Critics Consensus

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows Lacks Turtle Power

Plus, Me Before You is a middling tearjerker, and Popstar is a sharp music satire.

by and | June 2, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got turtle power (Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows, starring Megan Fox and Will Arnett), a tear-jerking love story (Me Before You, starring Emilia Clarke and Sam Claflin), and a pop music satire (Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping, starring Andy Samberg and Imogen Poots). What do the critics have to say?

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows (2016) 37%

Beloved by middle schoolers the world over, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles have yet to power their way into the hearts of movie critics, who say that while their latest big screen outing, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows, holds a slight edge over its 2014 predecessor, it’s still too noisy and juvenile to satisfy. The plot is the usual silliness — the evil Shredder is bent on world domination, and the Turtles must stop him — but pre-teens and nostalgic TMNT die-hards are unlikely to mind. The pundits say Out of the Shadows occasionally works as a cartoonish slam-bang popcorn flick, but mostly, it’s a relentlessly juvenile time-waster.

Me Before You (2016) 54%

Films about beautiful people falling in love on their way to a weepy ending are essentially critic-proof — just ask Nicholas Sparks — so it’s hard to imagine anyone involved with Me Before You worrying too much about how critics are reacting to their adaptation of the Jojo Moyes bestseller. For what it’s worth, many reviews note the strong work delivered by — and solid chemistry between — stars Emilia Clarke and Sam Claflin; it’s just that, as far as a good number of pundits are concerned, the movie doesn’t do a good enough job of handling its sensitive subject, and too often succumbs to sentimentality rather than treating its love story with the clear-eyed dignity it deserves. Still, if you’re looking for a tissue-worthy summer romance, you could do (and probably have done) a heck of a lot worse.

Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping (2016) 79%

You really can’t make a rock mockumentary without being compared to Spinal Tap — and those comparisons, more often than not, turn out to be unfavorable. So if nothing else, Andy Samberg and his Lonely Island partners Akiva Schaffer and Jorma Taccone would have earned points for moxie for even making an attempt to brave the genre with their feature-length debut, this weekend’s Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping. Happily for the comedy trio, critics say the film lives up to its title by lobbing a constant volley of often hilarious barbs at the modern mainstream pop scene and 21st century celebrity in general — and even if it can’t help but lose a little momentum after a sidesplitting first half, the end result stands as another solid entry in the SNL vets’ budding filmography.

What’s Hot on TV

Roots: Miniseries (2016) 96%

A powerfully impressive — and still relevant — update on a television classic, Roots boasts remarkable performances, deep emotion, and occasionally jarring beauty.

The Dresser (2015) 100%

The Dresser brilliantly showcases two of the most gifted actors of their generation within a thoughtful, well-executed production offering intelligent commentary on the human condition.

Bloodline: Season 2 (2016) 53%

Despite impressive performances and attractive cinematography, Bloodline‘s second season fails to recapture its predecessor’s dramatic intrigue.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Wailing (Goksung) (2016) , a thriller about a small town reeling from a series of brutal murders after the arrival of a mysterious stranger, is at 100 percent.
  • The Fits (2016) , a psychological drama about a young athlete whose peers are suffering from a strange condition, is at 95 percent.
  • The President (2016) , a drama about a deposed dictator who flees a coup with his innocent grandson, is at 88 percent.
  • The Witness (2016) , a documentary about the life and death of famed murder victim Kitty Genovese, is at 86 percent.
  • Time To Choose (2016) , a documentary that looks at various attempts to combat climate change, is at 80 percent.
  • The Final Master (2016) , a martial arts film about a young fighter fulfilling his master’s wish to establish a school of his own, is at 63 percent.
  • Approaching the Unknown (2016) , starring Mark Strong and Luke Wilson in a sci-fi drama about an astronaut undertaking a perilous mission to Mars, is at 33 percent.
  • I just don’t care about the reviews. I like X-Men movies more than I hate them. That’s about all you can reasonably hope for from this kind of film. The only two that were better than I expected were the X-Men and X-Men: First Class.

  • James Sunderland

    I don’t know about this movie,but Jennifer Lawrence can sit on my face ANYTIME!

