Total Recall

Definitive Ryan Reynolds Roles

In this week's Total Recall, we take a look at the roles that have helped define the Deadpool star's career.

by | February 10, 2016 | Comments

After years of fan outcry, Ryan Reynolds finally gets the chance to topline a solo Deadpool movie this weekend — and if early critical returns are any indication, it was well worth the wait. In honor of the occasion, we decided to take a fond look back at some of the best and brightest moments from Mr. Reynolds’ film and TV career, and the results add up to a list that includes big box-office hits and left-field choices from across the spectrum. It’s time for Total Recall!


Two Guys and a Girl (1998-2001)

TwoGuysAndAGirl

After getting his first big break in the Canadian soap Hillside, Reynolds picked up a handful of TV appearances (including a gig on Sabrina the Teenage Witch) before landing a co-starring role on the ABC sitcom Two Guys and a Girl, which lingered on the network’s lineup for an 81-episode run between 1998-2001. Initially part of a Wednesday comedy block that included The Drew Carey Show, the series was initially something of a midsized hit, but it was eventually doomed by a move to the Saturday TV graveyard — not to mention a glut of Friends-inspired shows about the travails of twentysomething urbanites. Still, for fans wanting an early glimpse of Reynolds (not to mention a pre-Firefly Nathan Fillion), it’s worth a look.


National Lampoon's Van Wilder (2002) 18%

VanWilder

There’s no denying that Ryan Reynolds is genetically well-qualified to play feckless, handsome charmers — or that, by 2002, the world was ready for a fresh take on the slobs-vs.-snobs story that National Lampoon perfected into an art form with Animal House — so National Lampoon’s Van Wilder, starring Reynolds as a legendarily shiftless college student scrambling to preserve his cushy lifestyle after being cut off by his dad, could have been a lot of fun. The problem, as most critics saw it, was that instead of being a schlubby, disadvantaged outsider with an axe to grind against the Man, Reynolds’ character was simply lazy, and thus inherently hard to root for. Still, it gave him an early chance to carry a film, and it’s become something of a cult comedy classic — which is just fine with John Patterson of the L.A. Weekly, who called it “An effervescent campus gross-out comedy that’s true to the amoral, anarchic spirit of Lampoon founder-editor and screenwriter Doug Kenney.”

Watch Trailer


The Nines (2007) 65%

TheNines

Whatever problems The Nines might have, lack of ambition isn’t one of them. This heady sci-fi fantasy, which marked the feature directorial debut of screenwriter John August, stars Reynolds in a triple role as three men struggling to understand the truth behind unusual occurrences in their lives — lives that occasionally intersect — while in the midst of fraught encounters with mysterious women (all played by Hope Davis, in another triple role). It’s the type of trippy metaphysical drama that demands a viewer’s complete concentration, and even then, the answers to the questions it poses are open to interpretation. Still, if you’re in the mood for a less-than-straightforward film, you could do far worse. “Confusing? Yes, and intentionally so,” wrote Christy Lemire for the Associated Press. “But it’s never boring.”

Watch Trailer


Definitely, Maybe (2008) 70%

DefinitelyMaybe

A romantic comedy with a twist, Definitely, Maybe finds its protagonist looking back on the love affair that led to marriage and a child — by telling the story to his young daughter, with some names changed and facts adjusted, while in the midst of a divorce. Thanks in part to those narrative curveballs, most critics applauded Maybe — and even if it still ultimately traced a rather familiar arc, it was difficult to find too much fault with a resolutely charming production that made smart use of a likable ensemble cast that included Reynolds, Abigail Breslin, Elizabeth Banks, Isla Fisher, and Rachel Weisz. “As the movie is about a character’s growing into his own truth rather than discovering some preordained truth, Definitely, Maybe is hard to outguess,” wrote Mick LaSalle for the San Francisco Chronicle. “For once in a romantic comedy, you won’t be able to tell after five minutes who will end up together.”

Watch Trailer


The Proposal (2009) 44%

Proposal1

It’s a special occasion when critics really go nuts for a romantic comedy — or when rom-com fans care enough about critics’ opinions to stay away from the cineplex even when a new entry in the genre is supposed to be subpar. For proof, look no further than 2009’s The Proposal, which endured a heap of critical brickbats on its way to theaters, yet still managed to roll up an impressive $300 million-plus gross — thanks in no small part to the chemistry between stars Sandra Bullock (as a publishing company’s abrasive editor-in-chief) and Reynolds (as the hapless assistant who’s browbeaten into marrying her to keep her from being deported). It definitely isn’t revolutionary stuff, and you know exactly where the movie’s taking the relationship, but that formula is a big part of the romantic comedy’s appeal. “The Proposal is just a good old-fashioned romance, one in which people actually bring out the best in one another rather than the worst,” wrote Betsy Sharkey for the Los Angeles Times. “How novel is that?”

