Critical Consensus: "Red Eye," "The 40 Year-Old Virgin" Soar

by | August 18, 2005 | Comments

This week at the movies brings four studies in aviation. What happens when you’re trapped on a plane with a creepy seatmate? (See "Red Eye.") Is it ever too late for Cupid’s arrows to take flight? (Check out "The 40 Year-Old Virgin.") Were the unsung heroes of the Allies in WWII… pigeons? ("Valiant," this one’s for you.) Isn’t it cool when those Supercross dudes, like, totally go up in the air, and like, for a few seconds, y’know, it looks like they’re, like, flying? (Ahem…."Supercross: The Movie.") And most important of all: which of these flicks will fly with the critics?

Alfred Hitchcock once famously declared, "I like to play the audience like a piano." Wes Craven is no Hitchcock (who is?), but in his finest moments, his work embodies the spirit of that sentiment. And critics say "Red Eye" is one of Craven’s finest moments. Much like many of Hitch’s films, the plot strains credibility, but who cares; brisk, paranoid, and tense, this is excellent popcorn fare, with stars in the making Rachel McAdams and Cillian Murphy getting their share of props. "Red Eye" soars, scoring 84 percent on the Tomatometer. And it’s Craven’s best reviewed film since "Scream" (87 percent) in 1996.

Speaking of overdue props, Steve Carell has been stealing scenes from movies for a while (and he was in those weirdly funny FedEx commercials — am I the only one who remembers that?). So now that he’s getting his shot in the spotlight, he’s unsurprisingly making the most of it. Critics are showing a lot of love for "The 40 Year-Old Virgin," a film that continues the recent trend of mixing tasteless humor with aching sincerity. At 85 percent, "The 40 Year-Old Virgin" may be worth a date. And it’s getting better reviews than even the surprise comedy megahit of the summer, "Wedding Crashers" (currently at 74 percent).

So CGI is the wave of the future? Maybe. But technology can only go so far; a movie still has to tell a compelling story. Critics say even the technology isn’t that good in "Valiant," a tale of carrier pigeons’ heroism in WWII. And though it features voice work from some of our favorites from across the pond (Ewan McGregor, Ricky Gervais, John Cleese, Hugh Laurie), the writers say it’s plucky but impersonal, and too odd in its plot to make much sense to younger viewers, the assumed target demographic. At 24 percent on the Tomatometer, this bird’s having trouble achieving takeoff. And it’s the worst-reviewed CGI film ever, sinking lower than last year’s "Shark Tale" (35 percent).

Since there is apparently little appeal in "Segway: The Movie" or, perhaps "Jet-Ski: The Movie," X-treme fans will have to make do with "Supercross: The Movie." But according to critics, there couldn’t be much less appeal to this teen romance in between totally radical and tubular stunts. The reason old-school exclamations make sense in this context is that the plot of this movie is pretty dated; heck, "Don’t Worry Baby," the classic Beach Boys song about romance and drag racing, pretty much told the same story in three minutes. But "Supercross" does soar above the competition in one respect: at three percent on the Tomatometer, it’s among the worst reviewed movies of the year.

Worst Reviewed Movies of 2005 (So Far):
1. King’s Ransom — 0%
2. Alone in the Dark — 1%
3. Supercross: The Movie — 3%
4. Son of the Mask — 4%
5. Modigliani — 4%
6. Fascination — 5%
7. Harry and Max — 5%
8. The Perfect Man — 6%
9. Elektra — 7%
10. White Noise — 9%

Recent Wes Craven-Directed Movies:
14% — Cursed (2005)
41% — Scream 3 (2000)
68% — Music of the Heart (1999)
81% — Scream 2 (1997)
87% — Scream (1996)

