Critical Consensus: "Red Eye," "The 40 Year-Old Virgin" Soar

by | August 18, 2005 | Comments

This week at the movies brings four studies in aviation. What happens when you’re trapped on a plane with a creepy seatmate? (See "Red Eye.") Is it ever too late for Cupid’s arrows to take flight? (Check out "The 40 Year-Old Virgin.") Were the unsung heroes of the Allies in WWII… pigeons? ("Valiant," this one’s for you.) Isn’t it cool when those Supercross dudes, like, totally go up in the air, and like, for a few seconds, y’know, it looks like they’re, like, flying? (Ahem…."Supercross: The Movie.") And most important of all: which of these flicks will fly with the critics?

Alfred Hitchcock once famously declared, "I like to play the audience like a piano." Wes Craven is no Hitchcock (who is?), but in his finest moments, his work embodies the spirit of that sentiment. And critics say "Red Eye" is one of Craven’s finest moments. Much like many of Hitch’s films, the plot strains credibility, but who cares; brisk, paranoid, and tense, this is excellent popcorn fare, with stars in the making Rachel McAdams and Cillian Murphy getting their share of props. "Red Eye" soars, scoring 84 percent on the Tomatometer. And it’s Craven’s best reviewed film since "Scream" (87 percent) in 1996.

Speaking of overdue props, Steve Carell has been stealing scenes from movies for a while (and he was in those weirdly funny FedEx commercials — am I the only one who remembers that?). So now that he’s getting his shot in the spotlight, he’s unsurprisingly making the most of it. Critics are showing a lot of love for "The 40 Year-Old Virgin," a film that continues the recent trend of mixing tasteless humor with aching sincerity. At 85 percent, "The 40 Year-Old Virgin" may be worth a date. And it’s getting better reviews than even the surprise comedy megahit of the summer, "Wedding Crashers" (currently at 74 percent).

So CGI is the wave of the future? Maybe. But technology can only go so far; a movie still has to tell a compelling story. Critics say even the technology isn’t that good in "Valiant," a tale of carrier pigeons’ heroism in WWII. And though it features voice work from some of our favorites from across the pond (Ewan McGregor, Ricky Gervais, John Cleese, Hugh Laurie), the writers say it’s plucky but impersonal, and too odd in its plot to make much sense to younger viewers, the assumed target demographic. At 24 percent on the Tomatometer, this bird’s having trouble achieving takeoff. And it’s the worst-reviewed CGI film ever, sinking lower than last year’s "Shark Tale" (35 percent).

Since there is apparently little appeal in "Segway: The Movie" or, perhaps "Jet-Ski: The Movie," X-treme fans will have to make do with "Supercross: The Movie." But according to critics, there couldn’t be much less appeal to this teen romance in between totally radical and tubular stunts. The reason old-school exclamations make sense in this context is that the plot of this movie is pretty dated; heck, "Don’t Worry Baby," the classic Beach Boys song about romance and drag racing, pretty much told the same story in three minutes. But "Supercross" does soar above the competition in one respect: at three percent on the Tomatometer, it’s among the worst reviewed movies of the year.

Worst Reviewed Movies of 2005 (So Far):
1. King’s Ransom — 0%
2. Alone in the Dark — 1%
3. Supercross: The Movie — 3%
4. Son of the Mask — 4%
5. Modigliani — 4%
6. Fascination — 5%
7. Harry and Max — 5%
8. The Perfect Man — 6%
9. Elektra — 7%
10. White Noise — 9%

Recent Wes Craven-Directed Movies:
14% — Cursed (2005)
41% — Scream 3 (2000)
68% — Music of the Heart (1999)
81% — Scream 2 (1997)
87% — Scream (1996)