Watch Trailer


Buried (2010) 87%

Buried

It takes a special kind of creativity and filmmaking discipline — to say nothing of actorly chutzpah — to pull off a film centered around a single person in a single space, and when Reynolds read the script for 2010’s Buried, he had to know he was facing an immense challenge. Both he and director Rodrigo Cortés deserve a ton of credit, then, for making the most out of screenwriter Chris Sparling’s tightly focused story about a military contractor who wakes up imprisoned in a coffin, and turning its seemingly limited premise into a 95-minute white-knuckle race against time. As Rex Reed argued for the New York Observer, “Nothing this underrated actor has done previously measures up to the emotional diversity, focus and self-control required of him in a one-man exercise in underground suspense that Alfred Hitchcock would envy.”

Watch Trailer


Safe House (2012) 52%

SafeHouse

Reynolds got the chance to go toe-to-toe with Denzel Washington in 2012’s Safe House, an action thriller from director Daniel Espinosa about a rogue CIA operative (Washington) whose interrogation is interrupted by a team of mercenaries that attacks and sends him back into the wind with a low-level field agent (Reynolds). It’s a premise rich with possibilities for cool set pieces and odd-couple bickering, but Safe House never really takes full advantage of those possibilities, settling instead for frenetic editing that can’t quite move fast enough to mask the clichéd plot developments along the way. Still, when the movie gets going, it does have its pleasures; as Colin Covert wrote for the Minneapolis Star Tribune, “I won’t deny that the movie hooked me with sheer brute energy and dragged me along with it most of the way.”

Watch Trailer


The Voices (2015) 74%

Voices

For most films, making your main protagonist an employee at a bathtub factory would more than fulfill the weirdness quotient. But for 2015’s The Voices, that’s just the beginning of a surreal odyssey into bloody violence and black comedy — oh, and talking pets. Directed by acclaimed graphic novelist Marjane Satrapi by a script from Paranormal Activity 2 co-writer Michael R. Perry, The Voices gives Reynolds free rein to indulge in all manner of strange behavior, but for the most part, critics agreed that the movie stays on the right side of the line between refreshingly different and quirky for quirky’s sake, and while its main character’s warped descent into a bleak, chaotic psychological abyss definitely isn’t for all viewers, those with a taste for the strange might find the end results intoxicating. As Sara Stewart wrote for the New York Post, “Ryan Reynolds is chillingly perfect as a nice-guy factory worker struggling with schizophrenia and murderous impulses in this tonally wild indie, which is nearly too horrifying to be funny — but not quite.”

Watch Trailer


Woman in Gold (2015) 57%

WomanInGold

Woman in Gold has an awful lot going for it, including a fascinating real-life story and a talented cast topped off by the mighty Helen Mirren. Unfortunately, while there’s plenty of drama to be wrought from the tale of a Jewish refugee battling the Austrian government for ownership of a Gustav Klimt painting of her aunt, much of it went missing on its journey to the big screen. Although critics were quick to praise Mirren’s work, and had kind words for Reynolds’ portrayal of a rookie lawyer enlisted to help win back the painting, many critics felt Woman in Gold lacked the depth and dramatic pull its story deserved — which is not to say the movie didn’t have its fans. “Sometimes you know a movie is going to work in about the first three scenes,” wrote Wesley Morris for Grantland. “This one really works.”

Watch Trailer


Mississippi Grind (2015) 91%

MississippiGrind

A number of his more successful films have found him playing characters that might be described as blandly pretty, so the idea of Ryan Reynolds playing an emotionally stunted drifter with a gambling problem might seem like a bit of a stretch. With his work in Mississippi Grind, however, Reynolds offered an excellent reminder that when given the right script, he’s more than capable of delivering a finely layered performance — and going toe-to-toe with Ben Mendelsohn in a melancholy road movie about a pair of aging losers who can’t quite seem to grow up no matter how many chances they’re given. “Mendelsohn plays Gerry as a stringy, sweaty hunk of pure desperation,” wrote Mike D’Angelo for the A.V. Club, “while Reynolds, as the ostensibly more stable partner, demonstrates yet again that he’s much more than a ridiculously pretty face.”

Watch Trailer

  • TheVoiceOfReason

    I’ve always liked Ryan Reynolds.

    • HurricaneJedi

      You clearly have good taste haha. He has been my favourite actor for years.

    • Sam

      He’s one of those underrated actors who is long overdue for a big break,hopefully Deadpool will do the trick.