Tag Cloud

Grammys PlayStation BET Awards Lucasfilm razzies Pixar CNN Brie Larson 24 frames italian Sundance ViacomCBS ITV Travel Channel Horror Disney+ Disney Plus TNT versus Star Trek stop motion DGA Winter TV Food Network spider-man joker IFC disaster talk show Election unscripted venice LGBTQ saw video on demand Marvel Television franchise NBC historical drama Pet Sematary Broadway politics black Universal The Walt Disney Company miniseries Kids & Family Nickelodeon australia Cannes 2019 YouTube Red zero dark thirty Amazon Prime natural history Holiday Christmas singing competition critics A&E new star wars movies animated renewed TV shows San Diego Comic-Con award winner television justice league Lionsgate comedies Creative Arts Emmys Rocketman CW Seed vampires Disney Plus japanese Apple FOX Marathons concert Awards Tour ABC Signature NYCC Crackle Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Music The Purge space anthology game show women indiana jones telelvision sports Arrowverse Nominations Black History Month Warner Bros. streaming Chernobyl monster movies finale Tarantino Year in Review Amazon Prime Video toronto binge free movies sequels what to watch Peacock Disney Anna Paquin Academy Awards BBC America Fantasy medical drama Pride Month die hard First Look mission: impossible superhero E! Super Bowl Fox News 2015 Turner Video Games Amazon Studios Reality Competition DC streaming service Hear Us Out Rocky RT21 Writers Guild of America blockbuster Logo comic Baby Yoda rotten movies we love scary movies christmas movies TBS Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt video Captain marvel Dark Horse Comics Alien IFC Films 4/20 MSNBC directors Pirates cinemax dogs breaking bad USA festival Rom-Com History psycho reboot Bravo spinoff halloween tv HBO Go elevated horror VICE 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Extras Calendar popular Pop TV Television Academy Holidays FX Acorn TV Quiz book GIFs 007 cops Oscars cancelled TV series dragons Watching Series cooking CMT scorecard SundanceTV ABC period drama TCA Winter 2020 APB Apple TV Plus parents Summer south america Mary Tyler Moore BBC Countdown Best and Worst halloween Spring TV Star Wars cults 2016 documentary PBS superman revenge based on movie police drama BBC One independent WarnerMedia OneApp sequel LGBT YouTube Opinion werewolf crime tv talk Awards TCA 2017 VOD romantic comedy cars TCM satire BET laika canceled TV shows green book The Walking Dead children's TV USA Network romance Britbox DC Comics fast and furious hispanic Shondaland Film Paramount Network remakes Winners HBO Max nbcuniversal casting Sundance TV cancelled television nature MTV Set visit Comedy Central Lifetime Heroines foreign high school blockbusters supernatural First Reviews PaleyFest The Academy kids Exclusive Video WGN SDCC VH1 travel See It Skip It ratings book adaptation Box Office FX on Hulu rotten heist movie Film Festival Shudder anime movie CBS Marvel Studios serial killer Television Critics Association Western true crime Red Carpet psychological thriller Sundance Now Netflix Christmas movies Mystery teaser Adult Swim name the review witnail crime thriller facebook thriller Walt Disney Pictures Family Pop ID Certified Fresh Country Tomatazos mockumentary adaptation Polls and Games TruTV X-Men cats MCU New York Comic Con spanish hidden camera prank cartoon Schedule harry potter worst movies Disney Channel science fiction Superheroes docudrama hist toy story films Musical 20th Century Fox comics trailers Lifetime Christmas movies Hallmark french reviews slashers El Rey political drama Comics on TV Nat Geo sitcom rt archives batman sag awards Funimation fresh classics Animation worst spy thriller The Witch Crunchyroll TV One Cartoon Network Disney streaming service 2021 ghosts Superheroe Ovation twilight Trophy Talk social media OWN boxing YouTube Premium Spectrum Originals Legendary aliens TV Women's History Month richard e. Grant Sony Pictures dceu movies diversity Martial Arts ABC Family Podcast comiccon SXSW Action Masterpiece emmy awards Netflix discovery series TIFF 45 TCA Tumblr Character Guide A24 Starz screenings BAFTA Turner Classic Movies zombie Mary poppins crossover Emmys golden globes game of thrones Mary Poppins Returns cancelled adventure archives The CW E3 Fall TV Trivia zombies DC Universe dc CBS All Access criterion Elton John Song of Ice and Fire 2020 festivals king kong Classic Film 2018 composers DirecTV Sneak Peek Paramount Plus Comedy Sci-Fi obituary war hollywood rom-coms Photos Binge Guide mutant Teen Black Mirror Musicals RT History YA Emmy Nominations 2017 Avengers Ghostbusters dramedy ESPN Amazon screen actors guild child's play Hallmark Christmas movies a nightmare on elm street Mudbound canceled news comic books doctor who Columbia Pictures football TLC quibi 21st Century Fox Ellie Kemper golden globe awards jurassic park Spike Rock asian-american boxoffice biography transformers Cosplay TCA Awards latino pirates of the caribbean TV renewals AMC strong female leads Toys crime drama Infographic Esquire National Geographic best kaiju GoT blaxploitation nfl 71st Emmy Awards Thanksgiving HBO American Society of Cinematographers Showtime Epix kong documentaries Interview Comic Book Reality spain The Arrangement FXX stoner Trailer indie Fox Searchlight Discovery Channel technology robots Paramount deadpool 93rd Oscars GLAAD Hulu stand-up comedy Syfy jamie lee curtis all-time Tubi Vudu President james bond 99% Stephen King Drama docuseries spanish language Marvel Premiere Dates Apple TV+ TV Land cancelled TV shows dark Endgame theme song Biopics godzilla chucky Freeform Valentine's Day universal monsters Mindy Kaling 72 Emmy Awards