Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Killing Them Softly Is Certified Fresh

Plus, The Collection improves a bit on its predecessor.

by | November 29, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an efficient enforcer (Killing Them Softly, starring Brad Pitt and Richard Jenkins) and a methodical madman (The Collection starring Emma Fitzpatrick and Josh Stewart). What do the critics have to say?

Killing Them Softly


The economic collapse of 2008 didn’t just deep six Wall Street — it put the squeeze on the underground economy as well. That’s the theme of Killing Them Softly, a twisty crime thriller that critics say is sharply written and visually striking, though it occasionally pushes its big ideas too hard. After a couple of incompetent crooks steal from a mafia-sanctioned poker game, the family sends Jackie Cogan (Brad Pitt) to rub them out. However, the mafia’s corporation-like structure makes Jackie’s task more complicated at nearly every turn. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Killing Them Softly doesn’t always match its outsized ambitions, but it’s still a thoughtful, visceral foray into gangland built around Pitt’s magnetic performance. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Pitt’s best-reviewed movies.)

The Collection


The Collection is a sequel to the 2009 frightfest The Collector, and critics say it’s an improvement — it’s a sleek, twisted, and well acted, though it intermittently gets bogged down in predictability and gratuitous bloodiness. Thinking she’s going to a party, Elena (Emma Fitzpatrick) is taken to a mysterious location, only to wind up in the clutches of the murderous Collector. In order to retrieve her, a rescue squad turns to Arkin (Josh Stewart), the only one to ever escape the Collector’s clutches. The pundits say The Collection will please gorehounds with its grisly inventiveness, but others are likely to blanch at its over-the-top violence.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

OWN ITV Drama cops Cosplay TNT DirecTV war A&E Awards period drama IFC docudrama Holidays Watching Series Red Carpet technology Fall TV TCM zombie Winners boxoffice aliens TCA 2017 cooking travel Disney Channel sports psycho Star Trek TruTV Nat Geo Trivia MSNBC Sneak Peek Logo Interview Set visit GoT thriller crime thriller NBC HBO Winter TV Starz SundanceTV Esquire Hulu discovery Reality CMT Schedule serial killer TV Universal 2015 Amazon President Pop Superheroes crime Emmys Reality Competition MTV Music SDCC Pirates Summer Nominations Mary Tyler Moore Star Wars AMC Toys Countdown GLAAD LGBTQ Opinion Thanksgiving CBS ABC TLC WGN Rock Kids & Family Syfy harry potter E! Comedy Oscars Election Certified Fresh Teen VICE Rom-Com PaleyFest History TIFF Writers Guild of America GIFs Netflix The Arrangement Year in Review Ghostbusters Mystery Comedy Central RT History FXX Calendar Sundance Video Games Character Guide BBC DC Comics Freeform FX The CW Marvel Podcast USA VH1 TV Land crime drama comiccon biography social media Photos Masterpiece Disney TBS Sci-Fi BET Grammys sitcom Rocky Country singing competition ESPN Nickelodeon Biopics adventure Tumblr Musical NYCC Fox News X-Men American Society of Cinematographers politics 007 supernatural Cartoon Network APB BBC America Comic Book ABC Family Musicals Best and Worst Horror Extras First Look Dark Horse Comics Spring TV TCA Food Network historical drama Tomatazos Action Lionsgate Fantasy Valentine's Day Adult Swim CNN Marathons Bravo diversity Polls and Games science fiction Martial Arts cinemax composers 2017 PBS Lifetime Infographic Box Office police drama FOX Super Bowl based on movie 24 frames CBS All Access dramedy 2016 Crackle Trailer Animation vampires Showtime Premiere Dates El Rey