Best-Reviewed Superhero TV Shows 2018

The Marvel-versus-DC debate is as heated as ever thanks to the dozens of comic book–inspired series on television, but looking at the best-reviewed superhero shows of the year — a year that lost Marvel legend and comics industry titan Stan Lee — Marvel emerges victorious. Excelsior!

The order of the rank below reflects the Adjusted Score as of December 31, 2018. Scores might change over time.

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: The Man with No Fear returns to top form with a third season that begins tediously slow but gradually generates comic book thrills, immeasurably helped by the welcome return of Vincent D'Onofrio's menacing Kingpin.

The Flash: Season 5 (2018)
94%

#2
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: The Flash's fifth season maintains the show's high standard for compelling visuals, chilling villains, and well-scripted moments of humor, but also turns a more focused gaze on the role of family dynamics amongst the increasingly complex characters.

Legion: Season 2 (2018)
91%

#3
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Legion returns with a smart, strange second season that settles into a straighter narrative without sacrificing its unique sensibilities.

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Cloak & Dagger blends soapy drama with superhero grit to create an exciting, surprisingly thoughtful addition to the genre -- even if it falls prey to a certain amount of narrative bloat.

Titans: Season 1 (2018)
78%

#5
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Despite a few tonal growing pains, Titans does justice to its source material and truly shines when its titular ensemble finally assembles.

