24 Frames

24 Foreign Thrillers Vs. Their Hollywood Remakes

by | November 17, 2015 | Comments

The 2010 Best Foreign Language Film winner The Secret in Their Eyes is being remade…as Secret in Their Eyes,  a murder mystery starring Nicole Kidman, Julia Roberts, and Chiwetel Ejiofor. As Americans, we don’t need definite articles in our movie titles, but we do occasionally need help thinking up stories to shoot, prompting this week’s 24 Frames gallery of foreign thrillers versus their Hollywood counterparts.

  • Charlton

    You’ve made a mistake.

    You say both Wicker Man’s are 15%. The original is has 90% saying “This intelligent horror film is subtle in its thrills and chills, with an ending that is both shocking and truly memorable.”

    • Not to mention the photoshopped pancake on his head!!!!

      • Mpkamowski

        Not the pancake!!! =)

  • “Argentinia”
    Better take a look at an atlas before trying to write about something you’re not familiar with (other countries).

  • ConnieHinesDorothyProvine

    I usually see the originals without seeing the remakes. Insomnia and The Birdcage were rare exceptions.

    I’d like to see a foreign country remake a Hollywood movie.

    • Richter Belmont

      Try the Japanese remake of Clint Eastwood’s Unforgiven made in 2013.

    • Richter Belmont

      Check out Unforgiven (2013) starring Ken Watanabe, a Japanese remake of Eastwood’s Unforgiven (1992).

    • MontyPythonFanatic2

      That actually happens a lot. Just recently, there was a Bollywood remake of Tom Cruise’s “Knight and Day” called “Bang Bang.”

  • can’t help commenting

    I saw the original “Secret In Their Eyes” a few years ago–it was brilliant and it took its time–which I suspect the US version will fail to offer, they seem to have already altered so much of the original story.

  • badgerly

    Not a single review for Secret In Their Eyes, two days before it opens. Does not bode well. ‘No name’ reviewers in the tv blurbs are gushing, though. Europe and South America do these kinds of thrillers so much better. “Tell No One” was great.

  • Thomas

    It’s sad that the American public is so lazy and scared of subtitles that they have to remake these movies.

    • B T

      I know. At least some of us aren’t. I’m American, and I love subtitled movies as long as they are quality.

      • And sometimes, a remake (I’m using the term loosely here) of a foreign film can actually be useful in the long run. “Gojira” would have been an arthouse curiosity if it hadn’t been for “Godzilla: King of the Monsters”. Thanks to that Americanized version of the original, Toho studios realized they had a gold mine on their hands. And eventually Hideki “Godzilla” Matsui got to appear in a cameo in “Godzilla v. MechaGodzilla” (2002)…. and the original “Gojira” is now readily available…

    • Laura Fellomini

      And how do you know that the public in nearly every other industrialized nation isn’t just as ‘lazy’? See, it’s easy to make predictable, dismissive glib remarks. It can be much harder to back up such remarks when presented with the reality that it can be much the same everywhere else. Also, the public goes to see movies because of what the trailers show the film to be as far as genre and story, and because of who is in them. The public in general doesn’t care or usually even know that they are remakes.

      • The public in most of the other industrialized nations is used to watching movies with subtitles, they can’t be ‘lazy’ if they want to watch movies. Most of the other industrialized nations don’t have English as their native language, you know. Watching a movie in English with subtitles or in Spanish with subtitles is the same thing to them, but not for Americans, who are not used to watching movies with subtitles at all.

        • Laura Fellomini

          As someone who has lived abroad in other such countries, I can tell you that there are as many if not more theatres in the U.S. that show films with subtitles as there are in those other countries, as there aren’t that many shown aside from U.S. films abroad. You need to get out of the sticks and spend some time in actual cities in the U.S. And small town/village theaters/kinos in other countries do NOT show a lot of films with subtitles as the local general public prefers films from their own country. Most European countries and others such as Japan, Brazil, Canada, India, and Mexico (to name a few) make more than enough films of their own that the public there need not settle for foreign films. The U.S. blockbuster films are enormously popular worldwide, but that doesn’t mean that there aren’t people in foreign countries who avoid them on purpose.

  • MR

    12 Monkeys was good.
    The rest… well… some things are better left unsaid.

    • Tenshi Ippikiookami

      The Insomnia remake wasn’t so bad :). It’s interesting that Nicholas Cage and his hair is as ubiquitous here as in everywhere else

