News

13 Reasons Why and 10 More Shows With Sophomore Slumps

Bloodline, True Detective, even Daredevil — the critics agree, these shows lost their magic in their second seasons.

by | June 7, 2018 | Comments

13 Reasons Why stars Dylan Minnette and Katherine Langford (Beth Dubber/Netflix)
(Photo by Beth Dubber/Netflix)

UPDATED Feb. 24, 2019

Sometimes the first season of a show is so good that the second season just can’t measure up, resulting in the dreaded sophomore slump. The 2018 season 2 release of Netflix’s 13 Reasons Why notably stumbled in its follow-up season, scoring an abysmal 25% on the Tomatometer after being Certified Fresh with a 79% score for 2017’s season 1.

How does that plummet compare to other sophomore slumps we’ve seen before? We’ve put together a list of shows with the biggest drops from season 1 to season 2 by Tomatometer, each with at least 10 reviews on each season. The series on this list fell for different reasons – some had good second seasons that simply weren’t as great as their first; others truly lost their way. Few that made it past season 2 ever truly recovered.

And if you’re wondering where shows like The Walking Dead, Friday Night Lights, Heroes, Glee, and even the original run of Twin Peaks are on this list, their second seasons still got good reviews even though word-of-mouth seemed to suggest otherwise. If you disagree, let us know in the comments.

Here are the 11 biggest sophomore slumps on television by Tomatometer score.

Please note that the percent change is based on the scores at the time of the update — scores may change as additional reviews are added to the Tomatometer.


Marvel's Daredevil: Season 1 (2015) 99%Marvel's Daredevil: Season 2 (2016) 81%

DOWN 19%

The show: Marvel’s first Netflix series told a grounded version of Matt Murdock (Charlie Cox), the blind lawyer who uses his other enhanced senses to fight crime as Daredevil.

The ratings: Netflix famously does not reveal their ratings, but the success of Daredevil launched several more Marvel series and more seasons of Daredevil.

What happened: Season 1 was a revelation, both compared to the derided Ben Affleck movie and to show how serious superhero shows could work on streaming. By the time season 2 rolled around, Daredevil couldn’t measure up to the monster it created in Jessica Jones. “It’s still nowhere near as interesting or innovative as Marvel’s Agent Carter or Jessica Jones,” wrote The Daily Dot’s Gavia Baker-Whitelaw. “It’s hard to do anything new in the superhero genre, but the second season of Marvel’s Daredevil seems resolutely determined not to try,” wrote Abraham Riesman 0f New York Magazine/Vulture. Sharing the spotlight with Frank Castle (Jon Bernthal) just made people more excited for The Punisher than Daredevil. Aggressive Comix’ Steph Cozza called Punisher “the true MVP here” in her Fresh review.


V: Season 1 (2009) 59%V: Season 2 (2011) 40%

DOWN 23%

(Photo by ABC)

The show: A modern-day reboot of the ’80s series, in which lizard-like aliens arrive wearing human skin.

The ratings: Season 1 dropped from 14.3 million viewers to below five, but ABC still gave it another chance. Season 2 couldn’t rise much above 5.7 million so that was that.

What happened: V went on hiatus after only four November episodes. By the time it returned in March following the Olympics, viewers just didn’t come back.  A second season may have been a chance to establish stability, but critics assured viewers it hadn’t improved. Uproxx’s Alan Sepinwall said, “This one’s not working, and it doesn’t matter how many fresh coats of paint or new showrunners they try to slap onto it.” The San Francisco Chronicle’s David Wiegand said, “The groan-worthy dialogue, usually spoken in a monotone by alien and human alike, is rarely credible and lacks the kind of self-aware irony that might make this enjoyable.”


Smash: Season 1 (2012) 79% | Smash: Season 2 (2013) 56%

DOWN 23%

(Photo by NBC)

The show: The NBC series featured all of the drama of putting on a Broadway musical, the fictional Bombshell about the life of Marilyn Monroe, along with the backstabbing and rivalries behind the scenes.

The ratings: Starting strong with 11.44 million viewers, season 1 steadily lost viewers week by week, ending with 6.74 million. Season 2 began with only 4.48 million and by the middle of the season NBC moved the show to Saturday to dump the remaining episodes.

