Cannes 2009: The Tomato Report - Gilliam Fails to Impress with Parnassus

While Noe makes a typically uncompromising return to Cannes.

by | May 23, 2009 | Comments

Critics in Cannes were amongst the first, yesterday, to see Heath Ledger‘s final performance in The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus, the fantasy flick that was long-delayed due to his death, played at the festival. Reviews have been mixed at best.

“Ledger’s performance provides an adequate swansong for loyal fans on pilgrimages to the multiplexes this autumn,” Charles Gant writes for The Independent. “But many will exit scratching their heads.”

Directed by Terry Gilliam, the film is a fantastical morality tale, revolving around the ancient Doctor and his magical mirror which allows punters to explore the darkest realms of their imagination. Christopher Plummer plays the Doctor, while Ledger stars as a suicidal soul he meets along the way. Many seem to have a problem with the film’s narrative structure however, with James Christopher of The Times stating, that it is, “impossible to unscramble what it all means.”

Cannes 2009
Critics failed to warm to Gilliam’s latest

Todd McCarthy of Variety seems to sum up the general consensus. “Especially considering the trauma and difficulties stemming from Heath Ledger’s death during production and the fact that Terry Gilliam hadn’t directed a good picture in more than a decade, the helmer has made a pretty good thing out of a very bad situation.”

The film currently has a score of 44% on the Tomatometer.

Gaspar Noe‘s typically uncompromising new film Enter the Void, on the other hand, had critic’s tongues a-wagging last night, with his sexually explicit feature impressing and disgusting the critics on the Croisette. The Cannes guide calls his film an, “hallucinatory maelstrom,” and judging by the general reaction, that seems to be an understatement.

The story revolves around drug dealer Oscar and his sister Linda. Newly arrived in Tokyo, Oscar is caught up in a drug bust and shot. His spirit refuses to abandon Linda however, and so wanders through the city in a series of visually stunning scenes.

Writing for Screen International, Mike Goodridge calls the film, “a wild, hallucinatory mindfuck for adults.” He adds that it’s, “More experience than narrative, meandering and careening in and out of story and into visual realms and moods that are nothing short of hypnotic.”

Cannes 2009
Gaspar Noe makes a typically uncompromising return to Cannes.

However, he qualifies these statements by adding, “If audiences care to, they can lose themselves in Noe’s images and trip on his imagination. If they don’t, they will be bored to tears.”

Variety’s Todd Nelson is even more cutting, claiming the film, “proves to be the ne plus ultra of nothing much. Having come in under the wire [it] may once again be ready to enter the editing room.”

The New York Times is less downbeat, with Manohla Dargis claiming that the director has mellowed since Cannes hit Irreversible in 2002. “This is the work of an artist who’s trying to show us something we haven’t seen before. The grungy milieu and calculated shocks might have been designed to make you flee – even while your attention is tethered to the camera – but, really, these aren’t the point. The point is the filmmaking.”

