Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Season of the Witch Doesn't Cast a Spell

Plus, Country Strong hits some sour notes.

by | January 7, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got courageous Crusaders (Season of the Witch, starring Nicolas Cage and Ron Perlman) and a country comeback (Country Strong, starring Gwyneth Paltrow and Tim McGraw ). What do the critics have to say?


Season of the Witch

Say what you will about Nicolas Cage, but give the man credit: at a time when too many movie stars studiously protect their images, he’s unafraid to look ridiculous. Sometimes, his devil-may-care attitude pays off (see Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans), and sometimes, well, we get stuff like Season of the Witch, a Medieval action flick that critics say is too dull to qualify as so-bad-it’s-good kitsch. Cage and Ron Perlman star as former Crusaders who are tasked with protecting and transporting a woman accused of being witch to a remote monastery; on their arduous journey, they must contend with wolves, zombies, and the black plague. The pundits say Season of the Witch is bottom-of-the barrel fantasy fare, with cheesy dialogue, so-so special effects, and a general air of silliness. (Check out Cage’s Five Favorite Films, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Perlman’s best-reviewed movies.)


Country Strong

A lot of country songs are great not for their originality, but because they’re infused with passion and craftsmanship. The same holds true for plenty of movies, but unfortunately for Country Strong, it can’t transcend its clichés, devolving into a showbiz melodrama despite good performances and heart-on-its-sleeve sincerity. Gwyneth Paltrow stars as Kelly Canter, a country superstar fresh from rehab; still shaky, she embarks on a tour, with hot young singer Beau Hutton (Garrett Hedlund), overseen by her manager/ex-husband James (Tim McGraw). Can our heroine overcome romantic entanglements and the bottle to reclaim her place atop the charts? The pundits say the leads give it their all, and the music is toe-tapping, but Country Strong is undone by meandering pacing and a slavish adherence to soapy formula.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