  • Giannis Agelopoulos

    For me as i can see is that whatever comes from Disney is praised as prefect and should consider as a masterpiece and if it comes from another company it should be bashed to death. The film isn’t perfect but i had a great time watching it and i highly recommend as a 7 out of 10, so ingore the tomato meter and see what the people say for X-MEN: APOCALYPSE.

    • Pinkk

      Through the Looking Glass was from Disney and bashed to death :p So no, just because it comes from Disney, does not make critics praise a movie as perfect :p

      As for X:Apoc , and someone who enjoyed it (seeing it a second time today) it had plenty of flaws. Intro of new characters that get very little if any time to really care about them (Angel, Psylocke, even new Storm) and a main villain we really don’t get much info on in the film. We get more out of Magneto than we do Apoc. :p

      Though you may be talking about the difference between the MCU and X-Men franchises, which, even the movie going audiences have preferred the MCU over the X-Men, if we go by the box office tallies. Most MCU movies surpass the X-Men ones.

    • Are you still mad Batman v Superman wasn’t given an above 90% rating? That was months ago.
      As for this X-Men movie, it’s decent, could be better for sure. A 48% tomatometer reflects that.

      • Giannis Agelopoulos

        As for the Batman vs Superman i consider it the worst super hero movie i have seen this year so don’t run in conclusions for what i think about this movie. For the latest X-men movie as i said the film isn’t perfect, but not worthy for 48% of the tomato meter ill just give you the link from IMBD and proves you that opinions differs from site to site

  • Disney owns everything now.

    • Clint3po

      Not DeadPool

  • Vits/Vicente Torres

    The X-MEN series hasn’t been rebooted.

  • Rakesh Ramachandran

    Out of the 3 super hero movies that released recently , i would rate Xmen as best. People should ignore Tomato meter go and see the movie ..Happy holidays.

  • Jim Hamilton

    The Language was unfit for adults let alone a 13 year old. It should not have a PG rating. Hollywood seems to think a movie can’t be good if it isn’t moraly corrupt. The directors, producers and play writers need discipline and I don’t mean self discipline. They need to have me to lay some discipline upside their jaw. Thats right a broken nose and a busted jaw from my fist may get the point a across. Some people need a good old fashion beating before they can be taught anything and the Hollywood types are just that kind. The movie was terrible by the way. It was totally predictable and the special affects looked like my kids Lego set. I t was nothing but over dramatic and the acting very poor I would not recommend it!


    TMNT: Out of the Shadows was really entertaining. Growing up in the 80s I feel this is the film I’ve would have wanted as a child while the cartoon series on. I don’t understand the backlash at all…

    • Clint3po

      Everyone who saw the first one got burned and was not going to give this new one a chance

      • WTFITBS

        I went into this film without any level of expectations and thoroughly enjoyed it. Felt like was 8 again when Rocksteady and Beebop where chasing the turtles in that river rapids scene. How long have we been waiting to see something like this on the big screen?