What happened: Show creator Theresa Rebeck departed the series following the first season, and the plot veered Off Broadway, literally, splitting its focus between Bombshell and a new independent rock musical, and in so doing losing some of its glitzy central appeal. “Its failure wasn’t so much that it didn’t reflect the real workings of Broadway; it never came close to reflecting any aspect of the real world,” New York Times critic Charles Isherwood wrote. With the grind of writing new songs every week and rehearsing the same show, basically it was never as good as the pilot. Or as Boston Herald’s Mark A. Perigard put it, “It still feels as if you’re trapped in the middle of opening night of a third grade dance recital.”


True Detective : Season 1 (2014) 87% | True Detective : Season 2 (2015) 62%

DOWN 23%

The show: Each season centers on a different set of detectives investigating a harrowing case.

The ratings: The first season debuted mid–Hunger Games mania for Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey‘s career “McConaissance” (coming off of acclaimed performances in the likes of Dallas Buyers Club and Magic Mike) and captivated 3.5 million HBO subscribers by the finale. Season 2 stars Colin Farrell, Vince Vaughn, Rachel McAdams, and Taylor Kitsch were each probably hoping for their own career renaissance (“Vaughnaissance”? “McAdaissance”?) after collectively starring in a number of Rotten movies around the time they signed on for the series. But the HBO thriller held onto viewers (2.7 million, which was on par with season 1 regular viewing), who stuck with season 2 hoping it would get good again.

What happened: They rushed it. With the first season’s success, HBO asked creator Nic Pizzolatto for another season, but a show as intricate as True Detective takes time. HBO President of Programming Michael Lombardo copped to essentially setting Pizzolatto up to fail. Lombardo told radio show The Frame: “When we tell somebody to hit an airdate as opposed to allowing the writing to find its own natural resting place, when it’s ready, when it’s baked — we’ve failed … I take the blame. I became too much of a network executive at that point. We had huge success. ‘Gee, I’d love to repeat that next year’ … I think that’s what I learned from it: Don’t do that anymore.” We’ll see if more time and new directors save the third season.


Under the Dome: Season 1 (2013) 83% | Under the Dome: Season 2 (2014) 61%

DOWN 25%

The show: Based on Stephen King’s 1,000-plus page novel, the town of Chester’s Mill becomes enclosed in a clear dome leaving the residents to deal with a lack of resources and laws.

The ratings: A summer hit for CBS, season 1 averaged 11 million viewers. By season 2, they were down to six or seven million, still enough to earn a third season. By the time season 3 hit a low of 3.7 million, there was no plan for season 4.

What happened: Under The Dome straying from the book showed early potential for keeping the story going beyond the finite novel. By the second season, viewers and critics alike felt the story was stretched too thin to try to make it last. Showbiz Junkies’ Rebecca Murray said the show “has taken itself so seriously and yet it’s one of the most nonsensical prime time shows to ever survive more than three episodes.” Backing her up, Screenrant’s Kevin Yeoman called it “one of the most frustrating and dim-witted shows on television.”


Bloodline: Season 1 (2015) 81%Bloodline: Season 2 (2016) 53%

DOWN 28%

The show: The dysfunctional Rayburn family admits in the series premiere that they killed Danny (Ben Mendelsohn), compelling viewers to find out just what tore this Florida dynasty apart. Kyle Chandler, Linda Cardellini, Norbert Leo Butz, and Sissy Spacek played the Rayburns.

The ratings: Netflix does not release ratings, but the creators of the show were planning five or six seasons. They got three.

What happened: Danny died by the end of the first season. The season finale ended with a cliffhanger reveal that his long-lost son came looking for his aunt and uncles, but the real mystery was over. The Young Folks’ Katey Stoetzel called the season “a long, drawn out plot that at times seemed to make up mysteries on the spot in an effort to be just as mysterious as the first season.” In Vulture, Brian Tallerico wrote, “This year’s story never felt as confident as the first.”


The Man in the High Castle: Season 1 (2015) 95%The Man in the High Castle: Season 2 (2016) 64%

DOWN 31%

The show: When you imagine what the world would be like if Hitler had won World War II, that’s good drama. Based on the Philip K. Dick novel.

The ratings: Amazon called The Man in the High Castle their most streamed original series. Season 2 came with no such announcement, but they are still making season 3.

What happened: The setup was great! The follow-up started treading water with aimless subplots and villains failing to remain threatening. “The scary people who were villains in season one ultimately become antiheroes,” said YouTube reviewer Jeremy Jahns. Andy Hartup of Gamesrada went further, saying, “Thanks to dull characters and mostly flaccid story lines, it falls short of being essential viewing.”


