The Best and Worst Reviewed Television Series of 2018 by Network and Streaming Service

NBC's The Good Place had a 100% score with the highest number of reviews. Netflix scored a big hit with Dear White People, but also a big miss with Insatiable, while BBC America's best and worst are both Certified Fresh.

by | December 28, 2018 | Comments

We had a look back at the year that was to see which network or streaming service had the best year and which had the worst, looking at their highest- and lowest-scoring series that received Tomatometer scores. From well-loved and award-nominated to yawn-inducing and cringe-worthy, the titles on our list have either entertained or dismayed TV fans all year. To compile the list, we compared the Tomatometer scores of the most recent seasons and the number of reviews for each title.

Some networks are so on-point that both their best and worst series are Fresh — some even Certified Fresh, like BBC America’s Killing Eve and Doctor Who. While Netflix’s top series was Certified Fresh at 100%, the streaming giant also had the series with the lowest score. CBS had the worst year overall by Tomatometer, with its top title, season 1 of Young Sheldon (which ended in May 2018), scoring a modest 76% and its lowest scoring title this year, Living Biblically, in second-to-last place and receiving only 18%. (Season 2 of Young Sheldon kicked off in September and continues into 2019, but has not yet received a score.)

In order to qualify, a show’s 2018 season had to have at least 10 reviews; a few exceptions, however, are Claws, Portlandia, and Mr. Mercedes, which were included for comparison with their “best” or “worst” counterparts on each respective network that did qualify (that is, The Alienist, Brockmire, and Condor).

The lowest-rated series on the list is Netflix’s Insatiable, which is Rotten at 12% with 50 reviews. The highest-rated are NBC’s The Good Place, which is Certified Fresh at 100% with 38 reviews, followed closely by YouTube’s Cobra Kai, which is also Certified Fresh at 100%, but with 36 reviews.

Check out the full list of the best and worst by network below.

Also read:Every Certified Fresh TV Season of 2018

Scores as of December 20, 2018.

ABC, Acorn, Amazon, AMC, Audience, BBC America, CBS, CBS All Access, Comedy Central, CW, FOX, Freeform, FX, HBO, Hulu, IFC, Lifetime, NBC, Netflix, Paramount Network, PBS, Showtime, Starz, Syfy, TBS, TNT, USA, YouTube Premium

ABC: How to Get Away with Murder | Splitting Up Together
Acorn: Mystery Road | Girlfriends
Amazon: Homecoming | The Romanoffs
AMC: Better Call Saul | McMafia
Audience: Mr Mercedes | Condor
BBC America: Killing Eve | Doctor Who
CBS: Young Sheldon | Living Biblically
CBS All Access: The Good Fight | Tell Me a Story
Comedy Central: Corporate | South Park
CW: Black Lightning | Life Sentence
FOX: The X-Files | Rel
Freeform: The Bold Type | Alone Together
FX: Atlanta | Archer
HBO: Barry | Here and Now
Hulu: The Looming Tower | Into the Dark
IFC: Brockmire | Portlandia
Lifetime: UnReal | You
NBC: The Good Place | I Feel Bad
Netflix: Dear White People | Insatiable
Paramount Network: Rest in Power: The Trayvon Martin Story | Heathers
PBS: Endeavour | The Miniaturist
Showtime: Billions | Our Cartoon President
Starz: Vida | Sweetbitter
Syfy: The Magicians | Nightflyers
TBS: The Last O.G. | Final Space
TNT: Claws | The Alienist
USA: The Sinner | The Purge
YouTube Premium: Cobra Kai | Origin

