Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Captain Phillips is Certified Fresh

Plus, Machete Kills doesn't cut that deep.

by | October 10, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a hostage situation (Captain Phillips, starring Tom Hanks and Catherine Keener), and a deadly mission (Machete Kills, starring Danny Trejo and Michelle Rodriguez). What do the critics have to say?



Captain Phillips

93%

Director Paul Greengrass (United 93, Bloody Sunday) is an expert at adapting true stories to the big screen with a sense of you-are-there immediacy. Tom Hanks is great at portraying relatable people operating under extraordinary duress. Together, they make Captain Phillips a tense, endlessly involving thriller that entertains even as it raises intriguing questions. Hanks plays Phillips, the captain of a cargo ship that?s hijacked by Somali pirates; as the situation becomes more grim by the minute, it?s up to the captain to maintain composure and keep his crew safe. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Captain Phillips is potent, powerful stuff, with terrific performances and a script that gives multiple dimensions to all parties involved. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Hanks’ best-reviewed films.)



Machete Kills

29%

There’s a thin line separating trashy fun and plain ol’ trash, and unfortunately, critics say Machete Kills is too often on the wrong side of the divide; despite its emphasis on gleefully over-the-top violence and campy laughs, the movie is too slackly paced and overlong to fully register as a guilty pleasure. This time out, the president enlists our blade-wielding hero (played by Danny Trejo) to stop a billionaire arms trader bent on inciting chaos across the globe. The pundits say Machete Kills is like its predecessor in many ways, just less so; it’s got some clever cameos and delightfully tasteless action, but there’s less energy on display this time out. (Take a look through our gallery of the ladies of the Machete movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