Tag Cloud

Universal indie book crime drama Crunchyroll Ellie Kemper zombie name the review Marvel Television Teen Mystery reboot Acorn TV FX game of thrones cars elevated horror cults El Rey crossover 2017 Animation Box Office composers rotten movies we love Nat Geo concert Turner Nickelodeon Rocketman Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Starz social media Drama films Christmas series justice league The CW Academy Awards Shondaland golden globes Fall TV USA Network slashers historical drama 24 frames psycho Biopics Star Wars ESPN spinoff PaleyFest Writers Guild of America Disney Plus Sneak Peek Film Festival comedies sitcom sports TCA 2017 Calendar Logo Britbox Mary Poppins Returns universal monsters miniseries video on demand binge witnail BET Tubi Year in Review Amazon Prime Epix zombies IFC Films Family Hulu war CNN werewolf Hear Us Out New York Comic Con adventure PBS free movies HBO Max stoner A24 Star Trek Netflix Trivia psychological thriller indiana jones Peacock Sundance Now Trophy Talk Kids & Family politics ghosts cops Arrowverse Awards cancelled TV series BAFTA Adult Swim Grammys comic TV sag awards Fox News Marathons police drama scary movies TBS Comedy natural history richard e. Grant Amazon Studios Classic Film The Purge HBO Go X-Men Red Carpet Apple TV+ The Witch Endgame Women's History Month asian-american 2015 2018 2016 disaster DC Universe Lucasfilm Rock Video Games Ovation renewed TV shows 2020 doctor who TCA Disney+ Disney Plus south america BBC DirecTV A&E Pixar anime APB YouTube Red 71st Emmy Awards technology Disney streaming service streaming NYCC satire Premiere Dates Heroines Freeform aliens Certified Fresh Amazon Prime Video Brie Larson franchise TV Land VH1 E! Toys twilight WarnerMedia Sundance Country Anna Paquin dragons criterion nature Valentine's Day San Diego Comic-Con Warner Bros. First Reviews reviews sequel TLC Binge Guide CBS All Access Best and Worst YA Martial Arts joker vampires Summer video blockbuster PlayStation HBO crime SXSW what to watch Esquire Oscars Columbia Pictures news SundanceTV TNT CW Seed VICE crime thriller GLAAD ratings chucky RT21 dogs DGA VOD CMT Television Critics Association USA Song of Ice and Fire Interview casting cancelled Black History Month dc transformers critics Photos Thanksgiving christmas movies Opinion Emmy Nominations LGBTQ Mudbound canceled Spectrum Originals MSNBC robots Disney versus Winter TV Tumblr teaser documentary Captain marvel ABC Family dramedy Winners cartoon Discovery Channel TCA Winter 2020 YouTube Premium all-time screenings space FOX Mindy Kaling President discovery Food Network Mary Tyler Moore Watching Series Extras OWN spain based on movie Western Hallmark Christmas movies E3 Rom-Com award winner TIFF TCM best Musical Masterpiece political drama The Arrangement Tarantino Spike Lifetime Christmas movies 007 DC streaming service Marvel directors harry potter hispanic Shudder canceled TV shows Ghostbusters Travel Channel serial killer Showtime television Emmys OneApp History spanish language DC Comics strong female leads Paramount Network talk show theme song revenge FXX parents stand-up comedy Sundance TV AMC Music travel singing competition WGN child's play Spring TV Walt Disney Pictures independent Holiday dark ITV Syfy Fantasy latino foreign breaking bad Pirates Hallmark Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comic Book a nightmare on elm street emmy awards animated Bravo Film mission: impossible zero dark thirty medical drama hist Reality LGBT NBC See It Skip It BBC One ABC Comedy Central Amazon Character Guide The Walking Dead thriller batman Superheroe Podcast YouTube cinemax true crime Marvel Studios mockumentary Superheroes BET Awards Infographic boxoffice Disney Channel CBS quibi 21st Century Fox spy thriller Paramount MTV Super Bowl kids festivals die hard First Look science fiction Stephen King Musicals TV renewals Awards Tour Dark Horse Comics Funimation Pop Pride Month diversity unscripted Sony Pictures FX on Hulu game show Vudu supernatural tv talk biography cats TCA Awards TruTV Quiz Elton John Television Academy Set visit Chernobyl screen actors guild Sci-Fi green book 20th Century Fox period drama comiccon Countdown adaptation jamie lee curtis finale Netflix Christmas movies Holidays RT History dceu Polls and Games Tomatazos facebook IFC blaxploitation Nominations Schedule romance BBC America spider-man Creative Arts Emmys 4/20 Cannes SDCC Trailer Comics on TV 2019 MCU Avengers Rocky Apple TV Plus cancelled television Cosplay National Geographic Mary poppins anthology Reality Competition Lionsgate movies 45 movie Horror Pet Sematary toy story Baby Yoda Apple cooking American Society of Cinematographers GIFs romantic comedy mutant Action Election halloween cancelled TV shows documentaries GoT Pop TV children's TV Lifetime comics docudrama Black Mirror Turner Classic Movies Cartoon Network Crackle