The Killing: Season 1 (2011) 97%The Killing: Season 2 (2012) 67%

DOWN 31%

The show: Based on the Danish series, detectives Sarah Linden (Mireille Enos) and Stephen Holder (Joel Kinnaman) investigate the death of Rosie Larson, which has ties to mayoral candidate Darren Richmond (Billy Campbell).

The ratings: Season 1 averaged two million viewers — pretty strong for AMC. Season 2 was down to 1.5 million and AMC canceled it. Thanks to a deal with Netflix, they revived it for a third season, and Netflix streamed the fourth and final.

What happened: They solved Rosie’s murder, but it was too little too late. By then, critics grew tired of the mystery and its characters. Slant’s Mike Lechevallier called it “a mystery show whose mysteries agitate and bore rather than mesmerize and astound.” The Mercury News’ Chuck Barney wrote, “The longer we spent with the show’s brooding characters, the more we came to realize that they were an unbearably dour and detestable bunch.”


Wayward Pines: Season 1 (2015) 78%Wayward Pines: Season 2 (2016) 43%

DOWN 36%

(Photo by Fox)

The show: A Secret Service agent (Matt Dillon) wakes up in the mysterious town of Wayward Pines after an accident, and the authorities in town just will not let him leave.

The ratings: Season 1 was a solid summer hit with about 3.82 million viewers. Season 2 dropped to 2.0.

What happened: Once season 1 revealed what Wayward Pines actually was, season 2 was just about new characters (Jason Patric, Djimon Hounsou) who didn’t know as much as the audience. IndieWire’s Ben Travers wrote, “You almost feel bad for the series in its second season, limping along, trying to rebuild from what little was left.” THR’s Dan Fienberg wrote, “If what you liked about the first season was the insidious unknown, that’s gone with little to replace it.”


Genius: Einstein (2017) 83% | Genius: Picasso (2018) 57%

DOWN 38%

The show: Each season told the biography of a different genius. Season 1 was Albert Einstein (Geoffrey Rush), season 2 was Pablo Picasso (Antonio Banderas). Season 3 will be Mary Shelley.

The ratings: Only two-thirds of Einstein’s audience of a million tuned in for Picasso, down to only half in week two, and only about one-third by midway through the season.

What happened: Perhaps artistic genius was too abstract to contain in episodic format. Surely an artist as complex as Pablo Picasso cannot be encapsulated in a TV series, but critics complain Genius didn’t even try. The Straits Times’ Alison de Souza called it “disappointingly conventional” and New Statesman’s Rachel Cooke said the script failed both Picasso and Banderas. “Even he can’t make his lines sound convincing,” Cooke said. Plus, the creative magic that led to ​season 1’s 10 Emmy nominations, including one for Rush’s buzzy performance, may have set the bar impossibly high for any subject or lead actor that followed.


13 Reasons Why: Season 1 (2017) 78%13 Reasons Why: Season 2 (2018) 27%

DOWN 54%

The show: Hannah Baker (Katherine Langford) commits suicide and leaves 13 tapes for her classmates. As Clay Jensen (Dylan Minnette) listens to the tapes, each one reveals one of the reasons Hannah ended her life.

The ratings: Netflix does not release ratings, but the first season was a water-cooler conversation piece, as well as the center of controversy. Some mental health advocacy groups worried it glamorized suicide. But season 2 remained a trending topic on social media, and on Wednesday, Netflix announced that 13 Reasons Why has been renewed for a third season.

What happened: We already found out the 13 reasons in season 1. Season 2 tried to add more reasons, and stretch out the story with the civil trial Hannah’s mother (Kate Walsh) filed, but it was obvious to fans and critics that the story had naturally concluded. ScreenRant’s Kevin Yeoman wrote, “Right away it becomes clear this season’s narrative foundation is built on sand, which is worsened by a lack of forward momentum and over-reliance on rehashing the past.”

Trying to tackle gun control only gave critics more reasons to grouse about the show’s handling of sensitive issues. “It is bleak and depressing, scarringly graphic and stupidly glamorizing in its treatments of guns and ideas of vengeance,” wrote Siena Yates of the New Zealand Herald.