Tag Cloud

Paramount golden globes History Television Critics Association mob classics james bond Super Bowl hist debate Trivia latino jamie lee curtis psychological thriller biography rotten Rock movie Showtime young adult Stephen King ratings book adaptation politics japan mockumentary all-time war NBA SXSW AMC Television Academy king arthur Mary Tyler Moore vampires IMDb TV 2021 mutant Marvel Studios LGBT Photos TCA 2017 science fiction BBC One VICE rt archives Crunchyroll hispanic heritage month Teen Broadway Heroines 45 Grammys Tarantino WarnerMedia AMC Plus ABC Signature halloween sequel TCA Awards versus Quiz spider-verse streaming movies TBS Nominations nfl sopranos Reality breaking bad Tumblr TV One San Diego Comic-Con Turner Star Wars romance MTV Film Festival Disney Plus Cosplay TV movies vs. Pet Sematary social media anthology 4/20 aapi prank football MCU films BBC America Academy Awards golden globe awards TIFF rt labs cancelled TV shows archives VOD Women's History Month Peacock Black Mirror 20th Century Fox suspense screen actors guild talk show crime Superheroes Action technology Thanksgiving Fantasy theme song parents olympics godzilla Paramount Plus Musical Adult Swim American Society of Cinematographers 24 frames Certified Fresh sag awards Mindy Kaling Elton John The Purge mission: impossible series know your critic Mary poppins Red Carpet Podcast Logo space WGN Interview Emmys ID CBS 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards rom-coms GIFs Apple TV+ deadpool SundanceTV cartoon werewolf action-comedy Toys dexter Ghostbusters natural history Sci-Fi DC Comics Comics on TV fresh adenture spanish language 007 crime thriller international CNN legend australia Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Election Ovation tv talk indiana jones dc Disney streaming service transformers Disney Channel reboot king kong Christmas Ellie Kemper Starz blockbusters Fox Searchlight Universal Pictures 93rd Oscars Sneak Peek FX superhero based on movie IFC Films Cannes The CW First Look Martial Arts Video Games canceled TV shows LGBTQ superman game show Turner Classic Movies true crime stop motion TruTV political drama Trailer docuseries laika See It Skip It Apple emmy awards DC Universe casting scary movies Sundance TV disaster asian-american Shondaland FX on Hulu Comic-Con@Home 2021 Extras Cartoon Network Black History Month Avengers Lucasfilm video on demand kids diversity slasher National Geographic marvel cinematic universe 90s Biopics festivals richard e. Grant TCA Netflix Christmas movies animated spider-man Columbia Pictures discovery book Chernobyl Disney+ Disney Plus X-Men Reality Competition slashers Anna Paquin TV Land Brie Larson Hallmark Christmas movies scary dark feel good Marvel Television dramedy wonder woman television TV renewals adventure blaxploitation green book Music Spike heist movie DC streaming service El Rey Writers Guild of America harry potter critics jurassic park rotten movies we love USA Network Valentine's Day Binge Guide south america new star wars movies Infographic Neflix pirates of the caribbean Year in Review VH1 Hear Us Out E3 Mary Poppins Returns marvel comics Spectrum Originals romantic comedy cancelled television TNT CMT crime drama Sundance Now blockbuster Marvel ViacomCBS Best and Worst game of thrones boxoffice Crackle Superheroe DGA lord of the rings psycho elevated horror Sony Pictures Calendar Masterpiece Hallmark anime criterion BAFTA CW Seed 99% OWN NYCC christmas movies Image Comics TCA Winter 2020 cars zombies Warner Bros. dreamworks serial killer Pride Month dragons IFC spanish Food Network Travel Channel royal family black Esquire Marathons 71st Emmy Awards The Academy Fox News 73rd Emmy Awards Endgame franchise satire screenings Shudder spy thriller Lifetime Christmas movies Amazon Prime Video Kids & Family die hard adaptation APB Instagram Live GoT black comedy trailers The Witch 72 Emmy Awards Legendary YouTube movies SDCC Character Guide directors Mudbound Pixar Amazon Prime Comedy Film a nightmare on elm street 21st Century Fox Funimation cooking new york children's TV Opinion cults ITV Sundance canceled Comic Book Pop docudrama Lionsgate Britbox what to watch child's play Schedule A24 Walt Disney Pictures french supernatural miniseries Nickelodeon Universal toronto A&E PBS Rocketman monster movies saw Comedy Central comic Classic Film universal monsters Syfy worst movies FXX Epix Vudu BET Awards E! YouTube Premium GLAAD witnail documentaries spinoff 2019 MSNBC Captain marvel italian Exclusive Video comic book movie telelvision thriller kong ABC Family comic book movies zombie RT21 DirecTV best reviews Netflix Box Office award winner biopic Tubi singing competition new zealand target Musicals unscripted President TCM The Walt Disney Company Alien composers 2020 razzies HBO Go high school concert critic resources TV toy story chucky Holiday Family joker comedies cats fast and furious sequels HBO Max RT History HBO Drama Tomatazos Rom-Com Oscars nature Wes Anderson historical drama Horror art house ABC Song of Ice and Fire The Arrangement nbcuniversal remakes USA cancelled TV series Pirates Polls and Games facebook news video comic books live action Winter TV Arrowverse sitcom Rocky Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Fall TV cancelled rt labs critics edition finale Apple TV Plus Creative Arts Emmys basketball travel strong female leads OneApp Awards Baby Yoda Discovery Channel FOX women stand-up comedy Bravo mcc New York Comic Con documentary ghosts Amazon Spring TV Mystery obituary BET First Reviews ESPN comiccon streaming comics hollywood medical drama scorecard binge gangster twilight worst The Walking Dead cops posters Pop TV name the review police drama 2018 Country Countdown cinemax Holidays festival Disney Amazon Studios Paramount Network free movies kaiju Animation Summer 2015 Emmy Nominations Freeform Nat Geo YA Trophy Talk Winners 2016 1990s crossover zero dark thirty Dark Horse Comics Western Hulu indie hispanic live event robots scene in color doctor who japanese 2017 boxing dceu spain foreign independent halloween tv PaleyFest renewed TV shows CBS All Access PlayStation genre Lifetime BBC Star Trek quibi period drama Watching Series TLC Set visit teaser YouTube Red Premiere Dates batman revenge NBC Awards Tour Acorn TV sports popular Tokyo Olympics dogs venice hidden camera stoner justice league Pacific Islander aliens