Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Transformers 2 Is Less Than Meets The Eye

Plus, My Sister's Keeper is well-acted but manipulative, and The Hurt Locker is powerful and vital.

by | June 25, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got robots in disguise (Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen, starring Megan Fox and Shia LaBeouf) and an engagement of convenience (My Sister’s Keeper, starring Cameron Diaz and Abigail Breslin). What do the critics have to say?


Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen

Most folks like their blockbusters big, loud, and loaded with spectacle. However, the masses also tend to enjoy good characters and some semblance of a plot, two things the pundits say are sorely missing from Michael Bay‘s Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen. This follow up to 2007’s Transformers finds the Autobots waging a battle to destroy the evil forces of the Decepticons (with help from Megan Fox and Shia LaBeouf), since they have designs on obliterating Earth. Critics say Revenge has a lot of problems: it’s loud, it’s bombastic, it’s way to long, it contains few recognizable human emotions, and its plot is borderline incomprehensible. Worst of all, they say, it’s not particularly fun. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down the top 50 movie robots of all time, and our primer on Revenge of the Fallen‘s bots.)


My Sister’s Keeper

A lot of movies walk a fine line between being emotionally involving and seeming merely manipulative, and critics are essentially split on which side My Sister’s Keeper falls. Cameron Diaz stars as a woman whose daughter Anna (Abigail Breslin) is born as a genetic match with her leukemia-afflicted older sister Kate (Sofia Vassilieva). When, at 11, Anna is called upon to provide a kidney for Kate, she sues her parents for medical independence. Some critics say My Sister’s Keeper is bolstered by outstanding performances and a sense of moral complexity. However, others say this three-hankie weepie doesn’t fully earn its tears, resorting to unconvincing plot machinations..)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

