Critical Consensus: "Red Eye," "The 40 Year-Old Virgin" Soar

by | August 18, 2005 | Comments

This week at the movies brings four studies in aviation. What happens when you’re trapped on a plane with a creepy seatmate? (See "Red Eye.") Is it ever too late for Cupid’s arrows to take flight? (Check out "The 40 Year-Old Virgin.") Were the unsung heroes of the Allies in WWII… pigeons? ("Valiant," this one’s for you.) Isn’t it cool when those Supercross dudes, like, totally go up in the air, and like, for a few seconds, y’know, it looks like they’re, like, flying? (Ahem…."Supercross: The Movie.") And most important of all: which of these flicks will fly with the critics?

Alfred Hitchcock once famously declared, "I like to play the audience like a piano." Wes Craven is no Hitchcock (who is?), but in his finest moments, his work embodies the spirit of that sentiment. And critics say "Red Eye" is one of Craven’s finest moments. Much like many of Hitch’s films, the plot strains credibility, but who cares; brisk, paranoid, and tense, this is excellent popcorn fare, with stars in the making Rachel McAdams and Cillian Murphy getting their share of props. "Red Eye" soars, scoring 84 percent on the Tomatometer. And it’s Craven’s best reviewed film since "Scream" (87 percent) in 1996.

Speaking of overdue props, Steve Carell has been stealing scenes from movies for a while (and he was in those weirdly funny FedEx commercials — am I the only one who remembers that?). So now that he’s getting his shot in the spotlight, he’s unsurprisingly making the most of it. Critics are showing a lot of love for "The 40 Year-Old Virgin," a film that continues the recent trend of mixing tasteless humor with aching sincerity. At 85 percent, "The 40 Year-Old Virgin" may be worth a date. And it’s getting better reviews than even the surprise comedy megahit of the summer, "Wedding Crashers" (currently at 74 percent).

So CGI is the wave of the future? Maybe. But technology can only go so far; a movie still has to tell a compelling story. Critics say even the technology isn’t that good in "Valiant," a tale of carrier pigeons’ heroism in WWII. And though it features voice work from some of our favorites from across the pond (Ewan McGregor, Ricky Gervais, John Cleese, Hugh Laurie), the writers say it’s plucky but impersonal, and too odd in its plot to make much sense to younger viewers, the assumed target demographic. At 24 percent on the Tomatometer, this bird’s having trouble achieving takeoff. And it’s the worst-reviewed CGI film ever, sinking lower than last year’s "Shark Tale" (35 percent).

Since there is apparently little appeal in "Segway: The Movie" or, perhaps "Jet-Ski: The Movie," X-treme fans will have to make do with "Supercross: The Movie." But according to critics, there couldn’t be much less appeal to this teen romance in between totally radical and tubular stunts. The reason old-school exclamations make sense in this context is that the plot of this movie is pretty dated; heck, "Don’t Worry Baby," the classic Beach Boys song about romance and drag racing, pretty much told the same story in three minutes. But "Supercross" does soar above the competition in one respect: at three percent on the Tomatometer, it’s among the worst reviewed movies of the year.

Worst Reviewed Movies of 2005 (So Far):
1. King’s Ransom — 0%
2. Alone in the Dark — 1%
3. Supercross: The Movie — 3%
4. Son of the Mask — 4%
5. Modigliani — 4%
6. Fascination — 5%
7. Harry and Max — 5%
8. The Perfect Man — 6%
9. Elektra — 7%
10. White Noise — 9%

Recent Wes Craven-Directed Movies:
14% — Cursed (2005)
41% — Scream 3 (2000)
68% — Music of the Heart (1999)
81% — Scream 2 (1997)
87% — Scream (1996)

