A Well-Acted, Satisfying Conclusion: Rotten Tomatoes Users Weigh in on It: Chapter Two

Check out some of the insightful user reviews for the second half of Andy Muschietti's adaptation of the epic Stephen King novel about an evil, shapeshifting killer clown.

by | September 9, 2019 | Comments

With Stephen King’s name behind it and a resurgence of interest in nostalgia-fueled entertainment, 2017’s It was probably always going to be successful, but few could have predicted that it would earn widespread critical acclaim (Certified Fresh at 86%) and break box office records when it first opened. The runaway success of the film, which covered just half of King’s behemoth source novel, only further guaranteed that the sequel necessary to complete the story would be produced in short order, and that’s what we got this past weekend. As it turned out, fewer critics were on board with It: Chapter Two, resulting in a 64% on the Tomatometer, but it debuted right behind its predecessor to achieve the second-highest grossing horror film opening — and second-highest grossing opening in September — ever.

So we know audiences absolutely turned out to see the film, but what did they think of it? Based on over 12,000 verified audience reviews, It: Chapter Two currently holds an Audience Score of 80%, just a few points shy of the first film’s 84% Audience Score, even though the critics found it far less satisfying. With that in mind, we decided to dig into the audience reviews themselves to see what it was that regular moviegoers saw in Chapter Two that the critics didn’t. Check out the user reviews of It: Chapter Two and let us know what you thought of the film, and these reviews, in the comments. (Note, some of the reviews have been slightly edited for length and grammar/spelling.)

(Photo by Brooke Palmer/© 2019 WARNER BROS. ENTERTAINMENT INC.)

How does it compare to the first chapter?

My first thought when it was over was, “There was no need for this film.” It basically tells the same story as the first one, except with adults.
– Anne M, 3 stars

If you like chapter 1, you’ll like this.
– The Weasel, 4 stars

I personally loved it more than the first.
– Cody A, 5 stars

Just as fantastic as chapter one!
– Simon B, 5 Stars

And what about the 1990 TV miniseries?

Loved it. Almost as good as the original, but no one can beat Tim! Didn’t even feel that long.
– Ross K, 4.5 stars

I felt I had way more closure and understanding of the story once the end came than I did over the original version of It.
– Michael, 4.5 stars

Warner Bros. Pictures
(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures)

Is it scary?

Felt like it was dragged out, and it wasn’t scary at all.
– Joey, 1.5 stars

Couldn’t figure out if it was trying to be funny or be a parody of itself, but it broke up any intensity it could have had.
– Adam R, 2.5 stars

It didn’t scare me, but it was sure funny. I could not stop laughing! It was good.
– Trenton S, 3.5 stars

This one actually scared me. At some times I was literally on the edge of my seat. Altogether a good film.
– Kyle, 4.5 stars

I haven’t seen a scary movie in years — I mean years, maybe a decade or so — that made me wanna go get baptized, christened, I mean, some type of soul-saving. Seriously. Now I’m scared of the following things: Baby hands, pomeranians, lumberjacks, old people (sorry, grandmom), fortune cookies — you know, everyday s–t. Thanks, Stephen.
– Stevie P, 5 stars

Is it emotional?

It… tried to be heartwarming in the end but fell short of that. It was kind of caught between fantasy and reality and couldn’t figure out where it wanted to rest.
– Adam R, 2.5 stars

It: Chapter Two brought a heartfelt ending to the 2-part story but fell short. It just feels like a movie I’d only watch one time and forget about later.
– Christian A, 2.5 stars

I wasn’t planning on crying in two separate scenes during this movie.
– Chris S, 5 stars

Warner Bros. Pictures
(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures)

Is it faithful to the source material?

A gorgeous, wonderfully acted, fluidly directed, faithful, and emotionally satisfying second half (NOT SEQUEL — ask King and Muschietti) to what is possibly the first true horror epic.
– Andy S, 4.5 stars

I thought it followed the book really, really well, and it was a lot scarier.
– Hanna, 4.5 stars

True to the book. Loved seeing the kids again in chapter two. Pennywise is creepily good 🎈🎈😆😆.
– ScoobyDoo, 5 stars

Is the length a problem?

Way too long and drawn out.
– Lucinda, 1 star

Movie was way too long. Boring.
– Carlos, 1.5 stars

It was too long. It was too slow. It was too cliche. It was too predictable. It was too repetitive. It would do something once. Then It would do it again. Then It would do it again. Then It would do it again. It often seemed more like a hackneyed action movie than a horror movie.
– Pat C, 2 stars

Because it was so similar to chapter 1, I kept glancing at my watch. It felt slow, perhaps because they wanted to give each actor some time to shine in their own mini-story.
– Anne M, 3 stars

It didn’t feel like it was nearly three hours long.
– Hanna, 4.5 stars

Could have been edited down a bit; a lot of unnecessary scenes for a movie that’s almost three hours long. All in all, a good movie.
– Mike M, 4 stars

(Photo by Brooke Palmer/© 2019 WARNER BROS. ENTERTAINMENT INC.)

And how is the cast?

