Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Hostel" Worth A Stay, "Casanova" Getting No Love

by | January 5, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a bunch of madmen ("Hostel"), a notorious lover ("Casanova"), a dhampir ("BloodRayne"), and a dude who lives with his grandma ("Grandma’s Boy"). Which of these movies will score with critics?

It’s a story that’s been told a thousand times: a group of young people stray off the beaten path, only to fall into the clutches of bloodthirsty crazies who inflicts torture upon them with sadistic glee. Heck, it was told a couple weeks ago ("Wolf Creek"). So what? Sometimes it’s how you tell it, and the critics say "Hostel" is told very well. Yes, scribes say, Eli Roth‘s film is grisly, but it’s also terrifyingly exciting and makes for some incisive social commentary. At 88 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Hostel" may be worth a stay, if you like this sort of thing.

Giacomo Casanova was the world’s greatest lover, a man of endless appetites who led an impossibly colorful life (which was probably embellished in his autobiography, but is a classic nonetheless). So you couldn’t go wrong with a movie about the notable rake, right? Right? Well, the critics say this period comedy romp, starring Heath Ledger and Sienna Miller, isn’t quite as romping as it should be, and despite noteworthy visuals, the film is frothy without being particularly ribald. Worse, the man whose name is synonymous with cad-dom chooses monogamy! At 41 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Casanova" is getting no love.

The people behind both "BloodRayne" and "Grandma’s Boy" must have made a new year’s resolution to not screen their films for critics. Here at Rotten Tomatoes, we feel it’s admirable to stick to your guns, when so many of us end up breaking our resolutions almost immediately. Unfortunately, the strategy sends a message to the world that perhaps these movies aren’t very good.

Recent Heath Ledger Movies
88% — Brokeback Mountain (2005)
67% — Two Hands (2005)
39% — The Brothers Grimm (2005)
53% — Lords of Dogtown (2005)
54% — Ned Kelly (2004)