Tag Cloud

series festival PBS movie cinemax Tomatazos Spectrum Originals TLC The CW Sneak Peek Pride Month Turner CNN Martial Arts cartoon video ABC TCA Awards independent Ovation DC Comics screenings Sony Pictures Writers Guild of America foreign Box Office stoner hist justice league NYCC Captain marvel child's play Infographic The Witch scorecard Apple Nickelodeon Mary Tyler Moore Television Critics Association Rom-Com WarnerMedia Rock Universal dragons MCU Discovery Channel CBS Stephen King nbcuniversal Biopics Pop singing competition Superheroes Thanksgiving Holiday Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Crunchyroll spanish language cancelled TV series TNT Arrowverse Mystery OneApp comics adaptation cancelled TV shows worst die hard See It Skip It films El Rey SXSW TCA docudrama Comedy Central Disney Channel A24 ID Trivia dark Anna Paquin nature franchise Elton John spanish sports Lucasfilm VOD Extras chucky Summer emmy awards composers Teen Acorn TV APB james bond science fiction jamie lee curtis Black History Month comedies 2020 GoT quibi period drama HBO Max crime Pop TV richard e. Grant Hulu YA San Diego Comic-Con SundanceTV ABC Family Fall TV A&E Song of Ice and Fire BBC rt archives Logo Mary poppins social media IFC halloween Turner Classic Movies Video Games RT21 Ghostbusters LGBT First Reviews Amazon Prime Video CBS All Access 007 biography VICE cancelled Film Red Carpet Starz Trophy Talk witnail reboot PaleyFest facebook YouTube Red DC streaming service indie Amazon Shudder Cosplay latino best USA Network Election USA Adult Swim documentaries comic mockumentary twilight zombies Tubi Sci-Fi black natural history CMT toy story TV renewals E! anime green book Baby Yoda Columbia Pictures IFC Films Apple TV+ finale dc Lifetime Christmas movies book hispanic worst movies Winners Tumblr BET Awards Super Bowl aliens TBS WGN First Look BBC America Family boxoffice The Walking Dead crime drama 71st Emmy Awards zero dark thirty BET Action ratings Music blaxploitation TCM Television Academy Netflix Academy Awards children's TV doctor who AMC ghosts spider-man psycho a nightmare on elm street fast and furious mutant mission: impossible Paramount reviews DC Universe versus Calendar political drama TruTV 2019 sitcom RT History Nominations Fox News elevated horror parents werewolf Grammys joker discovery DGA Showtime Marvel Television zombie Sundance Now comic books Travel Channel Emmys TCA 2017 romance FX on Hulu diversity Star Trek Freeform historical drama classics Mudbound Reality based on movie dogs Superheroe SDCC TIFF Awards Tour Opinion Vudu Toys Rocketman Photos Britbox 4/20 BBC One Comics on TV scary movies Warner Bros. harry potter 20th Century Fox stop motion Apple TV Plus History all-time Valentine's Day Mary Poppins Returns DirecTV venice Fantasy YouTube Creative Arts Emmys E3 Lionsgate kids CW Seed talk show HBO Go The Arrangement Walt Disney Pictures Marvel Studios rotten movies we love ITV sequels The Purge football American Society of Cinematographers YouTube Premium name the review casting Watching Series transformers FXX Quiz Holidays Reality Competition Avengers The Academy renewed TV shows Spike game show LGBTQ PlayStation Funimation anthology serial killer vampires Bravo Fox Searchlight Awards blockbuster romantic comedy politics Marathons Christmas Countdown Disney Plus Epix Food Network MTV 2016 Set visit what to watch Brie Larson 2015 supernatural Syfy spy thriller breaking bad directors award winner game of thrones Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TCA Winter 2020 batman animated medical drama National Geographic Rocky archives Spring TV hollywood Drama Schedule BAFTA concert Trailer spinoff disaster streaming laika Disney streaming service Amazon Studios television Emmy Nominations Comic Book Nat Geo Chernobyl canceled TV shows christmas movies Premiere Dates tv talk documentary video on demand spain cooking Binge Guide NBC halloween tv italian Year in Review Esquire Disney Dark Horse Comics nfl rotten 2017 Oscars Marvel Shondaland Musicals Black Mirror technology MSNBC news war Interview 2018 Tarantino cults Film Festival 24 frames Paramount Network Pet Sematary Mindy Kaling Endgame universal monsters Netflix Christmas movies GLAAD TV 21st Century Fox japanese remakes Women's History Month south america Best and Worst Disney+ Disney Plus Pirates deadpool Polls and Games FOX Cannes superhero Winter TV TV Land australia New York Comic Con robots OWN cops Peacock canceled Podcast stand-up comedy 45 revenge strong female leads screen actors guild cars teaser movies french dceu crossover Sundance President Musical Cartoon Network Masterpiece comiccon GIFs Country Heroines Kids & Family police drama binge psychological thriller cats Amazon Prime true crime criterion Character Guide critics Hear Us Out slashers Pixar thriller toronto cancelled television Lifetime festivals Animation indiana jones Certified Fresh Western FX free movies Horror Classic Film sag awards golden globes sequel adventure asian-american Ellie Kemper theme song Comedy X-Men crime thriller unscripted dramedy ESPN Star Wars Hallmark satire obituary travel HBO space Sundance TV miniseries Crackle 72 Emmy Awards Hallmark Christmas movies VH1