Tag Cloud

quibi Rocky 71st Emmy Awards psycho films Comic Book Mindy Kaling spinoff french Baby Yoda high school The Arrangement Interview NBA finale BBC One Superheroe movie Apple scene in color TCA Awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards lord of the rings MTV Amazon Studios hist harry potter australia BET Awards a nightmare on elm street justice league Trophy Talk OWN comedies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina President Family facebook nbcuniversal GLAAD popular 2020 hispanic christmas movies CBS All Access Disney Channel Netflix toy story Endgame 72 Emmy Awards HBO Shondaland Sci-Fi Action PlayStation MCU twilight Discovery Channel binge crossover festivals crime drama streaming Box Office Food Network Musicals space CNN war FX cooking Fox News Logo CBS Exclusive Video dc teaser book Warner Bros. Schedule criterion Paramount Plus Comedy Fall TV video on demand Sony Pictures Academy Awards TCA Winter 2020 TruTV cancelled Comic-Con@Home 2021 93rd Oscars cats Cosplay thriller halloween BAFTA transformers ratings remakes Cartoon Network Amazon Prime Cannes parents 2018 Turner Classic Movies Thanksgiving worst Showtime kaiju 45 Opinion Christmas police drama classics 007 ABC Signature The Witch Star Wars nfl BBC America TCM TV One SDCC Certified Fresh target Crunchyroll children's TV free movies werewolf franchise GoT NYCC San Diego Comic-Con Animation SundanceTV italian Travel Channel witnail Spike football know your critic X-Men Lucasfilm Binge Guide mutant Rom-Com spanish language sag awards game show Red Carpet Premiere Dates Classic Film Set visit jamie lee curtis Columbia Pictures streaming movies First Look spider-man cops stop motion Adult Swim Freeform worst movies YouTube Premium Sundance E3 mockumentary scary movies TNT DirecTV Photos Britbox Syfy laika Holiday halloween tv boxoffice Tarantino comic Arrowverse strong female leads Amazon Summer archives 2015 SXSW godzilla stand-up comedy black WarnerMedia Valentine's Day superman all-time movies period drama travel Film Festival chucky dceu 21st Century Fox Reality Competition Masterpiece Epix cinemax A&E blockbusters women Mudbound anthology zero dark thirty trailers FXX Television Academy spain Awards Tour 2016 WGN sequel venice Watching Series 90s based on movie king kong 1990s Elton John Tokyo Olympics social media medical drama TV dogs south america 24 frames series sports Sneak Peek Paramount Hulu adventure nature news fast and furious Pirates Winners ghosts scorecard Black History Month Hear Us Out Turner Oscars NBC talk show Esquire VH1 Drama DGA Comics on TV satire tv talk jurassic park 2019 TCA 2017 award winner romance name the review FX on Hulu Spectrum Originals Video Games crime documentary Pop TV kong YouTube Red FOX rotten latino spy thriller The Walt Disney Company Pacific Islander sitcom toronto El Rey political drama Kids & Family aliens TCA japanese Captain marvel japan new zealand CW Seed Podcast Chernobyl The Purge theme song richard e. Grant Pet Sematary best TV movies canceled TV shows Funimation hollywood olympics historical drama Crackle LGBTQ revenge 4/20 Tomatazos cancelled TV shows Film AMC superhero Infographic TIFF Stephen King diversity child's play Best and Worst rt archives serial killer IFC PBS Ghostbusters live action canceled adenture 2017 Horror dragons National Geographic Broadway Emmys Heroines Spring TV Brie Larson Nickelodeon Nominations universal monsters Western directors Character Guide screenings Sundance Now cults History dramedy Peacock asian-american Sundance TV HBO Go 20th Century Fox miniseries joker fresh Black Mirror OneApp Acorn TV Mary Tyler Moore video MSNBC VOD Grammys RT History The CW GIFs suspense Marathons Television Critics Association rotten movies we love USA Network concert Shudder marvel cinematic universe disaster Tubi supernatural foreign monster movies Quiz Ovation The Walking Dead Marvel Music independent Trivia Super Bowl politics television adaptation cancelled television Disney Plus ITV Calendar what to watch blockbuster Vudu golden globes james bond robots Writers Guild of America book adaptation boxing razzies RT21 Rock Marvel Studios vampires 99% stoner international Pride Month batman HBO Max new star wars movies renewed TV shows cancelled TV series Disney Legendary prank CMT First Reviews cars anime Emmy Nominations Creative Arts Emmys science fiction BBC obituary Year in Review technology cartoon Ellie Kemper Election ABC Family singing competition Image Comics Mystery Bravo The Academy Women's History Month saw comics spanish TBS BET Countdown green book E! Apple TV+ comic books rom-coms pirates of the caribbean true crime critics Amazon Prime Video Teen See It Skip It festival Disney+ Disney Plus Toys Fox Searchlight YA Nat Geo New York Comic Con Musical American Society of Cinematographers PaleyFest dark screen actors guild Star Trek Anna Paquin Netflix Christmas movies Dark Horse Comics Winter TV comiccon Reality Lifetime Lifetime Christmas movies Rocketman animated IFC Films reboot aapi Trailer doctor who Avengers Disney streaming service TLC Alien Polls and Games APB Martial Arts breaking bad Lionsgate new york casting YouTube Paramount Network DC Comics Holidays TV Land indiana jones romantic comedy deadpool Superheroes Hallmark Christmas movies Comedy Central docuseries heist movie elevated horror Extras TV renewals docudrama Tumblr 2021 documentaries Mary Poppins Returns mission: impossible indie Marvel Television Hallmark emmy awards crime thriller DC streaming service kids psychological thriller Pop game of thrones Country discovery ViacomCBS Fantasy sequels basketball versus ABC blaxploitation natural history unscripted USA Universal Awards Wes Anderson Biopics ESPN hidden camera Pixar slashers golden globe awards die hard Starz DC Universe Walt Disney Pictures VICE Apple TV Plus LGBT composers telelvision zombie Song of Ice and Fire biography zombies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Mary poppins ID A24 reviews