Tag Cloud

Showtime Family spanish language comics Brie Larson San Diego Comic-Con President Esquire TIFF natural history Rom-Com documentaries LGBT Baby Yoda mockumentary MSNBC romance zombies travel Sundance Now Trophy Talk Holiday Set visit GoT comiccon Tomatazos south america strong female leads Ellie Kemper comic Drama adaptation talk show cancelled television Schedule reviews TCA 20th Century Fox Action Chernobyl aliens Shondaland halloween jamie lee curtis spinoff Character Guide richard e. Grant Sci-Fi HBO asian-american child's play First Look all-time Turner Classic Movies First Reviews Horror The Purge period drama batman Spectrum Originals die hard directors Star Trek Heroines AMC stoner Black Mirror Oscars Tubi Sundance Opinion singing competition animated YouTube concert theme song latino Mary poppins canceled Sneak Peek Pet Sematary El Rey video on demand TV Rocky Paramount See It Skip It Apple TV Plus ABC Family DirecTV medical drama teaser mutant The Arrangement cartoon Winter TV zombie FXX Year in Review streaming Peacock Sundance TV NYCC Comedy Central FOX canceled TV shows harry potter APB IFC RT History Vudu BAFTA 45 Tumblr blockbuster zero dark thirty renewed TV shows independent tv talk breaking bad Pop SundanceTV A&E Trailer WGN blaxploitation chucky Amazon Prime Video indiana jones Tarantino Arrowverse Rocketman Star Wars christmas movies facebook movie Travel Channel TV Land scary movies Disney CBS All Access National Geographic Red Carpet HBO Go crime TCA 2017 21st Century Fox Martial Arts Superheroes cancelled TV shows rotten movies we love political drama TLC PlayStation 2020 Comic Book Polls and Games Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Holidays Syfy festivals criterion Universal Quiz LGBTQ foreign Winners Summer Christmas dc ITV robots RT21 movies crossover sag awards Marvel Television serial killer screen actors guild BBC One Columbia Pictures disaster Pixar Interview CBS Podcast GLAAD book Valentine's Day cats space Stephen King what to watch werewolf based on movie Grammys Cartoon Network Binge Guide elevated horror Crunchyroll Mindy Kaling hispanic Lucasfilm 71st Emmy Awards Disney Channel American Society of Cinematographers MCU sequel 2019 unscripted sitcom diversity cults Box Office Masterpiece Calendar ESPN anime toy story Nat Geo Epix universal monsters doctor who Avengers satire DC Comics Crackle television New York Comic Con miniseries slashers 007 Pop TV Dark Horse Comics Hear Us Out Shudder Kids & Family Anna Paquin Endgame dragons crime thriller YouTube Premium documentary Adult Swim 24 frames cinemax ghosts Awards USA OWN FX on Hulu Cosplay boxoffice docudrama Marathons TruTV war cops Fox News cancelled TV series Lionsgate Hallmark screenings Thanksgiving binge crime drama Turner best Superheroe Warner Bros. Mary Tyler Moore VH1 Film Film Festival Marvel Studios Television Academy psychological thriller children's TV HBO Max Musicals Creative Arts Emmys free movies dark The CW social media game show CMT Classic Film true crime composers series YouTube Red Biopics USA Network TCA Winter 2020 thriller Pirates DC Universe 4/20 Watching Series Ghostbusters Black History Month parents History GIFs Mary Poppins Returns Comedy news anthology Song of Ice and Fire twilight dceu finale Amazon Prime 2016 VICE Sony Pictures WarnerMedia cancelled Election OneApp game of thrones TNT discovery Women's History Month Countdown X-Men Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt IFC Films Amazon Studios versus Netflix YA historical drama witnail reboot Nickelodeon TCM Certified Fresh vampires biography BBC Comics on TV Rock Reality Competition Music Logo Food Network indie BET dogs SXSW SDCC dramedy Hulu supernatural adventure name the review technology Pride Month kids Animation Britbox MTV video Extras CNN ratings Country Mudbound cars Starz 2017 hist nature Discovery Channel Super Bowl films Best and Worst A24 Apple TV+ DGA CW Seed Fall TV spider-man casting politics 2015 cooking Elton John science fiction Spring TV E! VOD 2018 justice league Disney+ Disney Plus Emmys police drama Captain marvel Lifetime Christmas movies spy thriller Musical Spike TBS DC streaming service Toys revenge Marvel Awards Tour Writers Guild of America spain award winner joker PaleyFest FX Disney Plus The Witch Disney streaming service Emmy Nominations comedies Infographic critics romantic comedy Hallmark Christmas movies Paramount Network golden globes Acorn TV Photos Lifetime BET Awards TV renewals green book franchise sports Video Games Apple Ovation Freeform a nightmare on elm street Trivia Premiere Dates Cannes Bravo transformers mission: impossible The Walking Dead Academy Awards psycho E3 Nominations Walt Disney Pictures Western Teen PBS Mystery stand-up comedy BBC America Fantasy Amazon Netflix Christmas movies Funimation quibi NBC Reality ABC