Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2 Is Criminally Unfunny

Plus, Unfriended offers solid thrills, Monkey Kingdom shines, and Game of Thrones is Certified Fresh.

by | April 16, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a silly security guard (Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2, starring Kevin James and Raini Rodriguez), tech-savvy teens (Unfriended, starring Shelley Hennig and Renee Olstead), and parental primates (the Disneynature documentary Monkey Kingdom). What do the critics have to say?

Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2


Despite a lukewarm reception from critics, Paul Blart: Mall Cop was a sizeable box office hit. So naturally, we’re treated to Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2, which critics say lacks even the modest charms of its predecessor — it’s indifferently performed, tonally jumbled, and almost entirely bereft of laughs. Kevin James returns as the self-important Blart, who’s been invited to a security guard convention in Vegas. Will our hero overcome gluttony and boorishness to thwart a brazen art heist and rescue his kidnapped daughter? The pundits say Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2 is a startlingly empty experience, one that James’ inherent likability does little to enliven. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most critically-panned second installments.)



At first blush, Unfriended sounds pretty gimmicky: it’s a horror movie that consists entirely of footage from its teenage characters’ computer screens. However, critics say the result is smart and deeply unsettling, a clever thriller that has a thing or two to say about teen angst and modern communication. The plot: on the anniversary of a classmate’s death, a group of high schoolers are being hunted — via Skype — by her malevolent spirit. The pundits say Unfriended is an intelligent blend of form and content that feels utterly contemporary. (Watch our video interview with the cast here.)

Monkey Kingdom


Who doesn’t love monkeys? Critics say Monkey Kingdom might be Disneynature’s best film to date, and its breathtaking footage of primates in the wild makes for action-packed viewing. Narrated by Tina Fey, the film follows a group of toque macaques who live in the Sri Lankan jungle near an abandoned temple, with special attention paid to a single mother and her child who are trying to fit in with their new community. The pundits say Monkey Kingdom‘s stars are a playful, colorful bunch, and if the film sometimes anthropomorphizes them, they’re still likely to please animal lovers of all ages.

What’s On TV:

Bloody action and extreme power plays return full throttle, as Game of Thrones (Certified Fresh at 97 percent) enjoys a new-found liberation from the world of the source material, resulting in more unexpected thrills.

With tight adherence to its source material’s history, high production quality, and a no-nonsense dramatic flair, Marvel’s Daredevil (Certified Fresh at 97 percent) excels as an effective superhero origin story, a gritty procedural, and an exciting action adventure.

Beautifully filmed and brilliantly acted, Wolf Hall (Certified Fresh at 100 percent) masterfully brings Hilary Mantel’s award-winning novels to life.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Alex of Venice, starring Mary Elizabeth Winstead and Chris Messina in a drama about a woman who reinvents herself after her divorce, is at 82 percent.
  • The Oscar-nominated anti-war drama Tangerines, about two immigrant farmers who refuse to abandon their crops even with war on the horizon, is at 75 percent.
  • Felix & Meira, a drama about the tentative romance between a middle-aged atheist and a married Hasidic woman, is at 73 percent.
  • The Dead Lands, an adventure film about a Maori warrior who seeks to avenge his father’s murder and stave off an attack from a rival tribe, is at 60 percent.
  • True Story, a drama about a journalist working on a story about an accused killer who used the reporter’s name as an alias, is at 50 percent (check out our interview with stars Jonah Hill and James Franco).
  • Beyond The Reach, starring Michael Douglas in a thriller about a billionaire hunter who frames his guide for murder after accidentally shooting a man, is at 35 percent.
  • Child 44, starring Tom Hardy and Noomi Rapace in a period drama about a Soviet secret police agent on the trail of a serial killer, is at 23 percent.
  • Monsters: Dark Continent, a sci-fi action film about a platoon of American soldiers who must fight off an alien attack, is at 22 percent.
  • The Squeeze, starring Jeremy Sumpter and Christopher McDonald in a dramedy about three troubled young people who escape an institution and go on a road trip, is at 14 percent.
  • The Road Within, starring Dev Patel and Zöe Kravitz in a dramedy about three troubled young people who escape an institution and go on a road trip, is at 13 percent.

