Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Transformers 2 Is Less Than Meets The Eye

Plus, My Sister's Keeper is well-acted but manipulative, and The Hurt Locker is powerful and vital.

by | June 25, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got robots in disguise (Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen, starring Megan Fox and Shia LaBeouf) and an engagement of convenience (My Sister’s Keeper, starring Cameron Diaz and Abigail Breslin). What do the critics have to say?


Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen

Most folks like their blockbusters big, loud, and loaded with spectacle. However, the masses also tend to enjoy good characters and some semblance of a plot, two things the pundits say are sorely missing from Michael Bay‘s Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen. This follow up to 2007’s Transformers finds the Autobots waging a battle to destroy the evil forces of the Decepticons (with help from Megan Fox and Shia LaBeouf), since they have designs on obliterating Earth. Critics say Revenge has a lot of problems: it’s loud, it’s bombastic, it’s way to long, it contains few recognizable human emotions, and its plot is borderline incomprehensible. Worst of all, they say, it’s not particularly fun. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down the top 50 movie robots of all time, and our primer on Revenge of the Fallen‘s bots.)


My Sister’s Keeper

A lot of movies walk a fine line between being emotionally involving and seeming merely manipulative, and critics are essentially split on which side My Sister’s Keeper falls. Cameron Diaz stars as a woman whose daughter Anna (Abigail Breslin) is born as a genetic match with her leukemia-afflicted older sister Kate (Sofia Vassilieva). When, at 11, Anna is called upon to provide a kidney for Kate, she sues her parents for medical independence. Some critics say My Sister’s Keeper is bolstered by outstanding performances and a sense of moral complexity. However, others say this three-hankie weepie doesn’t fully earn its tears, resorting to unconvincing plot machinations..)


Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Emmys FOX VOD Election directors Pop The CW psychological thriller war USA Network natural history 79th Golden Globes Awards comic book movies TLC Box Office what to watch Summer Chernobyl rotten movies we love Cartoon Network 20th Century Fox leaderboard 2019 spinoff franchise Starz Neflix spider-man YA adventure mcc robots The Academy Comic-Con@Home 2021 Showtime Ovation crime drama best Star Trek Video Games Amazon Prime HBO Max ABC Signature popular Family series Film Pirates kaiju documentary parents reviews GoT rt labs critics edition Set visit godzilla reboot TV Paramount SXSW hist feel good james bond boxing 45 Marvel Television WarnerMedia comedies romantic comedy TBS science fiction TV One TCM all-time Classic Film twilight Ghostbusters TV renewals Disney Channel aapi Funimation USA singing competition San Diego Comic-Con Lifetime boxoffice Spring TV space The Witch Tomatazos toronto 71st Emmy Awards 2016 cancelled elevated horror christmas movies Infographic award winner Nat Geo nfl joker richard e. Grant disaster razzies cops cars superman television RT21 jamie lee curtis golden globe awards women news cats sag awards telelvision scary ghosts Martial Arts Masterpiece ViacomCBS DC streaming service rt archives First Look hispanic animated TCA Awards CBS All Access book adaptation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Universal Pictures Lucasfilm History Extras Avengers President TV Land cinemax PlayStation wonder woman Wes Anderson romance stand-up comedy ABC period drama movie Apple Super Bowl ratings discovery black new star wars movies fast and furious HFPA scene in color comic books universal monsters Trailer Anna Paquin Television Critics Association LGBTQ renewed TV shows theme song game show prank festival new york spider-verse travel WGN italian doctor who kids sports Adult Swim Fargo Tumblr video on demand talk show slashers Fantasy rt labs gangster zero dark thirty live action finale medical drama cooking BBC One Warner Bros. films zombie Kids & Family Britbox criterion First Reviews olympics psycho art house VICE TV movies Year in Review spanish Tokyo Olympics dceu Character Guide spy thriller Oscars Apple TV+ YouTube Mary poppins 99% PaleyFest Winter TV crime documentaries Brie Larson Horror Legendary CMT 2021 political drama Black History Month zombies IFC BAFTA laika streaming movies Shudder Academy Awards GIFs 24 frames BBC America Television Academy Sundance asian-american target aliens Sundance TV japanese independent ABC Family MTV Instagram Live basketball Black Mirror facebook Amazon Studios cancelled TV shows mutant binge 4/20 dogs Quiz dexter Song of Ice and Fire BET Western casting Reality crime thriller foreign Drama rotten FX french CNN Elton John composers Schedule Image Comics stoner Lifetime Christmas movies FXX The Walking Dead new zealand Christmas Heroines royal family blockbusters Opinion Paramount Network nature Rocky Discovery Channel mission: impossible National Geographic miniseries canceled TV shows Tubi saw Reality Competition American Society of Cinematographers 2017 live event posters transformers Peacock Syfy screenings Trivia Rom-Com Columbia Pictures Turner Classic Movies Fall TV Watching Series Marvel Studios NBC Esquire Netflix Christmas movies Sci-Fi BBC mob japan Captain marvel indiana jones vampires FX on Hulu batman Nickelodeon fresh HBO Go Epix A24 Star Wars comics dreamworks trophy Food Network Hear Us Out Shondaland comic book movie Nominations Pacific Islander Valentine's Day Awards 93rd Oscars revenge king kong scary movies children's TV Cannes ITV werewolf Certified Fresh 2020 international cancelled TV series MCU Interview 72 Emmy Awards PBS Hollywood Foreign Press Association Sundance Now Toys DGA unscripted Cosplay Comics on TV Mystery versus king arthur classics DC Comics a nightmare on elm street based on movie 73rd Emmy Awards IMDb TV Thanksgiving Writers Guild of America golden globes dragons book police drama vs. black comedy Disney Turner Spectrum Originals spanish language green book Animation A&E Comedy Central Broadway NYCC BET Awards DC Universe dark Amazon Creative Arts Emmys breaking bad young adult south america 1990s critic resources See It Skip It Teen Mudbound child's play obituary concert Universal Crackle Comedy cults DirecTV Pop TV MSNBC chucky Endgame ID dramedy satire E3 Biopics politics SDCC Holidays Awards Tour movies action-comedy Grammys thriller anime Countdown Rocketman Walt Disney Pictures Lionsgate Mary Tyler Moore Disney streaming service IFC Films lord of the rings Baby Yoda blaxploitation Netflix El Rey Stephen King Pet Sematary Apple TV Plus football blockbuster Country docuseries TIFF Binge Guide true crime Spike VH1 harry potter critics Marathons Mary Poppins Returns monster movies 21st Century Fox 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards trailers Disney Plus festivals Logo australia Tarantino SundanceTV canceled The Arrangement Amazon Prime Video sitcom indie Comic Book APB Pride Month hidden camera Disney+ Disney Plus LGBT Calendar ESPN halloween tv Holiday jurassic park Women's History Month cancelled television streaming Best and Worst Superheroes serial killer justice league Red Carpet Prime Video social media RT History Film Festival crossover Superheroe Sony Pictures Musicals The Purge worst movies diversity cartoon CBS E! NBA Crunchyroll Bravo 2018 emmy awards Exclusive Video toy story die hard sequel Acorn TV tv talk Mindy Kaling Action nbcuniversal YouTube Premium Tags: Comedy comic Musical remakes legend Vudu technology Paramount Plus hispanic heritage month latino quibi Winners Emmy Nominations Ellie Kemper Fox Searchlight OneApp docudrama hollywood comiccon teaser Dark Horse Comics know your critic scorecard heist movie AMC Plus mockumentary sequels Music Travel Channel kong superhero game of thrones deadpool marvel cinematic universe halloween suspense Photos Pixar screen actors guild dc Fox News Premiere Dates Podcast 90s Marvel Trophy Talk The Walt Disney Company YouTube Red TCA Winter 2020 Hulu Arrowverse video AMC venice biopic X-Men worst New York Comic Con Freeform marvel comics historical drama spain GLAAD archives high school supernatural Hallmark Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt pirates of the caribbean 2015 Sneak Peek rom-coms adenture witnail stop motion sopranos TCA 2017 adaptation Alien debate Polls and Games HBO free movies Rock biography strong female leads TruTV 007 genre OWN name the review TNT CW Seed Hallmark Christmas movies anthology slasher TCA