed Movies of 2005 (So Far):
1. King’s Ransom — 0%
2. Alone in the Dark — 1%
3. Supercross: The Movie — 3%
4. Son of the Mask — 4%
5. Modigliani — 4%
6. Fascination — 5%
7. Harry and Max — 5%
8. The Perfect Man — 6%
9. Elektra — 7%
10. White Noise — 9%

Recent Wes Craven-Directed Movies:
14% — Cursed (2005)
41% — Scream 3 (2000)
68% — Music of the Heart (1999)
81% — Scream 2 (1997)
87% — Scream (1996)

Tag Cloud

ABC Infographic romance Sundance CBS Rock teaser Valentine's Day Sci-Fi Horror theme song Action justice league Drama San Diego Comic-Con BET Creative Arts Emmys casting Election award winner Columbia Pictures cats Nat Geo CNN Epix spider-man sitcom crime APB National Geographic Stephen King elevated horror finale Emmys natural history Christmas Western biography crime drama Premiere Dates transformers 45 Reality Competition RT History facebook TIFF what to watch anthology Disney Channel DC streaming service RT21 Rocky Paramount Network Adult Swim aliens diversity 2017 discovery 2019 Esquire FX Anna Paquin golden globes doctor who Masterpiece dragons Summer NYCC adventure mockumentary Comics on TV Comic Book Paramount Schedule Superheroe comic Shudder hist CMT cinemax Showtime New York Comic Con Crackle SDCC Mary Poppins Returns true crime TCA 2017 Countdown ESPN BBC FOX Pop TNT Winter TV Shondaland boxoffice Lionsgate Fall TV American Society of Cinematographers Animation ABC Family SXSW Awards Song of Ice and Fire mutant Women's History Month disaster Netflix medical drama Lifetime E! DC Universe Elton John Extras Ghostbusters serial killer Star Wars The CW HBO ratings blaxploitation Cannes richard e. Grant Ellie Kemper composers Apple VH1 2018 Bravo historical drama Universal Mindy Kaling Amazon Prime Sundance Now Ovation Oscars Black Mirror robots 24 frames Mary poppins green book GoT OWN dceu sports Warner Bros. crime thriller Film Festival Toys Captain marvel TV Land Hulu Polls and Games talk show space Starz 2016 Pirates nature TBS Disney psycho Marvel IFC MCU Sneak Peek adaptation USA A&E GIFs YouTube Premium TLC technology Tarantino streaming BBC America DC Comics Opinion Acorn TV Spike docudrama dramedy Britbox Pet Sematary 2015 Star Trek miniseries Biopics supernatural History Reality Tomatazos Lucasfilm Chilling Adventures of Sabrina El Rey Rocketman 21st Century Fox MTV Quiz First Look cults GLAAD E3 Mystery anime political drama social media thriller vampires Food Network See It Skip It Fox News Year in Review YA 20th Century Fox PaleyFest psychological thriller Watching Series X-Men Heroines zombie singing competition Musicals Country Super Bowl Trailer Brie Larson Trophy Talk spy thriller comiccon Spring TV cops Teen Pixar Winners AMC Superheroes Syfy politics Dark Horse Comics PBS Walt Disney Pictures Comedy Calendar Video Games Nickelodeon cooking President jamie lee curtis Kids & Family Music zombies television sequel Set visit MSNBC dc Red Carpet travel IFC Films CW Seed Photos police drama DGA Marathons ITV Tumblr 007 war NBC TCM Grammys Holidays Cosplay Nominations witnail TruTV Sony Pictures Writers Guild of America YouTube Red Amazon Certified Fresh Freeform unscripted Logo Box Office Interview harry potter period drama VICE Fantasy Awards Tour TV Mary Tyler Moore The Witch DirecTV Thanksgiving based on movie Rom-Com binge Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Cartoon Network Character Guide TCA Spectrum Originals Martial Arts FXX Best and Worst Trivia Vudu SundanceTV Comedy Central CBS All Access science fiction The Arrangement USA Network crossover Musical festivals strong female leads LGBTQ Podcast WGN zero dark thirty Mudbound