Tag Cloud

Binge Guide mutant OneApp cancelled Sci-Fi comic TCA blaxploitation blockbuster APB book adaptation TV Land Calendar adventure political drama new star wars movies Comedy Central emmy awards NBC PBS witnail know your critic 2017 saw dc streaming movies Sneak Peek free movies directors deadpool series Schedule Netflix Christmas movies The Witch strong female leads royal family TNT Rom-Com screen actors guild Syfy Fox Searchlight name the review Oscar 24 frames Red Carpet spy thriller sopranos elevated horror Lionsgate AMC MCU Cosplay vampires YA Tags: Comedy harry potter asian-american 94th Oscars latino Bravo summer preview Comic Book BBC America dark HBO sequel new zealand Rocky Horror news movies crime thriller A&E Heroines Disney+ Disney Plus golden globe awards Mindy Kaling vs. rt labs critics edition TCM Elton John hollywood TV One mob Disney science fiction Showtime tv talk History 20th Century Fox Discovery Channel streamig Black Mirror versus revenge sequels GIFs live event Marvel Studios Best Actor E! X-Men Stephen King Reality Competition Martial Arts FOX black 2020 golden globes game of thrones kids theme song rt labs Apple TV Plus classics Music justice league Sundance Now binge psychological thriller Anna Paquin Baby Yoda festivals Winners ABC Signature CNN YouTube Red wonder woman Western slasher Pet Sematary critics Arrowverse popular natural history Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt debate Box Office Countdown crossover Turner Classic Movies superman Mary poppins YouTube The Walking Dead HFPA historical drama cinemax remakes Pirates 90s Podcast thriller composers Turner halloween worst movies DGA transformers art house Interview Pixar Broadway ViacomCBS quibi parents finale child's play romance Women's History Month Toys king arthur FX Tarantino YouTube Premium sitcom sports Emmy Nominations Photos DC Universe Sundance Pacific Islander black comedy live action mockumentary Epix biography Best Director Classic Film Pop TV Reality TV renewals FXX summer TV preview worst ABC Family 21st Century Fox TCA Awards Awards Tour indie new york space trophy MGM Best Picture discovery scary movies canceled Trophy Talk leaderboard police drama criterion twilight supernatural Valentine's Day 007 Black History Month Fox News Video Games PlayStation Extras Hollywood Foreign Press Association feel good IFC marvel comics Biopics king kong target spider-verse Adult Swim joker Freeform universal monsters dramedy Kids & Family South by Southwest Film Festival legend french Legendary award winner Film Festival Spectrum Originals Amazon Prime Video Ovation comic book movie 4/20 99% Shudder action-comedy Captain marvel spider-man MSNBC NYCC Super Bowl RT21 crime spain Rocketman biopic Acorn TV Nickelodeon Mudbound telelvision Paramount Plus streaming cooking Star Wars war El Rey hist USA The CW werewolf cartoon screenings E3 comics nbcuniversal fast and furious game show crime drama lord of the rings ABC Film spanish First Look 93rd Oscars documentaries fresh foreign broadcast kaiju technology Avengers Marvel Television Sundance TV heist movie Best Actress Hallmark Christmas movies Ghostbusters Instagram Live Travel Channel Lifetime Christmas movies Logo diversity international Exclusive Video Funimation kong Image Comics Netflix jamie lee curtis AMC Plus Hulu Tubi DC Comics Brie Larson Disney streaming service Emmys 79th Golden Globes Awards BET Awards critic resources Quiz Oscars Best and Worst VH1 franchise satire WGN Musicals cancelled TV shows suspense documentary cancelled TV series Crunchyroll superhero concert monster movies scary Chernobyl comic books docudrama Focus Features Endgame aapi Holiday Comedy films Comics on TV italian 72 Emmy Awards First Reviews Trailer DirecTV social media rotten Universal Pictures Food Network serial killer Teen dceu Set visit reviews Summer aliens TCA 2017 Universal independent SundanceTV 73rd Emmy Awards HBO Go Paramount Network HBO Max comic book movies Action summer TV Fargo Starz best talk show romantic comedy renewed TV shows ghosts Lifetime Pop zombies TV 2016 interviews genre dragons ESPN Comic-Con@Home 2021 Premiere Dates cancelled television Family Character Guide USA Network Disney Channel comedies Amazon festival National Geographic cults obituary robots mcc Vudu Ellie Kemper VICE razzies Hear Us Out A24 die hard psycho pirates of the caribbean Disney Plus hispanic spanish language Election 1990s sag awards TBS rom-coms See It Skip It Spring TV Wes Anderson Pride Month Drama Lucasfilm spinoff Nat Geo travel Marathons BBC docuseries children's TV batman doctor who Awards cops Sony Pictures anime book Christmas Spike TV movies Opinion Esquire Trivia IMDb TV Apple TV+ 2021 godzilla Paramount hispanic heritage month Musical Television Critics Association Cannes mission: impossible Television Academy football teaser zero dark thirty The Arrangement Creative Arts Emmys what to watch animated cars all-time breaking bad archives women Masterpiece The Purge 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards unscripted high school laika Star Trek toronto GLAAD dreamworks nature adenture based on movie Britbox 2018 CMT Apple Columbia Pictures LGBT NBA south america Fall TV TruTV BBC One obi wan 2015 gangster Superheroe Nominations posters dexter Watching Series halloween tv rotten movies we love nfl Country japan true crime medical drama casting anthology cats green book Infographic TLC Polls and Games christmas movies MTV CBS All Access Rock The Academy miniseries FX on Hulu trailers GoT SXSW richard e. Grant japanese jurassic park RT History Superheroes IFC Films The Walt Disney Company Tomatazos video on demand olympics ratings SXSW 2022 boxing Grammys Tokyo Olympics canceled TV shows boxoffice Dark Horse Comics television chucky New York Comic Con basketball Shondaland LGBTQ stand-up comedy Neflix Certified Fresh Alien OWN Crackle 71st Emmy Awards CBS reboot DC streaming service Mystery stop motion scorecard facebook Paramount Pictures Tumblr politics video Holidays Academy Awards blockbusters venice Mary Poppins Returns PaleyFest Warner Bros. 45 American Society of Cinematographers CW Seed toy story Song of Ice and Fire james bond comiccon scene in color indiana jones Cartoon Network australia young adult a nightmare on elm street Chilling Adventures of Sabrina prank dogs Amazon Studios Walt Disney Pictures Marvel Thanksgiving period drama singing competition disaster zombie movie Fantasy 2019 Winter TV WarnerMedia San Diego Comic-Con Animation slashers Mary Tyler Moore Writers Guild of America ID SDCC TCA Winter 2020 Peacock VOD Amazon Prime BAFTA BET marvel cinematic universe rt archives stoner Prime Video ITV Hallmark President TIFF Year in Review adaptation hidden camera