    • Will_Z_Macht

      Two Guys, A Girl, and a Pizza Place was great!

  • Hamza Joozer

    Buried is his best performance, 2nd best is Deadpool.

  • TomNewYorker

    My 10 Favorite Ryan Reynolds Movies are
    1-Van Wilder
    2-The Voices
    3-Green Lantern(Don’t care what anyone says, I thought it was pretty good, saw it twice in theaters and own it on DVD)
    4-Smokin Aces
    5-Just Friends
    6-Waiting
    7-Buried
    8-The Change-Up
    9-X-Men: Origins Wolverine
    10-The Proposal

    • HurricaneJedi

      I also like Smokin Aces. Green Latern, well he was good in it but I had a few issues but you are welcome to enjoy it.

  • HurricaneJedi

    Definitely maybe, the Proposal, Just friends, Van Wilder, Safe House, Mississippi Grind, The Voices, Smokin Aces, Waiting, Woman in Gold, Selfless ( a lot of hate but I enjoyed it) Buried. Those are I think all my favourite RR films.

    • Dave Guyett

      OMG, no one mentioned “Adventureland” ! His second best movie after “Buried.” TomNewYorker cites most of the rotten ones.

  • Jack Dee

    Two Guys and A Girl was way funnier than it had any right to be, and that was due to Ryan. it really is not fair to be handsome AND funny. Ugly guys like me need to be funny, if we don’t have funny we don’t have sh*t.

  • MovieBuff

    No one mentioned how he’s the only thing good about Blade: Trinity?

    • Vlad Vega

      Agreed. In my mind that was his breakout role. Showed he could do action and comedy.

  • asdfggg

    He hasn’t had a lot of good movies.

  • DK

    Absolute travesty to not have Just Friends on this list, hilarious movie!

    • ethomson92

      collider put it on their list

      • DK

        Nice, Collider is very wise!

  • Dave Guyett

    “Buried” is fantastic, one of my favorite movies. It and “Locke” are so cool. Rex Reed is right, he is under-rated, he was lights-out in the stupid “Smokin’ Aces,” but he has been in some terrible films like that body-change movie with Jason Bateman.

  • Afloarei Mihai

    Great actor in my opinion

  • James Allard

    I had thought him a pleasant, lightweight rom-com guy, nothing really suggesting greatness but definitely worth watching (kind of like George Clooney). My daughter suggested the remake of The Amityville Horror, at which I balked as the whole remake just to make a buck thing was starting to get on my last nerve. “No, dad,” she said, “when you see the very dangerous, creepy man peek out from behind the Nice Guy facade, you will think he’s actually lost his mind” (her words, I promise). Sat through it and at the moment she was suggesting but did not actually identify, as it is fairly obvious what scene she was talking about, I went from Hey, This Guy Is Kinda Sorta Okay to HOLY CRAP WHEN IS HIS NEXT MOVIE COMING OUT???

    So I would add The Amityville Horror remake to the list.

    The Voices was sheer brilliance, put on shelf next to Shaun Of The Dead, Tucker & Dale Vs. Evil and The Cabin In The Woods. Comedy and horror do work well together, and it was seamless.

    And as no one has mentioned the elephant in the room…. why hasn’t anyone cast him as Ben Stiller’s brother? Every single time the Green Lantern CGI suit popped on, he was indistinguishable from Stiller…

  • Flash6600

    Did no one see Chaos Theory? Might be my favorite movie he’s done

  • Jason N.

    I am a die hard fan of his – not sure why everyone liked the nines.. kind of blah… Chaos Theory is not only my fav Reynolds movie but its my all time fav movie! To mention the voices and nines over that is a shame!

  • jtedesign

    Funny, I wrote a blog article called “Forgettable Ryan Reynolds Roles” and almost all of these were on it! Life is strange…

  • Pepper Williams

    Always liked RR. I thought his ‘turn’ in Self/less was excellent! And “Buried” was a superb movie that I could only watch once!

  • Thanks Obama

    Buying the Cow

  • Tyler Napier

    what about Just friends, or Waiting?

  • Jennifer Dunn

    Let me get this straight, there was room on this list for Van Wilder but no room for Waiting? Blasphemy.

  • Jack Dennis

    All entertaining movies.Never seen Two girls and a guy.Favorites are The Voices,Mississippi Grind,Buried, and Definitely Maybe.Definitely Maybe is one of my favorite Rom Coms of the last 10 years.

