Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Water for Elephants Is A Little Soapy

Plus, African Cats? footage is purr-fect, and guess Madea's Big Happy Family?s Tomatometer.

by | April 22, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies we’ve got a big-top romance (Water for Elephants, starring Reese Witherspoon and Robert Pattinson); a maternal fixer (Tyler Perry’s Madea’s Big Happy Family, starring Loretta Devine and Bow Wow), and familial felines (African Cats, narrated by Samuel L. Jackson). What do the critics have to say?

Water for Elephants


Nowadays, the word “melodrama” is mostly used pejoratively, but it wasn’t always so: melodramas were the stock-in-trade of great directors like George Cukor and Douglas Sirk. However, we live in more cynical times, and critics say the Depression-set Water for Elephants has an evocative sense of its time and place but lacks the burning passions required to pull off this type of romantic weepie. Robert Pattinson stars as a cash-strapped aspiring veterinary student who gets a job with a travelling circus troupe and falls for the star performer (Reese Witherspoon). The pair bond over their shared love of animals — particularly pachyderms — but our heroine is married to the abusive, manipulative owner of the circus. Will these crazy kids make it — and jerk some tears in the process? The pundits say Water for Elephants is handsomely mounted and occasionally swoony, but it’s not quite passionate or sweeping enough to overcome its predictable script and languid pacing.(Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Witherspoon’s best-reviewed movies)

Tyler Perry’s Madea’s Big Happy Family


With the recent exception of last year’s For Colored Girls, Tyler Perry’s directorial efforts tend to hit theaters without screening for critics beforehand, and his latest, Madea’s Big Happy Family, continues the trend. Perry again stars as the no-nonsense, straight-talking titular matron; this time out, her children are each plagued by a variety of problems, and Madea takes it upon herself to set matters right. Kids, let’s play Guess the Tomatometer!

African Cats


Do you like kitties? Adorable, exotic kitties? If the answer is yes, you’ll probably be in heaven with African Cats, though critics say that while the film captures some awe-inspiring footage of these great felines in the wild, it also has a tendency to anthropomorphize its subjects. Samuel L. Jackson narrates the movie, which follows a lioness raising her cub in a pride, and a cheetah mother raising her litter alone; both moms face plenty of danger and hardship on the savannah. The pundits say that if you can get past the film’s persistence in equating the trials of these creatures to those of their human counterparts, you’ll be treated to a remarkably intimate and visually stunning portrait of survival in wild.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Sci-Fi Best and Worst RT History NYCC 2015 VH1 Superheroes Disney VICE Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Comedy Central 24 frames vampires what to watch Countdown The CW police drama Infographic Western Ellie Kemper Red Carpet FOX TCA 2017 X-Men Sneak Peek Horror Teen Nominations Fall TV Fantasy TLC period drama Calendar 007 Hulu boxoffice biography Year in Review Cosplay Dark Horse Comics BBC Mindy Kaling Super Bowl politics thriller Box Office Warner Bros. Emmys docudrama PaleyFest SundanceTV See It Skip It TBS Esquire OWN Tumblr Pop diversity Holidays USA 21st Century Fox Tomatazos Crackle TNT Food Network CNN American Society of Cinematographers justice league crime thriller Drama CBS Star Trek based on movie war Trivia ITV Polls and Games Fox News IFC Sundance Election Bravo Musical YA Lionsgate Masterpiece technology Spring TV Winter TV crime TCM Podcast Universal Pirates ABC 2017 Comedy Schedule Summer Rock adventure harry potter TIFF Opinion Certified Fresh President FX Biopics WGN Lifetime PBS 45 GLAAD Winners LGBTQ Country historical drama Starz Adult Swim Mystery serial killer Premiere Dates Marathons Reality Competition dc A&E Netflix El Rey sports psycho Showtime sitcom spy thriller Valentine's Day FXX Paramount cooking transformers cops Writers Guild of America dceu Christmas singing competition Grammys political drama Star Wars Interview Set visit cinemax dramedy science fiction medical drama BBC America HBO Action Character Guide social media APB TV Syfy GIFs Rom-Com Kids & Family composers Watching Series DC Universe MTV cats zombie Marvel SDCC The Arrangement Oscars First Look E3 Nickelodeon Nat Geo discovery Mary Tyler Moore NBC Toys History BET crime drama Animation aliens E! DirecTV CMT USA Network Logo binge Extras AMC supernatural CBS All Access Thanksgiving Freeform Reality travel MSNBC Rocky Comic Book Disney Channel Ghostbusters Music TV Land Photos talk show ESPN Video Games Awards DC Comics romance Amazon TruTV Martial Arts comiccon GoT Musicals Cartoon Network 2016 Trailer TCA ABC Family