The Best and Worst Reviewed Television Series of 2018 by Network and Streaming Service

NBC's The Good Place had a 100% score with the highest number of reviews. Netflix scored a big hit with Dear White People, but also a big miss with Insatiable, while BBC America's best and worst are both Certified Fresh.

by | December 28, 2018 | Comments

We had a look back at the year that was to see which network or streaming service had the best year and which had the worst, looking at their highest- and lowest-scoring series that received Tomatometer scores. From well-loved and award-nominated to yawn-inducing and cringe-worthy, the titles on our list have either entertained or dismayed TV fans all year. To compile the list, we compared the Tomatometer scores of the most recent seasons and the number of reviews for each title.

Some networks are so on-point that both their best and worst series are Fresh — some even Certified Fresh, like BBC America’s Killing Eve and Doctor Who. While Netflix’s top series was Certified Fresh at 100%, the streaming giant also had the series with the lowest score. CBS had the worst year overall by Tomatometer, with its top title, season 1 of Young Sheldon (which ended in May 2018), scoring a modest 76% and its lowest scoring title this year, Living Biblically, in second-to-last place and receiving only 18%. (Season 2 of Young Sheldon kicked off in September and continues into 2019, but has not yet received a score.)

In order to qualify, a show’s 2018 season had to have at least 10 reviews; a few exceptions, however, are Claws, Portlandia, and Mr. Mercedes, which were included for comparison with their “best” or “worst” counterparts on each respective network that did qualify (that is, The Alienist, Brockmire, and Condor).

The lowest-rated series on the list is Netflix’s Insatiable, which is Rotten at 12% with 50 reviews. The highest-rated are NBC’s The Good Place, which is Certified Fresh at 100% with 38 reviews, followed closely by YouTube’s Cobra Kai, which is also Certified Fresh at 100%, but with 36 reviews.

Check out the full list of the best and worst by network below.

Also read:Every Certified Fresh TV Season of 2018

Scores as of December 20, 2018.

ABC, Acorn, Amazon, AMC, Audience, BBC America, CBS, CBS All Access, Comedy Central, CW, FOX, Freeform, FX, HBO, Hulu, IFC, Lifetime, NBC, Netflix, Paramount Network, PBS, Showtime, Starz, Syfy, TBS, TNT, USA, YouTube Premium

ABC: How to Get Away with Murder | Splitting Up Together
Acorn: Mystery Road | Girlfriends
Amazon: Homecoming | The Romanoffs
AMC: Better Call Saul | McMafia
Audience: Mr Mercedes | Condor
BBC America: Killing Eve | Doctor Who
CBS: Young Sheldon | Living Biblically
CBS All Access: The Good Fight | Tell Me a Story
Comedy Central: Corporate | South Park
CW: Black Lightning | Life Sentence
FOX: The X-Files | Rel
Freeform: The Bold Type | Alone Together
FX: Atlanta | Archer
HBO: Barry | Here and Now
Hulu: The Looming Tower | Into the Dark
IFC: Brockmire | Portlandia
Lifetime: UnReal | You
NBC: The Good Place | I Feel Bad
Netflix: Dear White People | Insatiable
Paramount Network: Rest in Power: The Trayvon Martin Story | Heathers
PBS: Endeavour | The Miniaturist
Showtime: Billions | Our Cartoon President
Starz: Vida | Sweetbitter
Syfy: The Magicians | Nightflyers
TBS: The Last O.G. | Final Space
TNT: Claws | The Alienist
USA: The Sinner | The Purge
YouTube Premium: Cobra Kai | Origin