Tag Cloud

Dark Horse Comics south america Broadway game of thrones CNN canceled zombies archives CMT Pirates scorecard Comedy Central documentaries technology Disney streaming service target 007 Thanksgiving cats YouTube Premium Sundance Cartoon Network Box Office directors PBS 20th Century Fox 2016 adenture suspense werewolf Amazon Prime halloween tv Infographic independent reboot new york Fox Searchlight news Rocky TBS 90s revenge medical drama japanese video on demand films police drama tv talk dramedy GoT venice cancelled television Country First Reviews CBS The Walking Dead Apple name the review crossover period drama politics Tomatazos Disney Plus criterion miniseries TV renewals TNT ABC Signature indiana jones TV movies Fantasy adaptation President dceu international X-Men Shudder DC Comics Columbia Pictures Red Carpet BET VOD New York Comic Con Pop TV Showtime Holidays anime Pop spinoff worst cops Funimation strong female leads trailers james bond die hard Tumblr CBS All Access joker kaiju psychological thriller richard e. Grant TCM Nickelodeon Legendary book based on movie children's TV The Purge sports nfl Star Wars Martial Arts Kids & Family pirates of the caribbean Elton John razzies Interview fresh political drama Esquire rotten zero dark thirty Mystery justice league rotten movies we love ABC TCA Winter 2020 Cannes TV Land Toys cartoon television DGA emmy awards franchise Exclusive Video boxoffice Sundance Now green book serial killer ESPN BBC Trivia latino comiccon 2015 Drama Year in Review MTV Sony Pictures stoner DirecTV supernatural screen actors guild 45 CW Seed theme song Logo Epix football Amazon Reality Competition HBO Disney+ Disney Plus romantic comedy Mary poppins Musical space critics Marvel Studios dogs TLC Vudu doctor who Watching Series composers Best and Worst live action Biopics series IFC Films OneApp Hear Us Out The CW SundanceTV french Food Network lord of the rings Mary Tyler Moore Disney Channel Captain marvel docudrama saw superman mission: impossible 93rd Oscars golden globe awards PlayStation social media casting Apple TV Plus See It Skip It Academy Awards fast and furious toronto Bravo Comedy RT21 Podcast movie Paramount Plus documentary Television Critics Association San Diego Comic-Con Classic Film Black Mirror Pixar elevated horror olympics Starz hollywood DC Universe slashers superhero 72 Emmy Awards biography telelvision Reality blockbuster parents TruTV Family deadpool WarnerMedia Tubi singing competition true crime kong Television Academy historical drama animated VICE Comic Book festival 21st Century Fox movies nature 2019 blaxploitation adventure GLAAD American Society of Cinematographers Turner Classic Movies Winter TV rt archives A&E all-time Superheroes NYCC Amazon Prime Video streaming movies FOX Valentine's Day Paramount Network crime drama Nominations 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Adult Swim universal monsters Writers Guild of America LGBTQ binge PaleyFest Certified Fresh classics Western The Academy Pacific Islander high school legend comic scary movies FX best comics E3 YA RT History robots Pride Month Teen spider-man reviews comic books travel video toy story mutant A24 book adaptation a nightmare on elm street marvel cinematic universe Polls and Games Ellie Kemper game show Spike Extras Quiz Lifetime Christmas movies Musicals Trophy Talk dark Star Trek comedies Sneak Peek Avengers quibi finale 4/20 streaming 2020 Apple TV+ cars ABC Family teaser The Walt Disney Company science fiction Song of Ice and Fire romance cancelled chucky crime thriller Chilling Adventures of Sabrina prank 2021 Rock harry potter Pet Sematary Masterpiece zombie 1990s king arthur TCA Awards italian Turner Marvel Television award winner christmas movies screenings Comic-Con@Home 2021 Emmys APB halloween aapi wonder woman Tarantino stop motion hispanic boxing spain Sci-Fi Nat Geo unscripted Stephen King sag awards WGN Schedule Crackle Women's History Month Superheroe blockbusters Syfy satire Image Comics Hulu DC streaming service Awards 71st Emmy Awards natural history Film Travel Channel canceled TV shows Character Guide witnail Creative Arts Emmys Winners versus free movies transformers dc Sundance TV Paramount TV Cosplay 24 frames worst movies Britbox Universal basketball Film Festival Freeform Peacock AMC Disney Walt Disney Pictures FX on Hulu NBA rom-coms YouTube Mudbound discovery Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Trailer Hallmark Crunchyroll what to watch Calendar Summer monster movies Marvel Comics on TV E! Amazon Studios japan Alien Chernobyl VH1 National Geographic El Rey Ovation diversity dragons jurassic park Shondaland Ghostbusters OWN laika cults GIFs heist movie Premiere Dates talk show scene in color Holiday Video Games Emmy Nominations BBC One vampires Fall TV festivals BET Awards spy thriller Black History Month breaking bad Discovery Channel kids Warner Bros. docuseries Oscars golden globes Arrowverse know your critic USA Network Mary Poppins Returns Grammys FXX Lucasfilm USA The Witch jamie lee curtis Opinion aliens HBO Go spanish Mindy Kaling child's play mockumentary Lionsgate sequels black renewed TV shows Election disaster History 99% ITV indie cooking TCA foreign Wes Anderson Spectrum Originals hidden camera Awards Tour Countdown australia Photos Tokyo Olympics TCA 2017 twilight psycho Netflix Christmas movies The Arrangement women asian-american LGBT ViacomCBS sequel stand-up comedy NBC cancelled TV series obituary war Music Heroines Rom-Com SXSW Brie Larson cinemax YouTube Red king kong ratings crime godzilla Spring TV nbcuniversal new zealand thriller TIFF Animation facebook cancelled TV shows Horror First Look hist new star wars movies Fox News BAFTA Rocketman MCU anthology spanish language Endgame BBC America MSNBC Baby Yoda 2017 Lifetime SDCC sitcom HBO Max Netflix Acorn TV TV One Hallmark Christmas movies IFC Binge Guide remakes Set visit ghosts Action Marathons ID Christmas concert popular Anna Paquin 2018 batman Super Bowl