Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2 Is Criminally Unfunny

Plus, Unfriended offers solid thrills, Monkey Kingdom shines, and Game of Thrones is Certified Fresh.

by | April 16, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a silly security guard (Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2, starring Kevin James and Raini Rodriguez), tech-savvy teens (Unfriended, starring Shelley Hennig and Renee Olstead), and parental primates (the Disneynature documentary Monkey Kingdom). What do the critics have to say?

Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2


Despite a lukewarm reception from critics, Paul Blart: Mall Cop was a sizeable box office hit. So naturally, we’re treated to Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2, which critics say lacks even the modest charms of its predecessor — it’s indifferently performed, tonally jumbled, and almost entirely bereft of laughs. Kevin James returns as the self-important Blart, who’s been invited to a security guard convention in Vegas. Will our hero overcome gluttony and boorishness to thwart a brazen art heist and rescue his kidnapped daughter? The pundits say Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2 is a startlingly empty experience, one that James’ inherent likability does little to enliven. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most critically-panned second installments.)



At first blush, Unfriended sounds pretty gimmicky: it’s a horror movie that consists entirely of footage from its teenage characters’ computer screens. However, critics say the result is smart and deeply unsettling, a clever thriller that has a thing or two to say about teen angst and modern communication. The plot: on the anniversary of a classmate’s death, a group of high schoolers are being hunted — via Skype — by her malevolent spirit. The pundits say Unfriended is an intelligent blend of form and content that feels utterly contemporary. (Watch our video interview with the cast here.)

Monkey Kingdom


Who doesn’t love monkeys? Critics say Monkey Kingdom might be Disneynature’s best film to date, and its breathtaking footage of primates in the wild makes for action-packed viewing. Narrated by Tina Fey, the film follows a group of toque macaques who live in the Sri Lankan jungle near an abandoned temple, with special attention paid to a single mother and her child who are trying to fit in with their new community. The pundits say Monkey Kingdom‘s stars are a playful, colorful bunch, and if the film sometimes anthropomorphizes them, they’re still likely to please animal lovers of all ages.

What’s On TV:

Bloody action and extreme power plays return full throttle, as Game of Thrones (Certified Fresh at 97 percent) enjoys a new-found liberation from the world of the source material, resulting in more unexpected thrills.

With tight adherence to its source material’s history, high production quality, and a no-nonsense dramatic flair, Marvel’s Daredevil (Certified Fresh at 97 percent) excels as an effective superhero origin story, a gritty procedural, and an exciting action adventure.

Beautifully filmed and brilliantly acted, Wolf Hall (Certified Fresh at 100 percent) masterfully brings Hilary Mantel’s award-winning novels to life.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Alex of Venice, starring Mary Elizabeth Winstead and Chris Messina in a drama about a woman who reinvents herself after her divorce, is at 82 percent.
  • The Oscar-nominated anti-war drama Tangerines, about two immigrant farmers who refuse to abandon their crops even with war on the horizon, is at 75 percent.
  • Felix & Meira, a drama about the tentative romance between a middle-aged atheist and a married Hasidic woman, is at 73 percent.
  • The Dead Lands, an adventure film about a Maori warrior who seeks to avenge his father’s murder and stave off an attack from a rival tribe, is at 60 percent.
  • True Story, a drama about a journalist working on a story about an accused killer who used the reporter’s name as an alias, is at 50 percent (check out our interview with stars Jonah Hill and James Franco).
  • Beyond The Reach, starring Michael Douglas in a thriller about a billionaire hunter who frames his guide for murder after accidentally shooting a man, is at 35 percent.
  • Child 44, starring Tom Hardy and Noomi Rapace in a period drama about a Soviet secret police agent on the trail of a serial killer, is at 23 percent.
  • Monsters: Dark Continent, a sci-fi action film about a platoon of American soldiers who must fight off an alien attack, is at 22 percent.
  • The Squeeze, starring Jeremy Sumpter and Christopher McDonald in a dramedy about three troubled young people who escape an institution and go on a road trip, is at 14 percent.
  • The Road Within, starring Dev Patel and Zöe Kravitz in a dramedy about three troubled young people who escape an institution and go on a road trip, is at 13 percent.

