Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Evan Almighty" Is All Wet; "1408" Is Worth A Visit; Jolie Shines In "A Mighty Heart"

by | June 21, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Steve Carell and Morgan Freeman in the big-budget Bible comedy "Evan Almighty"; John Cusack and Samuel L. Jackson in the haunted house thriller "1408"; and Angelina Jolie in "A Mighty Heart," based on the memoir by reporter Daniel Pearl’s widow. What do the critics have to say?

At a budget in the ballpark of $175 million, "Evan Almighty" is said to be the most expensive comedy ever made. But judging from the critical reaction thus far, the filmmakers would have been wise to check out the Book of Proverbs: "Do not wear yourself out to get rich; have the wisdom to show restraint." A spinoff from the 2003 Jim Carrey vehicle "Bruce Almighty," Steve Carell stars as Evan, a TV anchor-turned-congressman who is told by the Lord (an aptly cast Morgan Freeman) to build an ark, much to the befuddlement of his family and constituents. Carell is one of the funniest men on the planet, but critics say that in "Evan" he’s mostly reduced to mugging, overwhelmed by costly but mediocre special effects. Pundits also note the scatological humor is a little extensive for a family film, and the usually dependable Freeman and Wanda Sykes are underutilized. At 22 percent on the Tomatometer, "Evan" is out to sea; it’s not even up to "Bruce Almighty"’s 49 percent standard.

When it comes to ark-building, Evan can’t wait.

For those of you out there who dig horror movies but prefer spooky atmosphere and suspense to buckets of blood, you’re in luck. In "1408," John Cusack plays a troubled writer who’s made a career of debunking the supernatural; for his latest, he sets out to spend one night each in 10 "haunted" hotel rooms. Bad idea, says Samuel L. Jackson, who plays the manager of the notorious Dolphin Hotel, since no one has survived the curse of room 1408. Pundits say the film, based upon a story by Stephen King, is an old-school chiller in the best possible way, featuring effective scares and outstanding performances from Cusack and Jackson. At 88 percent on the Tomatometer, "1408" is one hot little number.

"Hello, turndown? I am definitely disturbed right now."

Lost in the tabloid hubbub surrounding Angelina Jolie is the fact that she’s never less than an interesting actress. Playing Mariane Pearl, wife of the slain Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl, critics say she’s at the top of her game. Based upon Mariane Pearl’s book of the same name, "A Mighty Heart" recounts the frantic search for her husband following his capture at the hands of militants in Pakistan. Pundits say director Michael Winterbottom has crafted a sharp, worthy film about a difficult subject, and Jolie conveys the full emotional range of a woman in a desperate situation. At 78 percent on the Tomatometer, "Heart" is mighty, indeed. (Check out RT’s interview with Winterbottom here.)

A rare peaceful moment from "A Mighty Heart."

Also opening this week in limited release: "White Palms," a heartfelt drama about the conflict between a star gymnast and his coach, is at 100 percent; "Sicko," Micahel Moore’s polemic on the American health care system, is at 88 percent on the Tomatometer (check out RT’s review from Cannes); "Colma: The Musical," a low-budget, well-sung tribute to the San Francisco suburb, is at 88 percent; "Black Sheep," a grisly horror/comedy about a bunch of rabid rams and ewes, is at 83 percent; the German import "Longing," a delicate chamber drama, is at 78 percent; "Lady Chatterley," a lyrical take on D.H. Lawrence’s erotic classic, is at 77 percent; "You Kill Me," a comedy about contract killers starring Ben Kingsley and Tea Leoni, is at 76 percent; and "Broken English," a drama about a young woman looking for love starring Parker Posey, is at 56 percent (check out RT’s review from Sundance).

"…Ever watch ‘Before Sunset?’"

Recent Steve Carell Movies:
73% — Over the Hedge (2006)
92% — Little Miss Sunshine (2006)
83% — The 40-Year-Old Virgin (2005)
24% — Bewitched (2005)
51% — Melinda and Melinda (2005)

Recent Angelina Jolie Movies:
56% — The Good Shepherd (2006)
59% — Mr. and Mrs. Smith (2005)
16% — Alexander (2004)
34% — Shark Tale (2004)
74% — Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow (2004)

Recent John Cusack Movies:
71% — Grace is Gone (2007)
45% — The Ice Harvest (2005)
36% — Must Love Dogs (2005)
72% — Runaway Jury (2003)
63% — Identity (2003)