TV renewals cops talk show worst movies NYCC documentary Countdown vs. stop motion FXX quibi interviews hidden camera die hard fresh Apple TV Plus ratings New York Comic Con Brie Larson Awards Tour Television Academy Exclusive Video Columbia Pictures action-comedy Best Director travel Trailer Summer Turner directors kaiju olympics Drama GoT Sundance Instagram Live RT History Valentine's Day Fargo toy story Country festival Captain marvel crime films Avengers Writers Guild of America Paramount Network obituary Cosplay DC Comics festivals black comedy HBO Max crime drama black Tokyo Olympics HBO Go Star Wars fast and furious Holiday Comic-Con@Home 2021 feel good Mary Poppins Returns Pop TV remakes indiana jones foreign comic book movie Music comiccon broadcast spinoff cinemax social media Mary Tyler Moore book Arrowverse DGA Teen Disney Channel Grammys Tags: Comedy twilight Turner Classic Movies Watching Series miniseries TCM sag awards Sony MCU Shondaland blockbusters Image Comics telelvision heist movie hispanic laika rt labs Star Trek suspense TNT space adenture BAFTA classics boxoffice documentaries video on demand canceled YA TLC 21st Century Fox Disney chucky posters king arthur mission: impossible The Walking Dead spanish Superheroes doctor who venice mcc TCA scene in color 2016 debate 2015 YouTube Premium Marvel Studios Mudbound Chernobyl genre FX on Hulu discovery IMDb TV IFC Films Anna Paquin Photos 94th Oscars Fox Searchlight FX Film Legendary 45 71st Emmy Awards Disney+ Disney Plus italian game show 72 Emmy Awards summer preview young adult pirates of the caribbean LGBTQ children's TV YouTube GIFs 007 Food Network international TruTV First Look Pop E3 green book Hulu video 99% Fox News Character Guide cancelled TV shows The Arrangement halloween tv screen actors guild dexter sequels Extras joker finale breaking bad crime thriller robots Set visit obi wan zero dark thirty rt labs critics edition Crackle E! Trophy Talk Sci-Fi golden globes french Geeked Week Premiere Dates asian-american Oscars 90s Lifetime Martial Arts political drama spanish language rotten movies we love Amazon Prime National Geographic Apple TV+ cancelled Cannes The Academy comedies Epix slashers justice league Ellie Kemper unscripted nature Vudu scary movies stoner revenge high school aapi USA Network emmy awards President Tomatazos summer TV preview Christmas Tubi rt archives Native streaming casting PaleyFest Musicals Comics on TV AMC Comic Book book adaptation Netflix Christmas movies dragons Opinion Sundance TV popular psychological thriller Oscar razzies Calendar monster movies mob hollywood X-Men Mystery Fantasy Red Carpet Freeform ITV Hear Us Out Focus Features ghosts Paramount Plus Family FOX archives cancelled television ABC Signature Rocky target Broadway nbcuniversal Hallmark animated theme song DC Universe harry potter sopranos gangster reviews historical drama Travel Channel History true crime spider-man Amazon Prime Video name the review nfl Syfy live event cars superhero Box Office Horror ID spy thriller Western Video Games godzilla Peacock Marvel cats singing competition award winner Endgame 93rd Oscars Ovation Comedy Central Crunchyroll Lifetime Christmas movies vampires CBS Esquire superman CMT BBC biopic 2019 Bravo Star Wars Celebration SXSW 2022 Heroines critics crossover dc satire cooking Nickelodeon Sneak Peek hist Ghostbusters Marvel Television BET Awards OneApp blaxploitation deadpool Winners Netflix Sundance Now cartoon CBS All Access dreamworks Classic Film spider-verse BBC America child's play police drama Paramount Pictures Binge Guide comic book movies SXSW know your critic docuseries Year in Review HBO toronto marvel cinematic universe canceled TV shows PlayStation best Logo scene in color film series Showtime Warner Bros. 73rd Emmy Awards Schedule zombie parents 79th Golden Globes Awards Reality Creative Arts Emmys south america all-time Tarantino streamig trophy SundanceTV Lionsgate VOD war 2020 art house series a nightmare on elm street romance composers independent sequel halloween Black History Month Universal MTV 4/20 docudrama Disney streaming service natural history Superheroe thriller Television Critics Association Disney Plus 1990s anime concert Rock Holidays WarnerMedia indie Britbox teaser 20th Century Fox jurassic park witnail Kids & Family Acorn TV rom-coms Toys A24 Cartoon Network spain NBC new star wars movies Tumblr BBC One slasher IFC Stephen King 24 frames leaderboard diversity Winter TV TCA Winter 2020 Super Bowl Film Festival comic YouTube Red movie Spring TV live action Action Best and Worst Pixar supernatural dceu cults saw television Rocketman The CW richard e. Grant TV sports Fall TV christmas movies Funimation trailers Wes Anderson TCA 2017 Thanksgiving Awards Prime Video The Witch Amazon TCA Awards king kong Mindy Kaling new zealand cancelled TV series Quiz dramedy australia game of thrones Election DC streaming service streaming movies San Diego Comic-Con ViacomCBS mutant mockumentary free movies marvel comics kong legend universal monsters versus royal family Trivia scene in color series 2021 wonder woman binge Pirates batman dark Black Mirror screenings Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Shudder Neflix DirecTV target scene in color TV movies boxing Spike Emmy Nominations VICE Academy Awards BET kids Best Actor Hallmark Christmas movies Podcast sitcom rotten 2018 Reality Competition 2017 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards blockbuster psycho Biopics movies period drama Universal Pictures hispanic heritage month Best Actress TV Land LGBT Interview A&E new york elevated horror Baby Yoda Song of Ice and Fire The Purge women SDCC comics scorecard japan NBA Best Picture El Rey American Society of Cinematographers werewolf OWN MGM anthology reboot HFPA TIFF adaptation Walt Disney Pictures what to watch The Walt Disney Company science fiction CW Seed stand-up comedy serial killer Adult Swim biography Paramount RT21 Pride Month Pacific Islander USA Rom-Com Amazon Studios Animation Comedy politics zombies VH1 Alien ESPN TV One First Reviews golden globe awards Apple See It Skip It strong female leads PBS lord of the rings technology AMC Plus ABC Musical Polls and Games jamie lee curtis Certified Fresh aliens japanese based on movie prank Nominations Indigenous Hollywood Foreign Press Association facebook scary latino South by Southwest Film Festival Starz basketball news summer TV MSNBC TBS GLAAD comic books disaster Nat Geo Discovery Channel ABC Family Mary poppins dogs Elton John Pet Sematary critic resources criterion football worst Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Infographic Sony Pictures Lucasfilm CNN APB Marathons transformers renewed TV shows Women's History Month Emmys Masterpiece romantic comedy Spectrum Originals medical drama james bond WGN Dark Horse Comics franchise adventure tv talk