Critical Consensus: Critics Pan "Emily Rose," "The Man"

by | September 8, 2005 | Comments

This week at the movies features two of our favorite story elements: demonic possession ("The Exorcism of Emily Rose") and fish-out-of-water-cop-buddy-action stuff ("The Man"). Will the critics see the light, or is it off to the slammer for these two?

Nothing adds spice to a story quite like demonic possession; people are still talking about the time on "Days of Our Lives" when Marlenea was infected by Satan for close to a whole season. So how about a courtroom drama in which the bad guy is the Prince of Darkness himself? Well that’s what they tried to do with "The Exorcism of Emily Rose," and the scribes are split as to whether it works. While some have praised the film (which stars Laura Linney and Tom Wilkinson) for its sincere questions about the nature of belief, others say it is unable to sustain a coherent tone and suffers in comparison to the granddaddy of all demonic possession flicks, "The Exorcist." At 48 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Rose" isn’t smelling so sweet.

Ever get the idea that some movies are greenlit simply because someone thought, "Dude, that sounds like it might be mildly amusing!" That seems to describe "The Man," a buddy action comedy, starring Samuel L. Jackson and Eugene Levy, that critics say does absolutely nothing to transcend its premise. The plot involves a dental supply salesman (Levy) who wanders into a drug investigation headed by Jackson; as one would expect, Jackson plays a man who does not suffer fools gladly, and Levy plays a loveable fool. At 23 percent on the Tomatometer, the critics say this "Man" is a dog: predictable, uninspired, and utterly average.

Recent Samuel L. Jackson Movies:
15% — XXX: State of the Union (2005)
82% — Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith (2005)
64% — Coach Carter (2005)
24% — In My Country (2005)
97% — Incredibles (2004)

Tag Cloud

GoT Oscars aliens Lifetime El Rey cops President Tomatazos CMT CBS All Access FX First Look VICE Watching Series Pop Emmys Opinion war RT History IFC YA Rock Syfy History Disney Sneak Peek political drama Action police drama Trailer ESPN Photos Cartoon Network crime travel Paramount Horror 2015 Premiere Dates cooking romance Starz The Arrangement HBO social media X-Men Fox News Disney Channel Holidays talk show Nominations based on movie Star Wars Kids & Family 24 frames Summer TCA TV Land dramedy Comedy Central PBS adventure Food Network Calendar ABC sports politics Ghostbusters Martial Arts Pirates thriller serial killer Freeform GLAAD 2016 Country Dark Horse Comics Awards CBS E! Bravo E3 transformers Lionsgate TCM Superheroes Rom-Com Masterpiece discovery historical drama supernatural Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt vampires singing competition CNN DC Universe 2017 cats psycho BBC America Red Carpet zombie Musicals Certified Fresh docudrama Box Office MSNBC Podcast crime drama Tumblr Universal Cosplay cinemax Nickelodeon Infographic crime thriller NBC Netflix Winners Election Esquire boxoffice The CW Schedule BET harry potter Polls and Games AMC Hulu Musical ABC Family Interview Reality WGN TIFF Amazon ITV Ellie Kemper Mindy Kaling sitcom Winter TV composers Super Bowl comiccon TCA 2017 Adult Swim Music American Society of Cinematographers TruTV technology TNT Mary Tyler Moore PaleyFest Video Games Logo Trivia Valentine's Day Biopics diversity Teen Marvel Nat Geo Marathons MTV Grammys FXX DirecTV Warner Bros. 007 Extras 45 Rocky Comedy Fantasy SundanceTV TBS SDCC Animation GIFs TV Showtime what to watch BBC Fall TV APB A&E Countdown VH1 LGBTQ science fiction Star Trek Character Guide Year in Review DC Comics NYCC Comic Book Sci-Fi USA Set visit Writers Guild of America TLC Spring TV biography OWN Mystery Reality Competition Toys Crackle Drama Thanksgiving Sundance Best and Worst FOX period drama