Tag Cloud

adenture Best Picture Television Critics Association japanese NBA Lionsgate ITV Watching Series japan Paramount Esquire chucky Drama pirates of the caribbean WarnerMedia Brie Larson 73rd Emmy Awards best Columbia Pictures screenings Thanksgiving Amazon Prime Video The Arrangement reviews First Reviews batman Acorn TV CBS IFC Nickelodeon Disney streaming service adaptation VICE richard e. Grant discovery news Country dc video comic books Ghostbusters Sci-Fi telelvision Rock legend Elton John technology facebook war supernatural 45 black comedy boxing Funimation Star Wars Celebration Universal Writers Guild of America new zealand posters DC Comics independent American Society of Cinematographers cancelled TV shows jurassic park Netflix ABC Signature Rom-Com monster movies Apple TV renewals black Mindy Kaling Reality VOD Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pirates sag awards scary video on demand Emmy Nominations sequel 2016 royal family South by Southwest Film Festival child's play ratings Comic-Con@Home 2021 Emmys Nominations Reality Competition Fargo spider-verse boxoffice Avengers werewolf art house nfl talk show PaleyFest name the review 4/20 Amazon films Fall TV concert Star Wars rom-coms free movies spider-man spanish halloween tv game of thrones Creative Arts Emmys thriller Quiz The CW Comedy Central anthology criterion TV One Cannes PBS trailers emmy awards nbcuniversal live action crime summer TV popular zero dark thirty rt labs critics edition Arrowverse indie scene in color film series justice league TBS 90s Captain marvel summer TV preview Mystery lord of the rings jamie lee curtis high school asian-american San Diego Comic-Con ABC Family Spring TV Black History Month Superheroes Disney Year in Review Holidays Photos golden globe awards anime tv talk Logo Disney Plus 2019 Fox Searchlight CW Seed Netflix Christmas movies Trailer slashers live event Ellie Kemper romantic comedy CBS All Access GoT book BBC One Polls and Games leaderboard dragons aliens Mudbound 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Apple TV Plus BAFTA Freeform Teen Classic Film trophy Exclusive Video Western TIFF Syfy Sneak Peek HBO Sony Hulu feel good SXSW hispanic heritage month GLAAD worst foreign TV Showtime action-comedy The Academy 007 ghosts binge king arthur social media Pride Month Family mission: impossible die hard AMC Plus documentary 2021 21st Century Fox satire BBC Film scene in color series Stephen King canceled TV shows Turner critics USA Network kong Hear Us Out Infographic aapi DirecTV new york crime thriller Video Games teaser Endgame quibi cars 2017 critic resources Best Actor all-time Women's History Month 24 frames mockumentary disaster Crunchyroll Mary Tyler Moore Best Actress A24 Opinion Action superman Paramount Plus zombie Rocky Awards Tour politics science fiction 93rd Oscars Tubi NYCC Tokyo Olympics toronto AMC Kids & Family blockbuster Focus Features serial killer twilight Winners Horror Image Comics PlayStation TLC cooking YouTube Premium Character Guide CMT Marvel theme song MTV Pacific Islander james bond young adult australia Alien CNN Sundance Now TCA Certified Fresh toy story Sundance comiccon Comics on TV 2015 Neflix zombies El Rey Star Trek Election superhero strong female leads Holiday E! Pixar Oscar french Valentine's Day olympics Disney Channel green book what to watch Comedy italian Podcast Schedule Martial Arts New York Comic Con Ovation reboot Discovery Channel deadpool historical drama king kong First Look crime drama latino scary movies The Purge Bravo dark MGM Calendar LGBT ABC Cartoon Network Instagram Live hist classics Masterpiece canceled X-Men E3 Television Academy WGN MCU NBC BET Awards Marvel Studios ESPN casting saw DC streaming service USA Black Mirror Trophy Talk HBO Max Hallmark Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cats kaiju FX on Hulu directors biopic mutant 20th Century Fox razzies Baby Yoda Red Carpet animated Hollywood Foreign Press Association marvel cinematic universe Walt Disney Pictures President elevated horror Winter TV Fox News 94th Oscars Marathons broadcast Anna Paquin DGA spain streaming movies Universal Pictures streaming Grammys SDCC Oscars Apple TV+ rt archives witnail joker Pop TV IFC Films Pet Sematary Set visit GIFs Adult Swim Spectrum Originals rotten crossover comic book movie Music Premiere Dates blockbusters genre stop motion indiana jones scorecard Epix Countdown renewed TV shows rt labs Tags: Comedy ViacomCBS dreamworks Toys Disney+ Disney Plus TNT series VH1 Hallmark Christmas movies Britbox documentaries worst movies Paramount Pictures 99% obituary a nightmare on elm street women A&E sequels breaking bad TCA 2017 cults See It Skip It Native History football cinemax spinoff docuseries hispanic miniseries harry potter Song of Ice and Fire Spike Wes Anderson screen actors guild TV Land rotten movies we love blaxploitation Box Office SundanceTV TCA Winter 2020 stand-up comedy YouTube Sony Pictures period drama kids true crime gangster psychological thriller FXX doctor who cancelled natural history hidden camera Tumblr Tarantino space basketball Sundance TV sitcom Cosplay south america Peacock target scene in color movies comic book movies Binge Guide BET Paramount Network festival archives Lifetime Christmas movies ID biography adventure Trivia OWN Geeked Week heist movie 2020 Dark Horse Comics new star wars movies MSNBC 79th Golden Globes Awards Biopics spy thriller godzilla LGBTQ Pop game show franchise The Walking Dead mcc Interview Tomatazos Film Festival docudrama remakes FX comics YA sports composers debate vampires Extras police drama book adaptation obi wan slasher robots travel marvel comics finale Amazon Studios television TCM summer preview children's TV Musical golden globes Summer diversity know your critic dexter Warner Bros. BBC America cartoon dceu Heroines mob Starz 2018 YouTube Red Amazon Prime Crackle TV movies Mary poppins romance IMDb TV revenge hollywood HBO Go Awards Lifetime Christmas Broadway prank award winner comedies RT21 SXSW 2022 laika OneApp Nat Geo Shondaland Fantasy parents TCA Awards Indigenous Vudu fresh Animation christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns sopranos universal monsters Legendary scene in color unscripted stoner RT History Marvel Television DC Universe FOX Academy Awards TruTV comic nature interviews halloween suspense cops cancelled television medical drama transformers Chernobyl target Superheroe The Witch dramedy streamig political drama versus Shudder Turner Classic Movies cancelled TV series 72 Emmy Awards APB Comic Book singing competition Rocketman Lucasfilm 1990s 71st Emmy Awards psycho festivals dogs Super Bowl National Geographic venice Travel Channel movie spanish language HFPA based on movie Best and Worst fast and furious Musicals The Walt Disney Company Food Network Prime Video wonder woman Best Director international vs.