Tag Cloud

slashers Black History Month MCU Ovation japanese Martial Arts james bond Tags: Comedy superhero GoT crime drama Hallmark American Society of Cinematographers dceu vampires telelvision National Geographic blockbuster cancelled TV series spider-man Vudu werewolf Tokyo Olympics Character Guide boxoffice hollywood Video Games VOD comedies Western free movies spain cancelled TV shows strong female leads Red Carpet comics E3 police drama kids New York Comic Con Awards Emmy Nominations tv talk 93rd Oscars BBC America dreamworks President critics Broadway Sundance Now Best and Worst The Walt Disney Company composers science fiction Walt Disney Pictures Trailer dexter italian fast and furious Mindy Kaling indiana jones Heroines TCA 2017 SDCC Crackle australia Prime Video YouTube zero dark thirty harry potter talk show natural history new zealand animated Mudbound popular mcc dark spanish language Quiz PaleyFest suspense Paramount Network Emmys sag awards royal family golden globes leaderboard A24 Disney Plus A&E Warner Bros. 45 RT History Pop Polls and Games Baby Yoda ABC Family spanish basketball mockumentary elevated horror Rocketman Alien Stephen King criterion prank PBS binge OWN Year in Review 24 frames social media independent The Purge best action-comedy gangster TCA Mystery jurassic park children's TV Apple TV+ jamie lee curtis boxing Paramount Plus book Shondaland anthology Shudder casting RT21 sopranos Netflix 2019 NBA Rocky Toys San Diego Comic-Con festival marvel cinematic universe Winners 71st Emmy Awards Awards Tour VH1 olympics cinemax Certified Fresh documentary Columbia Pictures Oscars rt archives cancelled YA TCA Winter 2020 medical drama Lionsgate Extras ratings heist movie crime thriller Marvel Studios Ellie Kemper E! stand-up comedy worst movies ITV scorecard Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt women Legendary streaming movies cats laika dogs Anna Paquin Star Trek GLAAD hist Peacock Marathons stoner 72 Emmy Awards FX on Hulu Set visit Lucasfilm dragons WGN IFC Reality dramedy TV die hard TLC classics Hulu ViacomCBS Wes Anderson TNT Pride Month breaking bad IFC Films technology singing competition Crunchyroll target Premiere Dates wonder woman rom-coms razzies revenge WarnerMedia Creative Arts Emmys USA Pet Sematary sports hispanic heritage month Reality Competition Film posters critic resources disaster remakes comic directors superman 2020 political drama zombies Comedy X-Men a nightmare on elm street pirates of the caribbean series Country legend comiccon toronto supernatural latino MTV halloween tv Opinion NBC Comic Book cooking Pop TV finale french art house Trophy Talk TV movies international Action 21st Century Fox halloween satire CBS Fantasy Superheroe japan true crime space game show CMT deadpool godzilla Brie Larson AMC Plus Sony Pictures Sundance TV TCA Awards quibi feel good TCM Super Bowl Holidays HBO Go obituary black comedy SXSW Endgame Box Office comic books FX young adult 90s Kids & Family BBC One television Hear Us Out venice 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards mutant Avengers witnail NYCC canceled TV shows archives Drama Tubi Amazon Prime Video Teen Fall TV Paramount Winter TV twilight Spring TV travel 2021 game of thrones lord of the rings Trivia VICE theme song Esquire Rom-Com nfl Superheroes comic book movies HFPA Musicals Comedy Central hispanic Musical spinoff Britbox live action Horror high school nbcuniversal Family APB parents DC Universe video on demand Lifetime cancelled television ABC monster movies indie TBS Funimation joker HBO Academy Awards Showtime ABC Signature Photos 007 Television Critics Association rt labs anime TIFF Hollywood Foreign Press Association adaptation First Look Dark Horse Comics Christmas adenture BET Awards teaser TV Land toy story DC Comics spider-verse Tumblr aapi 1990s franchise crime Sneak Peek asian-american blockbusters Film Festival batman aliens transformers Travel Channel marvel comics Holiday diversity SundanceTV Adult Swim king kong unscripted what to watch DirecTV Schedule Starz USA Network Pirates Chernobyl trailers Cartoon Network romantic comedy Disney+ Disney Plus name the review Watching Series CNN Grammys zombie nature worst comic book movie 2017 book adaptation Apple 73rd Emmy Awards BBC screenings The CW Masterpiece crossover Marvel Television FOX Pixar Netflix Christmas movies Bravo movies fresh HBO Max trophy Turner Classic Movies live event Discovery Channel saw Nominations Freeform 20th Century Fox films reviews vs. 79th Golden Globes Awards ID Summer Nat Geo rotten movies we love Podcast Mary poppins TruTV psychological thriller Biopics cars 2015 Spike Disney Comic-Con@Home 2021 Tomatazos Neflix Fargo versus Mary Tyler Moore cops rotten foreign History OneApp kong 99% child's play Cannes cults Election Comics on TV football sequel chucky genre Elton John south america Ghostbusters thriller scary Infographic sequels BET TV One Amazon Studios mission: impossible FXX Tarantino biopic Sci-Fi emmy awards documentaries biography all-time dc Food Network canceled Fox Searchlight Apple TV Plus El Rey Star Wars Captain marvel docudrama Thanksgiving Epix black CW Seed Classic Film The Arrangement Fox News LGBT sitcom justice league Animation Universal romance Song of Ice and Fire concert facebook Women's History Month serial killer Valentine's Day ghosts Logo politics DC streaming service cartoon 4/20 green book Chilling Adventures of Sabrina screen actors guild BAFTA slasher debate blaxploitation Disney streaming service golden globe awards Music based on movie IMDb TV new star wars movies Amazon Countdown rt labs critics edition renewed TV shows richard e. Grant The Witch YouTube Red Syfy Spectrum Originals Lifetime Christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns YouTube Premium war 2016 discovery streaming robots period drama universal monsters hidden camera Disney Channel know your critic First Reviews Calendar mob stop motion Turner kaiju doctor who Marvel TV renewals Writers Guild of America Hallmark Christmas movies Instagram Live DGA Pacific Islander The Academy AMC award winner king arthur Sundance miniseries Exclusive Video Amazon Prime scene in color scary movies movie Black Mirror MSNBC PlayStation ESPN GIFs Cosplay Universal Pictures docuseries news Television Academy Binge Guide Rock LGBTQ video spy thriller historical drama 2018 The Walking Dead Interview Arrowverse Image Comics psycho reboot christmas movies CBS All Access festivals See It Skip It adventure Acorn TV Nickelodeon new york