Tag Cloud

BET Awards Trivia Sony Pictures Fall TV talk show asian-american Pride Month prank Sundance TV VICE A&E USA Women's History Month Certified Fresh new york crime drama ABC Family adaptation zombie Song of Ice and Fire finale rom-coms stand-up comedy Apple TV+ Sneak Peek Arrowverse See It Skip It supernatural 2020 sitcom MSNBC cops Tokyo Olympics movie Film 2016 science fiction Syfy romance aliens basketball documentaries GLAAD historical drama cinemax remakes 99% spy thriller australia Paramount Network Election italian Legendary know your critic comics 72 Emmy Awards Oscars TCA Awards Photos TV One game show aapi Mudbound ghosts Comic Book movies 24 frames screen actors guild deadpool spanish language critics Disney Plus Pet Sematary boxoffice Disney book adaptation unscripted composers ESPN travel mission: impossible TruTV marvel cinematic universe Character Guide ratings pirates of the caribbean ABC sports A24 trailers TV Watching Series docuseries BBC One Teen Spectrum Originals Binge Guide twilight politics criterion Hallmark Christmas movies classics Stephen King BET all-time Action cats directors Rocky Musicals San Diego Comic-Con rotten series Britbox miniseries Paramount Countdown 21st Century Fox FOX Esquire Cannes psychological thriller rotten movies we love ViacomCBS Rocketman space YouTube Red fast and furious Biopics dramedy 2019 sequels die hard The Witch indie Adult Swim fresh kaiju war SundanceTV book ABC Signature video on demand FXX ITV anime Logo Pirates HBO Max Chilling Adventures of Sabrina medical drama LGBTQ golden globe awards films TIFF halloween tv History 007 justice league GoT RT History obituary Emmys Musical Film Festival Anna Paquin Holidays DirecTV First Reviews comic books Star Wars based on movie name the review First Look Pacific Islander Nickelodeon cancelled TV shows Superheroes toy story Lifetime rt archives Television Critics Association Year in Review TCA Winter 2020 blockbusters Trailer Podcast Martial Arts President Amazon Studios DC Universe Mindy Kaling Crackle live action Disney Channel slashers CW Seed political drama The CW Best and Worst CBS All Access Vudu teaser Netflix Christmas movies joker Crunchyroll Nominations spain franchise NBC Lifetime Christmas movies emmy awards monster movies telelvision facebook Amazon diversity nature zombies National Geographic NBA batman jamie lee curtis natural history crossover OWN E! technology venice Summer AMC Classic Film WGN 45 NYCC archives TCA richard e. Grant Quiz werewolf Awards Tour satire japanese spider-man Pixar latino New York Comic Con halloween south america Spike Sundance Now Shudder Acorn TV theme song Family OneApp worst movies Hallmark CMT The Walt Disney Company scary movies cooking superhero Tubi TV Land dark YouTube PBS Pop TV Comedy Central E3 hidden camera Cosplay child's play Animation Comic-Con@Home 2021 Warner Bros. Kids & Family Infographic Interview Comedy 90s The Purge news cancelled screenings nbcuniversal Hulu DGA Rom-Com Premiere Dates universal monsters Paramount Plus Lucasfilm reboot American Society of Cinematographers high school hollywood heist movie Valentine's Day Star Trek Polls and Games french popular MCU 2021 laika zero dark thirty superman Brie Larson Marvel Studios lord of the rings Starz psycho 93rd Oscars FX on Hulu GIFs TLC kids dogs chucky canceled TV shows Thanksgiving BBC America quibi Horror 2015 Rock hist Tarantino Writers Guild of America Hear Us Out Captain marvel breaking bad foreign 20th Century Fox Wes Anderson golden globes DC Comics mutant streaming movies DC streaming service IFC Films Emmy Nominations green book Nat Geo Mary poppins 2018 saw PlayStation docudrama romantic comedy Turner Classic Movies Image Comics Discovery Channel 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards YouTube Premium Black Mirror social media Marvel Superheroe Music Fox Searchlight USA Network Christmas cancelled TV series spinoff Mary Poppins Returns international El Rey crime thriller Winter TV spanish TV renewals blaxploitation Tumblr transformers anthology doctor who SDCC Awards mockumentary black Disney streaming service FX video television independent Schedule Spring TV 2017 Cartoon Network revenge Calendar sequel Holiday RT21 what to watch a nightmare on elm street Freeform HBO HBO Go LGBT 1990s japan children's TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Amazon Prime Video Western new star wars movies cars Columbia Pictures boxing Creative Arts Emmys Trophy Talk Bravo Elton John cartoon Reality Ellie Kemper Mystery Funimation Fox News Epix Masterpiece nfl police drama Dark Horse Comics versus target witnail Country VH1 Opinion Pop thriller streaming comic Turner tv talk dc Black History Month best serial killer TCA 2017 71st Emmy Awards comiccon dragons dceu Exclusive Video james bond Set visit adenture WarnerMedia Marvel Television Apple ID Apple TV Plus Amazon Prime YA binge Academy Awards Television Academy Disney+ Disney Plus king kong Video Games stoner scorecard concert Mary Tyler Moore strong female leads Toys indiana jones free movies sag awards Heroines BBC Alien period drama APB documentary Baby Yoda cancelled television biography disaster adventure Lionsgate singing competition Box Office Endgame Universal jurassic park suspense cults Avengers 4/20 festivals VOD Sundance The Academy Red Carpet Tomatazos BAFTA Broadway reviews game of thrones Drama true crime Extras football Peacock The Arrangement SXSW Super Bowl Winners worst stop motion Shondaland Sci-Fi CBS casting Food Network CNN Netflix parents renewed TV shows award winner Travel Channel razzies godzilla olympics festival blockbuster MTV TCM Fantasy christmas movies scene in color X-Men The Walking Dead Ovation women Ghostbusters TNT harry potter hispanic comedies Comics on TV robots elevated horror Grammys Reality Competition vampires Marathons PaleyFest canceled Showtime kong IFC Walt Disney Pictures animated crime TV movies discovery Chernobyl TBS new zealand toronto