Tag Cloud

GoT Countdown natural history BBC One hispanic El Rey aapi 21st Century Fox Martial Arts ESPN Biopics video comic books TV renewals Apple TV+ indiana jones Britbox 2015 joker ABC spy thriller Amazon Prime Video children's TV heist movie History comics Tarantino Podcast award winner Universal Pictures Opinion 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards superman TCA Winter 2020 Action critic resources scary halloween toy story Sundance Creative Arts Emmys screen actors guild elevated horror best Lifetime OneApp independent Box Office screenings true crime name the review christmas movies FX twilight chucky The CW dogs DC streaming service NBA trailers Christmas Pride Month Winners Lucasfilm Calendar Extras streaming movies slashers DGA First Reviews TV Land Comic Book hispanic heritage month PBS TCA 2017 singing competition Heroines Animation Rom-Com 2021 versus foreign MTV Polls and Games Tubi TCA Awards book game show dreamworks Arrowverse Chernobyl 71st Emmy Awards based on movie spider-verse DC Comics TruTV prank thriller Pirates Stephen King marvel comics mission: impossible Winter TV 24 frames Film Festival Pop 4/20 pirates of the caribbean Dark Horse Comics FXX Women's History Month biopic Star Trek Horror Nominations Star Wars green book target hidden camera Ghostbusters documentary japanese CBS All Access Crackle BBC America Funimation reboot GLAAD CMT comiccon docudrama IMDb TV ID spinoff RT History classics blockbuster razzies Character Guide canceled Reality justice league Reality Competition Holiday DC Universe genre technology Spike boxing WarnerMedia transformers Disney Channel Rock mockumentary finale HBO Go Instagram Live Paramount telelvision New York Comic Con Valentine's Day Marvel dramedy new star wars movies 45 cartoon basketball sitcom Marvel Television BAFTA australia stand-up comedy cinemax scary movies Netflix 2018 strong female leads space Sundance Now Marathons Walt Disney Pictures jamie lee curtis miniseries Quiz Peacock HBO renewed TV shows composers kong comic book movies Pet Sematary Sci-Fi rom-coms Certified Fresh Hulu USA Network BET Awards science fiction rt archives CW Seed Drama theme song The Walking Dead Grammys mcc nfl Rocky SXSW hollywood Song of Ice and Fire Musical tv talk hist 1990s X-Men Tumblr high school Shudder Fall TV period drama young adult Sundance TV TV Pacific Islander LGBTQ Photos CBS Black History Month lord of the rings Lifetime Christmas movies what to watch Travel Channel Discovery Channel YouTube San Diego Comic-Con Family spanish language television animated french black blockbusters American Society of Cinematographers Spectrum Originals The Purge child's play VOD Kids & Family travel Image Comics Super Bowl Hallmark cars Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cancelled TV shows all-time Netflix Christmas movies Alien Brie Larson TCA dceu 2017 cults Video Games Oscars robots unscripted IFC Films Set visit SDCC rotten crime thriller police drama worst movies ABC Family batman crime aliens A&E VH1 Superheroes romance Broadway Crunchyroll 2019 Awards Tour Apple SundanceTV franchise 007 USA wonder woman TV One zombies superhero revenge Holidays golden globes Schedule Ovation MSNBC Comics on TV Musicals LGBT war psycho action-comedy AMC Plus Ellie Kemper streaming RT21 fresh crime drama concert The Walt Disney Company rt labs critics edition international laika President suspense Trivia A24 facebook NYCC Year in Review worst diversity TIFF Logo Showtime National Geographic live event kids Mudbound spider-man vampires art house FOX video on demand Apple TV Plus archives sequel legend series historical drama a nightmare on elm street marvel cinematic universe TLC supernatural disaster PaleyFest Best and Worst festival talk show TV movies Toys dc teaser stoner Neflix Elton John cooking Universal halloween tv Disney+ Disney Plus Classic Film See It Skip It Summer TBS movie Premiere Dates stop motion cancelled television Cannes Watching Series First Look football debate doctor who IFC Sony Pictures films anthology 2016 psychological thriller YouTube Premium deadpool sag awards Trailer Comedy Central cats anime BBC comic Starz obituary italian Esquire Mary Tyler Moore dexter VICE south america free movies latino 20th Century Fox vs. The Witch Bravo crossover Endgame Mindy Kaling ViacomCBS Thanksgiving emmy awards Paramount Plus Red Carpet dragons 93rd Oscars king arthur reviews royal family Vudu comedies documentaries witnail 99% Comedy Turner women Amazon zero dark thirty Spring TV Disney Plus monster movies medical drama Emmys directors Syfy Rocketman casting YA political drama Awards Academy Awards HBO Max Disney streaming service parents cops The Academy remakes Television Critics Association Legendary Mary poppins Cartoon Network venice toronto Nickelodeon Trophy Talk social media dark blaxploitation scene in color universal monsters adenture spanish CNN cancelled Music sopranos critics sports adventure Infographic breaking bad criterion spain APB 90s Television Academy james bond live action ghosts biography zombie Tomatazos nbcuniversal olympics Comic-Con@Home 2021 PlayStation mob richard e. Grant Fantasy Black Mirror NBC MCU Tokyo Olympics ABC Signature Paramount Network posters king kong serial killer golden globe awards boxoffice Avengers Freeform TCM DirecTV Epix Warner Bros. Marvel Studios Captain marvel godzilla Fox Searchlight Superheroe Lionsgate die hard Fox News new zealand game of thrones Writers Guild of America OWN feel good Wes Anderson Western news Baby Yoda 2020 Masterpiece satire Amazon Studios Anna Paquin WGN fast and furious mutant Amazon Prime jurassic park black comedy Binge Guide E! book adaptation festivals Hear Us Out kaiju new york rt labs know your critic movies Sneak Peek sequels Interview docuseries Cosplay E3 indie GIFs cancelled TV series Disney 73rd Emmy Awards asian-american slasher popular japan TNT BET saw Country Food Network adaptation AMC discovery ratings Teen canceled TV shows 72 Emmy Awards Exclusive Video nature scorecard Turner Classic Movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt quibi Nat Geo The Arrangement comic book movie Film Pixar Emmy Nominations FX on Hulu Hallmark Christmas movies Shondaland Pop TV harry potter werewolf romantic comedy Mystery Election Adult Swim Columbia Pictures gangster ITV Mary Poppins Returns Acorn TV YouTube Red politics binge rotten movies we love