2018 GIFs justice league Neflix Discovery Channel superman Columbia Pictures reviews Fall TV movies Crunchyroll RT History comiccon ABC Signature live action Walt Disney Pictures HBO Go IFC RT21 sag awards USA BAFTA king arthur Hulu women The Witch disaster theme song blockbuster El Rey Mary poppins BBC America Superheroes sitcom DC streaming service independent 21st Century Fox 90s Drama Shudder nfl what to watch spider-man Superheroe psychological thriller Television Academy golden globes joker stand-up comedy renewed TV shows X-Men Exclusive Video feel good WarnerMedia Best and Worst Shondaland Holidays new zealand Song of Ice and Fire video crime drama Thanksgiving A24 binge concert criterion wonder woman The CW Sundance TV latino rom-coms cancelled television crime science fiction Extras 24 frames Star Wars TV Land biopic HBO GLAAD 93rd Oscars Comedy Central Apple TV Plus TNT Showtime zero dark thirty FXX suspense werewolf docudrama documentary OneApp quibi Tokyo Olympics dogs FOX cooking MSNBC Ghostbusters BET Action Infographic Valentine's Day Marvel Studios SXSW 2019 kong Brie Larson cancelled TV series news 1990s unscripted cults tv talk true crime spinoff heist movie Black Mirror YouTube Red teaser Amazon Prime Video pirates of the caribbean olympics Certified Fresh comic books mcc Spring TV adaptation worst Image Comics vampires 73rd Emmy Awards biography prank CW Seed The Walking Dead young adult Animation Paramount south america Creative Arts Emmys Hallmark Christmas movies saw screen actors guild Broadway Oscars Rocky psycho series crime thriller DirecTV Star Trek Set visit IFC Films boxing Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The Arrangement cars TV renewals Trivia Epix Mary Tyler Moore Amazon Syfy kids Netflix Christmas movies cinemax book adaptation ABC comics screenings TV movies Legendary Baby Yoda dreamworks Cannes Disney new star wars movies name the review trophy Stephen King streaming Spectrum Originals Elton John rt labs critics edition First Reviews Esquire YouTube Classic Film Comic-Con@Home 2021 children's TV Quiz archives spider-verse remakes child's play Fox Searchlight rotten 45 Disney+ Disney Plus Photos Musicals Polls and Games free movies nbcuniversal History lord of the rings 79th Golden Globes Awards singing competition comic book movies Starz Grammys Box Office Heroines slasher comedies Avengers 20th Century Fox spanish Hallmark Academy Awards critics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Sundance Now Horror elevated horror PlayStation Vudu jamie lee curtis BET Awards black comedy directors laika know your critic Ellie Kemper mob MTV Fox News travel docuseries Disney Plus Lifetime Christmas movies die hard dramedy revenge TBS Binge Guide Sneak Peek Lifetime Disney streaming service IMDb TV political drama Year in Review telelvision Sci-Fi mutant Rom-Com spanish language Pacific Islander james bond Super Bowl Alien strong female leads Peacock chucky TCA 2017 blockbusters nature See It Skip It debate Mudbound Video Games Universal Pictures AMC Plus Tarantino historical drama talk show Character Guide NBC Writers Guild of America canceled TV shows Pirates all-time trailers Captain marvel 2015 OWN Freeform cops TV vs. royal family Cosplay spy thriller Podcast space game of thrones Rocketman Fantasy Acorn TV Lionsgate Countdown HFPA Paramount Plus Hollywood Foreign Press Association television spain reboot Pet Sematary APB Funimation romantic comedy cartoon parents new york composers transformers 71st Emmy Awards 99% 2016 Winter TV video on demand doctor who AMC films YA E! Christmas Tubi monster movies Marvel Television San Diego Comic-Con dc YouTube Premium worst movies Film PaleyFest diversity VOD Warner Bros. Arrowverse kaiju cancelled TV shows Apple TV+ TCA Awards ghosts Hear Us Out robots Red Carpet technology TCA target anime Schedule supernatural PBS thriller HBO Max golden globe awards 72 Emmy Awards Mary Poppins Returns romance adenture aapi fresh Fargo National Geographic FX finale BBC franchise period drama australia zombies Reality christmas movies leaderboard Nickelodeon Food Network BBC One American Society of Cinematographers Premiere Dates comic book movie Mindy Kaling ViacomCBS social media Tumblr foreign asian-american E3 TCM Holiday police drama 2017 hollywood venice Amazon Prime gangster scary movies Netflix SundanceTV Tags: Comedy CBS All Access toronto Cartoon Network A&E dragons high school crossover Pixar satire Trailer FX on Hulu 2020 Spike hidden camera richard e. Grant CBS Film Festival toy story marvel cinematic universe Mystery President basketball Emmys discovery Pop TV Toys miniseries Turner Classic Movies cancelled boxoffice godzilla Emmy Nominations harry potter book Rock TIFF serial killer posters mission: impossible Family blaxploitation TCA Winter 2020 4/20 live event Masterpiece Disney Channel indie slashers TV One halloween tv ID french 007 Bravo movie indiana jones Sundance DC Universe Martial Arts stop motion Television Critics Association Comics on TV Music Marvel Awards sports Tomatazos dark Britbox Comedy WGN Pop Watching Series DGA marvel comics casting Biopics aliens classics Crackle Apple Prime Video Endgame Ovation Nominations Sony Pictures TLC international ESPN war CNN Marathons The Walt Disney Company TruTV Country LGBTQ action-comedy award winner sequels game show Summer best Chernobyl documentaries stoner superhero DC Comics Teen batman art house hispanic Amazon Studios Election USA Network Turner king kong ABC Family Reality Competition hispanic heritage month ITV Awards Tour medical drama breaking bad rotten movies we love comic Adult Swim Interview jurassic park rt archives NYCC Wes Anderson scorecard The Academy anthology twilight Comic Book politics halloween versus witnail fast and furious a nightmare on elm street Musical VH1 The Purge First Look deadpool japanese japan Winners sequel SDCC GoT Nat Geo black dexter italian LGBT football NBA universal monsters canceled Calendar streaming movies Kids & Family genre Dark Horse Comics emmy awards Lucasfilm Black History Month adventure mockumentary based on movie Women's History Month Logo legend Western Instagram Live green book rt labs animated Pride Month festivals scary cats Trophy Talk critic resources popular festival MCU Paramount Network dceu obituary razzies Travel Channel scene in color New York Comic Con zombie hist natural history VICE Anna Paquin Universal facebook 2021 ratings 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards sopranos Opinion CMT