Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Paranormal Activity 3 is Certified Fresh

Plus, The Three Musketeers, Johnny English Reborn, and The Mighty Macs all misfire.

by | October 20, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a vengeful spirit (Paranormal Activity 3, starring Katie Featherston and Sprague Grayden), a trio of swashbucklers (The Three Musketeers, starring Logan Lerman and Milla Jovovich), a silly spy (Johnny English Reborn, starring Rowan Atkinson and Gillian Anderson), and some holy hoopsters (The Mighty Macs, starring Carla Gugino and David Boreanaz). What do the critics have to say?

Paranormal Activity 3


You probably know what to expect with the Paranormal Activity franchise at this point, but that doesn’t mean that part three doesn’t have a few tricks up its sleeve: critics say this installment is as spooky and shriek-inducing as the first one – perhaps even more so. This time out, we discover the origins of Katie’s mysterious bedeviling, revealed through some serendipitously recorded VHS tapes. The pundits say the series’ conceit may not be fresh, but the Certified Fresh Paranormal Activity 3 has plenty of effective scares and creepy atmospherics to satisfy anyone in the market for a good ghost story.

The Three Musketeers


All for one and one for all? Well, the critics certainly don’t have a feeling of esprit de corps when it comes to The Three Musketeers, calling it an overblown special effects extravaganza that’s largely bereft of coherence or wit. Logan Lerman stars as the hot-headed young D’Artagnan, who teams up with the legendary trio of swashbucklers to prevent the megalomaniacal Cardinal Richelieu (Christoph Waltz) from plunging Europe into chaos. The pundits say The Three Musketeers has moments of mad, manic energy, but too often it’s just loud, busy, and lacking a sense of ribald fun.

Johnny English Reborn


Rubber-faced Rowan Atkinson’s brand of goofy, good-natured comedy didn’t win over the critics in the first Johnny English, and the same can be said of Johnny English Reborn. Atkinson is back as the titular “intelligence” agent who bumbles his way around the globe on a mission to save the Chinese premier from an assassination attempt. The pundits say Atkinson’s proclivity for physical comedy generates some laughs, but mostly, Johnny English Reborn is poorly paced and overrun with weather-beaten gags. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most memorable spy spoofs.)

The Mighty Macs


Hoosiers at a Catholic school doesn’t sound bad on paper, but critics say The Mighty Macs feels awfully familiar in execution, failing to add much girl-power spice to the inspirational sports movie playbook. Carla Gugino stars as Cathy Rush, a college basketball star who takes a coaching gig at a tiny women’s religious college. Can she lead her team to victory while striking a modest blow for feminism in the process? The pundits say The Mighty Macs is sweet, well-meaning, and really, really predictable, featuring better-than-averages performances and no surprises whatsoever.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

45 Food Network SDCC Disney Channel The CW Character Guide NYCC Best and Worst First Look aliens romance Trivia Cosplay political drama Paramount APB Comic Book Video Games X-Men TCA 2017 science fiction Comedy Central Reality war historical drama vampires travel harry potter Sneak Peek Drama WGN ESPN Super Bowl politics transformers Marvel zombie Extras DirecTV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt President Opinion Starz Sci-Fi E3 adventure Netflix Amazon TNT Thanksgiving GIFs FXX Ellie Kemper serial killer Mindy Kaling Syfy Podcast psycho Emmys Pop crime cops crime thriller Biopics Musical technology cats Watching Series Tumblr Set visit Lifetime TBS talk show BET Calendar Certified Fresh ABC Family Summer GoT Rocky Bravo Warner Bros. Trailer supernatural DC Universe ITV Toys OWN Winners AMC TruTV CMT PBS Musicals social media The Arrangement Winter TV cooking what to watch 2015 GLAAD 2017 composers Infographic IFC Oscars Year in Review Fox News Tomatazos Countdown DC Comics Nominations LGBTQ MSNBC Superheroes BBC Grammys Pirates Dark Horse Comics VH1 crime drama singing competition Universal Masterpiece period drama USA Horror Spring TV TCM E! CNN TIFF Adult Swim binge BBC America Photos Animation Freeform sitcom Mystery dramedy El Rey Comedy 007 HBO Red Carpet Logo Rom-Com Awards Rock Cartoon Network FX Mary Tyler Moore Kids & Family Star Trek Martial Arts RT History Reality Competition Premiere Dates Nickelodeon Hulu MTV based on movie Ghostbusters Marathons boxoffice Action Crackle NBC Schedule Sundance Polls and Games SundanceTV American Society of Cinematographers diversity History Showtime Holidays police drama Esquire discovery thriller docudrama Valentine's Day Interview Box Office sports Fall TV CBS All Access Fantasy Star Wars Disney TLC Teen A&E Lionsgate TV TCA PaleyFest biography Election comiccon 24 frames cinemax Country VICE FOX 2016 Nat Geo Writers Guild of America TV Land ABC Music CBS YA