Tag Cloud

TV Trophy Talk natural history toronto Set visit Apple doctor who The Witch spanish X-Men black miniseries comics robots Countdown Image Comics Universal Bravo finale reviews telelvision SXSW San Diego Comic-Con Fox Searchlight TruTV Election critics nbcuniversal screenings Binge Guide Thanksgiving Kids & Family golden globes Watching Series cats 45 Awards Tour Trailer The CW festival Sundance Now Disney Channel TIFF mockumentary RT History DC streaming service slashers WarnerMedia Lucasfilm Endgame Amazon Studios anthology docudrama Interview 2016 The Walking Dead Sony Pictures venice romantic comedy Freeform nature strong female leads james bond Paramount Network Mystery TV One vampires classics australia Writers Guild of America RT21 mission: impossible sag awards Super Bowl Netflix 20th Century Fox FOX cults Horror Christmas Tomatazos The Purge cars crime drama new york dc PaleyFest indiana jones archives ABC El Rey what to watch Walt Disney Pictures Shondaland dceu technology Baby Yoda Teen Western space Premiere Dates Stephen King green book The Arrangement Musicals Mudbound Elton John Rom-Com video on demand FX GoT anime TCA Awards Tarantino VOD Pacific Islander psychological thriller Academy Awards Pirates Funimation worst movies Crunchyroll sports remakes television period drama 4/20 criterion best movie spider-man Hulu Holidays independent BBC FXX prank MTV A&E HBO Peacock Music Britbox streaming movies Cannes DGA kids E3 Anna Paquin TCA Winter 2020 The Academy Chernobyl Extras dramedy fast and furious Year in Review crime thriller discovery worst Esquire Pop rt archives Black Mirror DC Comics comedies Star Trek TV renewals stoner LGBT true crime DirecTV DC Universe foreign hollywood Infographic news Ovation Hallmark Christmas movies Fox News Television Critics Association Star Wars Sneak Peek hispanic Pet Sematary target Comics on TV Podcast spinoff free movies Reality screen actors guild festivals 21st Century Fox FX on Hulu scorecard cartoon Rock toy story Spike Martial Arts book adaptation Black History Month biography Tumblr Television Academy Superheroe zero dark thirty based on movie satire latino dogs twilight laika monster movies kong football ID documentary First Look Comedy Central harry potter Pop TV TNT Cartoon Network President universal monsters YA Acorn TV The Walt Disney Company parents Marvel Studios BET Mary Tyler Moore christmas movies Film Festival Biopics politics Mary poppins OWN Columbia Pictures BBC One book canceled TV shows Crackle Best and Worst blockbuster Spring TV saw Avengers die hard Country cooking CBS historical drama ESPN Creative Arts Emmys marvel cinematic universe zombie south america hidden camera police drama women Emmys ITV Shudder supernatural Logo halloween Disney streaming service TBS political drama Amazon Prime Video cancelled TV shows batman franchise lord of the rings Song of Ice and Fire Disney+ Disney Plus Marvel Television Rocketman Marathons Nickelodeon psycho YouTube Masterpiece streaming Syfy Dark Horse Comics Awards Comic Book king kong American Society of Cinematographers Heroines reboot Superheroes romance Animation Broadway Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Lifetime Classic Film OneApp Legendary APB 99% teaser high school Reality Competition Oscars Trivia Apple TV Plus Hallmark 2018 Showtime Ellie Kemper Grammys travel Box Office See It Skip It Musical comiccon BAFTA scene in color Winter TV live action BET Awards asian-american sequel Cosplay 24 frames Drama Hear Us Out CNN stand-up comedy 93rd Oscars 2020 National Geographic LGBTQ Amazon IFC rotten blaxploitation Ghostbusters popular disaster Tubi unscripted hist godzilla facebook composers PBS HBO Go TCM indie Opinion Disney Plus richard e. Grant Holiday french heist movie sitcom Lifetime Christmas movies Paramount Certified Fresh mutant science fiction Schedule Amazon Prime talk show emmy awards sequels HBO Max Travel Channel Marvel jurassic park new star wars movies chucky Alien SDCC Apple TV+ japanese 71st Emmy Awards VICE 2019 know your critic TCA 2017 Summer binge Photos superman rom-coms Warner Bros. halloween tv directors NYCC diversity Exclusive Video game show Spectrum Originals spanish language Fantasy zombies Brie Larson CBS All Access cops GLAAD cancelled TV series Mindy Kaling Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt razzies game of thrones PlayStation Vudu crossover war TV Land elevated horror nfl Toys movies MSNBC Epix video ABC Family Family Film medical drama Arrowverse Paramount Plus Lionsgate Nominations ABC Signature YouTube Premium Captain marvel 2021 Food Network dragons docuseries rotten movies we love theme song social media pirates of the caribbean international animated renewed TV shows History Adult Swim spy thriller documentaries TLC comic books Fall TV trailers A24 all-time obituary award winner Action 72 Emmy Awards aliens Video Games comic ghosts blockbusters versus thriller NBC children's TV deadpool kaiju WGN Quiz BBC America child's play a nightmare on elm street Nat Geo golden globe awards ratings Comedy transformers stop motion TV movies Red Carpet 2017 Starz fresh Sundance Mary Poppins Returns GIFs First Reviews ViacomCBS werewolf cancelled television scary movies YouTube Red Emmy Nominations Sci-Fi tv talk Netflix Christmas movies series CW Seed Rocky canceled name the review revenge films singing competition Disney adaptation Polls and Games crime casting IFC Films E! Turner Pixar witnail boxing concert adventure Sundance TV Calendar superhero spain Character Guide 2015 Winners cancelled Women's History Month justice league breaking bad TCA aapi serial killer VH1 italian CMT USA Network Pride Month Valentine's Day 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 007 quibi joker SundanceTV USA Discovery Channel jamie lee curtis cinemax New York Comic Con AMC boxoffice new zealand dark MCU Turner Classic Movies