best LGBTQ Sundance TV reviews FX on Hulu marvel cinematic universe high school Freeform mission: impossible Paramount Plus game show TCM dogs 99% toy story Avengers heist movie rom-coms new star wars movies black Lucasfilm documentary Binge Guide RT21 worst movies The CW Musical fast and furious video on demand reboot Summer TLC Premiere Dates MCU Year in Review screen actors guild Cartoon Network golden globe awards finale A24 ghosts San Diego Comic-Con remakes travel comic books Spike 20th Century Fox adenture blockbusters Crackle Apple TV Plus golden globes fresh Awards Pet Sematary 45 Rocky Biopics TV Land all-time Ghostbusters Mary Tyler Moore Fox Searchlight animated Film Festival BBC Set visit politics streaming movies Super Bowl Marvel Television Sundance USA new york HBO Go social media DirecTV Drama 71st Emmy Awards crime drama kong WGN Photos Reality History Superheroes Schedule french screenings Trailer Hallmark New York Comic Con die hard CW Seed BBC One romantic comedy FX Certified Fresh Travel Channel godzilla adaptation Amazon Prime strong female leads Hallmark Christmas movies Apple Infographic king kong independent Sundance Now saw IFC Films latino Action 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Opinion Women's History Month hist Horror superman Warner Bros. crime thriller Comic-Con@Home 2021 biography Universal Vudu Nat Geo discovery Best and Worst Holidays TV One elevated horror Cosplay APB festival Food Network game of thrones ratings Walt Disney Pictures Star Trek TCA trailers deadpool revenge Grammys DC Universe Marathons Syfy 1990s richard e. Grant book adaptation Fox News spider-man lord of the rings australia Rock award winner period drama breaking bad Television Academy cops canceled The Walt Disney Company universal monsters ITV miniseries 2015 legend Music Crunchyroll supernatural razzies Disney Channel binge SDCC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mary poppins Tomatazos cancelled TV series Mystery Pride Month Peacock Film crime robots TCA Awards El Rey thriller foreign adventure cancelled television cars Christmas Shondaland witnail Marvel tv talk Amazon Studios Heroines 72 Emmy Awards comedies Netflix Christmas movies 90s twilight Paramount Network werewolf WarnerMedia X-Men laika Broadway 2019 2017 Columbia Pictures The Purge TV movies SXSW 4/20 scary movies hidden camera psychological thriller nbcuniversal target satire TruTV Box Office stand-up comedy classics PlayStation asian-american festivals The Witch Disney+ Disney Plus NBA dragons zombies Watching Series stoner aliens 2020 parents TBS MSNBC theme song Teen james bond political drama Wes Anderson Extras Comics on TV live action facebook Superheroe critics halloween Lionsgate docuseries sports historical drama Awards Tour YA basketball Ellie Kemper emmy awards science fiction Shudder Pop what to watch Turner Classic Movies docudrama spanish language Holiday anthology sag awards films technology Starz scorecard canceled TV shows Hulu cartoon Star Wars nature First Look Calendar Disney TV TV renewals comic comiccon Masterpiece Spectrum Originals jurassic park Thanksgiving USA Network Martial Arts CMT dark GoT CBS criterion olympics OneApp Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt christmas movies Tokyo Olympics Exclusive Video spain Turner TNT Baby Yoda Legendary jamie lee curtis Sony Pictures hispanic pirates of the caribbean mockumentary LGBT toronto rotten movies we love Classic Film 2016 Showtime new zealand Apple TV+ Stephen King ViacomCBS cults The Walking Dead GIFs anime First Reviews Toys Acorn TV 24 frames hollywood japan boxoffice child's play Pirates free movies blaxploitation 93rd Oscars 2018 HBO Max cinemax romance italian ABC Nominations Tumblr Song of Ice and Fire HBO football spy thriller serial killer series a nightmare on elm street vampires Countdown Bravo mutant Rom-Com Alien prank natural history Black History Month DC Comics CBS All Access Sci-Fi Disney streaming service Pacific Islander police drama suspense National Geographic franchise Elton John aapi Character Guide streaming Amazon japanese telelvision Writers Guild of America Oscars 2021 President Emmys kaiju Lifetime Christmas movies cancelled archives versus BAFTA Country dceu Lifetime Cannes popular Tubi OWN international kids VOD Western Brie Larson BBC America crossover superhero Endgame harry potter Logo unscripted GLAAD ABC Family book name the review teaser news MTV blockbuster children's TV YouTube Premium Podcast dramedy Britbox war Television Critics Association casting Arrowverse Pop TV E! disaster cooking Trivia TCA 2017 AMC comics NYCC IFC Comic Book rotten ID nfl E3 Animation know your critic YouTube Red YouTube SundanceTV Sneak Peek Academy Awards justice league spinoff PaleyFest composers diversity stop motion Epix NBC VH1 21st Century Fox Kids & Family worst Interview BET television The Arrangement Family VICE Captain marvel Marvel Studios halloween tv Musicals south america Spring TV Mindy Kaling quibi obituary Comedy based on movie Adult Swim Emmy Nominations Winners Polls and Games Election Hear Us Out Discovery Channel joker documentaries rt archives Dark Horse Comics Creative Arts Emmys Image Comics video indie Pixar cats Esquire movie Netflix sequel FOX ESPN batman women green book boxing Fantasy BET Awards CNN Valentine's Day chucky space sitcom ABC Signature A&E Comedy Central Anna Paquin American Society of Cinematographers PBS medical drama Video Games dc psycho transformers singing competition Ovation Tarantino Winter TV Disney Plus scene in color directors Nickelodeon movies Paramount Quiz Amazon Prime Video TCA Winter 2020 Mary Poppins Returns RT History Chernobyl spanish 007 monster movies zombie zero dark thirty slashers Fall TV TIFF renewed TV shows Black Mirror concert indiana jones DGA See It Skip It true crime Reality Competition Red Carpet doctor who sequels venice DC streaming service Rocketman cancelled TV shows Mudbound FXX Trophy Talk talk show The Academy Funimation