Cannes 2009: The Tomato Report - Gilliam Fails to Impress with Parnassus

While Noe makes a typically uncompromising return to Cannes.

by | May 23, 2009 | Comments

Critics in Cannes were amongst the first, yesterday, to see Heath Ledger‘s final performance in The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus, the fantasy flick that was long-delayed due to his death, played at the festival. Reviews have been mixed at best.

“Ledger’s performance provides an adequate swansong for loyal fans on pilgrimages to the multiplexes this autumn,” Charles Gant writes for The Independent. “But many will exit scratching their heads.”

Directed by Terry Gilliam, the film is a fantastical morality tale, revolving around the ancient Doctor and his magical mirror which allows punters to explore the darkest realms of their imagination. Christopher Plummer plays the Doctor, while Ledger stars as a suicidal soul he meets along the way. Many seem to have a problem with the film’s narrative structure however, with James Christopher of The Times stating, that it is, “impossible to unscramble what it all means.”

Cannes 2009
Critics failed to warm to Gilliam’s latest

Todd McCarthy of Variety seems to sum up the general consensus. “Especially considering the trauma and difficulties stemming from Heath Ledger’s death during production and the fact that Terry Gilliam hadn’t directed a good picture in more than a decade, the helmer has made a pretty good thing out of a very bad situation.”

The film currently has a score of 44% on the Tomatometer.

Gaspar Noe‘s typically uncompromising new film Enter the Void, on the other hand, had critic’s tongues a-wagging last night, with his sexually explicit feature impressing and disgusting the critics on the Croisette. The Cannes guide calls his film an, “hallucinatory maelstrom,” and judging by the general reaction, that seems to be an understatement.

The story revolves around drug dealer Oscar and his sister Linda. Newly arrived in Tokyo, Oscar is caught up in a drug bust and shot. His spirit refuses to abandon Linda however, and so wanders through the city in a series of visually stunning scenes.

Writing for Screen International, Mike Goodridge calls the film, “a wild, hallucinatory mindfuck for adults.” He adds that it’s, “More experience than narrative, meandering and careening in and out of story and into visual realms and moods that are nothing short of hypnotic.”

Cannes 2009
Gaspar Noe makes a typically uncompromising return to Cannes.

However, he qualifies these statements by adding, “If audiences care to, they can lose themselves in Noe’s images and trip on his imagination. If they don’t, they will be bored to tears.”

Variety’s Todd Nelson is even more cutting, claiming the film, “proves to be the ne plus ultra of nothing much. Having come in under the wire [it] may once again be ready to enter the editing room.”

The New York Times is less downbeat, with Manohla Dargis claiming that the director has mellowed since Cannes hit Irreversible in 2002. “This is the work of an artist who’s trying to show us something we haven’t seen before. The grungy milieu and calculated shocks might have been designed to make you flee – even while your attention is tethered to the camera – but, really, these aren’t the point. The point is the filmmaking.”

Tag Cloud

werewolf Columbia Pictures cults Song of Ice and Fire Disney cartoon GIFs IFC political drama independent Pet Sematary Shudder OneApp cars Rom-Com 2015 unscripted cancelled TV shows PBS Netflix Peacock Disney streaming service breaking bad renewed TV shows kids Starz Sundance Now TV E3 CBS All Access YouTube Premium spain WarnerMedia NYCC dramedy HBO Hulu Country mockumentary Freeform TCM National Geographic Stephen King YouTube Red Pixar Fantasy 24 frames Western Set visit Film blaxploitation harry potter Britbox vampires USA Superheroe Mary Tyler Moore what to watch Pop TV renewals Writers Guild of America medical drama Disney Channel elevated horror Reality Sci-Fi Pride Month Cannes supernatural Amazon PaleyFest name the review Anna Paquin canceled DC Universe Musicals Mudbound Crunchyroll adaptation Character Guide Ellie Kemper Marvel Studios Trophy Talk batman spy thriller cancelled TV series Winners Food Network reviews Interview VICE technology adventure zombie binge romance space Action Comedy Central TCA 2017 dragons series Premiere Dates HBO Max Family south america true crime Television Academy ABC Arrowverse Awards Tour Amazon Prime TNT jamie lee curtis psycho Extras Disney Plus Election MSNBC comics anthology boxoffice Apple Pirates versus BBC Valentine's Day SDCC Certified Fresh A&E Hallmark Christmas movies thriller universal monsters Adult Swim green book 2020 free movies police drama Lionsgate Toys Infographic crime thriller USA Network See It Skip It Tumblr DC Comics El Rey Apple TV Plus television reboot cancelled toy story A24 blockbuster Oscars The Purge Calendar anime Epix latino MTV 20th Century Fox war game show Avengers Amazon Studios crime strong female leads Tubi festivals Paramount Walt Disney Pictures CNN Summer casting Horror Tarantino zombies CMT diversity science fiction movies Creative Arts Emmys MCU aliens First Look Acorn TV Marvel Martial Arts Syfy Polls and Games Lucasfilm Watching Series Captain marvel streaming Spectrum Originals Heroines VH1 Drama Video Games Disney+ Disney Plus Holiday biography First Reviews Trivia The CW Sneak Peek YouTube Women's History Month sag awards miniseries award winner FX on Hulu Winter TV indie APB BBC America Funimation New York Comic Con Rock Marathons quibi Fox News Marvel Television DGA Black History Month AMC romantic comedy joker Elton John Mindy Kaling Masterpiece Opinion spider-man Apple TV+ Awards Mystery 007 LGBT Rocky Ghostbusters BET CW Seed TruTV Trailer Red Carpet Musical Travel Channel Best and Worst Superheroes Music halloween Box Office Christmas nature Paramount Network Warner Bros. dc social media christmas movies serial killer Super Bowl WGN video Sony Pictures Nominations 2018 Schedule RT History tv talk TLC psychological thriller Grammys Teen X-Men historical drama canceled TV shows sports mutant spinoff documentary Hallmark based on movie discovery facebook talk show GoT E! Amazon Prime Video Cartoon Network Photos revenge cancelled television TCA rotten movies we love zero dark thirty Quiz Film Festival Cosplay period drama TCA Winter 2020 hist Emmys Turner DirecTV Vudu ITV Nat Geo Lifetime Christmas movies Pop TV Mary poppins robots DC streaming service screenings The Walking Dead Binge Guide sitcom FXX Esquire Showtime Podcast travel TBS Crackle RT21 Classic Film FX finale richard e. Grant Discovery Channel Fall TV Star Wars ABC Family Sundance Lifetime SXSW Star Trek GLAAD Chernobyl FOX Logo Reality Competition Kids & Family composers cinemax cops book Spring TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt San Diego Comic-Con children's TV YA Rocketman screen actors guild Holidays game of thrones dogs 71st Emmy Awards franchise Emmy Nominations docudrama 2019 Year in Review Spike ratings movie golden globes dceu ghosts OWN 21st Century Fox Turner Classic Movies The Witch Dark Horse Comics Biopics hispanic American Society of Cinematographers Thanksgiving politics crossover theme song comic cats 45 SundanceTV slashers CBS transformers ESPN Baby Yoda NBC 2016 disaster Academy Awards singing competition directors Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comic Book Tomatazos doctor who 2017 Ovation Bravo Countdown Endgame IFC Films TIFF Netflix Christmas movies Black Mirror Nickelodeon Comics on TV sequel Brie Larson Animation Sundance TV justice league cooking Comedy TV Land Shondaland History scary movies The Arrangement comiccon LGBTQ Universal witnail crime drama stand-up comedy teaser animated natural history foreign Mary Poppins Returns spanish language President