Bohemian Rhapsody First Reviews: Rami Malek Shines in a Disappointing Biopic

Critics say Malek's performance is electric and the music is full of energy, but the film overall follows a too-familiar template.

by | October 23, 2018 | Comments

According to the first wave of reviews for Bohemian Rhapsody, the Freddie Mercury rock biopic is loud and full of energy, at least in the concert scenes, but it lacks character development and isn’t much more than a play-by-play collection of big moments. If anything, it’s Rami Malek‘s performance as Mercury and a depiction of Live Aid that are worth the price of a ticket.

Here’s what critics are saying about the movie:

Does it live up to expectations?

The movie isn’t un-enjoyable to watch…But if you were expecting anything out of the ordinary, you might be disappointed.
Anne Cohen, Refinery29

The movie is just a conventional rock flick, one all too ordinary for a man and a band that exemplified the extraordinary.
Brian Truitt, USA Today

The movie, as it is, is fine. But it could have been so much more… I couldn’t help but feel disappointed.
Joanna Langfield, The Movie Minute

Does Rami Malek kill it as Freddie Mercury, though?

He is absolutely brilliant.
– Caroline Preece, Den of Geek

Start engraving that academy award.
– Tara Brady, The Irish Times

Malek gives an incredible performance and is honestly the only reason to keep watching the movie.
– Jason Guerrasio, Business Insider

What Bohemian Rhapsody does have is an electric performance from Rami Malek as Freddie Mercury.
– Russ Fischer, Birth.Movies.Death.

He goes big and bold… But it’s the small moments and expressions that truly elevate his performance.
– Kimber Myers, The Playlist

It’s a satisfying, hammy turn in a movie with no other meat on the bone.
– David Ehrlich, IndieWire

20th Century Fox

Does the movie go deep enough?

More often than not, the film makes you feel like you’re watching a group of talented actors cosplay Queen’s Wikipedia page.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

The news of his AIDS diagnosis is practically the only indication the audience gets that Mercury even had a sex life at all.
Richard Larson, Slant Magazine

For a movie that literally opens with an HIV-positive Mercury coughing — letting us know early that subtlety will not be on the menu — the film does handle its protagonist’s issues with AIDS-related complication respectfully, if fleetingly.
– Alonso Duralde, The Wrap

Someday another feature about Queen might go deeper. That might or might not make for a better movie.
– Sheri Linden, Hollywood Reporter

For a mainstream release celebrating a rock band whose songs have become sports anthems, a surprisingly gay film that does not shy away from depictions of intimacy between men.
– Russ Fischer, Birth.Movies.Death.

How ridiculous does the plotting get?

Freddie finally finds a man he’s spent years searching for and visits his parents for the first time in a decade on the morning of the famous Live Aid concert. That was a heck of a day!
– Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

If there’s anything more tiresome than the movies that inspired the Dewey Cox story, it’s a movie that uses Jake Kasdan’s damning parody as a template.
– David Ehrlich, IndieWire

Is the script formulaic?

[Paint-by-numbers] but the artist is really bad and can’t read numbers and just puts any color where he damn well pleases.
Mike Ryan, Uproxx

Screenwriter Anthony McCarten is no stranger to biopic contrivance, but he outdoes himself.
Alonso Duralde, The Wrap

[The screenplay] doesn’t so much flow as leap from one aha moment to the next.
Sheri Linden, Hollywood Reporter

20th Century Fox
(Photo by 20th Century Fox)

Are there any other good performances?

The performance by Lucy Boynton as Mary Austin… builds itself up over the entire course of the film. The rest of the members of the band are outstanding and perfectly cast.
– Ashley Menzel, We Live Entertainment

I’ve rarely seen actors look as convincingly like musicians as the ones in this film.
– Russ Fischer, Birth.Movies.Death.

Are there any standout moments?

Bohemian Rhapsody’s recreation of Queen’s Live Aid set is the movie’s clear highlight.
– Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

The final scene, a flawless, moving replication of Queen’s entire 20-minute set from Live Aid, is absurdly impressive.
– Tara Brady, The Irish Times

The lingering exhilaration of that concert scene is pretty darn magnifico.
– Sheri Linden, Hollywood Reporter

That Live Aid sequence so thrillingly captures what is considered both a high point in live rock performance and a historical moment in Queen’s career that it justifies making and seeing the movie.
– Alonso Duralde, The Wrap

The Live Aid performance… could be either seen as an impressive technical feat or an extended karaoke session, but at least ends the story on a high.
– Steve Rose, Guardian

Will Queen fans enjoy it?