It did have James McAvoy, who was good. It had Bill Hader, who was great. It also had a red-headed chick, a furrowed-eyebrow guy, a buff guy, and a token guy. Mostly though, It was just disappointing.
– Pat C, 2 stars

Well-acted, true, but the kids were just as good.
– Anne M, 3 stars

Bill Hader was easily the best character in this movie!
– Trenton S, 3.5 stars

It is well acted by all. Big props to Bill Hader’s wisecracking, yet not overdone, performance. Could have used a little more Pennywise, but definitely one of the better Stephen King adaptations.
– Allen L, 4 stars

The casting was perfect and the ending was beautiful.
– Hanna, 4.5 stars

Check out all of the user reviews for It: Chapter Two

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

diversity USA Network Interview Chernobyl serial killer USA OWN adaptation A24 TCA Awards comic Country Drama adventure sequels DirecTV Nat Geo Action news Captain marvel fast and furious chucky ghosts Superheroe Valentine's Day latino stop motion BBC award winner DGA stoner comics Shondaland singing competition Masterpiece LGBTQ Pirates FX Hallmark dark Character Guide hist based on movie Tomatazos Watching Series transformers Thanksgiving Holiday Horror Podcast worst Reality Competition Super Bowl Marathons blockbuster Spectrum Originals Cannes ITV witnail First Look Film crime drama Star Wars Certified Fresh foreign nbcuniversal cancelled tv talk ratings dc Lifetime Christmas movies ABC zombie The Arrangement Comics on TV Rocky Starz Kids & Family Musical period drama spanish language IFC Films game show Black Mirror PaleyFest Best and Worst comiccon The Witch Biopics Schedule TV Land 2016 Lifetime Cartoon Network joker Trivia franchise documentary Video Games crime cops Musicals Extras Sci-Fi A&E Warner Bros. series See It Skip It politics streaming DC Comics Acorn TV Walt Disney Pictures Film Festival The CW Song of Ice and Fire HBO screenings animated video on demand Box Office SXSW true crime El Rey 72 Emmy Awards spinoff dceu HBO Go 2018 Vudu Britbox Sundance TV Winter TV FOX 45 Television Critics Association quibi Set visit slashers Freeform Amazon Prime VICE Disney Plus 2020 Emmys boxoffice Quiz war Rom-Com Pixar what to watch The Purge Animation Toys Mary poppins theme song Baby Yoda canceled TV shows Ghostbusters Epix twilight psycho Shudder robots GoT Western Black History Month classics APB video space children's TV 71st Emmy Awards PBS Emmy Nominations LGBT stand-up comedy satire National Geographic anime Rocketman miniseries CNN TBS thriller Netflix Christmas movies Food Network child's play VOD BBC America Teen concert ABC Family natural history Opinion Netflix First Reviews CW Seed jamie lee curtis Spike critics Paramount Network cats Arrowverse Fantasy RT History blaxploitation Pop Women's History Month Logo Sundance Amazon Hear Us Out Reality elevated horror discovery 20th Century Fox historical drama sequel TV renewals Amazon Prime Video Trophy Talk Writers Guild of America Paramount Mystery X-Men Adult Swim TV TCA 2017 Infographic Countdown TCM Discovery Channel Showtime Superheroes MSNBC halloween Winners movies YouTube laika psychological thriller dragons composers Tubi Pop TV YA all-time 24 frames Anna Paquin Awards ESPN Pride Month book Peacock documentaries Nominations Mudbound Premiere Dates Dark Horse Comics BAFTA WGN Family Trailer E3 Photos Tarantino Esquire unscripted television BBC One Classic Film mission: impossible OneApp The Walking Dead biography Grammys BET cartoon 21st Century Fox TCA canceled medical drama Disney+ Disney Plus History name the review Comedy Central sitcom crime thriller Awards Tour Apple police drama NYCC travel YouTube Premium CBS All Access Crackle Nickelodeon Spring TV nature Academy Awards dogs Marvel renewed TV shows Creative Arts Emmys films Marvel Studios Disney BET Awards crossover Turner Classic Movies cooking Universal directors Disney streaming service harry potter SundanceTV zero dark thirty TruTV Lionsgate Summer cancelled TV series Mindy Kaling scary movies 2015 4/20 Sundance Now Hallmark Christmas movies cars free movies teaser Year in Review Hulu President Elton John sports Travel Channel 2019 Brie Larson Turner DC Universe AMC rotten Funimation die hard festivals Pet Sematary Lucasfilm obituary Marvel Television Amazon Studios DC streaming service Stephen King Tumblr Comedy Red Carpet CMT GIFs TIFF San Diego Comic-Con dramedy YouTube Red talk show Rock Calendar CBS Holidays Endgame Ovation science fiction Fall TV MTV kids Sony Pictures finale aliens revenge hispanic Chilling Adventures of Sabrina IFC indiana jones parents TLC golden globes universal monsters disaster sag awards Music justice league Television Academy cancelled TV shows cinemax Oscars WarnerMedia Disney Channel reviews facebook 2017 Fox News New York Comic Con indie docudrama PlayStation Sneak Peek Polls and Games mutant Bravo Binge Guide Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt spain richard e. Grant NBC E! romance Heroines vampires supernatural reboot Cosplay rotten movies we love doctor who game of thrones Election Martial Arts SDCC casting Syfy social media Crunchyroll Star Trek strong female leads RT21 FXX emmy awards VH1 asian-american a nightmare on elm street TNT green book Mary Tyler Moore HBO Max south america FX on Hulu werewolf mockumentary anthology hollywood best Apple TV+ romantic comedy christmas movies Christmas Mary Poppins Returns comedies Apple TV Plus Columbia Pictures screen actors guild American Society of Cinematographers cults GLAAD binge Ellie Kemper superhero movie breaking bad 007 zombies MCU Comic Book versus batman TCA Winter 2020 spy thriller toy story technology spider-man criterion cancelled television political drama Avengers independent