Tag Cloud

chucky SXSW Kids & Family casting concert Crackle best WarnerMedia USA Network IFC Films Arrowverse FX on Hulu toy story VICE TCM Thanksgiving movie Box Office Peacock Netflix Christmas movies Action Interview ESPN Brie Larson crime APB Film Festival OWN Super Bowl reboot The Walking Dead award winner directors LGBT DC Universe TruTV Disney+ Disney Plus comic unscripted TCA 2017 diversity Western renewed TV shows series Set visit biography spy thriller revenge FX halloween CBS comics Tarantino sports television First Reviews Freeform ratings Walt Disney Pictures Logo Red Carpet Pride Month Baby Yoda miniseries A&E christmas movies VH1 hispanic Marathons 2017 cops ABC Family Television Academy HBO Max Summer facebook anthology BET Endgame docudrama Pop talk show GIFs elevated horror theme song jamie lee curtis spider-man Classic Film 21st Century Fox sitcom President boxoffice science fiction TV Superheroe sag awards Marvel Studios Animation El Rey Mary poppins politics witnail Holidays child's play stand-up comedy Acorn TV canceled Syfy FOX TCA Winter 2020 SundanceTV CNN adventure Marvel 4/20 nature HBO universal monsters all-time Comic Book Apple TV+ composers dramedy Cartoon Network TLC IFC cancelled television Food Network movies Extras Captain marvel singing competition Comics on TV GLAAD Writers Guild of America indie Emmys critics Polls and Games Amazon YouTube Grammys Hear Us Out NYCC Disney Channel dceu 24 frames The Purge Fall TV Esquire period drama franchise Rock TIFF Women's History Month Mystery Turner Chilling Adventures of Sabrina PBS Video Games Sci-Fi Apple natural history Musical Quiz serial killer technology BBC Dark Horse Comics Travel Channel Black History Month political drama Academy Awards The Arrangement CW Seed Awards mutant See It Skip It First Look Ovation versus Ellie Kemper Vudu comiccon 007 cartoon Music batman Year in Review 20th Century Fox harry potter ITV hist MCU cancelled TV shows Election TNT Oscars free movies Rom-Com Disney Plus zero dark thirty Stephen King Emmy Nominations The CW Family ghosts transformers game show Disney streaming service Rocketman Watching Series Comedy Central TCA Best and Worst Tomatazos Shudder Nat Geo Tumblr Reality Competition Amazon Studios New York Comic Con Rocky Fantasy slashers Reality zombie based on movie Tubi a nightmare on elm street Sundance Now Star Trek TV renewals Sneak Peek Mary Tyler Moore space Epix strong female leads mission: impossible canceled TV shows Winter TV quibi Infographic parents breaking bad FXX Mindy Kaling animated Superheroes screen actors guild YouTube Red Sony Pictures AMC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt blockbuster MTV LGBTQ Amazon Prime crime thriller golden globes anime richard e. Grant sequel independent cults cats criterion Masterpiece National Geographic YA Paramount TBS spain Fox News Holiday comedies cinemax ABC Paramount Network Black Mirror 2015 Martial Arts Marvel Television children's TV TV Land Pirates spanish language Hulu zombies social media Lifetime Christmas movies discovery dark Spring TV travel SDCC Anna Paquin Avengers Nominations screenings aliens vampires psychological thriller DirecTV documentary binge asian-american E3 Toys Star Wars X-Men Crunchyroll RT History Podcast Certified Fresh Turner Classic Movies crossover Teen CBS All Access Ghostbusters Country war romantic comedy blaxploitation dragons Heroines 2020 2019 crime drama Discovery Channel Valentine's Day Warner Bros. video CMT tv talk joker MSNBC Lifetime The Witch Lionsgate game of thrones Drama spinoff Winners Trailer true crime Opinion Film Chernobyl 2018 romance Disney what to watch stoner festivals Awards Tour Universal Hallmark kids name the review teaser San Diego Comic-Con OneApp Amazon Prime Video Netflix Funimation NBC Starz Photos scary movies Mary Poppins Returns E! American Society of Cinematographers latino Biopics book finale justice league 45 Character Guide dc Nickelodeon Mudbound Sundance Christmas Spectrum Originals 71st Emmy Awards mockumentary Apple TV Plus disaster Cosplay supernatural green book Countdown cars Sundance TV BBC America Calendar WGN medical drama Spike Shondaland cancelled History psycho foreign Columbia Pictures Premiere Dates reviews adaptation werewolf Trophy Talk Hallmark Christmas movies south america cancelled TV series dogs Pop TV PaleyFest thriller DGA GoT Schedule 2016 doctor who Adult Swim Song of Ice and Fire rotten movies we love Creative Arts Emmys Britbox A24 die hard police drama Musicals Showtime Elton John DC Comics cooking YouTube Premium Cannes RT21 Lucasfilm Bravo historical drama Pixar robots USA DC streaming service Horror Binge Guide streaming Pet Sematary Trivia Comedy