Tag Cloud

Universal Pictures crime thriller 2021 crime drama TIFF saw cancelled television Hallmark lord of the rings Holidays Mary Poppins Returns parents mcc New York Comic Con TLC transformers deadpool name the review First Look Set visit Family war video on demand El Rey 24 frames dreamworks rom-coms spain christmas movies adventure game show Extras richard e. Grant Action cinemax BET Comedy Central WGN GoT Starz rt labs animated 2015 Comedy AMC zombies Syfy 72 Emmy Awards free movies classics halloween Winter TV Superheroes asian-american dogs screenings critics boxoffice Certified Fresh Pet Sematary San Diego Comic-Con Image Comics high school Quiz Creative Arts Emmys BBC America FXX Legendary LGBT television rotten movies we love suspense art house Mindy Kaling robots reviews Premiere Dates MSNBC DC Comics miniseries mission: impossible cartoon streaming young adult BET Awards video E! sequel 99% worst thriller CBS All Access toronto Tubi psychological thriller batman 4/20 HBO Go Pixar Chernobyl TBS Elton John X-Men Black History Month quibi Lifetime Christmas movies NBA politics crossover Television Academy comiccon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina comedies fast and furious Rocketman The Walking Dead Marathons Broadway what to watch marvel comics cars police drama Musicals golden globe awards fresh basketball Sundance TV italian stand-up comedy TV movies Esquire sports IFC Video Games Amazon Studios Comic Book Freeform First Reviews spanish language vampires 20th Century Fox rt archives social media Captain marvel venice NBC movies Film Festival Classic Film scorecard anime comic book movie Fall TV Emmy Nominations The Walt Disney Company Song of Ice and Fire rt labs critics edition genre PBS Ellie Kemper BAFTA Infographic zero dark thirty Crunchyroll 71st Emmy Awards YouTube spider-man kids 2019 IFC Films satire SundanceTV comics Musical ITV TV One Endgame wonder woman strong female leads Disney Food Network Comic-Con@Home 2021 golden globes indie scary Trivia movie Travel Channel Holiday Marvel Opinion nature canceled Fox News Thanksgiving ABC toy story Film live action Cannes VICE YouTube Red talk show Masterpiece Winners Turner Classic Movies Dark Horse Comics archives festivals spy thriller 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards versus ratings Reality Competition FX on Hulu OneApp BBC One aliens hidden camera President james bond films Red Carpet Netflix Warner Bros. critic resources documentary TCM legend mutant aapi 2017 foreign Christmas universal monsters Lionsgate laika child's play Acorn TV live event docuseries emmy awards spider-verse Polls and Games Character Guide Schedule Comics on TV period drama PaleyFest Awards Tour Marvel Television stoner biopic Baby Yoda Walt Disney Pictures biography Tumblr romance Fox Searchlight psycho cops Amazon Prime Video nfl Fantasy australia sequels serial killer Discovery Channel black Pop TV Martial Arts 2016 TV renewals The Purge kong razzies History SXSW criterion Epix Brie Larson AMC Plus based on movie blaxploitation Lucasfilm monster movies Apple festival Trailer PlayStation Shondaland ABC Signature Star Wars VOD Nominations 007 anthology 1990s zombie Crackle jurassic park Toys Box Office Neflix YouTube Premium Amazon FOX E3 Apple TV Plus theme song Country new zealand obituary Arrowverse Sony Pictures cults Universal docudrama Showtime know your critic Mary poppins true crime Disney Plus 73rd Emmy Awards witnail dragons prank hispanic series GIFs IMDb TV blockbuster Hulu Wes Anderson Super Bowl Funimation The Witch 21st Century Fox Watching Series 93rd Oscars Heroines japanese new york WarnerMedia latino Disney streaming service best cancelled TV series gangster Star Trek cats Rocky reboot TCA 2017 a nightmare on elm street vs. Exclusive Video king arthur ID TCA Awards Western supernatural harry potter doctor who Academy Awards TV stop motion singing competition Reality independent Pacific Islander cancelled TV shows jamie lee curtis game of thrones Adult Swim Year in Review Paramount Network binge See It Skip It medical drama A24 halloween tv Best and Worst scary movies Sundance Women's History Month diversity crime American Society of Cinematographers 2020 adenture Apple TV+ comic popular Turner Paramount Plus feel good Vudu TruTV Writers Guild of America ESPN 90s Binge Guide all-time LGBTQ posters pirates of the caribbean Netflix Christmas movies scene in color Logo 2018 Podcast slasher remakes documentaries french Shudder screen actors guild Tokyo Olympics joker breaking bad debate worst movies Biopics hist facebook mockumentary hispanic heritage month Disney+ Disney Plus Television Critics Association Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dexter Anna Paquin Countdown award winner adaptation SDCC nbcuniversal ViacomCBS Spring TV Pop HBO Max Bravo Alien YA NYCC The Arrangement RT21 HBO new star wars movies teaser sitcom Mudbound dc Avengers composers Black Mirror Teen revenge black comedy disaster science fiction Animation CBS children's TV renewed TV shows spinoff tv talk TCA Winter 2020 indiana jones Spike DC streaming service Interview Ghostbusters Election royal family sopranos The CW spanish comic book movies twilight BBC superman Marvel Studios casting technology sag awards blockbusters king kong green book Nat Geo cancelled Superheroe MTV DirecTV Britbox Kids & Family canceled TV shows Ovation Instagram Live rotten Mary Tyler Moore Grammys football dceu Photos CMT FX historical drama 45 book dramedy Emmys unscripted Trophy Talk Awards mob Horror CW Seed political drama comic books Summer Disney Channel TV Land Sneak Peek olympics south america werewolf Oscars Pirates VH1 travel telelvision Tomatazos directors news Rock Pride Month A&E trailers heist movie TNT chucky USA Sci-Fi ghosts Peacock APB hollywood action-comedy Nickelodeon space Paramount book adaptation USA Network marvel cinematic universe ABC Family GLAAD Stephen King Cosplay franchise CNN Music women Cartoon Network DGA natural history Hear Us Out Columbia Pictures superhero concert international MCU National Geographic kaiju TCA dark Hallmark Christmas movies streaming movies Lifetime OWN RT History Sundance Now Valentine's Day Rom-Com Mystery japan Amazon Prime slashers boxing romantic comedy cooking Calendar godzilla justice league discovery Spectrum Originals finale elevated horror DC Universe Drama target die hard Tarantino The Academy