Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Act of Valor Misses the Mark

Plus, Wanderlust is inspired wackiness, and guess the Tomatometers for Tyler Perry's Good Deeds and Gone.

by | February 23, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got real American heroes (Act of Valor, starring Roselyn Sanchez and Alex Veadov), a wacky commune (Wanderlust, starring Jennifer Aniston and Paul Rudd), a soul-sick businessman (Tyler Perry’s Good Deeds, starring Tyler Perry and Thandie Newton), and a mysterious disappearance (Gone, starring Amanda Seyfried and Daniel Sunjata). What do the critics have to say?

Act of Valor


Act of Valor is a fictionalized action film featuring real-life Navy SEALs, but critics say it’s not a particularly good one; it’s an over-adrenalized series of (literally) explosive set-pieces that never finds the humanity within these heroes. The film follows our most elite soldiers on a secret, globe-trotting mission to neutralize a terrorist threat; along the way, we learn a little about how the SEALs go about their business. No one can doubt the bravery and sacrifice of the Navy SEALs, but the pundits say the Act of Valor has more in common with video games like Call of Duty — its hyperkinetic action scenes bulldoze storytelling and character development, and we’re left with an odd, unsatisfying tribute to a group of patriots who deserve better.



If a movie simply makes us laugh, we’re likely to overlook its faults. Such is the case with Wanderlust — critics say this zany fish-out-of-water comedy isn’t the most disciplined film in the world, but it’s warm and often inspired in its absurdity. Facing financial ruin, George (Paul Rudd) and his wife Linda (Jennifer Aniston) leave the comfy environs of Manhattan to live with his brother in Atlanta. On the way, however, they stumble upon a commune and decide they kinda like it; ribald hilarity ensues. The pundits say Wanderlust isn’t much more than the sum of its parts, but those parts are often very funny, as the game cast works together to create moments of genuine lunacy.

Tyler Perry’s Good Deeds


As is often the case with Tyler Perry‘s films, Good Deeds was not screened for critics prior to its release. Perry stars as Wesley Deeds, a successful but dissatisfied businessman who snaps out of his rut after befriending Lindsey (Thandie Newton), an unlucky single mom who works in his building. Time to guess that Tomatometer!



It appears the people behind Gone feared that critics wouldn’t go along with their movie, since it didn’t screen before hitting theaters. Amanda Seyfried stars as Jill, who once escaped a kidnapping attempt. But now that her sister has been abducted, she suspects a serial killer is behind the crimes. Once again, guess the Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Fairy, a Belgian comedy about a young woman who claims she can grant wishes, is at 100 percent.
  • The Forgiveness of Blood, a drama about a young man who’s caught in the middle of a blood feud between families in his small town, is at 83 percent.
  • Tomorrow, When the War Began, a thriller about a group of Australian teens who must defend their homeland against a surprise invasion, is at 64 percent.

Tag Cloud

DirecTV Mary poppins Martial Arts Sneak Peek Tomatazos game show ESPN TCA 2017 Logo Pirates E! Captain marvel TLC cults 2015 21st Century Fox Superheroe Pet Sematary Biopics Trailer Rocky SXSW Infographic Women's History Month DC Comics mockumentary Tarantino Lucasfilm medical drama Action Chernobyl spy thriller casting Amazon Prime Video 24 frames strong female leads 2016 Holidays GLAAD Extras Trophy Talk blaxploitation jamie lee curtis Trivia TCM Marvel thriller Schedule Nominations ITV Election Emmy Nominations RT History Cartoon Network psychological thriller Music DC Universe Star Wars Grammys Toys war composers binge Mindy Kaling Valentine's Day OWN what to watch Hulu richard e. Grant Paramount Pop Mystery children's TV Video Games Animation Country cops Mary Tyler Moore Amazon Prime cats dragons Set visit kids Kids & Family series Apple Box Office aliens zombies true crime The Witch movies adventure DGA period drama VH1 sitcom Brie Larson Lifetime harry potter SundanceTV miniseries Marathons Anna Paquin finale Calendar Character Guide Comics on TV 2019 20th Century Fox Premiere Dates Photos HBO vampires doctor who Ovation The Arrangement romance ghosts comiccon natural history Bravo Shudder Spring TV boxoffice USA Network Emmys BBC America Red Carpet docudrama animated DC streaming service Ghostbusters festivals crossover FXX 45 National Geographic Nat Geo Opinion Binge Guide Lionsgate Teen WarnerMedia dc Fantasy justice league Warner Bros. Musical Family Elton John anime MTV witnail WGN President revenge Super Bowl MCU cooking E3 TIFF supernatural TV Land GIFs cars LGBTQ X-Men ratings Fox News television VICE adaptation Nickelodeon Universal Masterpiece Disney streaming service Pride Month Tumblr Film Mudbound NYCC facebook robots TruTV Stephen King A&E Crackle Showtime Musicals Star Trek Netflix technology Disney mutant IFC dceu Sundance Now Paramount Network elevated horror crime Drama Writers Guild of America 2017 book LGBT Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Food Network sequel Sony Pictures Awards crime drama BBC TV zombie Heroines Interview Creative Arts Emmys Shondaland science fiction Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Walt Disney Pictures nature Epix Disney Channel Mary Poppins Returns spider-man Cannes CMT Rocketman 2018 Song of Ice and Fire green book Pixar Fall TV GoT cinemax Best and Worst PaleyFest Superheroes Adult Swim BET Amazon 007 Comic Book Reality YouTube Red Columbia Pictures golden globes YouTube Premium Winter TV police drama CNN crime thriller NBC Western El Rey unscripted political drama YA teaser TBS San Diego Comic-Con Vudu TCA FOX transformers diversity toy story disaster Quiz Starz Acorn TV MSNBC Cosplay American Society of Cinematographers IFC Films dramedy RT21 HBO Max serial killer First Look APB New York Comic Con Countdown Sci-Fi hist Reality Competition Comedy biography sports psycho The CW Black Mirror travel Spectrum Originals Comedy Central Christmas Summer Year in Review discovery Freeform politics theme song Thanksgiving Rom-Com PBS CBS All Access historical drama Awards Tour CBS anthology TNT See It Skip It ABC AMC Certified Fresh Watching Series quibi SDCC Dark Horse Comics CW Seed zero dark thirty Horror Sundance social media Britbox ABC Family Podcast Oscars streaming Rock based on movie Syfy Spike Ellie Kemper FX Esquire Winners talk show History singing competition spinoff USA award winner tv talk comic space Film Festival Polls and Games