It is a fan film that will have audiences dancing in their seats. I can see it having the long term success that The Greatest Showman enjoyed last year into earlier this year.
– Ashley Menzel, We Live Entertainment

If you’re not singing along, we have nothing to talk about.
– Joanna Langfield, The Movie Minute

Bohemian Rhapsody is finally ready to be seen by Queen superfans and curious moviegoers alike. Unfortunately, despite great work from a lot of people, the film never feels daring or honest enough to please either.
– Caroline Preece, Den of Geek

Bohemian Rhapsody opens everywhere on Friday, November 2. Read all the reviews for it here.

Adjusted Score: 77.867%
Critics Consensus: Bohemian Rhapsody hits a handful of high notes, but as an in-depth look at a beloved band, it offers more of a medley than a true greatest hits collection.
Synopsis: Bohemian Rhapsody is a foot-stomping celebration of Queen, their music and their extraordinary lead singer Freddie Mercury, who defied stereotypes... [More]
Directed By: Bryan Singer

Tag Cloud

dc SXSW composers Shudder The CW Polls and Games Walt Disney Pictures boxoffice docudrama Animation Paramount Network facebook Amazon Marvel based on movie adventure Amazon Prime Schedule Mystery robots supernatural Disney Channel diversity finale TNT elevated horror Rock Superheroe TCA 2017 Set visit natural history DGA travel OWN Dark Horse Comics 2019 Tarantino LGBTQ 2017 Logo doctor who Captain marvel Trailer Grammys TV Interview SundanceTV television IFC crossover Elton John cooking YouTube Red USA talk show VICE Women's History Month Mary Poppins Returns Toys New York Comic Con Starz ratings Action Masterpiece Mindy Kaling mockumentary serial killer Apple Rocky Reality TV Land period drama MCU 007 Infographic Calendar President TIFF DC Comics VH1 BBC America Holidays Black Mirror Best and Worst Rocketman cats Super Bowl Fox News biography Film Festival SDCC Christmas Cosplay Spring TV Drama DirecTV RT History crime ABC Family Showtime History Martial Arts Disney CNN Nickelodeon Netflix Biopics dragons APB RT21 Nat Geo ESPN Comedy Central Horror Video Games Watching Series FXX USA Network Sci-Fi Pop mutant Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Ovation aliens Trophy Talk FX NBC Musicals Lucasfilm singing competition green book blaxploitation Oscars strong female leads GoT Sundance Now crime drama MSNBC witnail GLAAD Shondaland Comedy Summer Song of Ice and Fire Reality Competition Spectrum Originals Mary Tyler Moore sports Lionsgate political drama Pixar sitcom CBS Extras 20th Century Fox cops Countdown A&E Election Esquire Mary poppins streaming adaptation Sneak Peek First Look Superheroes Winter TV Lifetime Fantasy YouTube Premium NYCC TBS Ellie Kemper Britbox anime politics zero dark thirty E! unscripted The Witch Writers Guild of America Hulu CMT discovery Nominations Food Network Brie Larson Year in Review Comic Book zombie Tomatazos Cartoon Network Cannes Kids & Family Bravo YA BET golden globes Epix hist science fiction E3 X-Men vampires Sundance anthology Quiz thriller IFC Films BBC FOX Heroines Awards Valentine's Day theme song MTV zombies casting The Arrangement transformers Opinion crime thriller Warner Bros. Vudu Winners PBS 21st Century Fox comic Star Trek Podcast Adult Swim GIFs Country police drama Character Guide Red Carpet sequel Crackle space festivals 2018 harry potter true crime romance CW Seed Mudbound Music Sony Pictures teaser Fall TV Syfy Tumblr medical drama dceu 2015 San Diego Comic-Con Acorn TV miniseries Photos American Society of Cinematographers spider-man comiccon ITV Universal Box Office Awards Tour Trivia Emmys See It Skip It Thanksgiving 24 frames 45 DC streaming service DC Universe Musical 2016 historical drama Comics on TV cults binge Premiere Dates TCM technology jamie lee curtis Spike TLC AMC Stephen King Columbia Pictures Teen TCA Marathons El Rey what to watch Paramount disaster Ghostbusters dramedy ABC Western Star Wars richard e. Grant Creative Arts Emmys TruTV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cinemax psycho HBO psychological thriller Pet Sematary Pirates National Geographic Certified Fresh nature justice league social media WGN PaleyFest spy thriller CBS All Access Freeform Anna Paquin war Rom-Com award winner