Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Act of Valor Misses the Mark

Plus, Wanderlust is inspired wackiness, and guess the Tomatometers for Tyler Perry's Good Deeds and Gone.

by | February 23, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got real American heroes (Act of Valor, starring Roselyn Sanchez and Alex Veadov), a wacky commune (Wanderlust, starring Jennifer Aniston and Paul Rudd), a soul-sick businessman (Tyler Perry’s Good Deeds, starring Tyler Perry and Thandie Newton), and a mysterious disappearance (Gone, starring Amanda Seyfried and Daniel Sunjata). What do the critics have to say?

Act of Valor


Act of Valor is a fictionalized action film featuring real-life Navy SEALs, but critics say it’s not a particularly good one; it’s an over-adrenalized series of (literally) explosive set-pieces that never finds the humanity within these heroes. The film follows our most elite soldiers on a secret, globe-trotting mission to neutralize a terrorist threat; along the way, we learn a little about how the SEALs go about their business. No one can doubt the bravery and sacrifice of the Navy SEALs, but the pundits say the Act of Valor has more in common with video games like Call of Duty — its hyperkinetic action scenes bulldoze storytelling and character development, and we’re left with an odd, unsatisfying tribute to a group of patriots who deserve better.



If a movie simply makes us laugh, we’re likely to overlook its faults. Such is the case with Wanderlust — critics say this zany fish-out-of-water comedy isn’t the most disciplined film in the world, but it’s warm and often inspired in its absurdity. Facing financial ruin, George (Paul Rudd) and his wife Linda (Jennifer Aniston) leave the comfy environs of Manhattan to live with his brother in Atlanta. On the way, however, they stumble upon a commune and decide they kinda like it; ribald hilarity ensues. The pundits say Wanderlust isn’t much more than the sum of its parts, but those parts are often very funny, as the game cast works together to create moments of genuine lunacy.

Tyler Perry’s Good Deeds


As is often the case with Tyler Perry‘s films, Good Deeds was not screened for critics prior to its release. Perry stars as Wesley Deeds, a successful but dissatisfied businessman who snaps out of his rut after befriending Lindsey (Thandie Newton), an unlucky single mom who works in his building. Time to guess that Tomatometer!



It appears the people behind Gone feared that critics wouldn’t go along with their movie, since it didn’t screen before hitting theaters. Amanda Seyfried stars as Jill, who once escaped a kidnapping attempt. But now that her sister has been abducted, she suspects a serial killer is behind the crimes. Once again, guess the Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Fairy, a Belgian comedy about a young woman who claims she can grant wishes, is at 100 percent.
  • The Forgiveness of Blood, a drama about a young man who’s caught in the middle of a blood feud between families in his small town, is at 83 percent.
  • Tomorrow, When the War Began, a thriller about a group of Australian teens who must defend their homeland against a surprise invasion, is at 64 percent.

Tag Cloud

blaxploitation Premiere Dates Heroines romance Musicals cults Elton John DC Comics Syfy FX Song of Ice and Fire CBS All Access space Ellie Kemper El Rey dragons Masterpiece TLC PBS zero dark thirty mutant Toys what to watch boxoffice FOX Red Carpet CW Seed Christmas BBC TV Land social media anime Kids & Family award winner Video Games Lionsgate ESPN crime thriller SDCC 45 RT History Columbia Pictures Reality Competition science fiction Awards hist Chilling Adventures of Sabrina RT21 strong female leads Ghostbusters Trophy Talk docudrama VH1 Polls and Games Rom-Com Teen Superheroes justice league X-Men adventure Mary poppins Amazon Tarantino Writers Guild of America Disney TIFF Logo sequel Paramount 2019 Reality Infographic TCA Comics on TV ABC Mindy Kaling Awards Tour 2015 YouTube Red Showtime true crime Rocky based on movie GoT Box Office PaleyFest Paramount Network Emmys 20th Century Fox police drama The CW Interview APB Calendar Marvel Universal Mystery transformers Nickelodeon BET Ovation NBC Black Mirror Year in Review Rocketman dramedy IFC Films E! diversity Star Trek Extras richard e. Grant Anna Paquin disaster festivals Pop aliens Tumblr GLAAD Cannes Drama Netflix Action A&E Mary Tyler Moore comic Winter TV San Diego Comic-Con Sneak Peek WGN Esquire DGA The Arrangement OWN Thanksgiving Warner Bros. casting Amazon Prime finale Super Bowl CNN Epix Freeform cooking politics Country cops 007 Pirates Rock VICE crime drama war Nominations NYCC Election Captain marvel Lucasfilm mockumentary The Witch Comic Book teaser Brie Larson witnail YA New York Comic Con talk show Marathons Star Wars Shondaland Superheroe psychological thriller Tomatazos Creative Arts Emmys crossover Oscars Quiz adaptation Apple Holidays American Society of Cinematographers Bravo Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Photos spy thriller DC Universe Trivia green book 21st Century Fox E3 Acorn TV Britbox crime thriller vampires AMC Set visit doctor who DirecTV Countdown Starz comiccon Lifetime Sundance USA binge TCA 2017 2017 facebook supernatural Hulu TV MSNBC HBO TruTV Pixar Valentine's Day natural history Cartoon Network zombie biography zombies Sundance Now USA Network 2016 TCM dceu Shudder 2018 Food Network 24 frames historical drama jamie lee curtis See It Skip It Fox News Horror theme song Podcast Best and Worst Watching Series harry potter Trailer Biopics MCU Spectrum Originals Fall TV political drama BBC America technology Spike sports Music Crackle composers Winners Summer cats Musical psycho TNT Dark Horse Comics Martial Arts DC streaming service TBS Stephen King Vudu anthology Sony Pictures Film Festival GIFs National Geographic discovery Opinion miniseries ratings YouTube Premium Spring TV singing competition Women's History Month robots Walt Disney Pictures Mudbound Schedule nature Western television medical drama President travel Adult Swim Nat Geo Cosplay CMT period drama dc Sci-Fi SXSW Pet Sematary cinemax SundanceTV First Look CBS golden globes Fantasy History Disney Channel elevated horror ITV Certified Fresh Comedy Central IFC Grammys unscripted spider-man streaming Mary Poppins Returns Comedy sitcom Character Guide Animation serial killer MTV FXX LGBTQ ABC Family