My Week With PT Anderson, Day Three: Magnolia

Jeff delves deep into the world of interconnected LA stories.

by | September 20, 2012 | Comments



Magnolia (1999)

83%

When he pitched Boogie Nights to the studio, Paul Thomas Anderson famously demanded three hours and an NC-17 rating, and was told he had to pick one. He eventually missed both marks — but with his next outing, 1999’s Magnolia, he crossed the three-hour barrier in style, delivering a whopping 188-minute behemoth of a movie that unites a sprawling ensemble cast in pursuit of some equally outsized themes.

As with Hard Eight and Boogie Nights, Anderson tips his hand early on with Magnolia, establishing the tone with a camera that’s more restlessly omniscient than ever — from the opening shots, you know you’re in the presence of cinema. He spends the first 20 minutes of the movie introducing the viewer to characters who are in the midst of life-consuming struggles with fundamental things like death, violence, and love; clearly, you’re in for some statements about Very Big Things.

Fortunately, Anderson assembled a stable of outstanding actors to help him get his points across. Aside from the usual suspects — resurfacing P.T. vets included John C. Reilly, Julianne Moore, Philips Seymour Hoffman and Baker Hall, Melora Walters, William H. Macy, and Luis Guzmán — he made the wise decision to cast Jason Robards in the key role of Earl Partridge, a dying TV producer whose ties to several cast members (most notably Frank T.J. Mackey, the self-styled love guru who provides many of Magnolia‘s more unpleasant moments) drive much of the film.

Always a reliable actor, Robards delivers one of his finest performances in Magnolia, which sounds kind of funny, given that he doesn’t do much besides lie in a bed while the life drains out of his character. But that’s why he’s such an outstanding anchor for the movie — he does everything with nothing here, stripping his craft down to the bare essentials of voice and eyes to play a man struggling to atone for his sins while he still has time. And he’s perfectly matched with Hoffman, who — given a rare opportunity to play a character in an Anderson movie who isn’t heartbreakingly delusional or an abrasive weirdo — lends an element of much-needed normalcy to a movie that takes place in a world largely populated by broken people.

Some of those people include Partridge’s wife Linda (Moore), who harbors plenty of guilt of her own; Jimmy Gator (Hall), a legendary quiz show host who’s trying to reconnect with his estranged daughter (Walters); Donnie Smith (Macy), a former contestant on Gator’s show whose life has gone deeply awry; and Jim Kurring (Reilly), a good-hearted (albeit slightly incompetent and emotionally crippled) police officer. While not all of their stories initially seem to have much to do with one another, you know the drill — by the time the end credits roll, you will have been given a dramatic case study in the ways in which Everything Is Connected.

Again, Anderson gives himself a lot of ground to cover here, and while he occasionally seems unable to resist making his points overly explicitly — in fact, one entire scene, which rests on some awkward exchanges between Macy and Henry Gibson in a bar, feels like it was taken from a clumsier film — for the most part, Magnolia finds Anderson making his points with about as much restraint as anyone could expect from a three-hour film. Are some lines thunderingly obvious? Do we have to hang on through some tonal skips (not to mention a mad bit of ACTING! from Tom Cruise in the final act)? Yes, absolutely, but the movie’s flaws are kept to a fair minimum given the mad jumble of narrative.



Of course, we can’t talk about Magnolia without discussing the spontaneous Aimee Mann singalong and the frogs. I won’t delve too deeply into the particulars, so as not to spoil them for anyone who hasn’t already seen the movie, but they were definitely part of what kept me away from it when it was in theaters. I mean, a movie this long represents a serious investment of the viewer’s time, and if you’ve heard about these scenes outside the context of the rest of the film, it’s easy to conclude that Anderson is disrespecting that investment by jerking his audience around with flights of fancy.

So… is he guilty of that here? After finally watching Magnolia, I’m inclined to cut Anderson some slack. The movie warns you from the get-go that the world is an inscrutable place, filled with mysteries that impart horror and awe in equal measure, and if that provides a convenient loophole for some of the weirder stuff he gets us into here, then so be it; anyway, I’d like to think what he’s really trying to tell us is that life holds infinite potential for love in spite of our unworthiness — that literally anything can happen at any moment.

That’s kind of a gauzy, soft-focus interpretation for a movie where children are murdered, abused, humiliated, and possibly molested; where fathers’ sins are visited repeatedly on their sons and daughters; where death can mean a final, awful confrontation with what Robards’ character eloquently refers to as “the regret that we make.” But as so often happens with Anderson, in the end, everything leads back to love — where we find it, how we give it, how we move forward when it’s denied, and the power recognizing it can give us.

Speaking of which: Tomorrow, we fall in Punch-Drunk Love. Until then…


See more:

Monday: Hard Eight

Tuesday: Boogie Nights

Wednesday: Magnolia

Thursday: Punch-Drunk Love

Friday: There Will Be Blood

Saturday: The Master

Tag Cloud

Britbox MTV YA unscripted DC streaming service ABC Family police drama Amazon Thanksgiving Trailer GLAAD HBO Nat Geo Syfy CBS All Access Comedy BET Sony Pictures ratings politics Biopics Reality Winners APB Musicals zombie dc docudrama period drama Spring TV crime thriller harry potter Lifetime NYCC Universal E3 Nickelodeon dramedy Horror DC Universe 45 Nominations BBC America Comic Book Ellie Kemper Fox News Sundance Christmas Sneak Peek Musical Paramount Pixar President IFC technology Martial Arts SDCC singing competition Netflix Schedule SundanceTV Reality Competition romance Disney Channel 20th Century Fox aliens Dark Horse Comics based on movie MSNBC Music Polls and Games Freeform Year in Review Awards supernatural E! Teen golden globes Rom-Com Bravo Rock 24 frames DC Comics Lionsgate Sundance Now political drama American Society of Cinematographers Lucasfilm Photos Mary Tyler Moore FXX sports ITV BBC ABC discovery dceu Countdown Red Carpet 2016 Crackle travel GIFs TV Tumblr TCM The Arrangement Ghostbusters LGBTQ 21st Century Fox Video Games medical drama psycho Set visit Fantasy Best and Worst Writers Guild of America RT History Kids & Family cinemax Watching Series TNT First Look FOX Toys cults Valentine's Day Country Superheroes Premiere Dates Interview Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VICE Extras Podcast TLC Mystery Box Office cops Logo USA crime X-Men ESPN FX A&E Super Bowl transformers Marathons justice league Food Network Rocky talk show biography GoT adventure Disney Paramount Network TV Land PBS vampires Spike cats Adult Swim Grammys CBS Trivia OWN composers WGN IFC Films 2015 007 spy thriller diversity AMC serial killer Acorn TV CMT Fall TV boxoffice Certified Fresh sitcom The CW Oscars binge USA Network Star Wars Drama Winter TV Election VH1 PaleyFest Emmys Star Trek Pirates Marvel historical drama science fiction Masterpiece war Tomatazos Starz Hulu Sci-Fi TIFF TruTV Esquire 2017 thriller crime drama See It Skip It Mindy Kaling Showtime Creative Arts Emmys NBC what to watch DirecTV History Infographic El Rey comiccon cooking TBS TCA Western Comedy Central Cosplay Calendar Pop Summer social media Warner Bros. Character Guide Opinion Animation Action Cartoon Network CW Seed CNN TCA 2017 Holidays